News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by ravi-delia on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:19PM (#26265256)
Believe me, in general I'm with you. But at the end of the day you just don't have to buy an iphone. Get an android device, flash it with Linux, buy a pinephone, do whatever you want! But Apple doesn't sell tinker's devices, they sell a walled garden. Why force them to spend even 10 seconds of effort on something that isn't their business, when there are plenty of other options?

There's a reason I don't have any Apple device: they don't make anything that I want. It seems pretty pointless to mandate that all companies must sell products that I like.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by EvanAnderson on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:23PM (#26265313)
Why force them to spend even 10 seconds of effort on something that isn't their business...

The law should make it "their business". I don't believe it should be possible to waive your right to legally do what you want with your property.

(I have similar feelings about restrictive covenants in the conveyance of real property, for example.)

Since we're editing here:

It seems pretty pointless to mandate that all companies must sell products that I like.

We mandate lots of consumer protections. This seems no different to me.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by mrzimmerman on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:42PM (#26265595)
Don't you suppose you're being a bit dogmatic about it? Every device has to be as flexible as possible or it's against the law? Genuinely not trying to straw man, but should my oven manufacturer have to account for me wanting to turn it into a space heater if I feel like it?

Companies make and sell products for specific use-cases all the time. Saying the can't sell something unless they also make the product able to break away form that specific use case, regardless of time and cost to the company and consumers for parallel built in systems or whatever the lift may be doesn't sound feasible to me.

I don't know, I'm on your side that I should be able to dismantle my iPhone and use the parts to my hearts content if I want to. But I'm not sure that it's something Apple has to build into the system just in case someone feels like doing it, especially since I could buy any number of other computing devices that might work just as well.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by EvanAnderson on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:53PM (#26265743)
What Google did with the Chromebooks-- an interlock that zeros the manufacturer-provided root-of-trust-- is a good example of all that I want. No more, no less. Let me flip a switch and make the device "untrusted" so that I can load my own software.

I am being dogmatic. I can't think objectively about this because I have yet to see how it benefits society to absolutely remove the rights of owners to legally do what they please with their property (at least in terms of chattels).

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by freeone3000 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:58PM (#26266658)
Even with an iPhone, you have the right to flash whatever firmware you feel like. This has been upheld in US Supreme Court cases. Apple simply is under no obligation for it to be easy for you to do so. Jailbroken iPhones aren't illegal. Apple treats them as a security risk, since mechanisms for jailbreaking iPhones exploit security flaws in order to get root-level code execution. I can't say they're wrong to do so! It's no secret that they do. Or that Apple doesn't ship anything but iOS to an iPhone, or that you won't be able to install apps from outside the App Store. These are marketed as features.

Most people are interested in solving a task, and their device helps them with this. They are uninterested in general-purpose computers. And there's no shortage of them for the rest of us! Android devices are the obvious choice here, with their user-exposed flashable ROMs. (Not just the OS, but every ROM is exposed through fastboot) Or PinePhone. Or whatever Firefox is doing. You've got choices for tinkerers and general-purpose computation, it just doesn't live in a device with an apple logo.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by mindslight on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:39PM (#26268679)
> you have the right to flash whatever firmware you feel like... Apple simply is under no obligation for it to be easy for you to do so

This is disingenuous. Apple is not being called out for failing to create desirable functionality for iPhones. Rather Apple (et al) are being criticized for deliberately acting to purposefully constrain functionality. The first criticism would be asking manufacturers to do work to improve their products. The second criticism is telling them to stop crippling devices they sell.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by croon on Friday February 26, 2021 @07:47AM (#26274205)
> Don't you suppose you're being a bit dogmatic about it? Every device has to be as flexible as possible or it's against the law? Genuinely not trying to straw man, but should my oven manufacturer have to account for me wanting to turn it into a space heater if I feel like it?

You're reversing the burden. Apple is spending a lot of money to NOT make it possible to tinker with it.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by sjy on Thursday February 25, 2021 @05:29PM (#26269154)
> should my oven manufacturer have to account for me wanting to turn it into a space heater if I feel like it?

No, because their failure to do this has no structural consequences for the market in ovens or space heaters. Apple’s control over the market for software that can run on 2 billion iOS devices, on the other hand, is a big deal. Some think it’s Apple’s just deserts for creating a platform that users like; others think the government should end that control using the antitrust laws passed to limit corporate power at this scale.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by ravi-delia on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:29PM (#26268567)
I mean if I sell you a brick, it's not gonna connect to wifi. I'm not advertising it as connecting to wifi, so if you buy it than it's really your fault for thinking it will. Similarly, Apple doesn't prevent you from doing anything you want with an I-Phone. You can (if you so choose) saw it in half, open it up and try to figure it out, and interact with it in any way you please. If those interactions don't yield results you want, you really can't blame Apple since they pretty much told you what you were getting.

