News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by Ambolia on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @09:52AM (#26329053)
Imaginary numbers are not so scary if you just think of them as 2d vectors with a different multiplication operation added to it.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by injb on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:19AM (#26329417)
*complex numbers. But yes you're right. The biggest problem (at least for me) is the name. Because everyone recognizes "real" and "imaginary" as adjectives, they think that's how these words should be understood in the context of numbers. But in truth, they are _proper nouns_, i.e. labels, and nothing more.

As far as the adjective "imaginary" is concerned, all numbers are imaginary.

Really the sooner we stop calling them "real" and "imaginary" the better. They are terrible choices of name, coined by people who didn't really understand them, and didn't want you to understand them either.

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by janderson3 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:32AM (#26329642)
Absolutely agree.

What's your preferred terminology? I like "Forward" and "Reverse" for positive and negative number and "Lateral" for the imaginary unit, since it is just perpendicular to the Forward and Reverse numbers.

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by injb on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:55AM (#26330028)
That's pretty close to what Gauss said they should be called:

"If ... +1, -1, and √-1 had been called direct, inverse and lateral units, instead of positive, negative, and imaginary (or impossible) units, such an obscurity would have been out of the question"

(https://shitohichiumaya.blogspot.com/2016/10/gausss-quote-fo...)

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by Robotbeat on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:46AM (#26329873)
I just think of them as different axes on a 2D Cartesian plane. That’s basically how they work.

EDIT: similarly, quaternions as a number in 4D, with that extra dimension being handy for avoiding the instability problems when you get near “gimbal lock” in 3D rotations.

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by phkahler on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:18AM (#26330429)
But the quaternions sort of make the real component special dont they?
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by kortex on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:46AM (#26342296)
That it more an effect of how we use them in computer geometry. Unit quaternions with ijk plus real map to an xyz tilt plus a rotor. But I believe you could pick any such mapping.

On the other hand, dual quaternions do care which is the dual component, since multiplying by complex numbers looks like true rotation, while multiplying by a dual looks like rotation around a point at infinity, aka translation.

So in that case maybe there is something special about the real component.

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by klmadfejno on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:34AM (#26329677)
Good and evil.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by _jal on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:37AM (#26329731)
Spooky and strange?
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by andrewprock on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:55AM (#26330039)
Human and Werewolf.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by kortex on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:48AM (#26342322)
Spooky Werewolf Algebras on the Monster group. Coming to arxiv this October.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by yccs27 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:20AM (#26330464)
I also like the name "lateral unit", maybe call the field "planar numbers"?
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by bikenaga on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @07:49PM (#26337140)
Mathematicians have largely abandoned the term "imaginary number" and use "complex number" instead. I never used the term "imaginary number" when I was teaching (except to point out that it wasn't very good terminology).

But the old term still survives in some areas. For instance, the real and imaginary parts of a complex number:

  re (3 + 4 i) = 3  and  im (3 + 4 i) = 4.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by ko27 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @12:00PM (#26331176)
> They are terrible choices of name, coined by people who didn't really understand them, and didn't want you to understand them either.

Sorry to be blunt, but your comment is horrible. There is far more going on here than you realize. Real numbers have an isomorphism with our reality. We thought we didn't need imaginary numbers to describe reality. They were inteded to be used more as a mathematical tool.

Another good example is euclidean vs non-euclidean geometry. They are both incredibly useful, but the former one was though to be "real" and the latter "imaginary". But it turns, physics is okay with us living in a non-euclidean universe (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_of_the_universe).

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by fooker on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:13AM (#26339959)
> Real numbers have an isomorphism with our reality.

You can probably get a nobel prize by proving this. :)

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by GoblinSlayer on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:25AM (#26330565)
In quantum physics complex numbers are used to represent circular symmetry, so they are more like modulus and phase.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by jonnycomputer on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:32AM (#26329650)
Do you have a suggestion for an alternative to "real number"?
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by feisuzhu on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:37PM (#26338312)
Real number are called 实数 in Chinese which is literally `solid number`.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by injb on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:56AM (#26330047)
I responded to a similar comment above with a link to what Guass called them.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by gpm on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:42AM (#26329797)
Continuous numbers?
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by macksd on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:46AM (#26329869)
Imaginary numbers are also continuous, are they not?
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by gpm on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:22AM (#26330499)
So they are, so are many other spaces.

