News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by Scene_Cast2 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @04:14PM (#26334642)
The standard conversation that happens around such posts:

"Salaries in SV are so much higher than elsewhere" - "But so is rent, but SV still comes out to be more profitable"

"Salaries in USA are so much higher than elsewhere" - "But so is healthcare, and there's no social safety net"

"Salaries in FANG make smart people work on optimizing for clicks instead of doing something more beneficial for the world"

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by dang on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:25PM (#26335635)
You're quite right. I wish we had a more reliable way to downweight such generic responses, which reliably recur on every story related to an ongoing theme. HN threads are much better when they have interesting diffs.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...

Of course I need to downweight this subthread too, because metageneric is a subset of generic, plus meta is its own issue.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by clairity on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:03PM (#26336082)
at the risk of wallowing in the meta, sometimes i fantasize about having a button that zaps away all the tropey, partisan, bigoted, and ideological comments (even ones i might nod along with) in one fell swoop, leaving just the ~10 genuinely interesting comments (which seems to be about the average on any given story, regardless of # of comments). can we get a button like that? #downvotingfatigue (i realize this is practically impossible)
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by Scene_Cast2 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:47PM (#26335910)
Makes sense. My goal with the comment was to shortcut the stuff that's already been discussed.

I wouldn't necessarily call this topic "generic". The "gravitational pull" you mention seems like a product of "number of people affected" x "how much of a relatable concern it is"; employment compensation scores high. Apple launches are another example of this.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by dang on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @07:32PM (#26336999)
I just mean that as a topic becomes larger and more general, there are fewer new things to say about it.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by stack_underflow on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @04:52PM (#26335178)
One thing I've noticed is that the people making these counter-arguments seem to completely ignore (or don't know about) the ridiculous amounts of equity that $big_tech_co's are handing out.

Yes some of those points can be valid, and I understand that not all software companies hand out that much stock or are private and therefore it's harder to depend on, etc. But maybe it's just the bubble of tech that I've existed in within the PNW, but tonnes of people in my circle have built FIRE-level wealth by just having been driven enough to put up with bullshit interviews and staying long enough to get their stock grants.

I can say personally I definitely wouldn't have made it to where I did financially had I stayed in Canada, or it probably would've taken me at least 15 years instead of ~5.

If you're the type of person for who money can solve a lot of problems, I always suggest considering this as an option. It's solved ~90% of the problems in my life and has bought me years of time to be able to do what I actually want in life.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by ghaff on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:06PM (#26335362)
This is mostly an argument for people who have either gotten a lot of equity at large public tech companies--at least some of them--and/or just had a lot of money in equities, including large public tech companies, over the past 10 years or so.

Even if someone hasn't won the FAANG lottery, there are a lot of folks, including those that aren't collecting SV-level comp, who have done pretty well being well-invested in diversified equities.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by tomatotomato37 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:18PM (#26335538)
Equity is great when the stock market is booming, but when it decides to drop off a cliff every decade or so for whatever reason I'd prefer if my actual salary didn't go with it
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by dcolkitt on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:46PM (#26335894)
The thing is, it's very hard to get rich without some sort of equity. Maybe it's not equity in public companies, but almost all wealthy people get to that point by owning something. Whether that's stock options in a startup or a general partnership in a hedge fund or a medical practice or a piece of property that gets developed.

All equity comes with risk. Doubly so for the type of equity that generates a lot of wealth. Stability is nice, but expect to pay through the nose for it. The only real exception I can think of are people with exceptional talent in an exceptionally in demand skill. E.g. Tom Brady or Linus Torvalds or a world-class neurosurgeon.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by ghaff on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @08:40PM (#26337504)
Linus Torvalds makes a lot less than Tom Brady. He basically makes as much as the executive director at the Linux Foundation, something over $600K, but nothing extraordinary by SV standards. And there's no equity associated with the LF.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by wallflower on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @09:29PM (#26337882)
I once saw him walking the floor at Comdex (not the main Las Vegas one but in Chicago). Watchig him walking around, shaking hands, and catching up with his old friends at Red Hat and the like, I couldn't help but feel an intangible sense that the guy was happy. Someone who had created something significant out of nothing (This was before Linux really took off in the 90s). I was starstruck.

