This is a danger but I'd rather have "controversial" than "if you deviate from the politics of the publication that pays your salary, you get fired".
Personally, I like Sullivan, Greenwald, Yglesias, Taibbi, etc.
I think Sullivan and Yglesias are not drama queens and that Geenwald and Tiabbi are. But I like all 4, I just think the latter two need a responsible editor to rein them in a bit.
Introverted and shy geniuses tend to be discovered after their deaths, if ever.
Frankly a similar thing has already happened in the art world. Banksy, Jeff Koons, and Damien Hirst are fantastic marketers, not artists.
Do you think there was really a time that being a really successful journalist didn't require some charisma and a talent for publicity? Maybe the publication handled some of those things, but it doesn't change that they were required.
It wasn't called "loss leader" for nothing.
At least with substack the incentives are not there for daily churn articles, the journalists have independence to publish when they want to, how they want to, worst case they lost subscribers. I think those incentives make them a lot less likely to make everything about clicks and controversy actually.
This is the same thing that was said about Youtube creators vs network/cable TV shows that follow a regular schedule. Before too long, it became clear that channels needed to post at least one video per week to keep up with their competition and boost subscriber numbers.
I expect the same thing to happen here.
Unfortunately not all journalists are completely clear which of those they are.
https://www.wired.com/story/journalism-isnt-dying-its-return...
It was an interesting counterpoint to the "journalists used to be objective" stuff.
Perhaps getting accurate facts about the world is also important?
Wen it came out in 1988, Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman’s Manufacturing Consent rattled the accepted view in post-Vietnam, post-Watergate America that journalists’ relationship to power was essentially adversarial. Instead, they argued, the institutional structure of American media — its dependence on corporate advertising and sources in the upper ranks of government and business — created a role for the press as creators of propaganda. Without any direct press censorship, with full freedom of speech, the media narrowed the political debate to exclude anything that offended the interests of the market or the state.
https://www.jacobinmag.com/2018/10/matt-taibbi-interview-fai...
Nazism was also a historical aberration, but that's certainly not worth keeping around. Just because some "good" things were historical aberrations, doesn't mean that all historical aberrations are "good".
> Perhaps getting accurate facts about the world is also important?
I don't think anybody disagrees with this. The central question is: is journalism the institution that should be responsible for getting accurate facts about the world? That's almost never been the case, and even today, isn't the case in most countries (including Western Europe). We typically use other institutions to suss out facts, including academia and peer-reviewed research. News articles published by mainstream outlets aren't peer-reviewed, and bias has existed in journalism since time immemorial. That was the point of my original response. Substack isn't "good" or "bad" for the future of journalism, it's "neutral", since it doesn't change the status quo all that much.
And were neither objective nor neutral, just a close alignment of elite interests reflected in homogeneity.
I guess it's cool that writers make more money, but I'm not sure this is as revolutionary as it seems.
The opposite seems more the case to me. Convincing readers to get out their wallet encourages more thoughtful, longer form writing.
It's the larger media publications that are gradually getting more clickbaity in a desperate bid to gain clicks and ad revenue.
I don't think something like Substack could even support journalism. Sure, it could support various kinds of punditry, which is often confused for journalism, but beat journalism is probably too boring and investigative journalism produces on too irregular of a schedule.
The people who tell you otherwise tend to be journalists.
That said, sensation driven journalism can be pretty good at checking the powerful, since it's sensational when they do bad things.
Most mayor news outlets (including NYT) run branded/sponsored content. I doubt that you will see that on substack.
Here it’s happening already: https://medialyte.substack.com/p/the-curious-emergence-of-th...
Certainly what I've seen from writers on substack is much worse than what I've seen from the same writers in traditional publications. It seems to be a great way of catapulting anyone who has achieved even a bit of name recognition into that “doesn’t have to deal with editors/publishers/etc.” phase of their career that's often the quality downfall as ego takes over for many writers, but which has historically been more available to writers doing long-form work.
World-improving journalism follows a Pareto distribution where 90% of non-submarine hard-hitting journalism is done by 10% of the journalists and the rest just exist to peddle influence. The industry has been under pressure for a long time due to the death of print media, and substack just represents the 10% cutting the fat.
Good riddance. Learn to code.
While Substack is portrayed as being a good move for writers and journalists (and certainly it is, financially), I don't think this is actually good for journalism as a whole. It often will just mean that successful writers are the most celebrity-like ones: writing controversial things because it gets more traffic and therefore more income.
I don't know about you, but I don't want the tactics of Kim Kardashian to be the model of a future journalist.