News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by saddlerustle on Saturday March 27, 2021 @12:29AM (#26599910)
Houses and rent are expensive because there's not enough houses in the places people want houses. You're not paying for the house, you're paying for someone else not to live there. Governments further subsidising homeownership will only make them more expensive.
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by andrewstuart on Saturday March 27, 2021 @12:30AM (#26599915)
There's enough houses.

There just shouldn't be people owning more than 2.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by epistasis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @12:41AM (#26599976)
That's ridiculous, limiting people to owning one house wouldn't be nearly enough homes.

But, let's say that were the case, somehow. Why is your solution to stop people from owning more homes, rather than letting more homes be built? Why choose austerity over abundance?

There's a clear reason to choose austerity: it always, literally always, privileges existing power over those with less. However, most people who want to entrench existing power and oppress those with less don't admit it openly, instead they couch this undesirable anti-egalitarianism in obscure arguments to hide their true motives.

This is the stage we are at in California. People who have gained enormous real estate wealth through luck, which has let them exploit an entire class of extremely productive workers, know they can not create abundance on their own, but must instead farm workers like cattle. So they embrace this austerity couched in other terms.

Limiting people from owning more than one home will not actually produce enough for everyone that wants to live in highly desirable areas. But forwarding unworkable proposals will continue to create luxury goods (housing near food jobs) as luxury, rather than opening them up to more people.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by chadcmulligan on Saturday March 27, 2021 @12:54AM (#26600023)
>Why choose austerity over abundance?

Indeed, abundance is the way to go, then why bother investing? An anecdote - There was an oversupply of apartments in my city a few years ago, prices were dropping - oh no! So the response? Developers stopped building, there are foundations sitting around in a number of places that were planned to be built, but apartment development has basically stopped in the city. In a few years there'll be a shortage and no doubt the developers will start up again. The incentives are all screwed up, if they kept building then prices would drop, but the profit isn't there at the moment so they sit idle.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by epistasis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @01:43AM (#26600210)
In my city, about 20% or more of building cost are impact fees to the city, because Prop 13 gives massive tax breaks to old wealth and the city is forced to depend on newcomers and new entrants to fund all city activities. A fairer tax scheme would mean that cheaper housing would get built.

I 100% agree that incentives are all screwed up. But I think we should fix those incentives, rather than double down on a bad system by embracing austerity.

Another problem is that construction productivity has been going down in our economy over the past few decades, while manufacturing productivity increases. A lot of that is the bad political process that cities use to block new housing with discretionary approvals, and the other half is the huge cycles of building and not building that gut the workforce, make it difficult to find steady employments, and cause huge swings in supply and demand.

Personally, and I know this may not be a popular idea here, support a well-funded publicly owned housing developer to build social housing, that builds countercyclically to use the labor pool when there is lower demand, and build less when market forces suddenly pick up. Smoothing out this process will increase economic efficiency greatly, in addition to moving towards an abundance model rather than our austerity model, which is oddly embraced by both the right and the anti-development left.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by chadcmulligan on Saturday March 27, 2021 @02:03AM (#26600301)
> a well-funded publicly owned housing developer to build social housing

I've had similar thoughts, there was an overbuilding of these sorts of apartments in the 60's and 70's which resulted in inner city ghetto's though.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by epistasis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @09:24AM (#26602113)
I've read lots of problems with the US's past public housing programs, but I've never once heard somebody say that they were overbuilt.

The problems were poor construction, lack of maintenance, poor citing away from any sort of economic opportunity, and perhaps most of all racial segregation.

Any sort of modern effort would have to mirror Singapore or Vienna, where the housing is for people of all incomes, and wealthy people's rent cross subsidized lower incomes, and everybody lives together.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by whatshisface on Saturday March 27, 2021 @01:16AM (#26600110)
Isn't that the system working? If a house costs more to build than anyone would pay for it, wouldn't it would be a bad idea to build it?
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by chadcmulligan on Saturday March 27, 2021 @02:01AM (#26600291)
not really - the apartments being built are expensive luxury apartments, mark up I'm told is around 100%. If they can't get the profit they move elsewhere and start construction there, holding costs are obviously low for undeveloped land. If the government desired cheap rental apartments then the incentives would be different.
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by epistasis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @09:31AM (#26602159)
Markup is 100%? Which housing market is that?! I find that rather incredible, because construction is not usually that lucrative, anywhere, and if such profit margins were possible there would be a glut of people rushing in to do it. Construction loans mean that starting capital for such a project isn't super high.

Another thing about "only luxury," that means there's a regulation failure that only allows luxury homes to be built. We have a market system that means that the rich get served first. So if it's cheap to build, but only super expensive units come on the market, those who approve or deny building are letting too few units be built.

In expensive markets like California, profits are typically around 10%-25%, no more than a few year's worth of housing costs rise.

