News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by rossdavidh on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:27AM (#26377167)
I worked in Accounting (the dept that did it, not the one that taught it) IT at a major public university for several years. Something like half of the software complexity was in keeping track of each dollar's origin, and making sure that it was spent on only what the source approved it to be spent on. Whether the source was the federal government, the state, corporate donors, or wealthy individuals, they all had strong opinions on what the money could be spent on. It was much easier to get money donated for a new building, than to maintain an old one, so you can have a situation in which new buildings are being built while old ones fall apart.

The most surprising thing to me was how small a percentage of the budget was under the control of the president of the university; it was only a tiny amount. Virtually all of the money was controlled by the source, not by the administration.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by jasode on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:47AM (#26377357)
>complexity was in keeping track of each dollar's origin, and making sure that it was spent on only what the source approved it to be spent on. [...] they all had strong opinions on what the money could be spent on.

Understand your frustration but the public was outraged when $1 million of a librarian's donation was used for a football scoreboard.[1]

Yes, the university did comply to the exact letter of his will (only $100k was restricted for library and the rest was unrestricted) ... but the public thinks the spirit of his donation was ignored.

[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=librarian+donation+used+for+...

Re:Donate Unrestricted by throwawaygh on Sunday March 07, 2021 @05:13PM (#26380292)
Universities are literally the sole specific institutional exception in the essay:

> There are a couple exceptions to this principle. One is when the nonprofit is an umbrella organization. It's reasonable to make a restricted donation to a university, for example, because a university is only nominally a single nonprofit.

The article doesn't say what to do when donating to a university or college. So, when donating to a university, do also donate in a relatively unrestricted way. But donate to:

1. a department (in small amounts),

2. a scholarship fund (in medium amounts),

3. an endowed professorship for a specific department/discipline (in large amounts), or

4. some important component of the physical plant (in "Gates/Allen" amounts).

Not to the university as a whole.

At least that's what I've witness as being effective.

Oh, and if you donate to scholarships, make sure the university/college plays ball. If they won't at least match 4% of the principle, just set up the scholarship an independent thing and let the kid choose where they go. Why donate a student scholarship to a specific school whose value is literally just the sustainable withdrawal rate? What's the point of that? Certainly not to help a student. Your donation will turn into a chair on the deck to be rearranged. But lots of donors get suckered into doing this.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by saurik on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:12PM (#26379806)
I mean, when funds are unrestricted, they "should" become fungible; so, when I give unrestricted donations I also make it clear that I don't want them to try to tell me "we used your money to do X"... that way, I can look at anything I want on campus that was improved and think "I did that :)". If the university is spending money on bullshit, then probably they just don't deserve donations at all :/.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by smt88 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @09:06PM (#26381684)
Every large org spends at least some money on bullshit, usually amounts that would shock the typical person.

It's just one of the many inescapable inefficiencies that happen when humans try to create a large organization.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by User23 on Monday March 08, 2021 @12:57AM (#26382681)
True, but that doesn’t make it acceptable.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by xirbeosbwo1234 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:54AM (#26377431)
The problem with that is, in part, that they ignored the spirit of the donation, but also that the proper amount for a university to spend on a scoreboard is twelve dollars and thirty-seven cents.

OK, that's a bit unrealistic. I could build them one for a few hundred, though, and they could pay a student $50 to flip over the numbers during the game.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by bradleyjg on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:36PM (#26379000)
The proper amount to spend is zero. There’s no reason for universities to be running minor league football teams with unpaid labor. On the contrary that’s the exact opposite of “charitable”.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by throwawaygh on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:49PM (#26380108)
I mean, a few hundred for a score board seems right. Even a few thousand for a piece of infrastructure that can be used 20+ years for several different sports is not so unreasonable. Even rural middle schools will sometimes spend that much on scoreboards.

In University I participated in a club sport "funded" exclusively through the student government -- really more of a tax rebate than anything else since only 60% of what the climbing "team" paid in student fees we got back to buy ropes, biners, rent a van for outings. That sort of stuff.

College sports do serve a real community-building purpose. Just... a few hundred or maybe low thousands total per sport instead of a few tens of millions for the main sport.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by wpietri on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:39PM (#26380031)
Definitely. One of my modest proposals that will never happen is that colleges go back to teaching, and football and basketball become more like baseball, where they have minor leagues as a way of getting players. The jumbling together of college and professional-in-all-but-name athletics is absurd, and egregious exploitation of "student" athletes to boot.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by rossdavidh on Sunday March 07, 2021 @05:31PM (#26380436)
Fundamentally, you're correct. However, when working for a university, I was well aware that private sector donations (and maybe even state funds) went up or down depending on how well the football team did. A losing record for the football team ought not to result in lower private sector donations towards scientific research or scholarships at that university, but apparently at most universities it does. Universities that ignore this fact do so at their peril.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by bradleyjg on Sunday March 07, 2021 @05:44PM (#26380522)
I don’t expect universities to spontaneously do the right thing. I’m hoping the courts force them to at least stop exploiting the pro athletes that make them so much money.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by cortesoft on Sunday March 07, 2021 @06:44PM (#26380912)
So there should be no sports at all at schools? What about other extra curricular activities? No band, no drama club, nothing but academics?

