It's a nitpick, but the only irrationality that gets checked is unsustainable irrationality. It's a bit of a simplification to say that profits are actually "equilibrium irrationality," but not by much. If the market were actually composed of rational agents, all prices would be driven down to material cost + wages, and there'd be no need for advertising, either. Forces can, and in fact always do, push the market to irrationality. The only thing the market seems to do is moderate the degree of irrational excess.
I'm not really going anywhere with this. I just have a fascination with people's manifold faith in markets and their powers. It's interesting that "free market theory" flatters consumers (as rational) and benefits businesses (via consumer irrationality). I think that this is why the notion survives so well in popular culture.
(Micro)-Economics is much more like physics; here is how it tends to work, how it tends to optimize, how it tends to in practice actively subvert attempts to predict what it will do (and thereby actively resisting any attempt to create a macro-economic theory, or at least one that lasts for any period of time). It's a very physics-like definition of "efficiency". The fact that the dam broke in the most energy-efficient manner and the resulting water deluge can be modeled with a high degree of accuracy by assuming it will follow the least-energy course in an efficient manner doesn't make the resulting flood "good" or "desirable"... just... efficient.
On the other hand, start your economics model with anything else and it's like trying to rewrite physics starting with material ether or something. I have "faith in the markets" in much the same way I have faith in physics (which I will remind you contains a lot of similar "merely statistical" theories, what you learned in school is the aberration, not the rule, and also is really strong on the fundamentals and gets progressively weaker as the systems get larger, rather like economics), but that doesn't mean I blindly trust them. Physics will kill you without blinking. But if you want to prevent that, it's a lot better to come to understand the laws of physics than to try to create new rules for the universe by sheer force of denial. Trying to guide the physics while actively refusing to learn about it is doomed to failure, too. Same for microecon.
However, it's not efficient, since there is a lot you can do to make a better guess than assuming it is a completely random process.
While this will make it more efficient, there are plenty of people making random guesses, which reduces the effect your better guesses have on the overall efficiency of the market.
There are also plenty of fools, and they are investing on all sorts of techniques which ignore any of the global considerations, and of course this is how bubbles expand.
1.Mkt isn't like BM. BM permits -ve values & any market index say SPY must be non-negative.
2. We (quants) model market indices like SPY as a log-normal process like so : dS = rSdt + sigmaSdz where S = underlying ( or market index ) dS = change in S, dt = change in time r = risk free interest rate ( about 0.03 % currently ) dz = normally distributed rv with mean 0, std dev sigma
There is an embedded Brownian component in dz, so also in S. But that doesn't make S itself Brownian. More here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wiener_process
"No observer could possibly predict which direction it will jump next"
Nobody is trying to do that in the very next instant. OTOH, you can certainly predict where the market will go, say, in a year. Well known econ result: DP ratio regresses positively with return. ie. Dividend-price ratio predicts stock return with high statistical significance. Source: Cochrance, French/Fama, et al. http://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/3122601/campbells...
"there are plenty of people making random guesses...there are also plenty of fools, and they are investing on all sorts of techniques which ignore any of the global considerations, and of course this is how bubbles expand."
Ha ha ha! Very amusing but very inaccurate. I think this is my general problem with geeks on the outside of finance. They happen to think markets are purely stochastic. X has randomness doesn't mean X is unpredictable. Otherwise why have APT, CAPM, covariance matrices, factor models, Heath Jarrow, Black Litterman...you've written off some 100+ years of economics in one breath !
To summarize, there are tons of observers, who predict where the overall market or some portfolio of equities ( or bonds or agencies or munis or treasuries or whatever else ) will go. To get data points for these predictions, you use a historical time window, compute coVar matrices, invert them, build a CAPM....etc. Anyways, its not rocket science. There are tons of CFAs & Finmath engg ( I'm one of them ) who do this sort of work day in and day out. Its our bread & butter. If I said something like "market is a lot like brownian motion & people are making random guesses", I'd be out of a job.
That's one reason everybody models log-returns, which map non-negative prices onto the whole real line.
> 2. We (quants) model market indices like SPY as a log-normal process like so : dS = rSdt + sigmaSdz ... But that doesn't make S itself Brownian.
That's a geometric Brownian motion with drift. It is in fact the model developed by Louis Bachelier in his thesis of 1900 that presented the first mathematical description of Brownian motion.
Much of the argument you're trying to make can be made better, in my opinion, simply by pointing people to the Grossman-Stiglitz paradox [1]: markets cannot be fully informationally efficient or no one would have the incentive to provide information to them through trading.
1 - [PDF] http://www.math.ku.dk/kurser/2003-1/invfin/GrossmanStiglitz....
