News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by tptacek on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:55PM (#2626871)
Marco had two arguments on Build & Analyze for why he wasn't overly concerned with Reading List.

First, he didn't expect RL to have defer-reading, readability, and sync. But, like everyone's saying, it does. Shit.

Second, the defer-reading market is theoretically huge. It's something everyone needs to do. A tiny percentage captured off that market is worth millions of dollars.

iP is currently the best synced defer-reading app around and probably will remain so even after Reading List is released.

But more importantly, how hard is it to come up with 2-3 killer features to further differentiate iP from Reading List for the tiny fraction of the market required to be successful?

I'm sure it's dismaying to see what he expected to be an afterthought feature showcased in the keynote, but I'm still with him on the dynamics of this market. Reading List is not going to be the final word in deferred reading.

For whatever it's worth, Marco is the one I feel bad for here. Most of these other applications were so clearly implicated by Apple's roadmap that it's hard for me to get too worked up about it. How do you not cheer for Apple taking steps to replace SMS?

Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by mikeleeorg on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:17PM (#2626973)
I like Marco's current perspective:

http://www.marco.org/2011/06/06/safari-reader-and-instapaper

"If Reading List gets widely adopted and millions of people start saving pages for later reading, a portion of those people will be interested in upgrading to a dedicated, deluxe app and service to serve their needs better. And they’ll quickly find Instapaper in the App Store."

Basically: Reading List validates the deferred-reading market.

Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by cjoh on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:18PM (#2626976)
The interesting thing here is the subtle shot that Apple is taking at Google with iOS. Readability like functionality removes advertisements. In the talk they said that safari represents 2/3rds of mobile web browsing. And that web browser is about to be equipped with technology that can turn those ads off.

I think down the road, there's going to be a couple different aspects to content on the web. Advertising based content that you get from google, and for-pay content that you'll get from Apple's News Stand and iBook store.

Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by aphexairlines on Monday June 06, 2011 @08:09PM (#2627345)
Where are those 2/3 numbers coming from? Amazon logs show a completely different story.

The problem here is that nobody big (Amazon, Google, e-Bay, Yahoo, etc) wants to reveal their traffic numbers because they don't want their competitors to have this information when deciding where to allocate dev resources. So Apple can be completely making this up and nobody will call them on it.

Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by Steko on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:22PM (#2627769)
They usually cite net applications or something:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_web_browsers

Wikimedia stats are interesting although I wouldn't read too much into them: http://stats.wikimedia.org/archive/squid_reports/2011-05/Squ...

Toss out the wiki apps and do something with "mozilla" (toss it or split among other webkit I guess) and iOS is up in the low-mid 60%'s. That's without making any adjustments for Opera which will be much lower if you are US only.

Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by brown9-2 on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:04PM (#2627737)
a source seems to be cited in Apple's slides here (ctrl+f for "2 / 3"): http://www.engadget.com/2011/06/06/wwdc-2011-liveblog-steve-...
Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by ChrisLTD on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:12PM (#2626943)
The biggest problem for Marco is that adding articles to Instapaper on your iOS devices is difficult. Adding a bookmarklet on iOS takes 3 or more steps that were difficult even for a grizzled nerd like me. Reading List has absolutely no such friction on any Apple platform.
Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by noahth on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:38PM (#2627062)
Did you know that you can also add articles on iOS by copying the URL and opening the Instapaper app? I didn't realize that there was a way to add a bookmarklet to mobile Safari, and I discovered the clipboard method by accident. Not that I use it often, but when I do, it's good enough.
Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by ChrisLTD on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:48PM (#2627093)
I've accidentally activated that feature many times :-)

As an aside, I really wish Apple would make it easier to add bookmarklets to Safari on iOS. It'd be useful for more than just Instapaper.

Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by miccotech on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:55PM (#2627121)
I've never needed to add an article to Instapaper from my iOS device, but that's just me. I use Instapaper to sync things I want to read from my laptop to my multiple devices. At least in the near term, I doubt Reading List will do the things I want to do as well as Instapaper.

I wouldn't expect Reading List to take many Instapaper users away, and I think it will drive not-insignificant numbers from Reading List to Instapaper as people want an upgrade. Net gain for Instapaper, hopefully.

Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by tptacek on Monday June 06, 2011 @07:14PM (#2627157)
I'm the same way. The value prop of Instapaper for me is, "allows me not to read things I would otherwise feel compelled to waste time reading, while at my computer".
Re:Which Apps are threatened by iOS 5 by adam_albrecht on Monday June 06, 2011 @07:14PM (#2627158)
I add articles from my iPhone all the time, but rarely through Safari. The vast majority of my articles come from apps that have Instapaper built in, such as Twitter and Alien Blue. This is one advantage that Instapaper has, although I would assume that most apps will build in Reading List integration, as well.

The other big advantage that Instapaper has (which will keep me using it) is Kindle integration. I much prefer to read long articles on my Kindle over any other platform.