I get not wanting to have a minor league football team with unpaid labor, but even rec league basketball needs a scoreboard.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by rsj_hn on Sunday March 07, 2021 @08:33PM (#26381501)
In other countries, things not tied directly to a university's educational mission are still available, but as local community organizations. There are drama clubs, sports clubs, but available to the entire community, not just college students.

There is no reason why the state should spend its educational subsidies on funding auxillary recreational activities solely for the benefit of university students when a good GPA is not necessary to recreate, nor do university students have a greater need of recreation than anyone else.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by kmonsen on Monday March 08, 2021 @01:08AM (#26382727)
I think most countries have some form of student sports as part of universities, just not the kind of professional ones like in the U.S. students study better if they have something else in their lives.

The problem is that it is really hard to know where to draw the line and the US as usual takes it fully to the extreme.

All that being said, I thought the big sports were a revenue driver for the schools that chose to participate in the bigger leagues?

Re:Donate Unrestricted by rsj_hn on Monday March 08, 2021 @04:46PM (#26392082)
Intramural, sure, you can organize some soccer games between adjacent dorms as part of the responsibilities of the dorm admin, but in terms of paid programs, no.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by lrem on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:19PM (#26377641)
See, they evaded a recurring cost!
Re:Donate Unrestricted by remote_phone on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:26PM (#26378265)
> I could build them one for a few hundred

No, you couldn’t.

It has to keep working for years/decades, be maintainable, survive bad weather conditions, etc. even if you made the scoreboard out of wood and painted it, it would have to be large enough so that the stadium could see, the paint would fade and it would take weeks to make it, etc.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by dan-robertson on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:00PM (#26378643)
So rebuild it every time as necessary. It will take a long time to eat into $1MM
Re:Donate Unrestricted by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:32PM (#26377779)
> The most surprising thing to me was how small a percentage of the budget was under the control of the president of the university; it was only a tiny amount. Virtually all of the money was controlled by the source, not by the administration.

I consider that good news, actually, because it makes restricted donations meaningful.

I always assumed that restricted donations were pointless, because if I donated $x of restricted donations to cause A, the organization would simply take $x of unrestricted donations that it was planning to spend on cause A and instead spend them on other causes. All of my money technically went to cause A, but de facto it didn't.

I still assume that's the case for regular, non-university charities.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by Viliam1234 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:53PM (#26377961)
If you expect that someone just wants to steal your money (and I am not saying such expectation is always wrong), perhaps you just shouldn't give them any.

On the other hand, if you trust that someone wants to do a good thing, they probably have more information about the topic than you do, so you should give them freedom to actually act on that information. Like, maybe you think "X is way more important than Y", but maybe the lack of Y is actually what prevents them from doing X efficiently, so your restriction to only use the money for X is not helpful, even from the X-maximizing perspective.

Like, sometimes your mission is to distribute food to starving kids in Africa, but you can't organize your volunteers until you buy a new computer, because the only one you had just broke. Then someone gives you a paycheck with big letters "only use to buy food, I don't want to see you wasting money on computers". Yeah, thanks a lot, dear condescending saint.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:09PM (#26378111)
> If you expect that someone just wants to steal your money (and I am not saying such expectation is always wrong), perhaps you just shouldn't give them any.

This is indeed the approach I've been taking with some climate change charities: most of them have an "advocacy" component, and while I'd like to support effective emissions reduction projects, I'm not willing to contribute to the preaching for individual asceticism.

I have no issue giving to "some project + a proportionate share of central/overhead costs".

Unfortunately, it's often extremely hard to find a charity that is tax deductible where you live, part of employer matching programs, effective in running projects you want to support, and not performing activities you specifically don't want to support.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by scrose on Sunday March 07, 2021 @08:14PM (#26381397)
‘Advocacy’ is very broad. I hope you’re not discounting donating to places because you think it can only mean one thing!
Re:Donate Unrestricted by tgsovlerkhgsel on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:28PM (#26393649)
The word itself isn't the problem, and in general I don't have an issue donating to organizations that also tackle the problem on a political level.

