Consider: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-03-10/wall-stre...
For one, how would they even put capital movements controls on crypto? For example, I just have to remember my 12 word seed and I can hop on a plane to another country and my crypto comes with me.
The other part is, wouldn't those capital controls be the last nail in the coffin of "we lost complete control of the situation"?
That might be harder to find than you think, or might require a significant haircut on the conversion.
It’s like cash but even more effective for this purpose.
The real problem with bitcoin is you cannot physically transfer it. I can sell you a USB drive with a wallet on it, but you shouldn't buy it because you can't know if I have a copy of that USB drive in my other pocket. The only way to transfer bitcoin for-real is to submit it to the network and to make sure it's confirmed.
My take is that the censorship-resistant qualities of bitcoin are highly overstated.
Since the ledger is public, if the government knows which wallet is linked to you (easy if you’ve done KYC in order to use an exchange), they could also sanction any wallets that transact with your wallet, severely limiting who will be willing to do P2P/otc with you
I'm not convinced. Your scenario relies on people having some deep conviction about the value and usefulness of cryptocurrencies. I think that this is true only for a very small vocal minority of users/buyers. Most people just want to make easy money with it - that's why I think heavy regulation/bans will simply crash the prices instead of leading to a Streisand effect.
Government can very easily control almost all of those channels.
It’s like cash but even more effective for this purpose.
It’s like cash but even more effective for this purpose.
Regarding localbitcoins or other OTC in person deals I certainly wouldn't want to meet with a stranger and carry $1000 with me in cash to buy his Bitcoins. And localbitcoins was forced to implement KYC, so if Bitcoin gets outlawed or heavily taxed, the state will have a look into their customers.
There are 195 different nations on earth. That leaves a lot more options than the EU, Japan, and China.
A lot of crypto-expats are going to carribean island nations.
Are they going to buy Lamborghinis in pesos? More seriously, yes, some people are content with living like a rich native in the global south but for anyone else who plans to participate in the global economy (and I assume they do, because capital controls would likely only affect high net worth individuals), they would need to convert to EUR/JPY/CNY/USD.
No.
I don't know if gold is under threat, but there's certainly historical precedent for it, as mentioned in the article.
For Bitcoin, India and China have both been taking small steps toward limiting or banning it. Western media and influential figures (Bill Gates) have been recently talking about how wasteful it is.
No matter your arguments on either topic, the fact remains that governments can limit their own citizenry, by threat of force, from transacting with any instrument.
In fact, if crypto were used more as money in the real economy, banning it would have the reverse effect, shrinking the amount of money in the economy.
https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-india-cryptocurrency-ban/...
The financial picture Dalio paints is the first stage of this, but it merges with a lot of other trends to make something horrible. There's the ongoing migration crisis; conditions are becoming inhospitable in areas like Central America and the Middle East, which is driving migrants to developed nations like the U.S. and Europe and destabilizing those countries. There's the climate crisis, which is the root cause of the migration crisis. There's a trust crisis propagated by the Internet and Big Tech, where nobody knows what to believe anymore. There's a pending military technology shift where cheap autonomous weaponry fundamentally changes the power balance between large nation states and small insurgencies. And then there's a population that's just fed up, as evidenced by the Capitol Riots and lockdown protests (as well as plenty of Internet vitriol).
Unfortunately fleeing the U.S. won't do anything for this, because if the U.S. goes, the whole world will erupt in flames. Better to put down roots in a community whose values you agree with, ideally one in a well-defensible location with plenty of natural resources.
I'm also not sure that 50 years from now, the Capital Riot will be recorded as being a majorly significant event in US history. It'll probably be mentioned in history books but I'm doubtful it'll be referred to as a pivot point in US history.
Migration crisis: I feel there's been larger migration events in the past. Doubtful the climate crisis will actually be creating a massive scale migration crisis.
I do think climate change will change the dynamic in various areas.
I otherwise also agree on the paradigm shift in military technology.
Things like sea level rise, rising temperatures, and more frequent blizzards or cold snaps act over decades. That'll be a gradual shift in migration patterns, not a crisis.
