News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by smokey_circles on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:02AM (#26291262)
I don't know how/why people defend this test.

1. It's inaccurate. And that's not just "technically true", it's very rare that the test reproduces results.

2. Jung's theories (the ones used in the test) aren't just "controversial". They're wrong. He says it himself, in the same document they used to create the test.

It is just a cash cow now.

The _biggest_ problem with the test is it is harmful, not helpful. People believe the results are accurate _and permanent_ and so division is created where in reality there is more overlap than difference.

It's also not good to tell people "these are good" followed up by "you have none of them and never will".

By the way: This is true of a _lot_ of IQ tests too: We're still debating what IQ is, nevermind how to measure it. So we definitely shouldn't be telling people the results of their IQ tests, most of which are also not reproducible.

But the data these tests collect is useful. We just shouldn't wield such aouthority about a theory with a lot of apparent leaks we can't explain. There's a better way

Psychology is a young field. Lots of kinks to work out still

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by patentatt on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:23AM (#26293974)
Anecdotally I’ve taken an ‘official’ MBTI a few times over a couple decades, and always came out with the same results. I don’t think it’s magic or anything, but I also don’t think it hurts to reflect on how you interact with the world and those around you, and how those around you interact with you in return, and then try to identify some themes in those interactions to think about. I wouldn’t go making any grandiose proclamations from it, but as a conduit to some potentially beneficial reflection I see no harm in it either.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:56AM (#26291791)
Getting different results is pretty common. But getting the same results isn't very rare. The article points to studies showing MBTI and Big 5 repeatability are comparable.

It was inspired by Jung's theories. It doesn't rely on them.

MBTI related literature stresses it measures preferences not abilities. It says no type is better than any other. And it tends to encourage developing what doesn't come naturally.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fsloth on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:01AM (#26292142)
You can bin people in any number of arbitrary ways. Just the fact you can bin people does not make the binning usefull.

Meyers-Squid is equally valid as any other fiction driven binning process. Like dividing people into Hogswarts houses.

Stability alone is useless if the predictive qualities do not extend beyond the binning process. Being INTJ only predicts the next time you do the test (if the scoring is stable) you might be more likely to score INTJ again. It does not predict the tested persons’ life outcomes or performance at work, in personal OR statistical sense.

The scores don’t predict anything of value outside of the test framework. This is what it means to be useless pseudoscience. It can be a fun party game and thus be usable as a facilitation tool, but beyond that it’s useless (or harmfull if someone tries to use the scores for something like ’creating balanced teams’).

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by crispyambulance on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:45AM (#26293013)
> predictive qualities do not extend beyond the binning process

I agree that these tests should not be used for the purpose of evaluating/predicting the "fit" of any individual in an organization from an HR or leadership perspective. They are helpful, imho, for understanding some characteristics of one's own personality and how it relates to others.

Personality is a real thing. It's also very complex so having some "bins" to structure how you (as an individual) think about it can be super useful. But yeah, in the hands of HR and other amateur psychologists it's not a useful tool.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by concordDance on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:53AM (#26292403)
Are you really saying that testing as intj (for example) doesn't correlate with anything? Because that seems incredibly unlikely. E.g. three years ago Slate Star Codex readers were surveyed and found to be 10 times more likely to be INTJ/INTP than the general population.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fsloth on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:46AM (#26293719)
Statistically it would be very surprising if Meyers-Briggs score would not have correlations with some other samplings - but that does not make it any more relevant. The fact that you can bin answers does not make your questionnaire in any way relevant unless you have some theory how the binned statistic can be used outside of the scoring process. Meyers-Briggs is all about the scoring, and has no usable theory how that scoring could be used.

A correlation alone does not mean it "means anything". Accidental correlations are quite common. We also notice them really well and tend to give them more meaning beyond them being random events.

Picking only positive correlations from an arbitrary data set is also known as p-hacking - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_dredging

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Twisol on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:29AM (#26292601)
Not particularly having a horse in this race, if a theory can't reliably make useful predictions, it's not a very useful theory. There's certainly something to be said about identifying correlations, but it isn't yet clear to me whether we can draw inferences based on those correlations to make useful predictions.

In the SSC example, I wouldn't be especially shocked if there are no useful inferences in either direction, but rather a confounding variable that makes it more likely for SSC readers to answer MBTI answers in a particular way. MBTI itself wouldn't necessarily have a lot to say about this factor. (And given the intellectual, self-aware content of SSC, it seems pretty likely to me that this is the case.)

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:18AM (#26292863)
There are tons of correlations, for example INTP/INTJ subreddits on Reddit being most popular while these types generally are one of the rarest. There's tons of things you can predict with this. INTPs are often going to face similar challenges and obstacles in life, there's similar things that will help them grow as a person that would not help other types.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Twisol on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:51AM (#26293047)
Sure. Now can we do the same with the other fourteen types, or is the primary value here that there are two kinds of people: INTx and non-INTx?

There's probably some bias here, but I've only ever heard INTx specifically singled out when talking about MBTI. That suggests that MBTI may make too many clear distinctions where reality draws a much softer line. A coarser-grained theory is likely to have more predictive power and be more applicable. Alternatively, a fine-grained theory with the boundaries drawn differently, such as the Big Five, may better account for these softer distinctions.

I'm not saying this is definitively the case. I'm saying that a complex theory that makes a small set of predictions doesn't justify its weight. If MBTI does fall into that category, we should feel no qualms about finding something that works better for us.

(Personally, I get a lot more out of the Bartle taxonomy. Only four broad classifications, and more focused on what value one seeks from certain kinds of games. Not without its flaws, either.)

> INTPs are often going to face similar challenges and obstacles in life, there's similar things that will help them grow as a person that would not help other types.

I really am going to need a citation for this. Here's my new horse: there cannot be 16 broad (even with overlap) classes of obstacles and growth opportunities in life that are specific to each personality type. Humans are simultaneously too subtle for a personality test to provide this level of insight, and too similar for tactics to be inapplicable to all but one type of person. It smells like horoscopes, and there are only twelve of those.

We all have issues. Let's categorize those, not the personality types that we think correlate with them. It borders on claiming that the problems I have in life are because of something wrong with me, and not just the circumstances of life in general.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:13AM (#26293524)
Talking about personality models seems to appeal to INTJs and INTPs more than anyone else. Never hearing about other types probably says something about your social circles too.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by cb321 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:33AM (#26293631)
Are all psychometricians INTx's, then? This sounds like exactly the kind of over-conclusion that bothers people about personality testing and its applications. ;-)
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:39AM (#26293673)
Of course not. It's all probabilistic. I feel like the people who think MBTI and personality tests don't make sense are themselves the ones making those over conclusions and they can only think in binary, black and white way, when it really could be something like INTx is likely to be overrepresented in psychometricians fields by 4x, ESFJ might be underrepresented by 5x, etc.

So for instance maybe there's 6% INTXs in the world, but in psychometry field there happens to be 30% INTX representation. Nobody is making the claim that ALL psy

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by cb321 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:47AM (#26293721)
Or it could be these tests literally do not even discriminate 99% of the population if the measurement error is near the size of the mode width. See my other comment. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26292915
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by cb321 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:57AM (#26293794)
A simpler way to think about it might be "How would I assign a p-value to the personality type?" Once you have that answer, all your "over-representation" stats should, naturally, trim out (or otherwise down-weight) the poor p-value personality assignments (any such over-representation stats that you have heard very likely do no such filtering).
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:32AM (#26294051)
Never hearing about other types probably says something about their social circles because amateur psychometricians come in other types too.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by nicoburns on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:30AM (#26293280)
Have you looked into the "Cognitive Functions" that MBTI theory uses? If not, I'd recommend reading through the 101, 201, and 301 articles here https://personalityjunkie.com/typology-101/

To me I see "INTx" and think that makes no sense because INTJ and INTP have completely different functional stacks. INTJ's are dominant "Introverted Intuition" (Ni) followed by "Extraverted Feeling" (Fe), whereas INTP's are dominant "Introverted Thinking" (Ti) followed by "Extravert Inuition" (Ne). So they're basically completely different.

Once you have a functional stack, then the MBTI theory becomes a lot more subtle: not only does everyone have 4 our of the 8 functions in their stack covering both sides of each of the distinctions, but the relative strength of each of these functions can vary continuously.

And that's before you even get to variations based on experience, which the MBTI doesn't even attempt to describe (you'd typically use someone's MBTI type in conjunction with their life experience to explain their personality as a whole).

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Twisol on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:05AM (#26293488)
What 'pseudalopex mentioned -- and also note that I was responding to someboody who grouped INTJ/INTP together. I don't have much of a vested interest in MBTI; I was just trying to work from the ancestor post's foundation to think critically about what we're getting from that interpretation.

I know even less about "congnitive functions", but it definitely sounds more subtle than the axes most people interpret MBTI as. My specific criticisms don't immediately transfer.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:01AM (#26293464)
I think they just meant INTJ or INTP.

The functions are part of the controversial Jungian ideas the article mentioned. Most people ignore them entirely and treat the preferences as axes.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by nicoburns on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:09AM (#26293506)
> The functions are part of the controversial Jungian ideas the article mentioned. Most people ignore them entirely and treat the preferences as axes.

