Think of it this way, this has no practical implementation and does not solve the engineering problems we have right now but it might lead to a different yet related discovery down the line which we will solve a different problem in 10-20 years. Yes for us engineer this seems like a pointless (very stupid!) endeavour, but in practice that's just how research works. Scientist will explore ideas that are not necessarily feasible or useful and create building blocks for future research.
Not everyone in energy storage has to work on designing new alloys for anodes and cathodes otherwise we'd stagnate. We need the fringe and very stupid ideas as well.
I'm not familiar with this specific instance but GP's point is exactly the sort of technical oversight or omission I'd expect.
Maybe same OP is tired of imposter-type execs here on HN being super-positive about media-regurtitated ideas and bombastic headlines, so he opened a troll account where he doesn't need to be all appologetic and polite and just tell it like it is.