Indeed, abundance is the way to go, then why bother investing? An anecdote - There was an oversupply of apartments in my city a few years ago, prices were dropping - oh no! So the response? Developers stopped building, there are foundations sitting around in a number of places that were planned to be built, but apartment development has basically stopped in the city. In a few years there'll be a shortage and no doubt the developers will start up again. The incentives are all screwed up, if they kept building then prices would drop, but the profit isn't there at the moment so they sit idle.
I 100% agree that incentives are all screwed up. But I think we should fix those incentives, rather than double down on a bad system by embracing austerity.
Another problem is that construction productivity has been going down in our economy over the past few decades, while manufacturing productivity increases. A lot of that is the bad political process that cities use to block new housing with discretionary approvals, and the other half is the huge cycles of building and not building that gut the workforce, make it difficult to find steady employments, and cause huge swings in supply and demand.
Personally, and I know this may not be a popular idea here, support a well-funded publicly owned housing developer to build social housing, that builds countercyclically to use the labor pool when there is lower demand, and build less when market forces suddenly pick up. Smoothing out this process will increase economic efficiency greatly, in addition to moving towards an abundance model rather than our austerity model, which is oddly embraced by both the right and the anti-development left.
I've had similar thoughts, there was an overbuilding of these sorts of apartments in the 60's and 70's which resulted in inner city ghetto's though.
The problems were poor construction, lack of maintenance, poor citing away from any sort of economic opportunity, and perhaps most of all racial segregation.
Any sort of modern effort would have to mirror Singapore or Vienna, where the housing is for people of all incomes, and wealthy people's rent cross subsidized lower incomes, and everybody lives together.
Another thing about "only luxury," that means there's a regulation failure that only allows luxury homes to be built. We have a market system that means that the rich get served first. So if it's cheap to build, but only super expensive units come on the market, those who approve or deny building are letting too few units be built.
In expensive markets like California, profits are typically around 10%-25%, no more than a few year's worth of housing costs rise.
Therefore it's far easier to make money by buying and holding in California than through construction; higher profits and less risk.
But, let's say that were the case, somehow. Why is your solution to stop people from owning more homes, rather than letting more homes be built? Why choose austerity over abundance?
There's a clear reason to choose austerity: it always, literally always, privileges existing power over those with less. However, most people who want to entrench existing power and oppress those with less don't admit it openly, instead they couch this undesirable anti-egalitarianism in obscure arguments to hide their true motives.
This is the stage we are at in California. People who have gained enormous real estate wealth through luck, which has let them exploit an entire class of extremely productive workers, know they can not create abundance on their own, but must instead farm workers like cattle. So they embrace this austerity couched in other terms.
Limiting people from owning more than one home will not actually produce enough for everyone that wants to live in highly desirable areas. But forwarding unworkable proposals will continue to create luxury goods (housing near food jobs) as luxury, rather than opening them up to more people.