News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donate Unrestricted by Viliam1234 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:53PM (#26377961)
If you expect that someone just wants to steal your money (and I am not saying such expectation is always wrong), perhaps you just shouldn't give them any.

On the other hand, if you trust that someone wants to do a good thing, they probably have more information about the topic than you do, so you should give them freedom to actually act on that information. Like, maybe you think "X is way more important than Y", but maybe the lack of Y is actually what prevents them from doing X efficiently, so your restriction to only use the money for X is not helpful, even from the X-maximizing perspective.

Like, sometimes your mission is to distribute food to starving kids in Africa, but you can't organize your volunteers until you buy a new computer, because the only one you had just broke. Then someone gives you a paycheck with big letters "only use to buy food, I don't want to see you wasting money on computers". Yeah, thanks a lot, dear condescending saint.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by tgsovlerkhgsel on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:09PM (#26378111)
> If you expect that someone just wants to steal your money (and I am not saying such expectation is always wrong), perhaps you just shouldn't give them any.

This is indeed the approach I've been taking with some climate change charities: most of them have an "advocacy" component, and while I'd like to support effective emissions reduction projects, I'm not willing to contribute to the preaching for individual asceticism.

I have no issue giving to "some project + a proportionate share of central/overhead costs".

Unfortunately, it's often extremely hard to find a charity that is tax deductible where you live, part of employer matching programs, effective in running projects you want to support, and not performing activities you specifically don't want to support.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by scrose on Sunday March 07, 2021 @08:14PM (#26381397)
‘Advocacy’ is very broad. I hope you’re not discounting donating to places because you think it can only mean one thing!
Re:Donate Unrestricted by tgsovlerkhgsel on Monday March 08, 2021 @07:28PM (#26393649)
The word itself isn't the problem, and in general I don't have an issue donating to organizations that also tackle the problem on a political level.

With climate change specifically, if I can't reasonably rule out the risk that the org will spend the money to tell me that I can't have an air conditioner, meat, or travel (or worse, lobby my government to ban me from having these things), they're not getting any money.

I'm OK with taking some risk that the org will use money in a way that I consider non-optimal, but I draw the line where I see a risk that the money may be used directly against my own interests. "Don't feed the mouth that bites you", I guess.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by throwawaygh on Monday March 08, 2021 @11:29AM (#26387533)
In particular, drawing on an example from OP, advocacy sometimes includes things like "doing the legwork to be part of employer matching programs".
Re:Donate Unrestricted by theamk on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:14PM (#26378146)
Now all cases like this, many nonprofits have multiple independent projects

Like Mozilla foundation, which has a number of separate "initiatives"

Or Wikimedia, which partially works on Wikipedia.org website, but also works on a number of projects not directly related to the main website.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by account42 on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @05:39AM (#26397411)
Exactly the two charities I was thinking of!

Sometimes there is only one charity that covers a certain topic so if they also do other things you don't want to support the only choices are to make a restricted donation or to not donate at all.

Re:Donate Unrestricted by Viliam1234 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @08:12PM (#26381388)
Of course, if the charity itself encourages you to choose, then it's perfectly okay.