News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Retric on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:22AM (#26293240)
Raw IQ scores aren’t very stable over time. At 90+ peoples raw scores have dropped significantly vs age 30. Trauma, Alcoholism, and other diseases can also lower scores dramatically. You can correlate adult IQ’s with tests taken by 2 year olds, but the individual raw scores again vary significantly.

It seems stable because of how age is adjusting for and the huge sweet spot where 64.2% of the population is grouped between 85 and 115. Basically people with significant developmental disabilities at 5 don’t suddenly become normal, but an IQ of 180 at 5 isn’t stable long term.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by zippy5 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @08:48AM (#26293380)
At quantum scale or near the speed of light newtonian mechanics breaks down, so we know it a local approximation. However, for set circumstances it approximates it does it well. For many decades physists searched universally true theory to no avail.

My point is this, IQ seems to have signal. It probably doesn't hold up in extreme circumstances. Psychology in particular seems to have a difficult time holding large enough studies to find universal constants that we should accept that IQ might be the best local approxination for now.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Retric on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:05AM (#26294277)
That doesn’t support your original point. Color blindness is very persistent over time IQ isn’t. Sure +/- 7 IQ points sounds very accurate, but that can be more than a 30 percentile change from two different tests 1 month apart meaning the actual signal is very weak.

You can read papers saying IQ texts on 2 year olds are strongly correlated with adult IQ, but read the details and individual people’s scores varied wildly.

So sure in aggregate it seems consistent, but that’s largely an artifact of test design. Someone with mental handicaps so profound as to be non communicative will consistently score very low, it doesn’t mean much for the general population.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by bjoli on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:24PM (#26294993)
First of all, scores are normalized to age (you never compare 90 to 30 years olds. Only 90 to 90-ish year olds).

No serious IQ test claim to measure much more than 2 standard deviations up and down (meaning they all break down somewhere above 130-135 or below 70). I have done WISC/WAIS three times (as a part of a psychological assessment) and the conversion to IQ scores were within 3 points (the WAIS/WISC scale measures many different abilities, and can be converted to an "aggregate" IQ score). I asked about this and when people are healthy the tester said people tend to score very similarly on tests, even many years apart.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Retric on Sunday February 28, 2021 @02:02PM (#26296036)
Yes, the score is computed relative to other 90 year olds, however people’s individual cognitive decline is heavily influenced by heath and behavior so individuals can move up or down significantly on a that relative scale. Thus the computed score at 3 doesn’t accurately predict someone’s score at 90 nearly as well as a test taken at 30 predicts someone’s score at 40.

The issue with the underlying raw score at 90+ is it doesn’t map very well to a bell curve. Many people are quite healthy but a significant number are drastically reduced from their younger self.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mcguire on Sunday February 28, 2021 @12:31PM (#26295064)
My high school transcripts show the results of IQ tests taken in the 4th and 6th grade. Between those two tests, my IQ had dropped by 10%.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by bjoli on Sunday February 28, 2021 @04:14PM (#26297124)
What test was it? I have only taken one test (WAIS and WISC, which are more or less the same but for adults and children respectively). It takes about 1 to 1.5 hours and is done alone with the psychologist that administers it.