News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by gnramires on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @08:50AM (#26476014)
Indeed, I were once skeptical (remembering EEVBlog's Solar Roadways series) but it really seems a good deal. Short commutes in cities can probably be covered. And a killer feature to me: if you ever get stranded somewhere without power, you at least have the option to wait a day or two to charge and get to somewhere nearby with power (around 3 miles/day for ioniq, 10 miles/day average for sion according to the articles).

Of course, smaller cars will probably have a better surface-energy consumption ratio, I don't expect to make much of a range difference for larger and utility vehicles. It's something I'd add to offroad vehicles just for the cool factor (of independence), even if the range added per day isn't significant in that case.

Re:Electric car that charges itself by samcheng on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @09:17AM (#26476286)
I'm an electric car driver, and I'm still skeptical.

It's hard to imagine a scenario where I accidentally run out of batteries and then can afford to wait for MULTIPLE DAYS before finishing my trip. Pretty sure I'd at least want to get a tow to the nearest gas station, where they would be able to plug me in if necessary. Even a plain old 120V 15A plug has much more power than solar, and works overnight...

Re:Electric car that charges itself by stonemetal12 on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @09:48AM (#26476622)
The only plus I can see is that if you leave your car at the airport for a week or some other long term parking situation, you don't come back to a dead battery.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by Kirby64 on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @09:57AM (#26476727)
Assuming you aren't parked underground. Many airport parking lots are multi-tiered parking garages for density. Sure, you can park on the roof, but maybe rooftop becomes the more 'coveted' spot if this did take off.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by mikestew on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @11:58AM (#26478519)
Over the past twelve months our Leaf has sat for weeks at a time without being driven. It has never failed to “start”. When it sits at the airport, it sits in the charger spot with all the other EVS.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by eldaisfish on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @09:59AM (#26476749)
Many large airports and certainly the majority of airports in large metropolitan areas have underground or covered parking.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by mbreese on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @10:57AM (#26477548)
Most still have the large extended parking lots that are a bit further away. Those are always large outdoor lots, even at a place like SFO. These are more geared towards the longer term parking scenario the parent post referred to.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by bdamm on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @11:47AM (#26478381)
Normal EVs can sit for a week and not have a dead battery. There is some value to having that trickle charge but not a ton. IIRC there was a solar powered Prius where the panel powered a cabin fan and that kinda makes sense.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by bin_bash on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @09:56AM (#26476711)
You'd have to remember to park on the roof!
Re:Electric car that charges itself by vermontdevil on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @03:02PM (#26481335)
Airports have 24/7 service to jump start your car etc.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by jjav on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @07:27PM (#26484572)
You can't exactly jump start an electric car.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by arghwhat on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @09:58AM (#26476740)
> It's hard to imagine a scenario where I accidentally run out of batteries and then can afford to wait for MULTIPLE DAYS before finishing my trip.

In a lot of places, it's either keep moving or hope someone finds you fast enough. Not all roads are within throwing distance of a town or city.

In more common cases, it might be enough to cover limited driving (I think it might be able to cover my current car utilization in full), or at least offload the grid a bit. And in remote locations with limited or no power, it'll give occasional driving capabilities.

Re:Electric car that charges itself by dmos62 on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @09:45AM (#26476589)
It's not about substituting charging stations. It's about getting _part_ of your energy requirements from the panels. Check the figures in the grandfather comment: energy gains are in the ballpark of 1000 miles / year.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by Twirrim on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @11:42AM (#26478312)
> energy gains are in the ballpark of 1000 miles / year

That's not a small amount. The US DoT puts average US driving at around 13,500 miles/year. In Germany (Sono Motor's home market) it's 8,000.

So we're talking meeting nearly 7.5% of US, and 12.5% of German, average driving needs. Just from sticking a solar panel on the roof of a vehicle.

Re:Electric car that charges itself by ryathal on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @10:12AM (#26491477)
That's absolute best case for panels producing peak power at all daylight hours. 500 miles/year is more likely for a car parked outdoors away from shade during all daylight hours, based solely on panels not being at peak production. Then there are cloudy days, shaded spots, garages, tunnels, overpasses, dirt, bird poop. Then there is the difference between estimated miles and actual miles based on real driving habits. Then you have to consider any potential body damage that could occur, that will at best reduce the solar gains and at worst render the system useless or total the car.

If a car in a real scenario get more than 3% of it's miles from these panels I would be surprised.

Re:Electric car that charges itself by gnramires on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @01:09PM (#26479667)
Well yes it varies a lot by condition, it seems in the worst case (temperate winter, cloudy) you get about 5 miles per day, i.e. about 1 mile per hour of daylight.

Still, it does seem like a useful feature. It should be plausible to run out of juice relatively close to an outlet (gas station, hotel, good samaritan, etc.) since electricity is virtually everywhere. Waiting a few hours to get to the nearest facility should not be too bad.

It's more of the capability that attracts me (like having insurance without ever needing).

Given typical numbers of panel output I wouldn't be surprised if it (nearly) pays for itself anyway, so I don't see the need to be overly skeptical. (ben_w estimates ~1.8 year payback)

See other arguments cited elsewhere as well: avoiding deep discharge in case of battery depletion. If you leave your depleted car sitting for a while (days? weeks?), you will see degradation of the precious battery, which represents most (about 40%) of the cost of the car. A cheap insurance to preserve your most vital asset is also a great feature.

Re:Electric car that charges itself by tppiotrowski on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @11:08AM (#26477711)
With decent LTE coverage in national forest and BLM areas I could see people sitting in the desert for a week and then moving onto another location while they work remotely out of their van, though it’s pretty cheap to buy square 200W panels. I didn’t read about the efficiency of this technology.
Re:Electric car that charges itself by rootusrootus on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @12:40PM (#26479172)
People definitely do this already, there's several forums dedicated to people who stuff their van or RV with batteries and cover the roof with solar panels so they can live off grid or go on extended boondocking trips.

If Starlink does remove the location restriction, I'll spend more time in the wilderness than I do at home.

Re:Electric car that charges itself by MrRiddle on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @11:44AM (#26478337)
Imagine you go to a coastal area for vacation, and have a turbo charger 50 miles away. If you go around visiting beaches every day 10-20km away, it might remove the need to go to a super charger.

It might not be practical to plug in a place you’re staying at.

Re:Electric car that charges itself by Erlich_Bachman on Wednesday March 17, 2021 @04:18AM (#26487888)
> you at least have the option to wait a day or two to charge

This argument gets thrown around sometimes, but if you really consider it:

Who has time to wait a day or two at a random place, with no infrastructure? People who have no valueable job (where time is very valueable), and at the same time are outdoors enthusiasts who can sleep in a random spot? But who at the same time are in the market for a futuristic EV? Even for those, how many times out of each trip would that be a viable solution? If you consider this in practices, it just makes much more sense to call the tow truck.

And if you know that you are going on a really long trip where there is really no possibility to even call a tow truck (but like, where is that? Where is the place where you have a close proximity to an EV charger, otherwise you wouldn't be going there, and no possibility for a tow truck to access?), even in that unlikely circumstance - you can just already buy a 1000$ 10kg diesel generator and bring with you for emergencies.