They do. And IMO this is exactly why the results never reproduce. The functions actually make sense and anecdotally seem to correspond to something in the real world (they've rarely if ever been subject to scientific testing as far as I'm aware). The preferences by themselves are just a somewhat less reproducible variant of the Big 5 as criticisms claim.

> I think they just meant INTJ or INTP.

I'm sure they did. My point being that if you look at the functions (which most anyone who takes Myers-Briggs seriously does) then INTJ and INTP aren't similar at all. So talking about them together makes little sense. Although reading up the thread, it looks like they were just suggesting that they both have subreddits. Which I guess isn't really talking about their personalities at all.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:35AM (#26293644)
They are similar since they correlate similarly with lots of real world aspects. E.G. most simple is they are both very actively represented on Reddit and second one being top 2 highest average IQs. They also share very many similar interests.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:25AM (#26293591)
MBTI reproduces much better if you treat the preferences as axes.

Most people who take MBTI seriously don't use the functions.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fsloth on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:03AM (#26293838)
I think those Cognitive Functions are just Jungian pseudoscience. They are based on work that is closer to fiction than science. Not any better or worse than any psychologically motivated work of fiction - but fiction never the less.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by nicoburns on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:47AM (#26294158)
I like to see it as an as-yet poorly evidenced scientific hypothesis rather than an pseudo-scientific "fact". Which indeed may need to go through further revisions before the correct version is found. But I see lots of circumstantial evidence which makes me think it is worthy of further investigation.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fsloth on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:39PM (#26295136)
Lots of good fiction feels profound. Good fiction feels right and true. But feeling right does not turn the fiction into science.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by nicoburns on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:37PM (#26295810)
Sure, but neither does a lack of evidence mean that something isn't true. It's not science currently. But that doesn't mean it won't be (nor does it mean it will be).

I think you'd be surprised at how many scientific breakthroughs have come from individuals being bloody minded about things that everyone else thought were ridiculous. Science isn't just about testing hypothesis. The other part of it is about generating hypothesis to test. That part tends to be a lot more fluffy and subjective, but it's just as critical to the scientific process.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fsloth on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:34PM (#26296310)
The main issue I have with Jungian analysis is that it takes Jungs ideas as given and then implements no work to test or validate them. Any authoritarian system that does not evolve is more like religious or political dogma than science.

The difference between Jung and for example Alfred Wegener who was one of the early proponents of plate tectonics is that Wegener's ideas were validated.

"Lots of strange ideas have been true" is not incorrect, but I think there are a lot more strange incorrect ideas out there than correct ones.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by forgotmypw17 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:13AM (#26293522)
Thank you for your comment. How apt it is that I found it via synchronicity of reading the /newcomments page :)
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:27AM (#26293600)
> Sure. Now can we do the same with the other fourteen types, or is the primary value here that there are two kinds of people: INTx and non-INTx?

I started with INTx to have at least one detailed, specific argument that there is correlation and MBTI is at least not completely meaningless. There's also a correlation between INTx and IQ, to go as scientific as we can here. Just search for IQ by personality type. Now you could say we are putting two completely meaningless metrics together. If they truly were, how could they have correlation?

Big Five is not the topic here. The argument is whether MBTI can have meaning and whether it can be useful. Let's say Big Five was better, it doesn't mean that MBTI is completely useless. And I'm not going to argue about Big Five vs MBTI.

> there cannot be 16 broad (even with overlap) classes of obstacles and growth opportunities in life that are specific to each personality type.

No one has made this claim. There are various obstacles and challenges in life, and the only claim is that some personality types are more LIKELY to face some obstacles and challenges than other personality types. E.g. INTX will LIKELY have to put in more conscious effort to improve social skills in order to better communicate with people. This already is useful information. It also gives insights into how a person thinks and perceives the world, if you go into how functions work and which personality types are more likely to use which functions to understand what is going on. If there are 16 categories you can get a quick understanding of what a person might be like if you know the MBTI type, which otherwise you would have to read tons of paper on that person to understand what he/she LIKELY is.

It's all a game of probabilities and spectrum. You could do statements like, this person is 65% I, 70% N, 75% T, 66% P, therefore there's likelihood of this person facing challenges with social situations being 80-90%. The way this person is likely to make decisions is to use internal thinking to make conclusions based on logical analysis. All of this can say a lot about the person just with 4 letters.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Twisol on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:58AM (#26293800)
> E.g. INTX will LIKELY have to put in more conscious effort to improve social skills in order to better communicate with people

I knew I needed to work on my social skills long before I tested as an INTP. My criticism is not that the correlations don't exist. My criticism is that they don't seem helpful.

> It also gives insights into how a person thinks and perceives the world [...] which otherwise you would have to read tons of paper on that person

Can't you just talk with them? Somebody once asked me for my MBTI class as a shortcut to trying to understand how to interact with me. It didn't work very well for them, and I didn't much appreciate being binned that way.

I've always been binned as a logical person in particular, but my internal landscape has been, subjectively, dominated by creative thought and expression. Logic is just a tool I use to impose some structure on that experience. People who stop at the surface -- and worse, who label me under MBTI -- manifestly do not understand me, my motivations, my goals, or my challenges. (If you go point to some MBTI page on Logicians and say "it mentions creativity right here!" I will be very cross with you.)

To say this is a sore spot may be an understatement.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:15PM (#26294891)
Helpful is subjective. I don't feel like sharing something personal here though.

Do you take the time to understand everyone you meet, their motivations, their goals, and their challenges? Even the ones who don't want you to?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Twisol on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:20PM (#26298064)
> Do you take the time to understand everyone you meet, their motivations, their goals, and their challenges? Even the ones who don't want you to?

To the degree our relationship warrants. Don't you? We all form mental models of the people we interact with over time. I don't see how the MBTI helps that process. As mentioned, for some people who have interacted with me, it has hindered that process by establishing a totem to which I am compared.

Is the argument that MBTI is useful when interacting with people you don't spend time with, who have a brief and transient presence in your life? Or is it more akin to birdwatching? I don't see either of those options as especially useful, but I won't fault anybody for it.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Saturday March 13, 2021 @08:04PM (#26451768)
In other words, there are a lot of people you don't get to know as individuals really.

You don't have to understand how something helps other people to understand they find it helpful. Any tool can be misused of course.

You seem more interested in belittling other points of view than understanding. I'm done.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bakary on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:46AM (#26294152)
The more straightforward explanation is that the INTP/INTJ descriptions are much more exciting to someone with introverted traits than any other MBTI result. They are much more likely to be discussed for that reason alone. The glamor of the result affects its distribution, when in reality people who meet the description in a plausible way are quite rare and exceptional.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:19PM (#26294934)
The actual influence seems to be N - I - T - P.

If you look at raw subscriber counts, but it may still be I - N if there are that many more extraverts.

https://www.reddit.com/r/entp/comments/56tfmi/of_subscribers...

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:04PM (#26294777)
INTJ and INTP sound awful to other introverts in my experience.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fsloth on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:52AM (#26293760)
The population of people who get an INTP result might have quite many asperger spectrum non-neurotypicals among them. If MB contains an accidental asperger scoring system within itself it does not make it relevant in the _general case_ for other personality types.

That said if INTP can be used as a lodestar for creating asperger communities and peer-support groups it's not a bad thing. But it does not really validate MB in any way as a general purpose psychometric tool.

I personally filled an online MB questionnaire or two in adolescence and certainly found the INTP score as something that helped me acknowledge a few things about myself. But it was not really something I would call fundamentally important.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bakary on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:39AM (#26294097)
INTJ and INTP are basically the "coolest" introvert result of the Myers-Briggs. For a supposedly rare result, it's one of the most trumpeted online and one with which people identify the strongest. The description of the result is essentially what those introverted readers imagine themselves to be when reading rationalist literature.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:12PM (#26294855)
Thinking INTJ and INTP descriptions sound cool says more about you than the descriptions.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by souprock on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:53AM (#26291781)
The article covers reproducibility. The test does reliably reproduce results, at least if you don't quantize to boolean. Jung doesn't matter. Being a cash cow doesn't matter.

There is nothing in the field of psychology with better support than IQ. If you aren't going to accept IQ, then you've entirely tossed out the field of psychology. There is nothing left.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by wizzwizz4 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:31AM (#26292609)
> There is nothing in the field of psychology with better support than IQ.

This is not true. See Wikipedia[0][1][2].

IQ actually holds little support, compared with (e.g.) bilateral sound recognition, or somatotopic arrangement on the postcentral gyrus. (Among psychologists, that is; IQ probably has more support amongst the general population, because it's pop-pseudoscience.)

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_race_and_intell...

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient#IQ_testi...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient#Validity...

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by bjoli on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:06AM (#26292796)
What we can say about iq tests is that they test something, and those results remain consistent through life. The results are positively correlated to many things (such as academic success. The people scoring a 9, the maximum result, on the tests used in the Swedish conscription live longer, etc...).

Had it been completely pop-pseudoscience it would not be used by, say, the Swedish school system as a tool to gauge whether someone has special needs that warrant another form of school with extra support. The tests used are however not the same as most people have done online, like WAIS (but for kids. Can't remember the name of it).

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by wizzwizz4 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:58AM (#26293086)
> The results are positively correlated to many things (such as academic success.

