News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by macspoofing on Sunday March 14, 2021 @02:06PM (#26457328)
Yeah, I get it. It is a necessary change just so you take this of the table and not deal with the sporadic complaints that would come. Keeping the 'master' or 'master-slave' (in context of HA) terms just isn't worth potentially offending someone, or losing a sale, or getting bad press. We changed our verbage a couple years in our product as well just for that reason (Master-Slave to Primary-Secondary). The previous company I worked at (circa 2006) did the same as well after a complaint, so this nomenclature change was happening for a few years now. Meh, whatever.

It would be nice if that was the end of it, but it feels like we're now just looking for things to be offended by. For example, I have to admit that the terms 'whitelist'/'blacklist' being labeled as not 'inclusive' caught me by surprise because my brain didn't even make that connection ... at all. I wish we, the global community, didn't all have to pay for America's internal cultural hangups.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by somedude895 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @02:23PM (#26457471)
> I wish we, the global community, didn't all have to pay for America's internal cultural hangups.

Can't wait for Disney to remove any references to the "Dark Side" in Star Wars, Harry Potter to rename the "Dark Arts" into the "Bad Arts" and Lord of the Rings' "Black Riders" to become the "Evil Horsemen."

Nobody ever used to connect the term "blacklist" to race. But common sense doesn't seem to play a role anymore.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by yongjik on Sunday March 14, 2021 @03:44PM (#26458262)
> You are on this council, but we do not grant you the rank of Main.

> What? How can you do this?! This is outrageous! It's unfair! How can you be on the council and not be a Main?!

I dunno, the dialogues were always terrible in the prequels, maybe it will improve matters. :/

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by ondrek on Sunday March 14, 2021 @02:50PM (#26457741)
Seeing black / whitelists discussions I always wonder, if white color is racist also by containg all wavelengths, while black suffers by absencing visible light.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by macspoofing on Sunday March 14, 2021 @02:53PM (#26457761)
>if white color is racist also by containg all wavelengths, while black suffers by absencing visible light.

This definition of white/black colors is context dependent.

In some contexts white is defined as a combination of colors, and black is absence of colors.

In some contexts (e.g. art) white is defined as absence of colors, and black is a combination of colors.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by david-gpu on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:17PM (#26459937)
It is not a matter of context or definitions. It's a matter of the underlying physical process.

Typical computer displays generate colors by adding light of different wavelengths. However, paint pigments generate colors by absorbing light of different wavelengths.

Whether a system emits light directly, like a computer screen, or reflects incoming light, like a painted canvas, the perception of color is still determined by the wavelengths of the photons reaching the observer.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by macspoofing on Monday March 15, 2021 @08:17AM (#26465065)
Heh. I guess since I engaged in pedantry, I can't complain if others do as well.

I disagree though. Your argument is akin to complaining that we shouldn't use temperature because in the fundamental quantum field reality, there is no temperature. Or maybe you would complain about using various equation of fluid mechanics (all of which are at best approximations) instead of field equations to calculate behaviour of liquids. Or maybe complaining in programming that it is incorrect to reason about objects or monads because it's just bitshifts and logic gates underneath.

The notion in art that 'white is the absence of color, and black is a combination of colors' is a useful abstraction for that particular domain because the canvas is white, and black can be made by mixing paint colors. It is as real as anything else that we, as humans, engage in.

>the perception of color is still determined by the wavelengths of the photons reaching

Not quite right. Color is not a physical process. It is brain experience and does not exist independently. It is USEFUL to sometimes map physical wavelengths of light to colors but that is context dependent. Not only would different species experience color differently for some specific wavelength, but also different humans will experience them differently as well (color blindness is one example, another one is that you can train your brain to be more receptive to color variations)

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by diomedes on Sunday March 14, 2021 @02:31PM (#26457551)
> But common sense doesn't seem to play a role anymore.

If it were just a common sense problem the damage could be reverted in it's due time. It is about hierarchy, if you put weak people in power they'll game the system and push whatever the mob wants, it won't stop with random tech lingo.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by scrollaway on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:38PM (#26459543)
I don't mind so much when the renames make sense or are more comprehensible… master to primary for DBs, master to main for git. Indeed whitelist/blacklist is just ridiculous overreach, what can you do.

But Github went way too far by aggressively pushing devs to rename their own local master branches to main. This caught me by surprise and I almost accidentally renamed the branch of one of my previous clients.

https://twitter.com/Adys/status/1354468440753508355

Really gross.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by easton on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:25PM (#26460007)
Does it still do this if you don’t have your default branch set to main? I had to specifically go and set that on a settings page somewhere.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by ec109685 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @02:14PM (#26457385)
The terms whitelist and blacklist aren’t very precise. The better terms allow list, deny list or something that more concretely describes the auth model are actually helpful.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by yongjik on Sunday March 14, 2021 @03:34PM (#26458167)
The terms "whitelist/blacklist" are no less precise than stack, heap, queue, memory, signal, object, class, instance, process, and so on. They acquired precise meaning not by etymology but by usage. It's silly to argue "Oh you didn't want these terms anyway: they're not precise enough."