Now there are some real scummy practices that Apple uses, and those should be regulated. Software that detects tampering and shuts down the device? Sure, get rid of it. Some vital service they can (and do) shut down at any time, bricking the device? Regulate it to nothing. But ultimately 'do what you want with your property' is completely different from 'sell whatever I personally want in a device regardless of how others feel'. Apple sells a walled garden by design, and buying one of their devices pretty much entails realizing that.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by doteka on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:27PM (#26265371)
You have the right to do whatever you want to with your iPhone. Apple is not obligated to make it easy for you to do so, or honor their warranty if you choose to fiddle with it. The law getting involved here would be total overreach, and I say this as someone who’s politically left, a total commie by US standards.
Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by EvanAnderson on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:48PM (#26265669)
The technical protections in a modern device are impossible, from a practical perspective, for an individual to defeat. For all practical purposes Apple has removed the rights of owners to do what they please with the devices they own. It's not that they didn't make it easy-- they made it completely impossible.

I am not mature, informed, or articulate enough to argue about this objectively. I cannot conceive of how society benefits from taking away the rights of owners.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by anigbrowl on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:20PM (#26266963)
But you can cooperate with others to figure out to defeat those protections, or not buy into the Apple ecosystem in the first place. I agree they make it very difficult to fully personalize their products and share your dislike, but to me this is like complaining about a case being glued shut or requiring a special driver to access.
Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by grawprog on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:30PM (#26267096)
>but to me this is like complaining about a case being glued shut or requiring a special driver to access.

Both of those are fairly valid complaints though. Intentionally making a device hard to access or repair is almost as bad as not allowing it at all. That shows an actual concerted effort to stop or make it as difficult for consumers as possible.

That's basically the definition of anti-consumer practices.

It in no way benefits me to not be able to use a standard screw driver to open something and have to either purchase an expensive proprietary tool or at worst take it to an 'authorized' repair shop that has the license to use the proprietary tool.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by anigbrowl on Monday March 01, 2021 @07:52PM (#26310579)
OK, but that's when you make the decision not to buy it in the first place. I've managed to go my whole life without buying an Apple product because I always thought their products were kinda user-hostile and unfriendly to hacking/customization. On the other hand, I don't feel that Apple has any obligation to deliver the sort of product I want, when they have so many customers that actively prefer their walled garden/black box approach.

Occasionally I find myself thinking I'd like to own an Apple product, eg when I run across a cool iPad app or something, but this rarely persists longer than the few minutes it takes me to remember that I don't want to reorient around the Apple ecosystem.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by doteka on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:59PM (#26265836)
I’m sorry to say, but your first paragraph is blatantly false. The jailbreaking community has been active since the iPhone product line existed, up to this day. Feel free to look it up. They provide instructions that a high school script kiddie is able to follow. I know because I was one of them.

If you were not motivated enough to research the options available to you, you cannot in good faith argue that Apple did anything wrong here.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by EvanAnderson on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:07PM (#26265968)
I'm well aware of jailbreaks. I've jailbroken a number of Apple devices and some consoles.

In every "jailbreak" case, the manufacturer's intention was to make practically impossible owner control of devices. Jailbreaks are about exploiting bugs. The manufacturer's intention remains the same-- to remove owner control. Just because Apple made mistakes in their implementation of their architecture of control doesn't change their intention.

re: impractical for individuals - Try un-blowing an e-fuse in a Nintendo Switch. That's practically impossible. That's the kind of protections I'm talking about.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by Silhouette on Thursday February 25, 2021 @03:13PM (#26267645)
Believe me, in general I'm with you. But at the end of the day you just don't have to buy an iphone. Get an android device, flash it with Linux, buy a pinephone, do whatever you want!

The problem with this argument is the same as any essential utility. At some point, it becomes impossible to live a normal life without access to a certain facility. If access is only available through a monopoly provider or a small enough number of providers that they tend to move the market in unison even if not actively collaborating, that can become a serious problem.

This is why we have government regulation of essential markets. Regulators might impose pricing limits in violation of the "free market", to prevent exploitation of vulnerable customers (and in this context, remember that most or all customers might be in that category) where competition fails to do so effectively on its own. But laws and regulations can also impose other safeguards, such as requiring honest advertising, adequate privacy and security protections, or interoperability.

I think it is no longer credible, at least in my country (the UK) and others like it, to argue that a modern smartphone is a luxury. People use their phones to access government services, shops and home delivery services, banks and financial services. They are by far the dominant communication device of our age, not just for calls but also texts, emails, numerous Internet-based communications channels. Some people no longer have any other reasonably convenient means to access those services and communications. Some of those services and channels are provided exclusively via mobile apps and simply aren't available to those who don't have a phone (which is in itself a problem, because obviously not everyone does, and this is making things very difficult for some demographics during the strange times we are living in).