They would be so correlated even if they were a bad metric. Imagine a score that multiplies academic success and the highest Tetris score obtained within 100 miles of your birthplace, then subtracts 50 points if you're a girl. That would also be positively correlated with academic success.

IQ tests measure something, yes, but they're not magic. (See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law) I received a high-quality education including what amounts to IQ-test tuition (to pass an entrance exam); do you know of any studies that attempt to factor out this particular confounder?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by valvar on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:54AM (#26293415)
IQ tests measure the g factor and also happen to be the best way to measure it. So those opposed to IQ should either come up with a better way to measure g or be open about their rejection of the existence of differences in cognitive abilities.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by tsimionescu on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:21AM (#26294392)
If the best way we have to measure something is very bad, perhaps it's best to say we just can't measure it and keep looking, rather than using a very bad measure. It's like instead of trying to invent scales, we kept trying to measure objects' mass by their volume, which happens to work decently for many common objects, bud fails spectacularly for others. And instead of admitting we just can't measure mass, we'd fill our bags based on volume, and be consistently annoyed when we found we can pick up the "heavier" bag of balloons, but can't pick up the "lighter" bag of bowling balls.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mcguire on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:28PM (#26295035)
Don't you first have to define what you want to measure and demonstrate that it exists?
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by wizzwizz4 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:52PM (#26295261)
Only if you're doing science. It's possible to find things out without science slowing you down, but I wouldn't ordinarily recommend it; science is a great way to avoid the common traps that humans invariably fall into when they try to bypass the scientific method.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by notahacker on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:10AM (#26293510)
There's a pretty obvious false dichotomy between "rejection of the existence of differences in cognitive abilities" and assumption that such differences are as shallow as a single factor called g stably related to scores on a collection of pattern recognition tests.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by wizzwizz4 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:09PM (#26294829)
> IQ tests measure the g factor

Ah, yes. The g factor: “that which is measured by IQ tests”.

The main arguments for IQ tests, as far as I understand, that they correlate with an assortment of cognitive metrics, which all correlate with each other. This is a question. “It's the g factor” is not an answer; you've just stuck a circularly-defined label on the question (or, rather, on a particular frequentist analysis of the question) and declared it solved.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by runarberg on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:19PM (#26294937)
The best evidence for the existence of the g factor are IQ tests, and IQ tests are optimized to measure the g factor.

Do you see a problem there?

The g factor—or more descriptively—the theory of general intelligence has little support outside of the field of psychometrics. And the field of psychometrics is not known for it’s scientific rigor. Needless to say, there is little reason to believe that the theory of general intelligence has any grounds in reality, nor that the g factor exists outside of an operationally defined concept that might not hold any descriptive power for human behavior outside of a narrow setting of pen and paper tests.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Retric on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:22AM (#26293240)
Raw IQ scores aren’t very stable over time. At 90+ peoples raw scores have dropped significantly vs age 30. Trauma, Alcoholism, and other diseases can also lower scores dramatically. You can correlate adult IQ’s with tests taken by 2 year olds, but the individual raw scores again vary significantly.

It seems stable because of how age is adjusting for and the huge sweet spot where 64.2% of the population is grouped between 85 and 115. Basically people with significant developmental disabilities at 5 don’t suddenly become normal, but an IQ of 180 at 5 isn’t stable long term.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by zippy5 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:48AM (#26293380)
At quantum scale or near the speed of light newtonian mechanics breaks down, so we know it a local approximation. However, for set circumstances it approximates it does it well. For many decades physists searched universally true theory to no avail.

My point is this, IQ seems to have signal. It probably doesn't hold up in extreme circumstances. Psychology in particular seems to have a difficult time holding large enough studies to find universal constants that we should accept that IQ might be the best local approxination for now.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Retric on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:05AM (#26294277)
That doesn’t support your original point. Color blindness is very persistent over time IQ isn’t. Sure +/- 7 IQ points sounds very accurate, but that can be more than a 30 percentile change from two different tests 1 month apart meaning the actual signal is very weak.

You can read papers saying IQ texts on 2 year olds are strongly correlated with adult IQ, but read the details and individual people’s scores varied wildly.

So sure in aggregate it seems consistent, but that’s largely an artifact of test design. Someone with mental handicaps so profound as to be non communicative will consistently score very low, it doesn’t mean much for the general population.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by bjoli on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:24PM (#26294993)
First of all, scores are normalized to age (you never compare 90 to 30 years olds. Only 90 to 90-ish year olds).

No serious IQ test claim to measure much more than 2 standard deviations up and down (meaning they all break down somewhere above 130-135 or below 70). I have done WISC/WAIS three times (as a part of a psychological assessment) and the conversion to IQ scores were within 3 points (the WAIS/WISC scale measures many different abilities, and can be converted to an "aggregate" IQ score). I asked about this and when people are healthy the tester said people tend to score very similarly on tests, even many years apart.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Retric on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:02PM (#26296036)
Yes, the score is computed relative to other 90 year olds, however people’s individual cognitive decline is heavily influenced by heath and behavior so individuals can move up or down significantly on a that relative scale. Thus the computed score at 3 doesn’t accurately predict someone’s score at 90 nearly as well as a test taken at 30 predicts someone’s score at 40.

The issue with the underlying raw score at 90+ is it doesn’t map very well to a bell curve. Many people are quite healthy but a significant number are drastically reduced from their younger self.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mcguire on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:31PM (#26295064)
My high school transcripts show the results of IQ tests taken in the 4th and 6th grade. Between those two tests, my IQ had dropped by 10%.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by bjoli on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:14PM (#26297124)
What test was it? I have only taken one test (WAIS and WISC, which are more or less the same but for adults and children respectively). It takes about 1 to 1.5 hours and is done alone with the psychologist that administers it.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mcguire on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:26PM (#26295013)
"as a tool to gauge whether someone has special needs that warrant another form of school with extra support"

Someone is using IQ tests for their intended purpose?!

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by gudNess01 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:24AM (#26293982)
To be fair the person you replied to wrote it’s the best accepted option in psychology.

Not that it’s actually useful.

Who really cares if psychology goes the way of the dodo?

If IQ is all the field has produced that’s of value and we’ve been doing grand engineering and science things since before it was around (grand in then contemporary context perhaps) what’s the field really getting us?

Does it build infrastructure, feed people, and heal wounds?

Given human propensity for shallow vanity and gatekeeping it often tends to be used along those lines.

Having a high IQ does not equal more political power over anyone.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by runarberg on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @01:29AM (#26312453)
> Does it build infrastructure, feed people, and heal wounds?

The answer to all these is yes.

> Build infrastructure

Maybe not build but affects design. Civil engineers often use models from cognitive psychologists during the planing phase. E.g. how tall and how luminescent should the traffic lights be to optimize energy savings without risking safety? Or close to a dense population center can we build an airport before the sound pollution starts posing public health risks? Or even: “Is it wise to build water pipes with lead?’

> Feed people

To the same extent that quantum mechanics feeds people, by granting jobs and building models, maybe optimize some aspects of food distribution. A psychologist certainly can affect what food people choose. Food companies have a bunch of psychologists working in their marketing. And governments might hire psychologists to help persuade people to eat healthier food.

> heal wounds

This one is easy. Depression is a deadly disease. Psychotherapy is our best way to treat mild to moderate depression. And even sever depression is best treated with drugs and psychotherapy. Psychologists are saving lives every day. You asked about feeding people above, many people have been cured of anorexia because of psychologists. Behavior therapy is the best way we know of to treat many phobias and obsessive compulsive behavior. PTSD can develop into deadly depression if left untreated. This is also prevented with psychotherapy.

Note that none of the above examples have anything to do with IQ. If IQ goes away, psychologists will still continue their work in improving and saving peoples lives with better infrastructure, better public health policies, and by literally healing (or at least treating) peoples wounds.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by runarberg on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:06PM (#26294795)
IQ—or more accurately the theory of general intelligence—is highly controversial inside the field of psychology. In fact a part from developmental psychologists—which might use IQ tests to determine if a child requires special needs—I bet by far most psychologists go their entire career without ever touching an IQ test or citing a paper because of IQ results.

It is true that the debate about general intelligence is huge. So you see a lot of papers written about it. But this is a subfield inside psychology (in fact a subfield of psychometrics which is a subfield of psychology; the whole field of psychometrics invoking skepticism among many scientist).

I’m gonna do you a favor and list sub-fields of psychology that work regardless of the theory of general intelligence and therefor work just fine without IQ:

* Cognitive psychology (and computational psychology)

* Neuropsychology

* Social psychology (and psychological sociology)

* Pathological Psychology and Psychiatry

* Developmental psychology (although they might use IQ tests; but for different reason as psychometricians do)

* Psychological first aid (not a science but a method; similar to paramedics but for trauma victims)

And here are some generic theories inside psychology which have nothing to do with—and might reject—the theory of general intelligence.

* Behaviorism

* Neurological determinism

* Evolutionary psychology

* Psychoanalysis

Even inside psychometrics (which is the believe that any psychological effect that exists is measurable; and that operational definition is a legitimate way to describe psychological effect) I bet there are people that reject the theory of general intelligence on the grounds that IQ is not measuring general intelligence, but something else.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by feanaro on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:00AM (#26291807)
> There is nothing in the field of psychology with better support than IQ. If you aren't going to accept IQ, then you've entirely tossed out the field of psychology. There is nothing left.