Therefore it's far easier to make money by buying and holding in California than through construction; higher profits and less risk.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by whatshisface on Saturday March 27, 2021 @12:39AM (#26599968)
Without landlords, how would I be able to rent a house? Would I have to get loans whenever I moved, even if temporarily? All that would do is replace a mix of landlords and bankers with bankers. Renting money to buy something that you later sell to return the money is the same as renting the thing directly, except you're dealing with a huge bank instead of a midsize management company / wealthy owner-manager.
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by jjav on Sunday March 28, 2021 @04:52AM (#26608890)
> Renting money to buy something that you later sell to return the money is the same as renting the thing directly

Largely true, except that by renting it directly you're also paying the additional profit margin for the middleman who took out the mortgage (rented the money) for you to be able to rent it directly.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by yardstick on Saturday March 27, 2021 @12:35AM (#26599945)
I agree with the sentiment but disagree with the 2 house limit. For example a family holiday house should be ok. I would put the limit around 10 homes, and if any are rentals then any capital gains should be taxed more harshly unless sold to someone who will owner occupy for at least say 3 years. Yes I’m sure there are loopholes in what I’m describing but it’s the general concept I’m trying to show.
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by mjevans on Saturday March 27, 2021 @02:11AM (#26600335)
You should have to live in a house for at least 35% of the year to not pay EXTREME taxes on it. Notably that's 70% among two houses and 30% in slack that can go where-ever.

However we also still need __way__ more housing to get out of the 2 generation debt in many places and 3-5 in E.G. major Californian cities.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by jjav on Sunday March 28, 2021 @04:54AM (#26608900)
> You should have to live in a house for at least 35% of the year to not pay EXTREME taxes on it.

This would incentivize ownership since renting out would be prohibitive. But for anyone who'd like to rent, those extreme taxes will just be passed on to them.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by adrianN on Saturday March 27, 2021 @12:38AM (#26599962)
I'm sure that there are not enough houses in central Tokyo for everyone who wants to live in central Tokyo.
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by pdonis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @01:12AM (#26600092)
> there's not enough houses in the places people want houses

I think a possible solution to a lot of that problem is one that, by a tragic irony, we have COVID-19 to thank for making mainstream: remote work. If people's housing locations weren't tightly coupled to their job locations, there would be a lot more freedom for people to choose a place to live and places to live would be forced to compete on a more level playing field.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by Ericson2314 on Saturday March 27, 2021 @01:59AM (#26600282)
Unless you want to video-only the rest of your life too, remote work isn't good enough. We need to decrease distances for all purposes of transportation period for environmental, social, and economic reasons.

Dense development with public transportation does for society what increasing the component density and shortening wire length does for integrate circuits. There is no substitute.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by pdonis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @03:24PM (#26604772)
> We need to decrease distances for all purposes of transportation period for environmental, social, and economic reasons.

"We" have all kinds of different needs and desires. Not everyone wants to live in a densely populated area.

In any case, uncoupling the location of your home from the location of your job should improve your ability to live closer to the people and places you want to be close to in your personal life. That would go for everyone, those who want to live in densely populated areas and those who don't.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by Ericson2314 on Saturday March 27, 2021 @04:22PM (#26605288)
I don't want to subsidize other people's suburban and rural decadence. It's not a personal choice that doesn't effect others. Development is a collective choice no matter how much American ideology wants to obfuscate that.
Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by pdonis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @04:59PM (#26605588)
> I don't want to subsidize other people's suburban and rural decadence.

You don't get to decide what counts as "decadence". Nor are cities subsidizing suburban and rural areas; in most cases it's the other way around, it's the cities that continually get themselves into financial trouble and have to be bailed out, and the suburban and rural areas that are fiscally responsible.

> It's not a personal choice that doesn't effect others

Neither is your personal choice to live in densely populated cities.

> Development is a collective choice

And when there are significant sub-populations with widely different preferences, the right collective choice is to separate the sub-populations so each can have their own areas where they can implement their preferences, not for one sub-population to force its preferences on everyone else.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by Ericson2314 on Saturday March 27, 2021 @06:01PM (#26606016)
> You don't get to decide what counts as "decadence".

I don't, but the accounting does.

> Nor are cities subsidizing suburban and rural areas; in most cases it's the other way around, it's the cities that continually get themselves into financial trouble and have to be bailed out, and the suburban and rural areas that are fiscally responsible.

This is completely false.

It seems that way because of cities offering extra services get hit with austerity first, but the base line is is not no net subsidization. You are just observing cities being unable to fund those services and subsidize the suburbs at the same time.

Google "cities subsidize suburbs" and find things all across the political spectrum. For example, on the more right:

https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2020/4/16/when-apartment...

https://www.theamericanconservative.com/urbs/we-have-always-...

in addition to the original article on the left.

> And when there are significant sub-populations with widely different preferences, the right collective choice is to separate the sub-populations so each can have their own areas where they can implement their preferences, not for one sub-population to force its preferences on everyone else.

