Open-source Patent Troll
"""
Azoff,
My name is [ Mr. Troll ]. I am writing you from a company called RazDog.com. We have several patents pending for the rights to navigate like a smart phone on any web content deployed through a browser. We have software which we have had publically available for some time.
We have been made aware of your software which appears to potentially breach our patents pending.
I need you to call me to discuss options ASAP.
Your valuable time is appreciated.
"""
In case you are wondering, the software referred to by Mr. Troll is most likely a jQuery plug-in I currently maintain called OverScroll (http://github.com/azoff/overscroll). I first released it into the public domain back in 2009 (see: http://plugins.jquery.com/node/8738), about the same time RazDog was apparently in the music business and had nothing to do with user interaction on the web (see: http://web.archive.org/web/20090503201355/http://razdog.com/consumers_info.aspx).
Never, ever, in my time as a professional developer did I ever think I would have to deal with this blatant disregard for open-sourced contribution and innovation.
Mr. Troll, you are a vulture.
- Azoff
If you were hit with an actual patent claim, the first question you ask is what is the patent # and which specific claims are they referencing. Then go back to any referenced patents and see if the claims are unique to the new patent. Of the unique claims then you can make a case if your product infringes or not.
That your software is open-source is entirely orthogonal to the issue of infringement.
Depending on how you're feeling, either tell the guy to fuck off, or try to get those (pending) patents invalidated.
I'm reminded of Tony Soprano to an unhappy customer: "Satisfaction guaranteed, or double your garbage back!"
ps: recent rule changes mean that some patents (those that will be filed outside of the US) will be published 18 months after filing, even if they are not yet approved. Possibly not relevant here, as the troll would presumably want you to see the pending patent to prove the legitimacy of his threat.
Horrific usability, too.
I'm no expert on patent law, but I would enquire as to which patent applications he's referring to (an ambiguous "we has patents" statement doesn't get them anywhere), and then I would check the applications and the filing party's previous filing history. If they're a pending troll, ignore and move on. If they don't have any actual pending patents relative to your work, ignore and move on. If your work predates his patent application, file a prior art declaration with the patent office against his patents, and move on.
Personally I dislike software patents to the extreme. I believe copyright is enough for software. If people want patent protection on their software, they should have to demonstrate working code that shows their concept in action, and they should submit the full source code with build tools and instructions. The point of patents is that 50 years after a patent is granted, the public should be able to pick up the patent and exactly replicate the original invention from the patent materials alone. I know that is certainly not the case for most modern patents, especially software patents.
Of course you might head off the serendipitous granting of a ridiculous patent that might fall into the hands of a real troll ala Lodsys later. If he refuses to listen to reason, you might look into sending the prior art to the patent office in reference to his application.
Could a simple call to find out really be that bad. (seriously IANAL so I really don't know)
I think he's just an idiot who happens to be inadvertently trolling. Not a professional troll. It seems like he really does want to sell his goofy cloud motion and probably thinks he's the new new. Whatever.
Just junk it.
I'm happy there are others who have dealt with this before. I hate to sound like a bleeding heart, but it is really sad that any troll can effectively axe an open-sourced project like this. I really hope that it won't come to litigation.
"""
Azoff,
There are several options available to you along with an opportunity for you and or your company to make some money regarding your software. Please call me by Wednesday at [ Mr. Troll Hotline ].
Regards,
[ Mr. Troll ]
"""
You might wind up getting some useful ammunition for later use; or if nothing else, a hilarious recording for further public shaming.
Strike 2, RazDog.