Huh. That's quite a bold and incorrect claim. Are you a psychologist?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by exfalso on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:05AM (#26291839)
Perhaps the word "psychometry" would have been better. There isn't any psychometric test more stable than IQ.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by cannabis_sam on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:12PM (#26294860)
How do you define/consider “stable” this specific context?
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by feanaro on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:56AM (#26292746)
That's a bit better, but confusing the statements "IQ is the most temporally stable psychometric construct" and "IQ is the only valid psychometric construct" is still egregious.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by rcxdude on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:17AM (#26292855)
I don't read it that way, I think it's meant as 'if you reject IQ, you have raised your standards of evidence so high you must logically reject everything else in psychology/psychometry as well'. It's meant to highlight a contradiction.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by feanaro on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:00AM (#26293097)
Yes, if interpreted like that, I agree with it. What threw me off was "There's nothing left" part. I see now that I might've misinterpreted the meaning.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by feanaro on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:50AM (#26292712)
Thank you for the reactionary downvotes, but how about making an actual argument?

(self-reply because I can no longer edit the comment)

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mudita on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:21AM (#26291922)
Let's hear it from a psychologist: "If you don’t buy IQ research, you might as well throw out all the rest of psychology." (Jordan Peterson)

https://youtu.be/D7Kn5p7TP_Y?t=2938

For anybody interested in personality research, I warmly recommend this lecture series, by the way. These are the basics, which psychology students learn at university.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by efficax on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:37AM (#26293656)
Peterson is a jungian hack
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by bumby on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:11AM (#26294325)
Can you elaborate? I’m aware of his controversies in pop culture but I’d be interested in any disagreements within his academic field. I’ve heard him disagree with Angela Duckworth regarding her “grit” attribute but that’s the extent to which I’ve heard
[dead]
[dead]
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by 0x737368 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:14AM (#26292834)
Thanks for the response.

I think discussing whether he's liberal or conservative is a wishy-washy subject and I'm on shaky ground when discussing whether he's right about the left, but in the interest of having a dialogue I do have some retorts about some of the other things you've mentioned.

Re: men superior to women in intellect and rationality - only thing I've seen him state to this effect was describe the distribution of IQs and commenting that the average is the same, however the lowest and highest IQ individuals tend to be male, however women are more packed around the average. I wouldn't describe this as sexist or male-chauvinistic, he's discussing results of studies. From the same observations you'll find that there's more 75-th percentile women than men. When I formulate my conclusion this way, am I now being sexist towards men?

Re: white people being more intelligent than black - if you agree that IQ measures intelligence at least in some capacity, then the results of whites on avg. having a higher IQ than blacks, and Asians and Jews higher than whites, speak for themselves. It might be an inconvenient and unfortunate reality, but you can't fix or mitigate this problem if you just sweep it under the rug. On the other hand, whenever I watch highlights of the NBA, the CRUSHING majority(like 99%) of the athletes there are black/mixed race. So is NBA racist for presenting all of the most athletic players as black? Should we also not talk about how white basketball players are underperforming in physical aspects in the NBA as it's racist?

I haven't kept that much track about the cultural stuff he said nor am I educated enough in the subject so I can't agree or disagree with you there, however I wouldn't call him a conman. His lessons of personal responsibility and guidelines on how to improve and add structure to your life seem sound. I suspect that his advice resonates more with people of a certain temperament than others, which is why I often hear that his advice is useless, despite there being thousands(maybe millions?) of people that have said that his advice has helped them out of a very tough spot.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by tsimionescu on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:04AM (#26293136)
Re: men vs women - he has often claimed for example that women get payed less because they are unwilling to do the better paying jobs (most famously in the Cathy Newman interview [0]). He also claims often that women are more interested in empathy and men in systems, so that men are vastly much more likely to be in fields like engineering, while women are more vastly more likely to be interested in fields like nursing [1], with natural differences as large as 20:1. He himself may not make this value judgement, but given the general social consensus that views engineering as a more prestigious, intellectual job than medical nurses, I think it's mostly fair to characterize this claim as I did.

I disagree with this conclusion any way - I believe that IQ testing quickly loses any kind of predictive power when applied to different backgrounds, and many implicit and even explicit biases quickly show up. I also find it hard to believe that a society where women:men ratios in any profession are 20:1 or 1:20 can be characterized as the free-est in the world on this issue. More likely, there are great social and historical pressures trending in this direction, and the state is simply doing nothing to try to reverse this injustice. Looking at former communist countries, that are generally not even close to having any kind of women in STEM programs that could be considered to bias results, the women:men ratio in STEM fields is something like 30:70.

Re: IQ and "race" - I don't think so. You may accept that IQ has some correlation with what we understand by intelligence in regular usage, but that doesn't mean in any way that you can meaningfully compare people for IQ across arbitrary divides such as "race", especially when "race" is highly correlated with things such as poverty, teacher attitudes, social attitudes etc. And I keep saying "race" and not race because there is no scientific basis for our notions of race - they are arbitrary social constructs based on skin color and culture (for some examples: are Italians and Irish people white? 50 years ago, they were considered a different race; or, what is the race of the child of a mixed black-skin & white-skin couple? Is Kamala Harris black or white? What about her children? Are they white? black? semitic? south-asian? How many studies of IQ vs race on similar populations actually look at any kind of genetic evidence, vs just skin color?)

I will admit that "conman" was a bit rough and an exaggeration. Still, he is definitely using some conman-style tactics to sell his opinions outside his area of expertise. I am not talking about the area of psychology, which includes his self-help work, but about his political discourse.

[0] The Cathy Newman Interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcjxSThD54

[1] Jordan B Peterson: Why so many Male Engineers and Female Nurses? (3 minute video) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7uZOAzVRgU

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by 0x737368 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:34AM (#26293638)
But surely the social consensus that engineers are more prestigious than nurses is on the society and not on Peterson.

It might be difficult to predict the success of somebody via IQ if you compare two individuals from radically different socio-economic backgrounds, but you can compare two individuals with different IQs from similar socio-economic backgrounds and statistically IQ is a very good predictor of success.

With regards to men-to-women ratios, Peterson pointed out that countries that have the free-est social expectations(e.g. Scandinavian countries) have the most diverse differences between men and women. From my personal experience going to a university in the UK and studying CS, I could count maybe 3-5 women out of a cohort of 350+ students. I don't think you can accuse the UK of actively discouraging women from joining these fields, quite the opposite. So why don't they choose these high paying fields in such progressive countries such as UK?

I do agree with you that "race" has no strict scientific basis. I'm not sure how those studies qualified races, so that's something I'll need to look up.

I still disagree with him using conman-style tactics per se, but I will admit that I was a bit disappointed in SOME stuff that he was saying outside of his areas of expertise. Not because I thought he was wrong, but because for me his explanations of psychology set such a high standard that anything less would be overshadowed. I find that he has a very "conversational" approach at discovering new ideas - he'll sort of discuss different aspects as he goes and almost arrive at conclusions right in front of the audience. The drawback to this approach is that sometimes he might be wrong about some things - I think that's okay.

Case in point - in his debate with Zizek, iirc he quickly got shotdown by Zizek because he was pretty much out of his depth, and Peterson admitted that he was wrong. A lot of his detractors point this out as a coup de grace for Peterson, but I find it refreshing to see somebody who makes mistakes in the search of answers, but admits they were wrong and perhaps corrects themselves(not sure about the last part, I haven't kept up with his most recent stuff).

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bakary on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:01AM (#26294253)
Essentially, the problem with Peterson is that it's a boring rehash. It's a bit frustrating to see the guy defended along the lines of him being a victim of censorship and close-mindedness, when in fact the issue is the lack of content. This is a widespread problem in the YouTube era, where debate confrontations are inherently more popular and financially rewarding for their participants.

His ideas on Christianity and Jungian psychology are not novel. His self-help material is exactly the same fare dressed up differently. The combination of psychology, biology, and myth to redefine masculinity is not novel; Campbell and Evola and probably a wide range of previous writers treaded that ground. He doesn't bring anything insightful to the interpretation of Solzhenitsyn. His interpretation of postmodernism is an incoherent mishmash designed for Patreon support. It goes way beyond a person just making mistakes in the search for answers. His approach is conversational in the same way a Reddit thread is conversational.

If you are interested in those topics, you are better off reading Oakeshott, Nozick, Sowell, Scruton, actual Jungian books, actual theologians, actually delve into the precise ideas of postmodernism and Marxism and what the actual arguments are. After this, Peterson will seem incredibly boring.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by 0x737368 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:19PM (#26294935)
Whilst I am willing to concede that his approach and ideas might not be novel, it is his fantastic delivery of lectures and connecting different phenomena in a network to explain/support a concept is what draws me to his stuff. As a counterpoint, I really like Campbell's a Hero with a Thousand Faces, but darn if his book isn't hard to read.

I think it's a fair argument against him, but it is not Campbell or Evola who managed to get into the spotlight and spread those ideas to millions, but Peterson. Perhaps it could be argued that it's his captivating presentational style or ability to package things well are his USP?

