News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by rawtxapp on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:26AM (#26486525)
This was the part that caught my attention as well, it would be super interesting to see it play in real-time.

For one, how would they even put capital movements controls on crypto? For example, I just have to remember my 12 word seed and I can hop on a plane to another country and my crypto comes with me.

The other part is, wouldn't those capital controls be the last nail in the coffin of "we lost complete control of the situation"?

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by jljljl on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:34AM (#26486576)
If the USG (or Europe, or China) still have a strong military, or a lot of influence over the financial sector at that point, you may have a tough time finding a bank to convert your crypto into Fiat. At that point, you’d have to find a country that accepts Bitcoin directly as a payment method or whose financial system can shrug off regulations.

That might be harder to find than you think, or might require a significant haircut on the conversion.

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by randomopining on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:06AM (#26492234)
Can you not just go p2p/otc with the crypto and buy a hard asset plus some paper fiat?

It’s like cash but even more effective for this purpose.

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by nickysielicki on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:24AM (#26492514)
If cryptocurrency exchanges don't exist in good public standing, the price of bitcoin will collapse. This is a risk that does not exist with precious metals.

The real problem with bitcoin is you cannot physically transfer it. I can sell you a USB drive with a wallet on it, but you shouldn't buy it because you can't know if I have a copy of that USB drive in my other pocket. The only way to transfer bitcoin for-real is to submit it to the network and to make sure it's confirmed.

My take is that the censorship-resistant qualities of bitcoin are highly overstated.

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by jljljl on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:42PM (#26494508)
The problem is that if you can’t easily convert it, the OTC price is going to plummet.

Since the ledger is public, if the government knows which wallet is linked to you (easy if you’ve done KYC in order to use an exchange), they could also sanction any wallets that transact with your wallet, severely limiting who will be willing to do P2P/otc with you

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by JohnJamesRambo on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @03:22AM (#26487591)
The minute they try to impose those controls on crypto is the ultimate Streisand Effect moment that will confirm to everyone that they definitely need this asset. I suspect this is why they have avoided it so far.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by beforeolives on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @05:48AM (#26488739)
> The minute they try to impose those controls on crypto is the ultimate Streisand Effect moment that will confirm to everyone that they definitely need this asset.

I'm not convinced. Your scenario relies on people having some deep conviction about the value and usefulness of cryptocurrencies. I think that this is true only for a very small vocal minority of users/buyers. Most people just want to make easy money with it - that's why I think heavy regulation/bans will simply crash the prices instead of leading to a Streisand effect.

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by SyzygistSix on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:12AM (#26492328)
No, they just have to have more faith in it than than other assets. Which becomes easier when states make moves indicating they have lost control.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by bluecalm on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @05:25AM (#26488492)
I think they avoided it because they were asleep at the wheel when it started getting traction and now limiting it would make a lot of people angry. It's a mess of epic proportions. It's probably the best strategy for regulators to wait for some major collapse (like Tether being exposed as a scam) and use that to introduce counter measures. Meanwhile the negative sum arm race continues sucking more people in.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by dash2 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:24AM (#26491653)
The Indian government is going to ban it entirely. I'm unconvinced that many Indian investors will want to hold on to an asset which can land them in jail.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by missedthecue on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @08:48AM (#26490319)
Bitcoin is only useful if you can turn it into fiat relatively easily.

Government can very easily control almost all of those channels.

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by chii on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @09:37AM (#26491016)
in the world where you have heavy capital control, enough to warrant using crypto to escape, the fiat will be worthless to you (hence the capital control!), and thus, others will be willing to accept your crypto instead of fiat!
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by randomopining on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:06AM (#26492235)
Can you not just go p2p/otc with the crypto and buy a hard asset plus some paper fiat?

It’s like cash but even more effective for this purpose.

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by thebean11 on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:42AM (#26491922)
Presumably you'd be going into a country that is not attempting to control those channels though
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by emodendroket on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @02:11PM (#26494865)
So, assuming the USG is serious about this, you're probably looking at China, Iran, Russia, Venezuela, or North Korea. Color me skeptical that the captains of industry are headed there.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by pestatije on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @12:44AM (#26486638)
Well, if they impose such restrictions (I agree that's very unlikely), how much do you think your crypto will be worth then?
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by kebman on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @01:35AM (#26486976)
Depends. Corpors might want to offload, but then again perhaps not, since it would still be valuable in countries that chose to not impose restrictions. Then there's the ability to avoid middle men (both authorities and bankers) while making trades and purchases abroad. For everyone else, it matters little, unless they really need to get on a plane, and fast. But then whatever assets you have to trade for that seat matters less anyway.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by iSnow on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:02AM (#26491369)
The fiat on/off-ramps are the choke points of the whole crypto world. Yes, you could use your BTC to buy Teslas and drugs, but that's it. You can't pay at the supermarket or on the web directly, it all goes through payment providers who are regulated.
Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by randomopining on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:07AM (#26492240)
Can you not just go p2p/otc with the crypto and buy a hard asset plus some paper fiat?

It’s like cash but even more effective for this purpose.

Re:Why in the world would you own bonds? by iSnow on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @11:15AM (#26492373)
Someone needs to cash it out in the end to buy raw materials or bulk purchase food. That's the idea of hyper-Bitcoinization that this step would go away, but I don't see any indication for that.

Regarding localbitcoins or other OTC in person deals I certainly wouldn't want to meet with a stranger and carry $1000 with me in cash to buy his Bitcoins. And localbitcoins was forced to implement KYC, so if Bitcoin gets outlawed or heavily taxed, the state will have a look into their customers.