With climate change specifically, if I can't reasonably rule out the risk that the org will spend the money to tell me that I can't have an air conditioner, meat, or travel (or worse, lobby my government to ban me from having these things), they're not getting any money.

I'm OK with taking some risk that the org will use money in a way that I consider non-optimal, but I draw the line where I see a risk that the money may be used directly against my own interests. "Don't feed the mouth that bites you", I guess.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by throwawaygh on Monday March 08, 2021 @11:29AM (#26387533)
In particular, drawing on an example from OP, advocacy sometimes includes things like "doing the legwork to be part of employer matching programs".
Re:Donate Unrestricted by theamk on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:14PM (#26378146)
Now all cases like this, many nonprofits have multiple independent projects

Like Mozilla foundation, which has a number of separate "initiatives"

Or Wikimedia, which partially works on Wikipedia.org website, but also works on a number of projects not directly related to the main website.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by account42 on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @05:39AM (#26397411)
Exactly the two charities I was thinking of!

Sometimes there is only one charity that covers a certain topic so if they also do other things you don't want to support the only choices are to make a restricted donation or to not donate at all.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by Viliam1234 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @08:12PM (#26381388)
Of course, if the charity itself encourages you to choose, then it's perfectly okay.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by cortesoft on Sunday March 07, 2021 @06:46PM (#26380921)
This is true, unless there isn’t $x of unrestricted budget to move around.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by andrewfong on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:39PM (#26380030)
Reminds me of the story about the Yale donor who wanted a cathedral, but Yale wanted a gym, so they built a gym that looked like a cathedral. https://www.gpsmycity.com/attractions/payne-whitney-gymnasiu...
Re:Donate Unrestricted by HuShifang on Sunday March 07, 2021 @04:54PM (#26380146)
Yup. They're really into the medieval aesthetic there -- the Hall of Graduate Studies was built in the 1930s IIRC, and they splashed the stone walls with acid and purposefully cracked some of the stained glass windows to make it all look that much more Oxbridge-y....
Re:Donate Unrestricted by michaelt on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:25PM (#26377701)
> It was much easier to get money donated for a new building, than to maintain an old one, so you can have a situation in which new buildings are being built while old ones fall apart.

That seems logical enough to me.

I mean, if every new building is an unprofitable drag on university finances, they wouldn't be building more of them. At the very least a building should pay for its own upkeep, if not its original construction costs.

And given that the fundraising department will surely want to tell rich donors that buildings are good for the university, simultaneously saying that the previous buildings were all bad for the university would be a very confusing message.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by MattGaiser on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:33PM (#26377792)
> if every new building is an unprofitable drag on university finances, they wouldn't be building more of them.

No, you then need a steady supply of new buildings to provide funding to fix the old ones/replace the old ones.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by entangledqubit on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:16PM (#26378791)
I'd love to hear insider stories about how misaligned fundraising department metrics can end up being for the university.

Regarding donating buildings in general, Andrew Carnegie seemed to get a lot of prestige leverage when he funded thousands of public libraries by paying for the buildings while requiring the locals to pay the upkeep and operation.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by ISL on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:09PM (#26382215)
The problem is even worse than that: The desire for fiscal accountability within universities is so high, there is little room for trust.

My documentation and compliance burden was as high for a $5 purchase as a $5k purchase. My estimate of the salary cost (neglecting overhead) of approving a single purchase (my approval, electronic documentation, paper documentation, front-office approval, and PI oversight) was ~$80. That doesn't account for the impact of lost time on other tasks. For a $5 purchase.

The true accountability -- If I consistently spent money on something contrary to the aims of the lab? I'd be either out of a job or deprived of tools necessary to get the work done.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by hanniabu on Sunday March 07, 2021 @05:25PM (#26380391)
> keeping track of each dollar's origin, and making sure that it was spent on only what the source approved it to be spent on

Why not just keep a separate fund for each purpose and as these donations come in you route out the portions to the desired fund? If that is what's done then what's the difficult part that I'm missing?

Re:Donate Unrestricted by rossdavidh on Sunday March 07, 2021 @05:28PM (#26380410)
Part of it was that each source wanted to be able to audit _their_ money, and have traceability. So in some sense it was just what you say, but that roughly doubles the amount of work done for accounting software. It also meant that most private-sector software was insufficient for the task.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by ptest1 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @06:54PM (#26380965)
Not only that, but many nonprofits must force their employees and even volunteers to use annoying time tracking software!
Re:Donate Unrestricted by agumonkey on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:49PM (#26379108)
These kind of problems might be a good soil for some blockchain based things to reach actual utility. It pains me to see how difficult giving can be (even if it's justified) and having a solution to make it leaner would be very much welcomed.