Thank you for the reading list, I do want to delve deeper into this stuff.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bakary on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:19PM (#26296206)
He is captivating to a certain audience, but so are televangelists. That's the whole crux of the problem. If you recognize it as being entertainment and an aesthetic/subculture, that's fine. But Peterson is presented as a leading thinker to people, which is a problem. Despite what I've written, Peterson isn't even someone I'm specifically interested in, it's more about the underlying issue of which he is a prominent example.

Consider the following: during the Žižek debate, it became clear that not only was the Communist Manifesto the only Marxist text he had read, but he could not accurately recall some of its main points. And it's a really short pamphlet! That means that Peterson had expounded at length on Marxism, made it a central point of his critique and philosophical brand, while having almost no knowledge or understanding of it. Even with the most charitable interpretation, that goes way beyond just occasionally making mistakes due to a discursive style.

Imagine a charismatic professor with a large audience and who has talked at length about the worth of various programming concepts. Now imagine that it turns out the professor can't pass Fizz Buzz. Following that, his fans defend him by saying that he's a captivating explainer who is only sometimes wrong, and that the size of his audience and fantastic delivery is proof of his worth as a leading expert on computer science and programming. Wouldn't that set off alarm bells in your mind?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by 0x737368 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:51PM (#26296950)
>He is captivating to a certain audience, but so are televangelists. That's the whole crux of the problem. If you recognize it as being entertainment and an aesthetic/subculture, that's fine. But Peterson is presented as a leading thinker to people, which is a problem. Despite what I've written, Peterson isn't even someone I'm specifically interested in, it's more about the underlying issue of which he is a prominent example.

I think that's a reasonable point. I'd still maintain that his message is useful and his ideas are, imo, interesting and illuminating. I haven't thought of JP-televangelists comparison before so I'd need some time to mull it over. But in my personal experience I listened to Peterson for a while, internalised what I thought was useful and moved on. Whether televangelists have the same effect - I don't know.

>Consider the following: during the Žižek debate, it became clear that not only was the Communist Manifesto the only Marxist text he had read, but he could not accurately recall some of its main points. And it's a really short pamphlet! That means that Peterson had expounded at length on Marxism, made it a central point of his critique and philosophical brand, while having almost no knowledge or understanding of it. Even with the most charitable interpretation, that goes way beyond just occasionally making mistakes due to a discursive style.

I wish I had more knowledge on Marxism/leftists school of thoughts right now to have a more interesting discussion on this, but I don't. It does look bad on Peterson that he was so ill prepared for that debate.

Having said that, we cannot not say that there isn't a cultural shift happening in the academia and in our societies at large. Traditional cultural norms are being thrown out and in some extreme cases even shamed(not saying that's a 100% bad thing, but imo such things must not be done rashly), instead of bringing equality there are some attempts of inversing the inequality, and people are getting cancelled/silenced/fired/deplatformed in some cases simply for having a different opinion. Whether this is Marxism or not is really irrelevant, what's important is that we note these changes and act to mitigate them, and I believe this is what Peterson was referring to as "cultural Marxists". It might be embarrassing if he got the name wrong, but it doesn't change WHAT he's talking about.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bakary on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:16PM (#26298764)
It is a bit counter-intuitive, but the cultural shift you describe is a mirror image of Peterson's popularity, in the sense that both are the result of sloppy, black-and-white, and adversarial thinking and ideological repackaging.

If this cultural shift is a concern due to its effect on society and its norms, then Peterson would be a counter-productive solution, since this sort of person being considered an intellectual worth following is a step down from these very same norms. It's like putting out a house fire with a flamethrower. The problem is the breakdown in informed discourse.

The result is that the money and attention of people concerned about cultural shifts is then funneled into the pockets of people like Peterson or Shapiro or whomever, with some pretty unenviable results. You end up in a situation where people talk of rediscovering traditional norms and opposing them to new norms, without actually understanding what the traditional norms are or engaging with them beyond vague social-media ready descriptions. What could have been effective or at least thoughtful conservatism paradoxically turns into a post-modern parody of itself, with plenty of references to the aesthetic aspect (flags, slogans, freedom of speech etc.) without the substance that originally generated those symbols. And this substance and world lying outside of the Petersons and Shapiros starts to shrink because they monopolize the attention of people who would have otherwise engaged with deeper material and applied it in productive ways.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by 0x737368 on Monday March 01, 2021 @09:05AM (#26302847)
I'm sorry but I don't follow you here.

>If this cultural shift is a concern due to its effect on society and its norms, then Peterson would be a counter-productive solution, since this sort of person being considered an intellectual worth following is a step down from these very same norms. It's like putting out a house fire with a flamethrower. The problem is the breakdown in informed discourse.

Peterson DOES encourage informed discourse. Unlike some public figures that are wont to use strawman arguments and/or voice their opinions in an echo chamber, I've seen Peterson go on almost hostile interviews, keeping calm and giving accurate and measured answers to their questions whilst ignoring their jabs(see Cathy Newman or Vice interviews for example). And as was mentioned before, he's also known to change his opinion if he's convinced that he was wrong - now you show me another public figure that's willing to do that, not too many of those from what I've seen.

>The result is that the money and attention of people concerned about cultural shifts is then funneled into the pockets of people like Peterson or Shapiro or whomever, with some pretty unenviable results.

I can't speak about Shapiro since I haven't watched him or his stuff, but I have no problem with Peterson getting money or attention from his lectures, interviews, or books. I cannot find what harm his material can cause either.

>You end up in a situation where people talk of rediscovering traditional norms and opposing them to new norms, without actually understanding what the traditional norms are or engaging with them beyond vague social-media ready descriptions. What could have been effective or at least thoughtful conservatism paradoxically turns into a post-modern parody of itself, with plenty of references to the aesthetic aspect (flags, slogans, freedom of speech etc.) without the substance that originally generated those symbols. And this substance and world lying outside of the Petersons and Shapiros starts to shrink because they monopolize the attention of people who would have otherwise engaged with deeper material and applied it in productive ways.

I think it's healthy to be at least A LITTLE bit sceptical of new norms. Our society was pretty much the same for at least thousands of years and in a few decades we're changing things up very drastically. Are you that sure that it's not going to cause issues that can have dire consequences in the future? I'm not.

I'd like to reiterate again that I don't think Peterson is as conservative as you seem to be implying, he doesn't want everybody being under Sharia-like social rules of Christian propriety. He does seem to lean towards traditional family values, which I don't think is a bad thing. Otherwise he seems to champion personal freedom, especially against any form of tyranny.

With regards to him not understanding traditional norms I'd like to disagree. If you can show me some examples of where he does that please do.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bakary on Monday March 01, 2021 @11:26AM (#26304393)
To avoid confusion around semantics, I'll try to draw up a more stripped down version of the argument.

Cultural shifts linked to specific left-wing ideas underway in various parts of society → concern based on the idea of the foundations of society being weakened or changed too quickly as a result → public figure comments against the former shift in an accessible and engaging way → fanbase forms around public figure, who is then held in high esteem for their work → criticism of the figure is primarily interpreted as censorship and deplatforming

The above would be the simplified and idealized description of Peterson or another such figure from one of their supporters. The following is what I believe is happening instead:

breakdown in discourse over time for various factors → ideologies spring up based on their online marketability and accessibility instead of their depth → the change oriented/left-wing version turns into intensified identity politics that moves away from economic concerns → the conservative oriented version turns into a decaf, pretend version of what it used to be → media personalities from each camp do battle online with debates that are essentially entertainment only but are interpreted as discourse by fans on either side

From this we can see that a supporter of Peterson would see the Newman interview as an example of bravery and intellectual strength, whereas from the second framework it would look like another addition to the huge frothing pile of low-quality infotainment. This is what I meant by using a flamethrower on a flaming house. Peterson himself and others like him contribute to the alteration of traditional norms instead of defending them. Or to be more precise, the fact that they are the figures being listened to is the mechanism that accelerates this decline. This is what I meant with the Fizz Buzz analogy: Peterson and co. would have been laughed out of the room by earlier generations of conservatives for not having basic knowledge of the issues they argue about, and these would in turn have been horrified by the idea that a speaker's accessibility and popularity would be seen as a justification of their worth.

In the end, you have people who nod in appreciation when Peterson "destroys" a reporter/student/heckler in a meme-worthy contest, but don't actually know much at all about the Western canon or the traditional values they claim allegiance to or even the ideas that they claim to oppose. They repeat the words but don't actually live these values, and this is a direct consequence of decaf intellectualism taking up all of that mental space. The conservatism is then ironically no longer conservative, in the sense that it no longer conserves the norms it references.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by 0x737368 on Monday March 01, 2021 @10:44PM (#26311687)
Thank you, I understand your point of view now. I would need to get a bigger grip on the underlying issues to fully agree or disagree with it(your previously mentioned reading list), but your argument seems reasonable and plausible to me.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by tsimionescu on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:32AM (#26294050)
> countries that have the free-est social expectations(e.g. Scandinavian countries) have the most diverse differences between men and women. From my personal experience going to a university in the UK and studying CS, I could count maybe 3-5 women out of a cohort of 350+ students. I don't think you can accuse the UK of actively discouraging women from joining these fields, quite the opposite. So why don't they choose these high paying fields in such progressive countries such as UK?

