I don't think it's an issue that it uses your contact list. Why should that be a concern? It doesn't upload them into a database like other services.
Signal is a privacy app, not an anonymity app.
I see people expressing their concern about seeing their boss using the app, etc. and I just cannot relate. Is their argument that they prefer to use insecure SMS with their boss instead? What's the point? Both parties _already have_ each other's phone number as a unique identifier.
I only have a limited # of people I can use Signal with because I don't post my phone number everywhere, though I am old enough that I remember telephone books back when people used to give out their phone number and address and nobody thought anything of it.
Today with a phone number you can:
1. Port it, steal 2FA and password resets, take over critical accounts that don't allow alternate 2FA (happened to two friends of mine)
2. Pay first party or shady second party bounty hunter cell carrier APIs to get current GPS location on a number.
I do not even have a cell carrier anymore for these reasons, social consequences be damned.
My whole point is revealing cell numbers you rely on to strangers is a bad call.
Being forced to do it by baking them into a chat protocol is idiotic.
Here's a situation I ran into: I have a stalker ex with whom I went no-contact ages ago. Years have gone by, I've been lucky enough to not hear from them in a while, it finally seems like the nightmare is over. They forgot about me and moved on to other things.
Then, they sign up for Signal. The app, for no discernable reason, sends them a message informing them that I'm also using it. Now I'm back in their head. I blocked their number on Signal, but I'm seeing "X viewed your profile" messages on LinkedIn, so it looks like the stalking frenzy might start again, all because Signal wants to be Whatsapp.
Why? It's one thing to let any signal user message me, it's another to actively remind people that I'm still around and reachable using it. SMS does not do this.
Do both parties need to have each other's phone number or is enough that one party has the other's phone number for the contact suggestion? I couldn't find it clearly stated in the article.
Practical example: someone has a spam list of phone numbers in his contact list. Will Signal suggest passively profiles that match that numbers?
If Alice installs Signal and Alice's contacts include Bob, then yes both parties will see the other suggested in their Signal app. Else no.
In the past Alice could assume Bob is capable of receiving phone calls and SMS, and now Alice could assume Bob is capable of receiving phone calls and SMS and Signal messages. Is it too revealing for people to be able to know this 1 extra thing when they already knew 2 extremely similar things?
The way I see it, you have three options:
1. Apps that upload your contact list to their server to contact match (like WhatsApp, and others)
2. Apps that use your contact list locally to match (like Signal, and others)
3. Apps that work without your contact list and let you do it manually (like Signal, and others)
Are you looking for a fourth option? If so, what is it?
(Substitute other OSes as able.)
At some point it's a problem I'd like someone to be working on, but taking on a huge amount of individual burden for a low probability scenario isn't anyway to live life.
Heck, switching to Signal wasn't high on my agenda list until the Whatsapp TC change suddenly made my entire Facebook Messenger contact list worry about these things - and now I'm completely off Messenger, but it took collective engagement.
It is 100% possible to use Telegram without giving it access to your contacts. It is even easier than Signal, because your contact can set usernames, etc. You can also chat with people without sharing your phone number.
Even if you give Telegram access to your contacts,you can disable syncing of contacts to their server.
You can also create your own contacts on telegram and add a select few people manually. Like a custom address book just for Telegram. I don't think that is possible on Signal.
I don't agree. All I want from Signal is an e2ee, cross-platform replacement for SMS. I don't think of SMS as "social software" and to the degree Signal keeps acting like it wants to be a social network the more uneasy it makes me. I do appreciate that, unlike Telegram, I can use Signal without giving it access to my contacts but I wish it didn't try to leverage my contacts list at all.