This being the case, it is reasonable to argue that people should not have to choose between two dominant ecosystems for their phone when both have serious problems in areas like privacy, security, reliability and data lock-in, some of which are a direct result of the interests of the providers of those two dominant platforms, without any realistic ability for most people to protect themselves from those risks or with any such ability relying essentially on luck (for example, the availability of jailbreaks and the continued operation of essential apps despite any jailbreak that has been applied).

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by ravi-delia on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:38PM (#26268659)
It may well be that internet access in general is an essential utility, though I'd disagree that any device in particular is. However, the fact that the 'two dominant platforms' continue existing is mostly due to people's personal preferences. Besides, saying that Android devices even approach the same level of locked-downness of Apple devices is absurd; I run an open source version of android on all my mobile devices, and not once was it particularly difficult to install.

Even more, it doesn't seem to me that cell phone manufacturers are currently moving the market in particular unison. There are still more and less open devices, just as there are more or less expensive ones. Perhaps we're moving slowly towards that, but we're certainly a long way away as of now.

My primary issue is the difference between ensuring that no one has to get screwed and ensuring that no one can get a product they want. So long as there are more open devices, no one is compelled to use an IPhone. Anyone who wants to be protected from big bad apple may simply refrain from paying them. A utility is generally regulated not because of its vitality, but because of inherent restrictions on consumer choice. Unless it becomes impossible to just not buy Apple's shitty locked down hardware, it doesn't make sense to constrict.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by InvertedRhodium on Thursday February 25, 2021 @06:56PM (#26269950)
Does your banking application, Google Pay, and other services that (needlessly) rely on SafetyNet work on that phone?
Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by ravi-delia on Saturday February 27, 2021 @07:35PM (#26289574)
Yep, although getting it to work if you root your device takes a few extra minutes. More importantly, to what extent is it Apple's fault that banking apps don't work on my android phone? Even if every device had a little hardware switch that would grant root access, those apps would then be under no obligation to function. And if you then go after the apps, why did you bother with the phone anyway?
Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by boring_twenties on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:28PM (#26271095)
Not the same guy, but Chase and Fidelity apps work on my LOS devices.

No idea about Google Pay, it's never even occurred to me to try it.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by InvertedRhodium on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:58PM (#26267463)
As someone who owns a Pinephone, don't buy a Pinephone if you're expecting a functional, usable device. It might get there in a year or more, but it's nowhere near there now.
Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by asdff on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:35PM (#26267162)
That's like saying you don't have to buy a car, or you don't have to get an air conditioner. Sure, you could tolerate a 2 hour bus ride and a summer with 90+ degree heat waves, but there is no reason to put yourself through that given the cost of the alternative luxury is not insurmountable even for working people in expensive places.

We are in a similar place in the mobile world, where life is getting increasingly reliant on electronic luxuries. If you want to take advantage of the convenient electric scooter or rideshare, you need an app. If you want to cash a check without going to a bank or paying a fee with a third party like a grocery store, you need an app. If you want to get early warnings from the city and/or state about earthquakes of all things, you need an app (MyShake). And for all those apps, you can't build from source on your own hardware. There is rarely a mobile website alternative. You need to get them from one of two centralized and moderated marketplaces, where only sanctioned and licensed devices may participate. You could make a stand here with a dumb phone and yell at the clouds that the world is this way, and it really is bad that it is this way, but you'd realistically be living a decade in the past and miss out on all this useful functionality.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by njharman on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:44PM (#26267282)
No it's not! The parent listed other phones as options, not "do without a phone".

Following your weird examples the parent's comment is like saying you don't have to buy a *Ford* car, or a *Carrier* AC. There are many more car and AC options if you don't like Ford or Carrier.

Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by InvertedRhodium on Thursday February 25, 2021 @03:02PM (#26267510)
They also listed the Pinephone, which had no facility to do most of those things. It's either Apple or Android, and both of these are making it harder and harder over time to run your own software stack.
Re:The decline of computers as a general-purpose technology by ravi-delia on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:43PM (#26268717)
But I mean, you can just buy a different type of car. Like, if you feel really strongly that every car ought to have a headphone jack because otherwise consumers are stripped of their right to play music through a headphone jack in their car, you can buy a car that has one. You aren't forever stuck on the bus, you just have to look at more than one whole car before you decide which one to buy.

Same goes for Apple; I would never use an Apple device, because I like to have control over my technology. Somehow, despite my amazingly brave stand against tyranny and capitalism, I still have a phone, running a LineageOS install that took me 20 minutes and an online guide to get running years ago. On the other hand, if I wanted to give my grandma a device I was confident she couldn't somehow force into a bad state, I would like it to be legal to sell me one.