In humans, the haploid phase of the lifecycle is single-celled, while the diploid phase is multicellular. In contrast, in mosses and fungi the haploid phase is multicellular while the diploid phase (sporophytes/zygote) is single-celled.
Red blood cells are discussed in the article.
The unfertilized eggs of bees become drones, so they must be alive. As a side effect, this indirectly make bee-like insects evolve a lifestyle with a big colony with a queen.
In fungus, most of the life is as haploid (i.e. a single copy of the chromosomes, like sperm and eggs) instead of diploids (i.e. two copies of each chromosomes, like most of our cells.)
In some ¿unicellular organism? [I can't find a good link now] the haploid and diploid versions are almost equal.
[And plants are also weird, some have 4 or 6 copies of the chromosomes instead of 2.]
I think in reality like most things its not black and white, there is a continuum of life and some things are more alive than others.
Edit: perhaps adapting to environment through mutation/evolution or learning or both might be better.
Simple historic example: change of oxygen level, change of temparature is another likely event
Interestingly this definition would encompass countries and probably any social group as long as they have a name, an identity and processes to maintain it. I think life doesn’t need integrated intelligence to be life, though intelligence could probably be defined as a predictive kind of self-preservation process. Essentially devising a chain of actions for moving from state A to state B with a limited set of possible operations and minimized energy consumption. An efficient way to return to initial state, or to another state that increases likelyhood of identity preservation.
As someone else said in a comment, life may be seen as a continuum where these characteristics are more or less developed and integrated, for instance making coutries or viruses living organisms while still distinguishing the unique character of humans or animals.
I think it's a thin pro-argument. Viruses are completely dependant on the host cell and the host cell's metabolism. The host cell's protein unwraps the jacket, and the host cells' proteins replicate the viral DNA/RNA payload. The virus does not reproduce itself, and it does not metabolize anything. There are no inputs to a virus.
Whereas living cells, give them the proper inputs, and they metabolize energy, catalyze reactions, and create copies of themselves.
IMO, self-replication is the most fundamental characteristic, and the ability to mutate/evolve is key as well. The rest is all details.
I'm asking this question because the aforementioned definition of "life" is flawed in my opinion. Evolution has nothing to do with it.
1. Unless you have some way to stop time, it is impossible to stop humans from mutating/evolving.
2. I would argue it is part of being human, and being alive, to evolve and adapt to your environment. Humans have multiple ways of doing this. Beyond our ability to genetically evolve, our intelligence is a mechanism we use to adapt to your environment much faster than genetics permit.
They don't metabolize energy.
1. metabolic cycle
2. ~~stores information~~
2. membrane/boundary
3. template replication
More recent origin of life theories (even proto-cellular) focus on: 1. periodicity/cycles
2. compartmentalization/boundaries
3. microdiversity/entropy
https://sci-hub.st/10.1016/j.cocis.2007.08.008But that such a thing as AI life forms will exist and be accepted as such by scientific consensus is not a given, at all.
The question seems to be to be "what exact criteria categorises what is commonly meant when people talk about what is alive". I think you could interpret OP as claiming that there is an idea of artificial or alien life as presented in science fiction which people would commonly describe as life but may not replicate.
You cannot say "this definition of life fails to account for an uncertain future phenomenon not everyone is convinced will count as life, therefore your definition of life is incomplete".
Fictional life is not real life. Authors, especially fiction authors, are not bound by the rules of nature. Sometimes they guess right, sometimes they don't, sometimes they simply provide thought experiments or parables.
That is, again, begging the question.
Bees and Humans fit the definition. Therefor, aggregations of bees and humans, like hives and countries, also fit the definition.
"Countries" seem more of a stretch, as replicating would technically mean creating other countries like itself. Not just sustaining itself into the future.
Do hives seed other hives? I suppose they would, so they better fit the definition.
But with bees it's much worse -- in each hive, only the queen and some drones reproduce, most bees are worker bees that can't. So this definition fits bee hives better than it does individual bees.
Seems the definition would need to say something about the species as a whole reproducing. But that leads to the species definition problem. And what about that tortoise that was the last of its species?
The world is full of countries, nations and so forth. At some time in the distant past there was no nations. After that there was one. Now there is over a hundred, with the corpses of many more lying in our past.
All usable land on Earth has been claimed now so they have no space to grow in number without cannabilising one another. Their walls have grown hard and inflexible with the passage of time and laws and agreements, and the evolutionary pressures of conflict have subsided of late, as they cannot move against one another without incurring the wrath of alpha predators, and the alpha predators cannot attack one another without the assurity of mutual destruction.
But countries live a long time, and their frame of reference is different from our own. Their moods encompass entire generations of the lives of mankind. They will eventually again fight among themselves unless ordered into cells within a higher organism. They will fight and devour one another, birthing new border states or vassal states. To any greater being it would appear like an almost peaceful dance, the ebb and flow of lines on a map, the respiration of civilisation.
To us it would be every bit as savage and chaotic as it must be for the cells and bacteria which comprise us.
Not sure how often or even if countries self-reproduce.
Colonialism and independence.
OTOH, not all human populations are states, as in countries, and arguable that is the "organism" said to be reproducing itself....
People self-replicate. People are alive. Societies are composed of people. Therefore, societies are alive.
(may or may not be a hole in your argument depending on whether you think a society is "alive")
This definition is a rubric of several qualities:
1. Metabolizes energy
2. Stores Information
3. Self-replicates
#1 rules out crystals; they are formed by outside forces, they don't metabolize themselves. It also rules out viruses and prions; they don't ingest any "food" to perform metabolic activity. #2 rules out fire; it doesn't store information in a DNA-like molecule or anything simliar. It's purely a chemical reaction. #3 is the obvious thing that differentiates non-living things like rocks from plants and animals.