News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by lukev on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:31PM (#2625539)
That's the whole point of bitcoins. Anonymous, hard-to-trace payments. You can't get that kind of "freedom" without also being really attractive for illegal uses.

Bitcoin is designed to be subversive, and subversive means illegal as far as the government is concerned.

This is the main/only reason I'm not making any long term investment in Bitcoin.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by mycroftiv on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:05PM (#2625665)
I think it is entirely possible Bitcoin will provoke the mother-of-all battles for control over communication networks and how people use them. The outlines are very clear: Bitcoin allows nearly complete escape from the current financial regulatory systems that control currency movements and taxation. Trying to prevent people from moving money from one country to another or using Bitcoins for buying drugs, weapons, whatever is impossible without a truly draconian censorship and control regime in which private citizens are more or less forbidden from using encrypted communications.

I see government control over money as basically an immovable object - I don't think so-called constitutional protections mean anything when it comes to governments doing what they feel is necessary to maintain control. Internet freedom and encryption are not as much of an irresistible force as net-romantics would like to think.

If anything can force governments into legislating backdoors into all encryption systems and creating a clearly established set of "choke points" for control of data flows, it is the possibility of Bitcoin and other crypto-currencies to render basic imperatives of the modern nation state impossible to enforce.

It is more or less infinitely depressing to me, because as much as I would like to believe that the "good guys" are going to win, I doubt it. People generally don't realize how much we are already living in a dystopian panopticon, and Bitcoin is one of the rays of light shining through the cracks in the prison walls.

What is even more depressing to me is my own cowardice. I am too scared of the US government to even try to resist in any way, no matter how trivial. I would like to participate in Bitcoin and other projects, but I don't want to end up in a federal prison for conspiracy to assist in money laundering and tax evasion, as I imagine that any participation in Bitcoin will be interpreted by government prosecutors of the near-future.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by wmf on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:18PM (#2625729)
It seems like it would be a lot easier to just shut down the USD-BTC exchanges. If people can't get money in or out of the system they don't need to worry about what happens inside the system. (I'm ignoring mining, since there's a serious limit on how large that can get.)
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by elliottcarlson on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:24PM (#2625751)
And yet, just yesterday I met with someone and sold him bitcoins for cash. Anyone can be an exchange.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by jxcole on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:37PM (#2626166)
Not necessarily. If it became apparent that people could pay each other in bitcoins without being taxed, there would, eventually, be no point in have USDs at all.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by SkyMarshal on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:44PM (#2625843)
>I see government control over money as basically an immovable object

Fyi, governments don't control money, the international reserve banking system does, centered on the Bank for International Settlements (BIS.org). Governments' enforcement arms are just their proxy. They'll be even less likely to tolerate an upstart competitor like bitcoin.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by jxcole on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:45PM (#2626218)
Awesome observation.

Another interesting tidbit. Imagine that bitcoin became the de-facto currency. Not only would the government be unable to tax, it would also be unable to control the financial systems it uses to affect markets. For example, the government can print a small amount of money for itself without causing hyper-inflation. This "inflation tax" would also be noncollectable. Further, the federal funds rate would be useless.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by T_S_ on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:00PM (#2626628)
You touch on one of the important reasons why fiat money maintains its value. You can always use it to pay your taxes.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by weavejester on Monday June 06, 2011 @04:59PM (#2626616)
The government will always be able to tax its citizens. Even if all money were transferred anonymously, the government could tax you based on the value of the land you own.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by dusklight on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:42PM (#2625830)
This is a bit like saying in the 19th century that slavery is inevitable and that slave owners will do anything to stay in control.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by mycroftiv on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:18PM (#2626037)
Wait, doesn't that actually support what I'm saying? I recall a shooting war in which a lot of people died as part of the process by which slavery stopped being a reality in the USA. Or is that your point?
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by pathjumper on Monday June 06, 2011 @04:44PM (#2626526)
Which kind of slavery? Wage slavery is alive and well. It is the slavery of the 21st century, and continues today. Or can you quit your job without going bankrupt due to debt unlike me and millions of others like me?
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by LeBleu on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:11PM (#2626687)
Hmm, perhaps you should consider a few differences between so called wage "slavery" and chattel slavery as practiced in pre-civil war US:

1) Modern workers are not owned from birth.

2) Debt is not forced upon you against your will, debt is a choice.

3) The alternative to choosing debt is not getting whipped nor killed.

4) Bankruptcy is neither getting whipped, nor killed.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by nomurrcy on Monday June 06, 2011 @08:46PM (#2627435)
One small note:

Debt for an individual is a choice. However our monetary system mandates that some people or entities must always be in debt. If there were no debt there would be almost no money in circulation.

So while you say that debt is a choice, it is impossible for everyone to be debt-free. If everyone stopped borrowing (consumers, industry and government) in this country, we would have a complete economic breakdown.