I'd avoid calling complex numbers "numbers" personally. In the context of plain english (and not currently in the context of mathematics) I think of the word "number" as saying that this is somehow a measure of a quantity (We have "a number" of brands of cereal in the store). Complex numbers are not a measure of a quantity.

I'd probably replace the "numbers" part with "field". I don't have a good replacement for the "complex" part, but I think that should change also (because telling people things are complex is almost as bad as telling them that they are imaginary). If no one proposed something better and I was king of the universe I guess I'd just name them after whoever discovered them.

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by injb on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:52AM (#26331036)
Would you consider -3 a number? It's certainly not a measure of quantity. A better way of thinking about it is that it's 2 things: a magnitude and a direction. Complex numbers just expand the direction into two dimensions. As long as you accept negative numbers, then you already accept the fact that there can be more than one number of a given size. The complex numbers just contain infinitely many numbers of a given size, instead of only 2.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by gpm on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @12:06PM (#26331265)
In plain english, no I don't think I would particularly consider -3 a number. If I say someone gave me a number of horses I don't mean they stole my horse. I think it is the right call to include them in the mathematical definition though. Unlike complex numbers they are almost always useful (they are needed to turn the object into a field, which is needed if you want everyday operations like subtraction to always remain within the set), have a much more intuitive definition of multiplication, are a smaller generalization, etc.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by rimiform on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:42AM (#26329808)
That's great, but my intuition fails me when I try to consider what it would mean for the answer to some question to be a complex number. It's even worse for quaternions, because I can't even use the spatial analogue there.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by munchbunny on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:09AM (#26330281)
I think about it this way: the complex-ness of the number is really just a representational trick. What it means, intuitively, depends on what the question is really asking and why the behaviors of math on complex numbers is well-suited to representing the answer, and that reason might change based on the context.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by srean on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:43AM (#26329830)
There is more to it. Vectors typically don't have multiplication defined. Complex numbers form a field and that is a major extra feature. Multiplication and division I'd defined on them.

If this property is not needed one can make do with 2d vectors instead.

There are 4d and 8d analogues as well. Hamilton started an ambitious program to base mathematics of nature on the basis of the 4d ones -- quarternions

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by gspr on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:02AM (#26330159)
> Imaginary numbers are not so scary if you just think of them as 2d vectors with a different multiplication operation added to it.

Perhaps, but that view makes them seem arbitrary. It makes it seem as if you could just do the same thing in 3d, 4d, etc. and they'd all be equally impacful and meaningful.

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by leereeves on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:07AM (#26330251)
You can (almost). You can do the same thing again to get quaternions, and again to get octonions, and so on.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cayley%E2%80%93Dickson_constru...

That's different from extending 1d to 2d, 3d, etc as vectors.

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @12:44PM (#26331856)
"And so on"? I thought octonions are where it stops? At least, anything past the octonions is not able to be a normed division algebra, if I understand correctly.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by leereeves on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @01:24PM (#26332412)
It doesn't stop, but as you said, the next step (sedenions), and all steps after that have non-trivial zero divisors and aren't division algebras.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by gspr on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:48AM (#26339803)
Exactly. This is what I was hinting at when critical at people who say complex numbers are "just 2d reals with fancy multiplication". It's true, of course, but it makes it seem as if the 2 in "2d" is unimportant/arbitrary.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by gspr on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:33AM (#26330691)
I know. But these are not as fundamentally important as the complex numbers.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by bikenaga on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @08:24PM (#26337409)
Representing complex numbers as 2-dim. real vectors is just one way of constructing complex numbers. It is convenient because you can draw 2-dim. vectors, and it makes complex numbers feel more tangible.