So are you saying you consistently outperform the market? If not, what are you 'modeling'? In 'science', a model is considered useful in how well it predicts the observations of some experiment, especially experiments on effects which were not known when the model was created. What do your bragged about models predict? What are they good for besides talking about with other quants?
I think a bunch of armchair analysts on this thread are going overboard with their predictions of imminent failure.
If I raised a few hundred million dollars, I could create a website where you went, and gave your credit card number. I would charge your card $1.00 and then credit your card $1.40. I would be Groupon, except I would be slightly more profitable.
Groupon believes they have a reliable fix on the Customer Lifetime Value. Some very smart investors who have done _actual_ analysis of Groupon (including the team that did due diligence for Google when they made the buyout offer earlier this year) clearly have at least some faith in these CLV numbers.
All of the "armchair analysis" you see here -- including your opinion on the subject -- is looking at a snapshot of Groupon from their S1 backward. That's fine but if you want to leave pro forma out of it, but then quit making pro forma statements about the failure and decay of the business!
All businesses are a money-multiplier machine, right? What you're complaining of is that by your analysis, that multiplier for Groupon is 0.72. Not a very good money machine at all really.
Suppose that when you factor in the CLV, that multiplier falls into the range you'd expect from a company that has low variable product costs and a large sales team: 1.21.
If you run that company, once you have enough data to really believe in the efficacy of those numbers, then you're going to do everything you can to purchase as many customers as possible. And if you're an investor, you're going to encourage management to do just that.
I mean, this is the very handbook on non-seed startup investing. Find a profitable CLV model, and scale it out.
But I'll give you this: you did a good job creating some outrageous, tongue-wagging scenarios.
You were saying that I was wrong, just look at their revenue. I replied, revenue doesn't mean anything, it's easy to build a giant revenue machine. Your point was crap. Now you are coming up with all sorts of other facts and analysis, which is certainly much more valuable than your original "just look at all that juicy revenue" argument. Again, I was pointing out how terrible and stupid the 'look at all that revenue' argument was by showing I could create another company with even more revenue that is even more worthless. If you have an issue with this, I would stop using revenue as a basis for anything since it is a shit indicator.
Again, GM has MASSIVE revenue, that has no bearing on how good of an investment it would be.
And that when I pulled out "other facts and analysis" -- like the fact that Groupon must feel they're doing the right thing by spending a ton of money to grow their customer base (duh) -- you've got nothing to say?
And you really think in your post that you were "showing you could create another company with even more revenue?" Because what you're missing is you made up a fantasy example and you're calling it a counterpoint. It had no merit and was nothing but empty calories.
But people are investing a lot of money in Groupon. And their revenue growth that you dismiss is no small part of that, Justin.
Do you have any idea how rare a billion dollar business is?
Look at my comment history. I've got a long history here of reasonable discussion. But you've brought nothing to the table here. You've made no cogent argument.
"To demonstrate the economics of our business model, we have compared the revenue and gross profit generated from the North American subscribers we acquired in the second quarter of 2010, which we refer to as our Q2 2010 cohort, to the online marketing expenses incurred to acquire such subscribers. The Q2 2010 cohort is illustrative of trends we have seen among our North American subscriber base. The Q2 2010 cohort included 3.7 million subscribers that we initially spent $18.0 million in online marketing to acquire in the second quarter of 2010. In that quarter, we generated $29.8 million in revenue and $12.8 million in gross profit from the sale of approximately 1.2 million Groupons to these subscribers. Through March 31, 2011, we generated an aggregate of $145.3 million in revenue and $61.7 million in gross profit from the sale of approximately 6.3 million Groupons to the Q2 2010 cohort. In summary, we spent $18.0 million in online marketing expense to acquire subscribers in the Q2 2010 cohort and generated $61.7 million in gross profit from this group of subscribers over four quarters."
They are seeing >3x profit on typical cohorts, so they decided to buy as many users as possible (which is smart).
And many of the startups then that DID post revenue were involved in quasi-illegal quid pro quo scams where Startup A invests in Startup B with the understanding that B will use that newfound capital to purchase from A.
The facts of the housing bubble were widely argued during the bubble itself, and yet after the crash, somehow, 'no one saw it coming'.
1. Hype (check)
2. IPO talk (check)
3. Turn down acquisition at incredibly high P/E (check)
4. Superbowl Advert (check)
5. IPO just in time to avoid running out of money (on the way)
6. Market goes rational (inevitable, forces pushing it irrational can't do so forever), valuation plumets
7. Unable to raise money by selling stock, and a business model of 'sell stock to pay bills while making no profit', bankruptcy is announced
8. The talking heads repeat the mantra "nobody saw it coming" for the next 6 months.