What would I do if I were concerned about inflation but wanted cash? I suppose this doesn’t help anyone who’s solely into indexing, and I know this locks up cash, but I’d look for unlikely-to-fail dividend-paying companies that are relatively protected against inflation and that are trading at relatively fair values. Essentially, you’d be saying “I don’t care if I can’t sell this stock for 10 years so long as the 4%+ current dividend yield ratchets up at or above inflation.”
To use my Ford Fiesta analogy, if you come to me and say “this Ford Fiesta is only 60k! That’s 40 percent off! I would say you’re using a sleazy sales tactic on me, because it’s not worth 60k either. Comparing it with some other, even more outrageous price and then claiming that it’s therefore cheap is not something I’m going to fall for.
Hope the treasury yields moving up don’t wreck you, if yields move N%, then bond values move (N*years remaining)% down. Disregard if you buy individual bonds and hold until redemption.
The problem is that you could lose money for 10 years. 1970-80.
Mindless buying S&P 500 is great but you might want to do better. Most people will do worse if they try to beat the index but some people will do 20% a year for as long as they keep buying good businesses at good prices.
“Buying the dip” is a bad strategy if it’s not paired with understanding value. Dips are sometimes temporary overreactions or part of a continued decline. Enron had a big “dip” soon after reaching its high. I suppose if you bought the dip then sold very quickly after, you’d make money, but you’d have to choose the right dip.
"Buying the dip" as a strategy only makes sense in hindsight. Say it's late 2007 and you have some cash. On Sep 28 of that year, the VTI was at $75.60. By April 2008, it had fallen over 12% to around $66. But it would still go down even more. Same thing as in early 2020: the market falls 5%... do you buy then? Once it fell around 30%, could you identify that as the "bottom" given the information you had at the time?
I'm not saying it isn't overvalued, just that there needs to be more detai here than just "the P/E is historically high".
I know there’s a quote out there that says “the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent” but that doesn’t apply in this case. I don’t need this money. It’s for later. I can stay solvent indefinitely. The market can go suck eggs. If it stays at this inflated level forever, I still haven’t really lost anything. If the cost of a Ford Fiesta goes to a million, well c’est la vie. But everyone knows that it isn’t actually worth that much so it seems like a dumb assumption to make that that will happen. Why would you just assume there’s always going to be a bigger idiot? You eventually run out of idiots and someone will come to me hat in hand and say, “...what about 15k?” and then I’ll get off my pile of money.