This is like saying smoking is a choice: from the perspective of the single potential smoker, it is. From the perspective of the marketer this is unimportant as they don't need you to smoke, they just need some people to smoke.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by CodeMage on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:08PM (#2625971)
Not really. You're not accounting for technological progress. The "reach" of governments (and other entities that hold the power) has expanded due to the technology. Communication was a lot slower and a lot less reliable in the 19th century. So was transport, for that matter.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by weavejester on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:46PM (#2625592)
I agree that's the perception, but the reality is that bitcoins are not inherently anonymous, in the same way that normal net traffic is not inherently anonymous.

Sure, you can use Tor, launder your bitcoins, and effectively become untraceable, but how many people actually do this, and do this correctly? Even Lulz Security, who presumably have a reasonable degree of technical expertise, didn't bother to use Tor when talking over IRC.

Also, Silk Road is kinda ridiculous anyway, because despite all that security and anonymising, in the end you have to give out a physical address that you'll visit in person.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by a1k0n on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:31PM (#2625784)
Bitcoins are much less anonymous than normal net traffic, even. If someone sends you some money, you get to know the address it came from, and plug it in on http://blockexplorer.com/ and you can see which addresses that address got its money from, and how much, and you can trace it all the way back through history to find out which block generated the money and how it got to that address. Depending on how people consolidate their wallets, you can even see how much money they have.

I don't have to be routing packets for you to find all this out; every transaction goes to every node.

There are "laundering" services which try to play a shell game with addresses, but I think they're probably easy to reverse-engineer, at least probabilistically if not completely.

OTOH, unlike IPs, you can't pinpoint addresses to any location though or find out who owns what addresses for sure. I guess they're more pseudonymous than anonymous.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by w01fe on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:49PM (#2626237)
Anonymizing bitcoins is not difficult. For example, you can deposit your coins in an online wallet service, and then withdraw some fraction of that amount to an anonymous address. Because the wallet provider can pool its coins, the coins coming out can have absolutely no relationship to the coins going in, outside the private records of the wallet provider.

The wallet provider could, in principle, be subpoenaed / coerced /hacked / owned by the NSA. I imagine there will eventually be a Tor-like "onion" anonymization method, where bitcoins are routed through multiple such services, so that no single service need be trusted (except to not steal your money). The main challenge with these techniques is avoiding forms of traffic analysis, where I notice B$98.23 heading from A to B, and shortly thereafter, B$98.22 heading from C to D, and infer that these represent a single transaction chain despite being disconnected in the block chain record. Such attacks can be minimized by, e.g., settling on a fixed transaction amount for all transactions with a given service, and adding random delays commensurate with the transaction rate and degree of anonymity required.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by wmf on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:56PM (#2625894)
I wonder if Palantir has a Bitcoin plugin yet.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by ahi on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:43PM (#2625582)
That is the main/only reason I am making a long term investment in Bitcoin. Given the volatility I think the people speculating in Bitcoin purely for financial gain are nuts.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by zby on Monday June 06, 2011 @04:17PM (#2626390)
"Given the volatility I think the people speculating in Bitcoin purely for financial gain are nuts" - that's a strong statement mate. Any reasoning behind it or you just like insulting people?
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by ahi on Monday June 06, 2011 @04:39PM (#2626502)
http://bitcoincharts.com/markets/

Today's exchange rate range is 16.45 to 19.23. That's pretty typical, and some days are a lot worse. In the forums, the consensus seems to be that any attempt at economic analysis is largely a waste of time due to there being way too many unknowns. The Bitcoin "investors" and "speculators" just look like gamblers to me. That qualifies as "nuts" to this coward.

However, I do like insulting people.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by weavejester on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:08PM (#2626664)
A lot of Bitcoin speculators have invested only what they can afford to lose. I don't think it's "nuts" to invest a few hundred dollars (for example) in something as technically interesting as Bitcoin. People probably lose more in a Vegas vacation.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by ahi on Monday June 06, 2011 @05:58PM (#2626889)
Agreed, but then those people and the people gambling in Vegas aren't approaching it as though it were a rational investment strategy.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by weavejester on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:48PM (#2627091)
True. I don't think you should view it as an investment, and certainly not a reliable one. At best, it's like investing in a startup you think has promise and is undervalued.
Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by nextparadigms on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:05PM (#2625668)
Should they make Tor illegal too then because it helps you stay anonymous? Should they make it illegal for people to sign-up with a fake name to social networks, websites and commenting systems?

Just because something is anonymous doesn't make it inherently bad. It's how you use it that can make it bad. If hackers can hack into sites anonymously, it doesn't mean we should ban all anonymity.

Re:Schumer Bashes BitCoin, Wants to Shut Down Silk Road Drug... by redthrowaway on Monday June 06, 2011 @03:18PM (#2626035)
Tor is a case of one hand not knowing what the other was doing, in that LEAs hate it but it was developed by navy intelligence, and a lot of people had to use it in order for it to be effective. When law enforcement goes up against the military, law enforcement loses. That's not the case with bitcoin.