But a lot of the second-order effects operate on much smaller timescales. Hurricanes can cause large dislocation on the timescale of a week: look at Rita & Katrina in 2005, which cut the population of New Orleans in half and gridlocked all the freeways out of Houston for days. Wildfires also can trigger large migrations within a matter of weeks. We've been lucky that most of the West Coast wildfires have been in relatively unpopulated areas, but if one were ever to jump highway 280 in the Bay Area or get into the Pasadena/Glendale/Burbank area by LA, we could have a mass evacuation crisis. Crop failures too: that's what's driving a lot of the Middle East migration. If it happened in the U.S. or China millions of people would starve.
There's also violence caused by resource constraints. We see that in Central America now, in the Middle East, and increasingly in the middle of U.S. cities.
The other major factor is a demographic crisis: worldwide, we have a large bulge in the number of people who are just about hitting 30 in 2020. Historically, when a lot of people reach reproductive years and there aren't the resources needed to support all of them having families, violence and social instability tends to result. This has been predictable since all these kids were born in the 90s, but obviously I'd hoped it'd go differently and technology would find some way to alleviate resource limits. Now we're here and seeing all the discontent from peoples' lives not turning out quite how they envisioned as kids.
Nevertheless, we know from history that these events do occur, and they occur much more frequently than those of us alive now believe (again a form of survivorship bias - folks that don't live in a time of peace tend not to survive). The 250-year stability of the United States - and the 75-year Pax Americana after WW2 - is a historical anomaly. The article gives a bunch of reasons why the 2020s will be different, financially, from the 1980-2020 period, and I gave a bunch of reasons why it'll be different sociopolitically. You can choose to believe them or not, but I (and Dalio) at least explained the dynamics that lead me to believe them.
It would seem to me that this shift towards remote weapons would favor the military, not insurgents in the event of civil strife.
Shrinking the weapon system usually results in physics limitations on range and speed - a 20-ton plane can carry enough fuel to go 2000 miles, but a 1 kg drone might have enough charge to go 2 miles. This favors the defender and prevents the use of these weapons for power-projection. Drone swarms are great for close air support, field defense, and urban warfare, but you can't do precision strikes across a continent (but you can defend against precision strikes, as long as your drones are accurate enough to intercept a missile). That fundamentally changes the balance of power toward smaller political entities.
The transistor is the only physical process that I know of that has improved at that pace. What makes you think drones can improve to that magnitude?
Your perspective on this seems to be a bit U.S.-centric. No developed country in the world botched its national response to Covid-19 as badly as the United States did. In several countries — like Australia and New Zealand — public trust in government has grown as the public benefited greatly from its government’s world class results in handling the Covid pandemic.
Granted, it does seem that most people these days consider their own government to be at the very least incompetent. But I don’t get the sense countries like Australia have anywhere near the same level of anti-government resentment to contend with. It seems to me a good deal of the blame for the dysfunction of modern America falls on American culture.
> There's the climate crisis, which is the root cause of the migration crisis.
I’d think quality of life factors and economic opportunity would be the primary drivers for migration from the global south to North America and Western Europe. Am I misreading your take on this? It’s a bit of a leap to pin it all onto climate change.
Some runners-up included the Bay Area & Coastal California (easily defensible & fertile, but has overpopulation, water issues and limited timber), the Great Salt Lake valley (ditto), and the Colorado & Wyoming foothills (pretty dry, but a great mining/oil shale area). The worst areas were in the Southwest (which already has a migrant crisis and is going to get totally screwed by global warming) and the Great Lakes area (overpopulated relative to its natural carrying capacity).
Suburbia could be a decent place, if the population density is low enough and it's surrounded by arable land and resources. Livermore, for example, wouldn't be a bad place. But the rows upon rows of tract houses (say San Jose or LA) would become a miserable place without the rest of society to support it, as would the inner cities. I think that the ideal density would be a small self-contained city of say 50-80K people: small enough to maintain social cohesion, but large enough to support some division of labor and have enough of a workforce to support & defend the region.