Well, there are two options: either this is right and there is a vast gulf between the workings of the male and female mind, or these countries are not as free of social expectations as they like to think they are. Not sure how the UK and Northern Europe compare, but a (female) friend who left Romania for Germany was shocked at how large the social pressure on women to give up working after having a child are. She has had multiple colleagues directly and indirectly pushing her into feeling like a bad mother for holding a full-time job while having a child at home.

In my own university days in the CS department, there was a marked difference between the number of men and women, but nowhere near what you're saying: it was more like 10 women for every 20 men, maybe a little less. I've had several female professors, including the head of the Polytechnic institute and the head of the CS department. In my job today, I am on a team of 4 men and 3 women (all programmers), working on a project with a female project lead, and probably overall 30 men and 6 women in Dev, and 50 men and 14 women if you include QA (who also do Python-based automated testing). This is on a project deep in the world of computer networking, not some soft field. And the team is about half in Romania, half in India - not exactly countries known for their courageous tearing down of social norms.

So again, I'm very skeptical of claims that a society where a major professions are overwhelmingly dominated by either men or women is "(one of) the most free societies in the world in terms of choice". It's possible, but I think it's far more likely that the studies claiming this were simply wrong, given the outcomes. Especially since I doubt nurses are significantly better viewed in Northern Europe in terms of job prestige and intellectual rigor than in other places.

> But surely the social consensus that engineers are more prestigious than nurses is on the society and not on Peterson.

Well, if he's saying that women are more fit to be nurses and men are more fit to be engineers, than I feel justified in saying that he's implying women are less suited than men for intellectual labor (not necessarily dumber, but at least less likely to enjoy it). That may not be his intention (though I believe it may well be), but he also doesn't go out of his way to disclaim it.

> So why don't they choose these high paying fields in such progressive countries such as UK?

My strong belief is that it's a problem of education and social pressures. Even in Romania (to be clear, I keep bringing it up because it's the country where I have the most experience), where women do choose these fields in much bigger numbers for whatever reasons, there are deep biases against women's ability in this field. Female colleagues were more likely to be a professor's target for ridicule, or simply receive lower grades on exams for the same mistakes. They would be less likely to be given as positive examples, and less likely to be encouraged towards this field.

> I find it refreshing to see somebody who makes mistakes in the search of answers, but admits they were wrong and perhaps corrects themselves

Yes, that is a quality I also appreciate in people and in Jordan Peterson in particular. I have also seen him change his opinion on the right to deny service to gay people during an interview (he was for this right initially on grounds of freedom of religion essentially, but then when presented with the fact that the same arguments were often used to deny black people service 50 years ago, he took a moment, thought about it, and admitted that his previous position was wrong and that people shouldn't be denied service based on their sexuality). I truly appreciate this, and it is quite a rare thing to see.

> but you can compare two individuals with different IQs from similar socio-economic backgrounds and statistically IQ is a very good predictor of success.

Yes, agreed - that's why I'm not necessarily against the idea that IQ is meaningful at least to some extent. I do think however that the moment you start comparing IQ results across populations, biases quickly creep in and it gets much harder to tell if the difference is caused by a difference in the underlying IQ or in the test itself. Even if comparing between two similar-income American (non-recent immigrants) families in the same city in America, one with black skin and the other with white skin, there is some SMALL chance that there are inherent biases, either internal or in the test, that may affect the validity of results. And from what I've read, many such comparisons are far, far from this close. Some famous books on the topic, such as "The Bell Curve", include horribly, obviously biased studies, such as comparing the IQs of white and black kids as measured by apartheid South Africa!

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by 0x737368 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:53PM (#26295278)
>Well, there are two options: either this is right and there is a vast gulf between the workings of the male and female mind, or these countries are not as free of social expectations as they like to think they are. Not sure how the UK and Northern Europe compare, but a (female) friend who left Romania for Germany was shocked at how large the social pressure on women to give up working after having a child are. She has had multiple colleagues directly and indirectly pushing her into feeling like a bad mother for holding a full-time job while having a child at home.

Yes, it seems even the most progressive countries haven't eliminated all pressure yet. And that might be for the best, but that's besides the point.

>In my own university days in the CS department, there was a marked difference between the number of men and women, but nowhere near what you're saying: it was more like 10 women for every 20 men, maybe a little less. I've had several female professors, including the head of the Polytechnic institute and the head of the CS department. In my job today, I am on a team of 4 men and 3 women (all programmers), working on a project with a female project lead, and probably overall 30 men and 6 women in Dev, and 50 men and 14 women if you include QA (who also do Python-based automated testing). This is on a project deep in the world of computer networking, not some soft field. And the team is about half in Romania, half in India - not exactly countries known for their courageous tearing down of social norms.

Peterson and the study that he referenced specifically did point out that the less pressured men and women are to follow a path the more pronounced the differences become. So far your anecdote, as well as my own from previously living in an ex-USSR country, confirm this. Why this is so - I have no idea but I find it fascinating.

>Well, if he's saying that women are more fit to be nurses and men are more fit to be engineers, than I feel justified in saying that he's implying women are less suited than men for intellectual labor (not necessarily dumber, but at least less likely to enjoy it). That may not be his intention (though I believe it may well be), but he also doesn't go out of his way to disclaim it.

Whilst Peterson never specifically said that men are more fit to be engineers than women, I do agree that what he HAS said is analogous to that. However, I believe his views on that came from evidence and not from a sexist point-of-view that women are inferior. The inverse of that is that women are better at child-rearing and people-facing roles, a statement which I think is on average just as true as the one about men and engineers. Is it then misandrist to say that men are, on average, not as good at raising children? I wouldn't say so personally.

>My strong belief is that it's a problem of education and social pressures. Even in Romania (to be clear, I keep bringing it up because it's the country where I have the most experience), where women do choose these fields in much bigger numbers for whatever reasons, there are deep biases against women's ability in this field. Female colleagues were more likely to be a professor's target for ridicule, or simply receive lower grades on exams for the same mistakes. They would be less likely to be given as positive examples, and less likely to be encouraged towards this field.

I do trust what you say about this 100% when it pertains to Romania, but let me assure you that in the UK even a minor complaint of sexist harassment of any kind will very likely result in a rapid and unexpected vacancy in the company. Sometimes it can be even unfair, but that's besides the point again. In fact, in my experience whenever I see women in engineering fields, I'd see guys pretty much bend over backwards to be nice and supportive of them. So much so that it'd seem saccharine and the women would be either put off by this treatment(perhaps another pressure that dissuades women from the field? I doubt it but it could play a role I suppose, especially if the guys are doing it in the hopes of "surreptitiously" getting in their pants) or have everything so baby-proofed for them that they'd have no challenge because everything would be done for them.

>Even if comparing between two similar-income American (non-recent immigrants) families in the same city in America, one with black skin and the other with white skin, there is some SMALL chance that there are inherent biases, either internal or in the test, that may affect the validity of results. And from what I've read, many such comparisons are far, far from this close. Some famous books on the topic, such as "The Bell Curve", include horribly, obviously biased studies, such as comparing the IQs of white and black kids as measured by apartheid South Africa!

I agree that it can be an apples to oranges comparison. This conversation did make aware of how ignorant I was of the actual methodology of that IQ between races study, so that's something I'll have to look up. That "Bell Curve" thing is shocking! A good reminder how "science" can be manipulated by using a bad methodology to push results to confirm a bias and then touting it as the empirical truth. What I like to call the "I F**ING LOVE SCIENCE" brand of science.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by feanaro on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:53AM (#26292734)
I do not understand this statement as claiming that IQ is the entire content of the field of psychology. Do you?
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mudita on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:36AM (#26293313)
No, of couse not, that would be a very, very strange claim. I agree with rcxdude's reading of the statement: 'if you reject IQ, you have raised your standards of evidence so high you must logically reject everything else in psychology/psychometry as well'
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bodell on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:28AM (#26293603)
Jordan Peterson is a great example of the failing of Psychology in the academic world. I'll list some quotes by him below and you can decided weather or not he should be listened to, or if he is simply selling right wing propaganda on Youtube.

"If men are pushed too hard to feminize they will become more and more interested in harsh, fascist political ideology."

"the current hierarchy might be predicated on competence." [referring to men being placed higher than women in society]

""Peterson says that "disciplines like women's studies should be defunded", advising freshman students to avoid subjects like sociology, anthropology, English literature, ethnic studies, and racial studies, as well as other fields of study that he believes are corrupted by "post-modern neo-Marxists".""

He also has a bible series on YouTube that asserts that god created the appropriate hierarchy of man, and that it should not be tampered with. We should mold society on the archetype of the book of Genesis. Which in my humble opinion is simply Calvinism in the extreme.

Most of this can be found on YouTube or his Wikipedia page.

This is not to say everything he says is wrong, that would be silly. But I believe it should be approached with a heavy dose of skepticism.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mancerayder on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:38AM (#26294532)
>Most of this can be found on YouTube or his Wikipedia page.

Not a Peterson acolyte, a Jungian, or even right wing for that matter, but I'm a political philosophy junkie so I have some familiarity with Peterson's claims, mostly from watching debates and listening to arguments. And I will say this, your random out of context quoting, and hiding behind "check his Wikipedia page and YouTube yourself" is the same sophistry you're accusing him of. To give just one example, the claims around Western Civilization you bring up imply neo fascism, while they are in defense of Enlightenment ideals. Forget Peterson, there has been a debate between idealists and materialists about the value of Enlightenment ideals since the horrors of WWII (Frankfurt School being prominent critics), and a defense in the 90s by Idealists and classical liberals (The End of History) and an attacks by Postmodernists since the 70s (Foucault et. al).