If suburbs can function without my money and without leaking their pollution in my air water, sure. But that is not possible.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by pdonis on Saturday March 27, 2021 @07:48PM (#26606724)
> I don't, but the accounting does.

Assuming your facts are correct--I have seen factual claims all over the map on this, and government subsidies and favoritism are all over the place, not just in favor of suburban homeowners--this is still not an argument for forcing everyone to live in densely populated cities. It's an argument for removing government subsidies and favoritism. Which I am completely in favor of doing; I'm quite willing to pay whatever the actual costs are of living where I want to live, and factoring those costs into my choice of where to live. What I'm not willing to do is force my choices to conform to someone else's idea of how people should live.

> without leaking their pollution in my air water

Where is that coming from? Certainly not from the references you gave. And if you think cities don't pollute, I don't know where you're getting that from either.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by Ericson2314 on Saturday March 27, 2021 @11:19PM (#26607648)
> I have seen factual claims all over the map on this

Would love to see a counter argument if there is one

> government subsidies and favoritism are all over the place, not just in favor of suburban homeowners.

There are many subsidies, but the magnitudes differ. Note it's not only home ownership subsidies, but zoning and other regulations, preference for building highways and not trains, low gas tax and lack of carbon tax, and many other such things.

The strong towns people also talk about longer and improperly financed pumbling and electrical lines, etc., but I don't know as much about that.

> Which I am completely in favor of doing; I'm quite willing to pay whatever the actual costs are of living where I want to live, and factoring those costs into my choice of where to live.

Great! But watch for big changes if this happens.

> This is still not an argument for forcing everyone to live in densely populated cities.

It doesn't need to be coerced, and properly accounting the externalities alone would make me quite happy too.

But some things like public transit the market just cannot do. The portion value captured is too small a portion --- while the operational costs can break even the capital costs might take > 50 years to recoup --- so that conventional finance says no. And that's not to say it's not worth, but it's a level of "risk" that even for truly great efficiency the private sector won't stomach. Also it is a natural monopoly so it would have to be regulated to death anyways if was privately run, basically defeating the purpose of trying to involve a market.

Also, note I said density not size. If people want to live in a https://media.timeout.com/images/103639693/1024/576/image.jp... in the middle of nowhere and there is a train running to it, that's fine with me.

> Where is that coming from? Certainly not from the references you gave. And if you think cities don't pollute, I don't know where you're getting that from either.

No not those sources but suburbs have far higher energy usage because the inefficiency of the sprawl and large homes, and even if we electrify everything with good power sources, there is tire pollution of electric cars, environment issues from the shear amount of land being taken (e.g. drainage like we saw in Houston during Hurricane Harvey).

--------

Bottom line is suburbs can work, but at great efficiency costs, so you have coordinate globally and fixing all our externalizes, and sacrifice the wealth that would come from greater efficiency in a rather heavy de-growth way, and probably rely on a shrunken population. In other words, if we were to do everything else right, this would be a "luxery" we can maybe get away with the next century.

But if so, what's the point? What's the point of individualist- nuclear-family-ist- vineer of that suburbanization if behind the scenes there is massive collecitivism to enforce everything to need it work? I do hope there is a time after this big mess of unsustainability to have more "ethical luxeries", but I can't imagine suburbanization would be one anyone would want at that point.

Re:Lessons from ten nations about building affordable, low-c... by pdonis on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:13AM (#26618195)
> some things like public transit the market just cannot do.

Sure it can. Many major cities in the US had multiple competing private companies providing public transit, and doing it quite efficiently and cheaply, up until around World War II. Then governments took over, drove the private companies out of business, and proceeded to make public transit in the US the mess that it is today.

But even with all that, private companies can still provide efficient public transit in the US today--if they're allowed to use buses traveling on roads to do it, instead of rail. For example, in the area where I live, a privately owned bus company was providing affordable bus service, faster than a driving commute, until the government stepped in and forced it out of business, in favor of a huge white elephant project to extend the rail system, giving people a longer commute (1 hour or more from train station to work, vs. a half hour to 40 minutes from bus stop, at the same location, to work) at a higher price (even though the rail system is government subsidized while the bus company was not).

> What's the point of individualist- nuclear-family-ist- vineer of that suburbanization if behind the scenes there is massive collecitivism to enforce everything to need it work?

You don't need massive collectivism to make suburbanization work. You need massive collectivism to make urbanization work. And the only reason we use the term "suburban" at all in the US is that we've urbanized so much. Before the massive urbanization of the US in the mid to late 20th century, the places we now call "suburbs" were just towns--towns that had developed naturally through freedom of choice and cooperation among people who wanted to form communities. Urbanization is what killed so many of those towns and destroyed what used to be a well functioning system of communities in favor of massive collectivism.

> this big mess of unsustainability

The claim that any lifestyle but an urbanized lifestyle is "unsustainable" is nonsense. What is unsustainable is massive collectivism. Massive collectivism killed more than a hundred million people in the twentieth century. It doesn't work.