They thought they were in charge of running a shiny business that was in the process of transforming away from being principally a domain registrar, in the name of growth. The CEO was a mergers and acquisition specialist.
You can find their stated reasons for believing that growth was vital here: https://www.nominet.uk/the-case-for-growth/
« Without growth, we can’t innovate, and innovation is essential if we are to be ready for new technologies and emerging threats.
Without growth and innovation, we can’t keep our vital staff who connect more than 10 million .UK domains and maintain our service without disruption or downtime. »
I don't know whether they really believed these theories, or whether they really think of growth as an end in itself and were reaching for justifications, but the latter seems more likely to me.
People who do "growth" and "strategy" invariably seem to believe they're worth the big money, even if they're actually harming their organisations and lowering their effectiveness and survival prospects.
If they're as good as they think they are they should have no trouble selling their innovation elsewhere.
Handing humans a revenue stream and a dictate to "keep a steady hand on the tiller" seems prone to the same failure mode as asking a proverbial AI to "just make us some paperclips".
They had all of their growth and innovation, and couldn't keep their own basic website up (before being posted to HN) [1].
Presumably it was, as you say, a justification.
[1] https://twitter.com/444rrrggghhh/status/1374103065889026053
You pay yourself in excess when you think your business's ROIC will be poor/risky or your tenure will be short. These folks are either not very smart or just hypocrites.
Oh, they mad.
They got 70% over 4 years, this Haworth got 30% in the last year.
They're just rotating one group of people who leeched out their worth to replace them with some others who will do the same.
It's ironic that for a company that regards itself as critical infrastructure, their homepage/CMS didn't seem able to handle the traffic from people checking the EGM result. [1] (an hour before being posted to HN)
For a registrar that makes the case it is that important, it does seem like they ought to (for that executive compensation) have a website that can handle that level of traffic...
[1] https://twitter.com/444rrrggghhh/status/1374103065889026053
People who have 20 years of experience running core routers and backbone operations at globe-spanning international transit and transport ISPs that have thousands of POPs don't get paid anywhere near that figure. The complexity of an ISP on the scale of Telia, Level3 or NTT is far beyond a top level domain operator.
"Those supporting the vote are also unhappy at compensation paid to senior management. The website points to a 38 per cent drop in operating profit between 2016 and 2020, while at the same time the pay of the top three directors, who also sit on Nominet’s board, jumped 70 per cent, from £1m to £1.7m total. Last year, Haworth received a 30 per cent pay rise, bringing his annual compensation to £593,000."
https://www.theregister.com/2021/01/31/nominet_board_vote/