Re:Why Groupon Is Poised For Collapse
by jerf on Monday June 13, 2011 @05:46PM
(#2650856)
The "efficient market hypothesis" is broadly misunderstood. What it really says is something more like "a free market will strongly tend not to have easy arbitrage opportunities", not that it's guaranteed to produce a result that conforms to any particular person's goals for ideal societies or anything, not even free market advocates.
(Micro)-Economics is much more like physics; here is how it tends to work, how it tends to optimize, how it tends to in practice actively subvert attempts to predict what it will do (and thereby actively resisting any attempt to create a macro-economic theory, or at least one that lasts for any period of time). It's a very physics-like definition of "efficiency". The fact that the dam broke in the most energy-efficient manner and the resulting water deluge can be modeled with a high degree of accuracy by assuming it will follow the least-energy course in an efficient manner doesn't make the resulting flood "good" or "desirable"... just... efficient.
On the other hand, start your economics model with anything else and it's like trying to rewrite physics starting with material ether or something. I have "faith in the markets" in much the same way I have faith in physics (which I will remind you contains a lot of similar "merely statistical" theories, what you learned in school is the aberration, not the rule, and also is really strong on the fundamentals and gets progressively weaker as the systems get larger, rather like economics), but that doesn't mean I blindly trust them. Physics will kill you without blinking. But if you want to prevent that, it's a lot better to come to understand the laws of physics than to try to create new rules for the universe by sheer force of denial. Trying to guide the physics while actively refusing to learn about it is doomed to failure, too. Same for microecon.
(Micro)-Economics is much more like physics; here is how it tends to work, how it tends to optimize, how it tends to in practice actively subvert attempts to predict what it will do (and thereby actively resisting any attempt to create a macro-economic theory, or at least one that lasts for any period of time). It's a very physics-like definition of "efficiency". The fact that the dam broke in the most energy-efficient manner and the resulting water deluge can be modeled with a high degree of accuracy by assuming it will follow the least-energy course in an efficient manner doesn't make the resulting flood "good" or "desirable"... just... efficient.
On the other hand, start your economics model with anything else and it's like trying to rewrite physics starting with material ether or something. I have "faith in the markets" in much the same way I have faith in physics (which I will remind you contains a lot of similar "merely statistical" theories, what you learned in school is the aberration, not the rule, and also is really strong on the fundamentals and gets progressively weaker as the systems get larger, rather like economics), but that doesn't mean I blindly trust them. Physics will kill you without blinking. But if you want to prevent that, it's a lot better to come to understand the laws of physics than to try to create new rules for the universe by sheer force of denial. Trying to guide the physics while actively refusing to learn about it is doomed to failure, too. Same for microecon.