Think of it this way, this has no practical implementation and does not solve the engineering problems we have right now but it might lead to a different yet related discovery down the line which we will solve a different problem in 10-20 years. Yes for us engineer this seems like a pointless (very stupid!) endeavour, but in practice that's just how research works. Scientist will explore ideas that are not necessarily feasible or useful and create building blocks for future research.
Not everyone in energy storage has to work on designing new alloys for anodes and cathodes otherwise we'd stagnate. We need the fringe and very stupid ideas as well.
I'm not familiar with this specific instance but GP's point is exactly the sort of technical oversight or omission I'd expect.
Maybe same OP is tired of imposter-type execs here on HN being super-positive about media-regurtitated ideas and bombastic headlines, so he opened a troll account where he doesn't need to be all appologetic and polite and just tell it like it is.
Surely there's a more respectful way to criticize the idea.
I don't know, he didn't call the person who had the idea stupid, he called the idea itself stupid. Sure, it's harsh, but so what? The idea isn't going to get offended.
To add fuel to the off-topic grammar pedantry fire: "Stupidly phrased" applies "stupid" to the phraser, not the phrasee. So no, you did in fact call them stupid, not their comment.
I mean, fine, if we're going to be grammar nerds, let's do it. "Stupidly" is an adverb. It applies to the act of phrasing not the subject doing that verb. At the moment that the person was doing the phrasing, they were doing something in a stupid manner, but that doesn't necessarily imply that they are themselves generally stupid.
For example, I can "randomly choose a card from a deck." That doesn't imply that I'm a particularly random person.
A quick search reveals no mention of CO2 Poisoning for hydrogen fuel-cells, but a majority mention of carbon monoxide poisoning. An additional search reveals catalysts that rectify this issue as early as 2005.
Storage technology is capable of powering cities. Heck, the largest grid storage sites in the US are for backing up nuclear power plants on the East Coast (matching day/night loads with baseload supply). This silly infighting between different clean energy technologies (storage, nuclear, renewables) needs to stop.
Or maybe they care enough about climate change to not make another long-term mistake out as the solution, only to then have to repeat a very similar situation a few decades from now.
Increase the use of fission reactors and you will also increase the frequency of catastrophic events, it will increase the production of waste we still have no real way to reliably deal with, very comparable to the emissions we pumped in the atmosphere because "whatever could go wrong with that". We've been handling nuclear in a similar irresponsible short-sighted way for way too long [0].
So while fission might be a tempting solution to the climate change problem, it also has very real potential to become the very next problem we burden future generations with.
Is exchanging one long-term debt for another really that useful of a solution, or shouldn't we rather look for actually innovative and sustainable solutions?
What is your idea of a "real way to reliably deal with waste"? Waste in general is stored or burned all over the world. Nuclear waste is best stored, at NPPs or at dedicated sites. Which is already done since the beginning. It is a non problem.
Nuclear PR is top notch. It's because it's 2-3x the cost of other renewables.
In most other fields that would put it out of the running entirely.
Better storage would be nice but for now at least, every MWh generated by solar and wind is a MWh not generated by a gas fired power plant.
The reason it doesn't get an even harder time than it already does is because nuclear powers like the US and UK like to keep reactors and know how close at hand for military purposes.
People won't say this out loud, however. It's all about fixing global warming any way we can all the way. "Why not use a mix of sources?"
The messaging only does a 180 when it's a designated enemy trying to build a nuclear power station. Then the default assumption is that it's a cover for building out military capabilities.
This is mainly why the UK agreed to pay an inflation adjusted £93 per MwH for non dispatchable nuclear power in 5 years and £33-40 for solar/wind now. The ability to threaten nuclear annihilation matters to many governments, and nuclear reactors are useful to have around for that purpose.
Cost should always be a consideration, but when people conveniently ignore some costs and focus on others, it does a disservice to the goal of decarbonizing the grid and it isn't clear what they are really trying to accomplish.
The levelized cost for residential rooftop solar is about as high as nuclear, but that cost doesn't seem to matter to some advocates and they continue to support subsidizing it. The potential costs for renewables + storage is about the cost of nuclear, but that cost also doesn't matter to some advocates. (If grid storage was cheap, we would have built it decades ago.)
https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...
Some advocates recommend massively overbuilding solar or wind to deal with seasonal differences. This is obviously at least a cost multiplier but that doesn't seem to matter to some advocates.
Advocates also describe how we will rebuild the electrical grid to move vast amounts of solar or wind power across the USA. This will not be cheap, simple or easy to protect against terrorism. Even the relatively small proposed Tres Amigas super station hasn’t been completed yet. The potential costs here don't seem to matter to some advocates.
Advocates for renewables seem happy with relying on natural gas peaker plants where necessary to get around the costs of building grid storage, but methane is a very potent GHG in the short term. There are lots of methane losses in its capture and distribution. No one concerned about climate change seriously thinks that burning natural gas is a long term answer.