My own answer is Delta/Montrose, Colorado. It has water, good farmland, nearby mountains (timber) and coal fields. You could even do some hydro power from the river. It's somewhat defensible - an attacker would have to cross a fair amount of inhospitable terrain to get there, unless they came from the south, and the San Juans would not be that difficult to defend.
The one issue would be oil - there's oilfields around Aztec, New Mexico, but that's kind of a long way in a collapsed society.
As a city-dweller, your strategy for surviving this is to join one. As a wealthy suburb dweller, you better hope you have a private security advantage where you can kill the whole mob before it kills you. As a rural dweller, your strategy is to be far enough away, high enough up, and insignificant enough that it's not worth going after you. Gas will be in short supply after a collapse; it's not worth driving 100 miles to take food from a farm that you don't know exists. Most of the towns and small cities in the regions I mentioned are easily that far away from the nearest city.
It's pretty likely that the dominant political organization after a national collapse would be city-states. However, that doesn't mean that it's best for an individual to be within them. We might see 75% depopulation within cities, but people in rural areas can go on about their normal business, if they don't get conquered entirely by the local city. It's a choice between living in privilege in the aftermath of the collapse but having a good chance of not making it there, vs. a higher chance of survival but you'll be a vassal state to the local city.
The driver of that is more like unfree markets which always result in mass poverty and misery.
The United States is the only major power with a strong ideological belief in unrestricted capital flows. The EU and China have both implemented capital controls in the modern era, sometimes repeatedly. (U.K. currently stands out, too.) All it takes is a populist “the rich are fleeing with their capital” trope to take hold on the far left and/or the right, and the centre to crumble, for such policy to become politically palatable. At that point, there really isn’t anyone else defending free market capitalism.
Put another way, do you really think you couldn’t get a lot of people in e.g. San Francisco to sign onto a mandate that requires the rich to register outgoing capital flows?
Doesn't seem that way for citizens considering we still have to pay US taxes when living abroad (there are some tax agreements but still), have to pay an exit tax if we want to renounce our citizenship, and the US requires foreign banks to report US citizens assets to the US government.
I don't like it, but the US is free to decide to want to tax their citizens even if the income is earned outside the borders - and they have the capability to enforce it.
Your example is poor; there are 10s of millions of people in California who have been trying to get healthcare reform passed for nearly a decade now and the trend so far has been Obamacare being slowly unwound. It's unclear if the far left/right is anything more than a boogeyman at this point considering the glacier pace of the Senate in the last 20 years. The media would have you believe the democrats are well on their way full blown communism, but the reality is the party self-sabotaged their own $15 minimum wage proposal and managed to be less generous than Trump on stimulus checks.
If the Federal Reserve decided to implement capital controls, I doubt it would happen democratically. It's more likely that you would wake up one day and all the major banks would have limits on how much gold you could purchase in a year for "liability reasons". I'm sure a Senator or two would scream, but the next week there would be the next culture war story with Ted Cruz complaining about MTV.
I was responding to "who...believes this is a likely scenario?" The argument isn't "this will happen." Just that it shouldn't be beyond the pale of reasonable debate. (Like universal healthcare.)
> If the Federal Reserve decided to implement capital controls, I doubt it would happen democratically
Capital controls are populist. They shift power away from the wealthy to those at the political levers. The Fed would almost certainly not do this; the Treasury could under emergency powers. The potential for popular support would give them cover to do so.
No? Capital controls in western history is hardly populist. When I think of populist economic movements, the Bretton Woods System doesn't come to mind. And it's clear China's capital control serve to keep power in the hands of the autocracy; not the other way around.
If the value of the dollar was spiraling to zero it's the Fed, and their clients, that would have the most to lose.
This belief in ideological attachment to policy sounds so silly to me. It can change and it can change quite quickly in fact. It's like saying the US has a strong ideological belief in democracy that guides all it's geopolitical moves abroad.
> so they could very well impose prohibitions against capital movements to other assets (e.g., gold, Bitcoin, etc.) and other locations. These tax changes could be more shocking than expected.
Who truly believes this is a likely scenario? A number of folks I know are already considering fleeing the US but if this was to pass, that number would skyrocket and I can't imagine a good outcome in the next few decades from capital flight in the US.