I'm curious to hear what dumb use of energy you have in your head that rivals this level of stupidity.
edit: I'll address the "apple to oranges" replies here: you can combine the energy consumed by VISA and whatever other financial service exists that would together match the feature-set of bitcoin (eg. VISA + Bank of America + ...) and you'd still have energy consumption many orders of magnitude lower than the Bitcoin network.
[0] https://usa.visa.com/dam/VCOM/download/corporate/media/visan...
And I'm sure that Visa + banks for settlement are still using a lot less energy than Bitcoin if you normalize it to transaction volume. Even if you only count the settlements as "real" transactions.
I'm personally mixed on crypto but strongly dislike the glossing-over of its various fundamental properties by people taking intense absolute positions about what free people should be able to do. That can get me shaking my fist at the internet, though now I mostly realize these opinions are as irrelevant as mine is, and this is good.
That drew me in with some geeky allure as something quite unique. And the scenarios like "crossing a border with a fortune stored as a memorized passphrase in your head" are cool in a cyberpunk kind of way.
But these days I'm in the "bitcoin is a paperclip maximizer" camp. I don't really want control of my money to be based on crypto keys that I could lose or have stolen with one bad mistake. And proof of work is so wildly expensive for what it does, I can't endorse it.
The PoW stuff, yeah, there is a reason it exists as you know but it is undeniably insane too. PoS is going to be interesting to see how it goes with Eth.
As a third dimension, I am very optimistic that we're on the order of 1 decade away from a huge change in energy, where solar is dirt cheap. If we see an S curve style shift to that mode of energy production, I think the PoW conversation changes a lot.
If solar becomes 100x cheaper than today's energy sources, but bitcoin mining still pays a large reward, bitcoin miners will just use 100x more energy, right? They're in a race with each other, it doesn't make sense to leave any extra hashrate capacity on the table since if you don't use it, somebody else will and they'll get more of the block rewards.
Maybe that's fine, since solar is still zero-emission, but surely there's still some cost to producing that energy (such as the space taken up by the solar panels, the cost to make and replace them, etc). Otherwise it'd be free, not just cheap.
You're comparing your bicycle to a cargo ship saying "see how much more energy efficient my bicycle is?". Meanwhile your bicycle can't tow 1000 tonnes of freight across the ocean. That's why is moot to compare them.
[0] https://www.cnn.com/2013/10/04/world/americas/silk-road-ross...
[1] https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/29/16060344/btce-bitcoin-exc...
[2] https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm556
[3] https://cointelegraph.com/news/slippery-slope-as-new-bitcoin...
- Geographic distribution of nodes and mining is important for decentralization.
- I don't live in the United States. I can wash/tumble my coins, proxy through other networks. Transact through Monero. The power is on the side of the users.
> But visa doesn't provide most of the functions of bitcoin infrastructure. Visa does[n't] need to hold the balance of my account. Visa does[n't] need to or makes available all of my equity worth of assets for me to transfer. Visa does not custody my assets. This is literally apple to oranges (or visa to bitcoin)
Yes they do?
> Visa does[n't] need to or makes available all of my equity worth of assets for me to transfer.
This is a horrifying bug, right? A thing that no person would ever want, and it's so rare that visa would make you talk to a person and raise your limit first, or they'd get more people involved to make sure you're not being coerced because it's such an abnormal thing to do. Lawyers in some cases, just because you're being so silly. But if you REALLY wanted to make a $1b debit card transaction, you probably totally could, just call the visa billionaire line.
> Visa does not custody my assets.
But a regular bank can, and visa will send to and from there with a debit card.
How does one ban a blockchain? Serious question.
Would you only arrest the miners or would you also arrest non-mining full node operators?
How could you tell if regular citizens were transacting with POW coins? Would you subpoena telecom companies for records where customers have visited known sites which transact in POW coins? Or would you go the AT&T route and pipe telecom traffic through a little cabinet that uses deep packet inspection to sniff out POW transactions occurring over RPC?
What about traders? Would you outlaw trading POW coins and make exchange exclude US customers? That could make for some serious arbitrage opportunities for tech savy citizens.
I would genuinely appreciate your answer to any or all of these questions.
I build cryptocurrency software and would gain a lot from additional insight into the threat model I face in the not-so-distant future.
Then the demand for the crypto currency plummets.
In 2010-2011, I traded BTC for USD in person, with a laptop on wifi. And via PayPal with someone I met on IRC, where there was a bot that kept track of your reputation so the BTC sellers would know if it was safe to sell to you.
At that time the price of 1 BTC was about $1 USD.
I think we'd see something similar, if there was an outright ban.
* cocaine prices aren't $1/kg, even after governments around the world banned it
* exotic/endangered species are still being traded for top dollars, despite anti-poaching and anti-trafficking regulations
* stolen art is still worth millions
The only reason I would ever want to hold a Bitcoin is that I trust that somebody else will give me something of value for it in the future.
If governments make it very difficult for me to exchange bitcoins for other things, its utility as a "store of value" gets lower. I'd rather store my value in stocks, real estate, gold, or whatever else. The regulation directly interferes with the use case.
On the other hand, all the regulation in the world doesn't interfere with cocaine's use case of getting you high. If governments could make it so that cocaine doesn't get you high, its price would certainly plummet.
Also you can look for energy consumption. Towns in upstate New York are banning new permits for mining. So it's already happened.
In short, society has certain expectations and if you violate those there will be consequences. Govt and laws are always behind the publics will, so it's coming for cryptos. Which survive is the real speculative bets that will pay off
Then what? Do you end up with this problem? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26226470
speculative bubble =/= ponzi scheme
BTC mining makes the miners more wealthy. In service of the BTC network, which has what utility?
There are quite a number of criminal or at least grey market uses for BTC.
But what are the legitimate uses that are not as well or better served by the traditional payment networks?
The safest safe haven asset. A global currency of fixed supply controlled by computer algorithms.
> There are quite a number of criminal or at least grey market uses for BTC.
Criminals the world over prefer cash. Should we ban cash?
> But what are the legitimate uses that are not as well or better served by the traditional payment networks?
A programmable, internet-native inflation-proof store of value with transparent fully-auditable supply metrics. Or to quote Elon Musk, “simply a less dumb form of liquidity than cash”.
However, I've been wondering lately what happens in a future where the grid is destroyed by a sun storm? Say the power grids get knocked off for 21 months (I read this is a very possible scenario with a big sun flare), as well as a lot of satellites.
If we move a lot of the world's monetary systems/value to blockchain, how do we use blockchain with no internet or electricity?
There are quite a number of criminal and grey market uses for data centers.
What are the legitimate uses of data centers that are not served by traditional pen & paper?
At this point BTC is a speculative bubble that benefits a very small group to the detriment of the rest of us.
I also have a lot of personal frustration with how mining (more of ETH and others) is impacting the global GPU supply.
A whole cottage industry has cropped up of sites, discords, etc that provide notifications when GPUs come into stock. Not all the issues are related to mining, but it certainly is enough of an issue that Nvidia has announced mining specific cards and is throttling mining on their 3060 series. AMD is rumored to be doing similar soon.
Edit: Replaced 'anti-social Ponzi scheme' with 'speculative bubble' to be more accurate.