> His fortunes changed in 1999. Red Hat and VA Linux, both leading purveyors of Linux-based software packages tailored for large enterprises, had granted him stock options with no strings attached, thank-yous from entrepreneurs who hoped to grow rich off his creation. When Red Hat went public that year, Torvalds was suddenly worth $1 million. On the day VA Linux (now VA Software) went public, Torvalds was worth roughly $20 million, though by the time he could sell his shares, they were valued at only a fraction of that.

> Torvalds hesitated before buying himself his first expensive bauble, a two-seater BMW convertible. "I was a bit nervous about people's reaction," he confesses. "Are they going to think I've gone over to the dark side?" In the end he decided that the shape and price of the hunk of metal he drove to and from work each day was his own business. Despite counsel to the contrary, Torvalds wisely sold all of his stock and spent almost all of the windfall on his home and his cars, trusting that he'd always be able to earn a good salary as an engineer.

https://web.archive.org/web/20031127045640/https://www.wired...

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by stack_underflow on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:30PM (#26336370)
Sure, but there are also strategies to buffer yourself from that. Barring the first year where you have to wait/make it up to the 12-month mark to get the full 25% of your equity paid out, 99% of companies (i.e. almost everyone except for Amazon IME) will vest 1/4 of your annual 25% stock comp quarterly - I've even seen 1/12th-monthly in an offer.

If you're willing to take the short-term cap gains hit you can sell your stock immediately after vesting and reinvest in a total market index or w/e aligns with your investing philosophy. If we're talking hard numbers, you'd still be pulling in 150-200k+ in base salary/cash and let's say, in a non-ideal situation, what would've been your $125k of annual stock vest is now worth 30% less - still not a bad deal IMO.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by laurencerowe on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:57PM (#26338804)
By my understanding RSUs vest monthly at Google and Facebook with no cliff, making them a slightly more volatile cash equivalent. Many diversify immediately by auto-selling the bulk of their stock grants and buying tracker funds.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by logicslave on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:48PM (#26336558)
Nobody gets rich without owning equity in a business.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by laurencerowe on Thursday March 04, 2021 @12:14AM (#26338900)
> I can say personally I definitely wouldn't have made it to where I did financially had I stayed in Canada, or it probably would've taken me at least 15 years instead of ~5

This is my experience coming from Britain too, but honestly not sure it's had any great effect on my level of life satisfaction - you can live a pretty comfortable life on software engineer's salary most places. The work available in Silicon Valley is definitely more interesting, but you now work in an office park 30 miles form the city centre and housing has gotten so expensive its driven out a lot of the interesting cultural life.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by notJim on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @07:06PM (#26336748)
My idea has always been that you can take a topic like this, and generate 90% of the discussion using machine learning. If I ever have some time, I will give it a shot, or hopefully someone else does it.

Then write a forum software that just fills in the appropriate discussion for each article, and save us all a lot of trouble :)

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by vmception on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:24PM (#26335620)
when the deepest financial discussion from the general population is about cost of living, I rest assured that I have no competition
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by ketamine__ on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:11PM (#26335433)
On balance, anyone remote before the pandemic and traveling the world has probably had a better life than someone with the same skills making double the salary in SV. Just the reduction in poop on sidewalks speaks for itself.

Apparently this comment triggered someone lol.

Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by Rebelgecko on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:31PM (#26336380)
Maybe this is falling into the trap that OP wanted to avoid but I think you're right. Sure, if I moved to the Bay Area my income would go up by 10-15%. But about half of that would go straight to taxes, and IMO the remainder wouldn't be enough to set me up with a comparable quality of life.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by dang on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:26PM (#26335652)
Scene_Cast2 should add this as a fourth element to their list.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by ketamine__ on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:24PM (#26336295)
It will all make it to n-gate.com. Don't worry.
Re:Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across... by astrange on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:22PM (#26335586)
San Francisco isn't in Silicon Valley. They're just pretending.