It is possible there will be some major advances in grid storage that will allow us to stop using natural gas to cover for the intermittent nature of wind and solar. In that case - great! But... what if that doesn't pan out? The dangers we are facing in the coming decades are immense. If you were forced to choose, would you prefer the world to suffer through catastrophic climate change rather than use nuclear power?
Civilian power reactors themselves are of limited value for military purposes, particularly light water moderated ones. It's certainly true that maintaining a nuclear industry and the technical and operational knowledge is cross subsidised from civilian power generation.
> non dispatchable nuclear power
What definition are you using for dispatchable here? Because in my understanding nuclear power is generally considered dispatchable power generation.
The kind used in nuclear submarines?
>It's certainly true that maintaining a nuclear industry and the technical and operational knowledge is cross subsidised
It's the main reason nuclear reactors exist at all, and why theyre predominantly built by countries with nuclear arsenals or aspirations.
They've never been particularly cheap, and while they haven't gone up in cost, they're relatively more expensive than theyve ever been. This is why public support is even more critical for their survival, which is why there's about 1 pro nuclear propaganda article per week popping to the top of hacker news each week. The military industrial complex is spooked.
>What definition are you using for dispatchable here?
It takes hours to scale up production of a nuclear plant and seconds for a gas fired plant:
From your link "Although theoretically dispatchable, coal and nuclear thermal plants are designed to run as base load power plants".
Dispatchable means the power is available when it is needed. Not when it is available i.e. when the wind is blowing or the sun is shining.
Modern nuclear reactors incorporate grey rods which allow them to be used in a limited load following capacity.
Unlike gas.
Does a business that delivers a meal to you only with 24 hours notice count as a restaurant? Theoretically yes.
In reality, power coming from nuclear power plants is very predictable, this makes it easy to incorporate into the grid energy mix. Nuclear power has many problems but this isn't one.
So when we really need a "green" party they're filled with zealots who're unable see the harm reduction tradeoffs that needs to be done.
But I have never heard any nuclear advocate give them any credit for this. It required a fair bit of political capital, given then (then) recent meltdown at Fukushima. Maybe a little less complaining about 'green zealots' and a little more humility about nuclear's negative externalities would improve cooperation.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Pla...
The US 2 party system makes the US one mostly irrelevant.
But in countries like Germany and Sweden where more parties are in parliament, they have over time had the chance to apply influence over time to the extent where nuclear power is really on it's last straws despite the only reasonable replacement during winters is fossil fuels.
https://www.gp.org/green_new_deal (US) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alliance_90/The_Greens#Energy_... (Germany) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Party_(Sweden)
I was clearly referring to the likes of the actual US Green party I linked previously for whose the US presidential election candidate was Howie Hawkins that has an explicit policy document stating that Nuclear power should be abolished (no idea what the democratic "green new deal" includes but it's hopefully less nutters).
Harrisburg was quite important global factor in most of these parties history worldwide in the sense that the accident was the spark that bought early technohostile environmentalists into action to create these parties in the years following the accident.
You can find a list of the parties since they seem to have global cooperation organisation (the map on the page also shows where they are in parliament)
I'm pretty sure if there was enough desire for nuclear from politicians and commercial interests, the public could be convinced.
I think we should support nuclear. But my biggest reasons for being negative towards a big push for nuclear, is that nuclear doesn't really solve our problems. It only solves part of the grid electricity problem, and probably only for major industrial countries. We still need massive improvements in energy storage solutions and renewable hydrogen/ammonia/synfuel production for transportation, industry and farming. If you solve those problems, you've also solved energy balancing of renewables. Since renewables seems to be scaling faster, the logical answer is to focus 95% of efforts on renewables and energy storage/conversion. Keep nuclear R&D at a low but sustainable level. Then we can start to convert some of the wind/solar farms to nuclear down the line. Hopefully with small modular reactors that'd be easier to mass-produce.
That is, if you assume we'll need nuclear power, you're basically assuming we're not going to solve the climate crisis.
But seriously, don't shut down existing nuclear reactors unless it's absolutely necessary. That's just dumb.
> That is, if you assume we'll need nuclear power, you're basically assuming we're not going to solve the climate crisis.
How on earth does this make sense? The country that has come closest to solving the climate crisis (France) is heavily nuclear. Their carbon intensity of electricity is 1/7th that of Germany.
Another claim I see regularly: Angela Merkel decided on the German nuclear exit as a response to Fukushima and she permanently shut down all reactors.
When in reality Merkel tried to draw out and prolong a nuclear exit that was already decided and ratified in the early 2000s and Germany still has fission reactors running to this day.
Aluminum fuel cells have a slow energy discharge rate, largely due to the Oxigen-Reduction Rate (ORR) limit, even when the air Cathode is doped in exotic catalysts such as Platinum.
Furthermore, fuel-cell Electrodes, be it an Aluminum-air or Hydrogen-air fuel-cell, suffer from "CO2 Poisoning", which makes their efficiency drop in open air.
Not commercialy viable.