Something like the original motivation (which you might find less "arbitrary") goes like this. We know how to solve some quadratic equations like x^2 = 9: We get x = 3 and x = -3 (though it was a nontrivial thing to realize those negative solutions are there). What about x^2 = 2? We can "see" the solution should be the length of the hypotenuse of a right triangle whose legs are both 1, so maybe encouraged by the geometry we don't feel too bad about having solutions (+/- sqrt(2)) which are, however, not rational numbers.

(Notice that we keep "extending" our idea of "number". Well, if we didn't have feature creep no one would buy the new version.)

Since we now have negative numbers, we ask about solutions to x^2 = -1. The first response is there are "no solutions", because there are no real numbers that square to -1. Rather than give up, we decide to "extend" the real numbers to provide solutions to this equation.

The idea is actually pretty easy if you know some modular arithmetic. For instance, mod 6 arithmetic means that you take the integers and consider things that differ by multiples of 6 to be "the same". As a consequence, 17 = 5, 4 = -14, and (importantly) 6 = 0.

Thinking in the same way, to get solutions to x^2 = -1, we want x^2 + 1 = 0. That's like "6 = 0", so "x^2 + 1" should be our "modulus", but what "number system" do we "mod out of" (instead of the integers, with the integers mod 6)? Since x^2 + 1 is a real polynomial, it looks like our "base number system" should be R[x], the (ring of) polynomials with real coefficients (stuff like -17 x^3 + 1.374 x^2 - 31/42 and so on).

So we should take real polynomials, but agree that two polynomials differing by a multiple of x^2 + 1 are "the same". We conclude that the complex numbers "should be"

  R[x]  mod  <x^2 + 1>
where the "<x^2 + 1>" means "all (polynomial) multiples of x^2 + 1".

For instance,

  x^3 + 4 x + 1 = (x^3 + x) + (3 x + 1) = x(x^2 + 1) + (3 x + 1)
    = 3 x + 1 (mod x^2 + 1)  (the multiple of x^2 + 1 is 0)
(To agree that some things should be regarded as "the same" is to construct an equivalence relation, and the "bags" of "same things" are equivalence classes. I'm omitting the details from abstract algebra, but this construction is called "forming the quotient ring R[x]/<x^2 + 1>".)

By this construction, "3 + 4 i" appears as

  3 + 4 x (mod x^2 + 1)  or  (3 + 4 x) + <x^2 + 1>.
In the construction of the complex numbers via 2-dim. real vectors, "3 + 4 i" appears as (3, 4).

You can also construct the complex numbers as a subring of the 2 x 2 real matrices, so "3 + 4 i" appears as

  3 [1 0]  +  4 [0  1]
    [0 1]       [-1 0] .
Notice that

  [0  1]^2 = [-1 0] = - [1 0]   (like i^2 = -1)
  [-1 0]     [0 -1]     [0 1]
So those are three ways of constructing the complex numbers, and each has pros and cons. No one of them "is" the complex numbers. "The" complex numbers are really an isomorphism class of rings, and we're just giving different representatives from that class.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by 1996 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @09:52PM (#26338030)
Wonderful explanation, thanks a lot!
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by pfortuny on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @12:30PM (#26331646)
The thing (which is subtle) is that the dimensionality is 1. Which is, as far as I have read the intro to the preprint cited in the Quanta article, what the authors are mistaken.

Algebraically, as vector spaces:

C is the change of base of R when tensored by C

which is not the same as

R^2 as R-vector space tensored by C

(not at all the same).

Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by SavantIdiot on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:19AM (#26330456)
Where the analogy to a 2D vector starts to diverge is raising something to a complex power. There's no meaning in raising 3 to the [x,y], but Euler clearly defined it for 3^(xi+y).
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by denkquer on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:23AM (#26329488)
Imaginary numbers are 1d. complex are 2d.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by yakubin on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:41AM (#26329784)
And real numbers are ∞-d, over rationals.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality by simonh on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:39AM (#26329751)
There are 2d values that aren't imaginary numbers.