Today there still is that debate, because the Postmodernist epistemology dominates and both other dominant alternatives, let's call them free market Western liberals and Marxists, don't agree. For you to summarize the debate Peterson weighs in on as a Western superiority is straight up manipulation on your part. You hide behind the manipulation by telling readers to go to his Wikipedia page and YouTube videos as if you've just cited something.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bodell on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:14PM (#26296616)
I do not believe I mentioned a single thing that you are talking about in your comment. I'm not entirely sure what you are talking about in your comment. You seem to have quite the bone to pick with postmodernism, something I left completely left unaddressed about Peterson.

I only implied that saying men will become fascists if they are feminized is ludicrous. Does "postmodernism" mean feminizing men? And I suggest that the idea of men having rightfully taken their god given place higher up the hierarchy of society, is Calvinistic, by definition this is true. Is this what you think is "western superiority"? because I don't think I've ever said those two words together in my life. I also don't think I quoted out of context. Though it seems you feel the context reaches as far back as the enlightenment, in this way I have not given a history of the world before judging Peterson's arguments as something that should be met with skepticism.

I really do mean to go check it out for yourself. All the quotes I grabbed were from the Wikipedia page, I have not hidden anything. I've seen very little of what Peterson has to say, but all of it strikes me as very crackpot like. If I were a professor and publishing psychology papers I do agree my "citations" would not be up to snuff. But I am not either of those things and was not attempting to cite him in that manner. I think there should be more proof to the legitimacy of Peterson being a scientist rather than my HN comment needing more proof that he is not.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mancerayder on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:09AM (#26315454)
We're not going to debate the ins and outs of whether his views or crazy or correct, not least because I don't agree with many of them, but also because I'm not interested in playing devil's advocate.

I just think it's not fair to quote - anyone - out of context, referencing a Wikipedia collection of a few quotations, and finger that as proof of insane or bad or incorrect views. Your explanation of his views is about as long or longer than the quotes you're referring to. These are extremely nuanced, complex issues, and to summarize with outrageous highlights (feminizing men, which you've brought up) is sophistry.

Peterson can be completely wrong, a bad intellectual, whatever you want to call him, but the correct thing is to understand the ideas that you disagree with without relying on an authority (The New Yorker, among others, which were quoted a few times in your Wikipedia article references) before calling them out, because they're not being portrayed accurately.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bodell on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:24PM (#26359359)
You have accused me of saying many things thus far that I have emphatically not said. Which I would point out is worse than not providing "full context". I specifically stated that it would be silly to think everything Peterson said was false. I made almost no explanation of his views that were my own words other than accusing a portion of it to be Calvinistic thinking. If you think there are finer points in believing in hierarchical superiority amongst genders because of "Genesis" feel free to let me know as I must be too unsophisticated to recognize the nuance.

In fact I have not much of a clue as to anything of the things your referring too and lack the imagination to see a context larger than what those quotes establish. I have watched a bit of his videos, they are full of outrageous and unsubstantiated claims, often self defeating, and because of that, to your point, are hard to summarize. There seems to be beliefs that Peterson holds that are dear to you in some way, and I'm sure a great many of them have merit. Feel free to debate Marx, Foucault, WWII, etc. but if you claim the pecking order is the way it should be due to "nature" and "god" expect some kick back. Such as I would have expected a person, who believes those quotes to not be reflective of Peterson's views, would have said exactly what they believe them to have meant instead. Did he not imply that feminism leads to fascism, does he in a more complex way than I can see supporting gender equality? What are these enlightenment ideas that I missed? Not sarcasm, here, I really do not know what you mean.

I'm sorry if quoting the New Yorker, Wikipedia or the man himself is sub-par to your standards. If you have some better sources I'd be glad to hear you out.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by danaris on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:06AM (#26293860)
Your conclusion ("the failing of Psychology in the academic world") is not supported by your evidence.

You have demonstrated that there is one prominent psychologist who holds some fairly-obviously terrible and inaccurate beliefs, and is willing to trumpet them to anyone who will listen.

This is no more an indictment of the field of psychology than the occasional right-wing "climate scientist" Fox News brings out to "prove" that climate change is not real is an indictment of the field of climate science.

Many scientific fields likely have a handful of far-right kooks who would be happy to rack up YouTube views promulgating alt-right talking points dressed up in the trappings of science. That says very little about the state of their fields, and a great deal about the state of our nation. And YouTube.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Bodell on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:29PM (#26296765)
I'm sorry. I was very murky with my wording. I was not trying to say that the field of Psychology had failed or was a failure. What I meant to say was that, our current state of academia has in this instance demonstrated "a" failure. That failure to me is highlighted by the comment I responded to when it was implied that Peterson's view was more "bonafide" because it was from a "real" psychologist. By all academic standards the commenter would be correct. Peterson is not only a Psychologists but also a professor, A widely published and cited one at that. One who has been afforded debates at collages with Sam Harris and Zizek. This to me is a failure of the academic world to distinguish between leaders of the field of psychology and crackpot YouTube personalities. By credentials alone he is both and this is unnerving to me.

That said, of course, I do not believe that it speaks to psychology as a whole. But again I poorly worded that sentence and take responsibility for the misunderstanding. I would only add that I think, and I may very well be wrong, that if a physicist were to parrot "free-energy/perpetual-motion" to anyone that would listen, that person would be promptly removed from teaching at any legitimate university. That is not to say physics is better than psychology, if anything it implies that it is easier than the still very important soft sciences.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by KuzMenachem on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:58AM (#26291798)
I agree with your points re. Myers-Briggs, however modern IQ tests are generally regarded as pretty reproducible and an individual’s score remains quite stable over long periods of time. Confidence intervals are about 10 points for decent tests. [1]

They are not perfect of course, but it’s a little unfair to compare MB with IQ tests in this manner. I know you caveated your comment by saying that not all IQ Tests are like this, which is certainly true. However, I see no statistical reason not to tell people the result of a high-quality IQ test.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient#Reliabil...

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mancerayder on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:09AM (#26294309)
>2. Jung's theories (the ones used in the test) aren't just "controversial". They're wrong. He says it himself, in the same document they used to create the test.

Not a Jungian, but the "wrong" claim is a bold one, in reference to Jung's theories. Are they even falsifiable ? Psychology isn't a hard science. For example, how could you falsify something like the idea of archetypes?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by NoOneNew on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:29PM (#26296277)
Not trying to be an ass, but i think "hard science" is a bad term. Psychology is a young, very complex science. Real psychology really started with Freud, and yes he was inaccurate. Way better than the understanding of human behavior at the time (wandering womb, look it up), way off the mark these days. We're talking about less than 100 years of real research in the field. Electricity, physics, chemistry and even modern atomic theory (1803) have plenty more time in comparison. Freud had to escape the Nazis, just so you have a general timeline. We dont look back to the 1800s at all the cats that made atomic models and go, "what a bunch of fuck ups". They were building up on knowledge. In some respects, they weren't necessarily wrong, just insufficient.

I dont understand the pop culture enjoyment of trashing psychology turn. Every real psychologist in practice and in research are the first to admit how little we know, how incredibly complex it is (meaning we still dont even know all the moving parts involved) and the fact we are still at the starting line. The fact is, we're trying to understand the human mind with millions of broken examples. Learning to rebuild a car using old, junk, crashed, broken, pillaged and uncooperatively hostile junkyard cars isnt an easy feat especially if you dont know what a functional car looks like.

Though, Myers Briggs was just a cash grab with some cliff notes on Jung. Its an intelligentsia zodiac horoscope. Cute, fun, dont take it seriously.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by austincheney on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:16AM (#26291895)
> 1. It's inaccurate.

Reproducibility is most directly correlated against certain identifiers. For example no matter where or how I take a MB assessment I am always INTP. This indicates that for some persons, as associated to certain scored identifiers, this test is always reproducible. That is less a flaw in this test than the test subjects and further suggests MB becomes more valid when correlated with other tests that measure self-awareness and objectivity. The same persons that score poorly on objectivity are the ones less likely (less capable) to accept that suggestiveness and sensitivity are greater culprits in their measures.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by xvector on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:39AM (#26292017)
Same here. I have taken the test multiple times throughout my life and I get INTP every single time. The description is completely accurate too, down to the individual nuances describing an INTP. It’s frighteningly accurate.

I wonder if less common MBTI types are more accurately defined.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by austincheney on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:49AM (#26292072)
I don’t think it’s a matter of either assessment description or population percentage but rather a measure of confidence on questions where a persons may, outside of testing, otherwise defer to social reinforcement.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by TheCoelacanth on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:07PM (#26295447)
I get the same Hogwarts house every time I take that test too.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Smaug123 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:48AM (#26293384)
You are aware of the Barnum effect, I presume? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect)
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Isinlor on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:56AM (#26293788)
I'm aware of this effect and I never cared for horoscopes, Harry Potter houses and what not.

But INTP description is very specific.

> Chief among Logicians’ interests is exploring and building models for underlying principles and ideas, even going so far as to find these concepts, in their own way, beautiful – this makes them natural mathematicians, systems analysts, and career scientists, especially in more abstract fields such as physics.

