Re:Seasonal energy storage in aluminium for 100% solar heat ...
by sir_bearington on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:16PM
(#26478822)
I'm not sure I follow. The fact that a nuclear grid doesn't require storage is precisely why it's so much better. In order to make renewables viable we'd need to redirect a huge portion of our storage capacity away from electric vehicles and towards grid storage instead.
> That is, if you assume we'll need nuclear power, you're basically assuming we're not going to solve the climate crisis.
How on earth does this make sense? The country that has come closest to solving the climate crisis (France) is heavily nuclear. Their carbon intensity of electricity is 1/7th that of Germany.
Re:Seasonal energy storage in aluminium for 100% solar heat ...
by tstrimple on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:33PM
(#26479074)
It's always funny to me how proponents of nuclear power use France as their example while ignoring that France is trying to dramatically reduce the amount of nuclear power they have because it's too expensive. If you're going to use them as an example, let's use them as a full example instead of just trying to paint a rosy picture on a nuanced subject.
Re:Seasonal energy storage in aluminium for 100% solar heat ...
by freeflight on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @01:36PM
(#26480105)
There's just so much misinformation about nuclear out there it's kind of crazy.
Another claim I see regularly: Angela Merkel decided on the German nuclear exit as a response to Fukushima and she permanently shut down all reactors.
When in reality Merkel tried to draw out and prolong a nuclear exit that was already decided and ratified in the early 2000s and Germany still has fission reactors running to this day.
Re:Seasonal energy storage in aluminium for 100% solar heat ...
by posix_me_less on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:53PM
(#26479397)
The GP point is valid. France production is much cleaner thanks to nuclear energy. Whether nuclear energy being "too expensive" is actually a relevant problem in this discussion depends on your ideas about the role of government, importance of the CO2 reduction, importance of big private profits and so on.
Re:Seasonal energy storage in aluminium for 100% solar heat ...
by sir_bearington on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:51PM
(#26479356)
Emphasis on "trying". They aren't actually reducing nuclear production because renewables can't replace it.
Re:Seasonal energy storage in aluminium for 100% solar heat ...
by posix_me_less on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:46PM
(#26479288)
Nuclear energy solves one pretty big problem: the need for coal and gas power plants. Big fat proportion of CO2 and other toxic stuff is released to atmosphere at those power plants.
I'm pretty sure if there was enough desire for nuclear from politicians and commercial interests, the public could be convinced.
I think we should support nuclear. But my biggest reasons for being negative towards a big push for nuclear, is that nuclear doesn't really solve our problems. It only solves part of the grid electricity problem, and probably only for major industrial countries. We still need massive improvements in energy storage solutions and renewable hydrogen/ammonia/synfuel production for transportation, industry and farming. If you solve those problems, you've also solved energy balancing of renewables. Since renewables seems to be scaling faster, the logical answer is to focus 95% of efforts on renewables and energy storage/conversion. Keep nuclear R&D at a low but sustainable level. Then we can start to convert some of the wind/solar farms to nuclear down the line. Hopefully with small modular reactors that'd be easier to mass-produce.
That is, if you assume we'll need nuclear power, you're basically assuming we're not going to solve the climate crisis.
But seriously, don't shut down existing nuclear reactors unless it's absolutely necessary. That's just dumb.