News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by enkid on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:05AM (#26292473)
So IQ measures something, but we don't know what and we don't know how it impacts the real world. How can we meaningfully say it measures something then?
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by notahacker on Sunday February 28, 2021 @09:41AM (#26293687)
The main issue is we know IQ is meaningfully correlated with real world outcomes, but also that real world environments are meaningfully correlated with ranges of (non-normalised) IQ in a way we can't adequately explain or replicate. It's less obviously correlated with prior knowledge than most tests, but still very trainable (especially if you're a neural network with no generalised reasoning ability whatsoever...)

And like all types of performance test the "something" it measures is a vector of pattern matching ability (both the component generalisable to solving more difficult problems and the component that doesn't except in the domain of career-relevant tests) but also other things obviously correlated with future performance but not fitting most people's definition of intelligence (attitude towards test, comfort in guessing, time management in timed tests, and to a degree experience), so whilst we know what the scale of the apparent impact is, we don't know really know what's behind the cause

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by Twisol on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:21AM (#26292562)
Without having a horse in a race, it's probably the idea that the results persist between multiple tests and vary by who's taking the test. Persistence seems like a decent lower standard to say that there's _something_ present, even if you're not quite sure what it is.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by singingfish on Sunday February 28, 2021 @06:58AM (#26292759)
Well, for example, you can definitely see variations in people's short term memory capacity, basic facilities with dealing with language, and logical problem solving skills. And importantly from a clinical perspective you can see when these are mismatched. However these are very reductive variables, and in the real world there are many more things in interacting with each other than these isolated components.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by silvestrov on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:10AM (#26292814)
For many, many years we could not explain why gravity exists and how it works. We could only experience it.

We knew of gravity much before we knew of electricity. Try explain electricity to somebody in year 1300 and you'd be burned as a witch.

And yet we understood electricity much earlier than gravity. How electricity works is much simpler to explain than gravity.

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by fmajid on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:24AM (#26292887)
> “intelligence is whatever my test measures”

— Alfred Binet, inventor of the IQ test

Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday February 28, 2021 @07:21AM (#26292875)
We do know what it measures and we do know what impact it has on real life scenarios.
Re:In Defense of Myers Briggs (2020) by singingfish on Sunday February 28, 2021 @03:06PM (#26296547)
To some extent, yes. But I think it's better to emphasise the fact that we're ignorant rather than what we know because people really like abusing IQ test results.