News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD 3rd Gen EPYC Milan Review by rbanffy on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:24PM (#26468807)
What AMD does is not magic and is not beyond what others can do. My question is why they chose to have just 32MB for up to 80 cores when AMD can choose to have 32MB per 8-core chiplet.

As a comparison, an IBM z15 mainframe CPU has 10 cores and 256MB per socket.

Re:AMD 3rd Gen EPYC Milan Review by dragontamer on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:43PM (#26469034)
> As a comparison, an IBM z15 mainframe CPU has 10 cores and 256MB per socket.

Well, that's eDRAM magic, isn't it? Most manufacturers are unable to make eDRAM on a CPU.

> My question is why they chose to have just 32MB for up to 80 cores when AMD can choose to have 32MB per 8-core chiplet.

From my understanding, those ARM chips are largely I/O devices: read from disk -> output to Ethernet.

In contrast, IBM's are known for database backends, which likely benefits from gross amounts of L3 cache. EPYC is general purpose: you might run a database on it, you might run I/O constrained apps on it. So kind of a middle ground.

Re:AMD 3rd Gen EPYC Milan Review by floatboth on Monday March 15, 2021 @08:19PM (#26471272)
Didn't Intel push eDRAM magic into various laptop chips around Broadwell?

> those ARM chips are largely I/O devices

Anything Neoverse-N1 is pretty good at general compute and databases. There's definitely a lot of Postgres running on AWS Graviton2 instances already :)

Re:AMD 3rd Gen EPYC Milan Review by meepmorp on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:46PM (#26469071)
IBM doesn't fab its own chips, right? I thought they used GF.
Re:AMD 3rd Gen EPYC Milan Review by wmf on Monday March 15, 2021 @05:11PM (#26469143)
It's basically IBM fabs that were "sold" to GlobalFoundries. AFAIK IBM processors use a customized process that isn't used by any other GF customers.