Well, the whole discussion is made of silly hills not worth dying on, so to speak, so maybe it's par for the course ...

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by macspoofing on Sunday March 14, 2021 @02:20PM (#26457452)
Sure. The existing terms are a little quirky and you can make the argument that 'allow' and 'deny' lists make more sense ... but come on man, why be obtuse? You know that's not why these terms are being changed.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by snicker7 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @04:49PM (#26459012)
In 2022: the terms "allowlist" and "denylist" evoke the realization that marginalized groups where and are DENIED privileges afforded to others. You are now cancelled.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by enigma20 on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:59AM (#26467588)
What to expect, if we live in the world were intelligence is becoming rare, and people can't read the context, and get insulted by anything. More and more have such delicate souls, poor things.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by raydev on Sunday March 14, 2021 @03:55PM (#26458387)
That’s a lot of words to say “this is a good change and nothing has been lost.” Incredible that this post has almost 200 comments.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by fuzxi on Sunday March 14, 2021 @03:57PM (#26458415)
He didn't say it's a good change. He said it's a CYA move that's become necessary.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by erik_seaberg on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:42PM (#26460200)
Time has been lost. When management required this change, it broke some test and deploy automation, and some git non-experts screwed up their clones and needed help.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by rvnx on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:59AM (#26462774)
and there may be security issues down the line due to non-authorized users claiming ownership of "master" branches.

Time is the most precious thing you have in life, you cannot get it back.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by martin8412 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:22PM (#26459983)
This will absolutely cost customers.. The rest of the world is getting fed up with the US. Most of the world is not as deeply racist and the US... Master is not associated with anything negative here.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by sacomo on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:33PM (#26460113)
"Whatever you do, don't use gitlab. They changed their default git branch to 'main'."
[dead]
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by tasogare on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:29PM (#26460058)
> There is no end goal here being offended is the goal.

Nop, it’s a mean. Being perceived as a victim is very bankable these days, so the craze will continue with more people being offended and asking compensations (often monetary) for it.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by noxer on Monday March 15, 2021 @06:09AM (#26464185)
The people who are offended mostly aren't even the people who would get any kind of compensation. They are offended on behalf of others.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by jlizzle30 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @03:32PM (#26458154)
The natural conclusion of the black/whitelist argument is renaming the colors.
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by devnull255 on Sunday March 14, 2021 @03:59PM (#26458437)
If you dig a little deeper you might find your brain does make that kind of connection subconsciously.

This article gives a nice introduction into the work of cognitive linguists George Lakoff and Mark Johnson. https://theconversation.com/how-did-white-become-a-metaphor-.... The language constructs we use embed positive and negative associations with the words used to describe black or white things, low or high concepts.

But I have to admit my bewilderment with the default branch name change too. I've seen older uses of the word master to mean original source of truth or master of students -- or padawan.

I believe it's better to live in a time where we think more seriously about the words we choose to use than in one we don't. Language is fluid and always changing anyway.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by dvdgsng on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:19PM (#26459335)
> your brain does make that kind of connection subconsciously

This should work both ways then. So loving black tea, black humor, Black Mirror, Black Swan and the color black in general would make me like "black people" more because my brain does the wiring subconsciously when it reads the term "black"? Nope. Don't think so. But maybe making everything about race is, well, racist?

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by macspoofing on Sunday March 14, 2021 @04:28PM (#26458793)
>If you dig a little deeper you might find your brain does make that kind of connection subconsciously.

I'm sure the brain makes all kinds of connections subconsciously. The specific claim though is that your brain makes racist connections (where 'racist' is broadly defined by certain kinds of social 'scientists', where the academic field of 'social science' in general is sloppy and non-rigorous), with the corollary being that you then perform racist actions. Those propositions are wholly unproven and on the surface strike me as pseudo-science.

I have also yet to see any evidence that that cultural connotations behind the colors 'white' and 'black' (like 'white is pure' and 'black is evil') actually even maps to people or racist behaviour. Do people see 'dark eyes' or 'black hair' as evil? First I hear of that. And I'm not even sure if the white/black connotations are cultural at all. I suspect that they come from something deeper, namely, nighttime was/is dangerous for our species. As I child, I was afraid of the dark and I can guarantee it had nothing to do with race or anything from culture. Where did I learn that?

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by TechnoTimeStop on Sunday March 14, 2021 @04:02PM (#26458470)
It's not America. America is the only truly free country. Only 15 counties in the world allow you to even own land if you're not from a specific religious group, ethnicity, or born in the country.

And guess what they're all western democracies.

Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by noodlesUK on Sunday March 14, 2021 @04:22PM (#26458730)
What? Citation needed. Unless you’re talking about citizenship/permanent residence being a prerequisite to owning land, there’s 27 countries in the EU alone that I think serve as counterexamples...
Re:Gitlab default branch name changes to main by taylodl on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:29AM (#26467146)
The US doesn't require citizenship in order to own land. The US also has public lands where anyone is able to hunt, provided they have a license. In most states a license requires paying a nominal fee and maybe taking a 1-2 day hunter education course.