Maybe 5% of population would identify with this?

> Logicians are known for their brilliant theories and unrelenting logic – in fact, they are considered the most logically precise of all the personality types. They love patterns, and spotting discrepancies between statements could almost be described as a hobby, making it a bad idea to lie to a Logician.

Maybe 20% of population would identify with this?

[0] https://www.16personalities.com/intp-personality

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Smaug123 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:17AM (#26293937)
Can you distinguish yourself from the INTJ description? This was my main problem with the personality types: I agreed wholeheartedly with the (rather long!) descriptions of maybe five of the sixteen.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by andrewingram on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:13AM (#26294339)
Anecdotally, whenever I’ve read all 16 descriptions on a site, only one has ever “felt” like me. I’ve never done it blind (reading the descriptions without knowing the types), but each one does come across as distinctive enough that they can’t just be accused of being Barnum phrases.

Another quirk is that the only people who are going to advocate for these tests are those for who felt their own results were highly descriptive and meaningful to them. So they’re useful in that personal sense, one can point to a few paragraphs of text and say “look, this describes how I think and see the world, read this if you want to understand me better”. To me that undeniably has utility, even if it’s only for a minority of the population (assuming most people sit somewhere in the middle of the bell curves and therefore don’t identify that strong with any of that types).

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by IndySun on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:17AM (#26292223)
> I have taken the test multiple times throughout my life and I get INTP every single time.

Are you aware of Hobson's Choice?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by singingfish on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:23AM (#26292250)
You have good points there. From reading the article, the inaccuracy is by inappropriately classifying people into groups, and the groupings lack sensitivity. As you also point out the underlying theoretical framework is also wrong. The article does point out that the Myers Briggs does correlate reasonably well with four of the big 5 though. Having said that I would definitely discourage use of the Myers-Briggs.

The original author has a good point about the naming of the big 5 factors though.

Two things I take issue with though - IQ is reasonably well understood in that we know it measures something reliably and accurately. Exactly what that thing is though, is not really understood - and probably can't be. And how it relates to the real world is also somewhat poorly understood, and may not be possible to fully understand. But it does have good ecological and construct validity. I'm talking about good IQ tests here - any less validation than the huge amount that the Wescheler scales go through and the validation is questionable. I'm aware of the racial biases in IQ testing which is a significant problem.

Psychology isn't a particular young science - big chunks of modern statistical analysis have their roots in 19th and early 20th century psychology. So psychology is a young science in the same sense that modern statistics is. Back when I was studying psychology 20 to 30 years ago, a lot of what is now called "neuroscience" was then called "cognitive science" or more rarely "cognitive neuroscience". Neuroscience sounds sexier though.

I do have a massive issue how many social scientists abuse psychometric techniques in inappropriate ways. Management research is particularly guilty here, and I've been pressured into doing this kind of inappropriate analysis in the past.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by enkid on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:05AM (#26292473)
So IQ measures something, but we don't know what and we don't know how it impacts the real world. How can we meaningfully say it measures something then?
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by notahacker on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:41AM (#26293687)
The main issue is we know IQ is meaningfully correlated with real world outcomes, but also that real world environments are meaningfully correlated with ranges of (non-normalised) IQ in a way we can't adequately explain or replicate. It's less obviously correlated with prior knowledge than most tests, but still very trainable (especially if you're a neural network with no generalised reasoning ability whatsoever...)

And like all types of performance test the "something" it measures is a vector of pattern matching ability (both the component generalisable to solving more difficult problems and the component that doesn't except in the domain of career-relevant tests) but also other things obviously correlated with future performance but not fitting most people's definition of intelligence (attitude towards test, comfort in guessing, time management in timed tests, and to a degree experience), so whilst we know what the scale of the apparent impact is, we don't know really know what's behind the cause

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Twisol on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:21AM (#26292562)
Without having a horse in a race, it's probably the idea that the results persist between multiple tests and vary by who's taking the test. Persistence seems like a decent lower standard to say that there's _something_ present, even if you're not quite sure what it is.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by singingfish on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:58AM (#26292759)
Well, for example, you can definitely see variations in people's short term memory capacity, basic facilities with dealing with language, and logical problem solving skills. And importantly from a clinical perspective you can see when these are mismatched. However these are very reductive variables, and in the real world there are many more things in interacting with each other than these isolated components.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by silvestrov on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:10AM (#26292814)
For many, many years we could not explain why gravity exists and how it works. We could only experience it.

We knew of gravity much before we knew of electricity. Try explain electricity to somebody in year 1300 and you'd be burned as a witch.

And yet we understood electricity much earlier than gravity. How electricity works is much simpler to explain than gravity.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fmajid on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:24AM (#26292887)
> “intelligence is whatever my test measures”

— Alfred Binet, inventor of the IQ test

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:21AM (#26292875)
We do know what it measures and we do know what impact it has on real life scenarios.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by singingfish on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:06PM (#26296547)
To some extent, yes. But I think it's better to emphasise the fact that we're ignorant rather than what we know because people really like abusing IQ test results.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by heliodor on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:51AM (#26292394)
What surprises me about Myers Briggs is that people are placed on each dimension either on one side or on the other. Three no center for each dimension. Yet these traits are normally distributed so most people would fall in the center. Telling most people they are average would not sell well. So yeah, this test is unnecessarily polarizing.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by pseudalopex on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:33AM (#26293627)
The traits aren't normally distributed. And the article mentions nearly every test treats them as axes.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by criddell on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:57AM (#26293082)
I never thought about the lack of a neutral trait, but you are right.

However I don't think there's any reason to expect these traits to have a normal distribution. Humans have plenty of bimodal-ish traits.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by todd8 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:45AM (#26293368)
The Central Limit Theorem is one big reason to expect that traits have a normal distribution. Wikipedia has a good explanation. [1] and [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_limit_theorem

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Moivre–Laplace_theorem

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by runarberg on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:52PM (#26295263)
Central limit theorem does not apply unless each experiment is independent. This is not true of the concepts which psychometrician operationally define including personality factors and intelligence.

As an example: Human height is not normally distributed. It is multi-modal based on geographical location, socioeconomic status and sex. There are genetic and environmental factors that makes it so that each childbirth is not an independent event marking a new height.

The same holds for personality traits (if they exists) and intelligence (if it exists as described by IQ tests). The field of psychometrics has a problem with assigning normal distribution to everything even though there is reason to belief things are not normally distributed.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by criddell on Sunday February 28, 2021 @10:47AM (#26294157)
How would the central limit theorem apply to seemingly bimodal distributions like left vs right handedness?
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by todd8 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:42PM (#26295168)
With respect to personality, I believe that there are likely a number of independent factors, perhaps hundreds, that affect in some way where one’s position lies on each of the axes of personality. These factors could be particular childhood traumas, birth order, parent’s behavior/addiction, childhood friends, and genetic factors. Even if each of these numerous random variable is binomial the central limit theorem applies.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by criddell on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:01PM (#26295372)
This article [1] about what determines a persons handedness starts out:

> Like most aspects of human behavior, handedness is a complex trait that appears to be influenced by multiple factors, including genetics, environment, and chance.

It goes on to say that there are up to 40 genes that contribute. It seems like it's complex enough that the central limit theorem should apply yet handedness is definitely a bimodal distribution.

[1]: https://medlineplus.gov/genetics/understanding/traits/handed...

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by heliodor on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:44PM (#26297376)
Handedness is not what people care about in discussing personality assessment.

Check out the big five model: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Five_personality_traits

Neuroticism, openness, agreeableness, conscientiousness, extraversion.

On each dimension, many people are average and a few are on each extreme. At least that's the world I've observed. It's not a world full of extreme introverts and extreme extroverts. Most people are in the middle of that scale.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by criddell on Sunday February 28, 2021 @05:51PM (#26297871)
When I did a Myers Briggs test almost 40 years ago, I think I came up INTP (or something like that). I never interpreted the I to be extreme introvert, although I'm definitely on that side of the scale.

I wonder how many people score exactly on the mid-point and when that happens, what do they do?

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Terretta on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:11PM (#26298743)
Sort of the main point of the article, wouldn’t you agree?

At least that’s why I gathered it proposed a letter “x” for centered traits.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by centrinoblue on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:36AM (#26293646)
Do you have a link where Jung said his theories are wrong?
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by IndySun on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:35AM (#26291995)
Agree, the test has been dismissed enough times. People are far too complex.

It has recently been renamed and represented by Jordan Peterson. Unfortunately, the JP readers I've met who mention his version were unaware of the MB version. The critical history of MB should serve as a warning. They are not eureka moments, but smaller steps.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by dfn43589 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:55AM (#26293781)
>It has recently been renamed and represented by Jordan Peterson.

You've been downvoted because the OCEAN/Big Five model is not Myers Briggs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Five_personality_traits

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers-Briggs_Type_Indicator

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by IndySun on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:54PM (#26297457)
Ok. Thank you.

My reply would be...

By any other name.

Another way of how 'not' to understand the world, but a way to simplify it, for both benign and nefarious reasons. Control is in there somewhere. And it is more than mildly concerning that people here understand something that is considered deeply complicated by most, computers, and yet seem convinced humans can be pigeon-holed into a few 'types'.