News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by PaulKeeble on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:56AM (#26252227)
Google's business model is to have no customer service and have customers discard-able without notice when Google chooses. Why would a business want to do business to business with Google and actually pay them at this point? They do 'free' sort of well but they are a terrible option for dependable partner whether you pay them or not.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by avery42 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:14PM (#26252533)
From GCP docs [0]:

  Effect of ToS violations
  
  Google-wide disabled account
  
  In some cases a Google-wide account (which covers access to a variety of Google products like Google Photos, Google Play, Google Drive, and GCP) will be disabled for violations of a Google ToS, egregious policy violations, or as required by law. Owners of disabled Google accounts will not be able to access their Google Cloud resources until the account is reinstated. If an account is disabled, a notification is sent to the secondary email address provided during the signup process, if available. If a phone number is available, the user is notified via text message. The notification includes a link for appeal and recovery, where applicable.
  
  In order to regain access to their GCP resources, owners of disabled Google accounts will need to contact Google support and have their account re-enabled.
  
  To minimize the effect of an account being disabled on Google Cloud resources, we recommend that you add more than one owner to all resources. As long as there is at least one active owner, GCP resources will not be suspended due to the one of the owners being disabled.
Given the Google account horror stories that pop up every few months, seems risky if you're solo/only have one GCP owner.

[0]: https://cloud.google.com/resource-manager/docs/project-suspe...

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by firloop on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:26PM (#26252716)
Google will suspend entire accounts even if you have more than one owner.

A few years back, our business credit card was somehow stolen and used to buy Google Adwords. We disputed the charge with our bank. A day or two later, at 4am local time, our GCP account was suspended for fraud (presumably because the same, stolen, card was attached to that account). All instances were stopped and our service was brought to a halt.

We couldn’t contact Google Cloud support because our account was suspended. We had to go through our network to get our account re-instated. Pretty awful way to start our morning, to say the least.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by theginger on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @02:19PM (#26254294)
On the link above there is a separate section for billing account suspensions and it seems to work how you described.

You can fairly easily swap billing accounts a project is using if you still have an organisation admin account that isn't suspended. I saw this risk coming at a previous company and tried to get them to treat billing accounts like any other important resource and go for redundancy, but the director could not see the value and our Google account manager denied the risk existed, luckily they have been more fortunate and this has not happened to them yet, although it did come close once with some issues with the payments.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by kyrra on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @09:32PM (#26259023)
Googler, opinions are my own.

We actually created a portal where you can report unknown charges to Google directly; https://payments.google.com/payments/unauthorizedtransaction...

Credit card companies tell you to work with a company before issuing a chargeback, as chargebacks are a last resort. The above form helps you keep you account active without being swept up in the chargeback process.

It's something we all want to keep improving. I'm hoping as SCA (strong customer authentication) rolls out across europe and maybe other countries pick it up, it should cut down on issues like this.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by amscanne on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:46PM (#26259803)
I believe that the "work with a company" guidance is for a dispute (e.g. you ordered something, but didn't get it or are otherwise unhappy) -- not an outright unauthorized purchase by someone other than the card holder. I don't see what most companies would do if you approached them in this case: you have no order number, no information about the purchase, nothing to return, etc.

The only logical thing to do in the case of a stolen or copied card is to contact the bank directly, so that the card can be canceled and fraudulent charges reversed.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by kyrra on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:07AM (#26259913)
Point taken. I thought of that same point after I wrote the above.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by meepmorp on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:19PM (#26253477)
What happened once the account was reinstated and everything was up again? The customer service obviously sucked; did they acknowledge that and try to make it right?
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by notyourday on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:52PM (#26253114)
That's why one should not use GCP for anything
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by jrockway on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @02:43PM (#26254628)
AWS doesn't suspend your account if you chargeback your AWS charges?

Hold on while I go mine myself a ton of crypto coins.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by notyourday on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @03:12PM (#26255123)
AWS does not suspend your AWS account if there's an issue with you Amazon account. AWS reps are contactable and dare I say it capable of escalating and resolving issues.

The idea that someone could use a stolen credit card associated with an account, buy something on some Google service, have a chargeback processed as fraud and that would trigger Google's suspension of services on GCP is absurd.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by drstewart on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @05:03PM (#26256682)
> To minimize the effect of an account being disabled on Google Cloud resources, we recommend that you add more than one owner to all resources. As long as there is at least one active owner, GCP resources will not be suspended due to the one of the owners being disabled.

When even Google themselves is recommending gaming their system since they can't guarantee it won't screw you over, that should be a warning sign.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by Clewza313 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @07:08PM (#26258018)
Having more than one owner is just basic common sense though. What if the single owner is hit by a literal bus?
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by janosett on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:01PM (#26252314)
I was involved in a mid-sized software company migrating from AWS to GCP. My experience was that the GCP team was very hands on, and that enterprise support was very responsive.

The support isn't perfect, nor is the product -- but I would say the level of customer service for GCP can't be compared to other Google products.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by llbeansandrice on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:14PM (#26252523)
Why did the company choose to migrate from AWS to GCP? Just curious.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by cbushko on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:55PM (#26253160)
Not the original poster but we migrated to GCP because:

  1) AWS was extremely expensive   
  2) Our GCP bill is about 1/3 of what AWS was  
  3) The Kubernetes offering is top notch  
  4) Google giving us credits and offering us consulting were the triggers that started us talking.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by llbeansandrice on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:32PM (#26253673)
Seems like k8s is a big seller for a lot of companies. We don't use it currently on our team and the larger company is whole-sale in on AWS I'm not sure they'd ever be able to make the switch.

Always like to see why people make these big changes though, thanks!

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by cbushko on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @02:08PM (#26254153)
I spent over a year doing a full migration from AWS EC2 + ECS instances to GCP + docker + kubernetes. It was a huge task that has paid off very well.

  1) Costs per customer are lower because you can fit more containers per VM due to kubernetes doing the scheduling for you. Customers also include developer environments.
  2) The number of deploys is way up because there is a simple and established pattern that everyone follows.
  3) The speed of creating new services has increased because of the established patterns with containers, kubernetes resources, and deploys. Thinks days vs weeks to get something running.
  4) The number of Ops issues are lower because kubernetes handles so many things for you. For example, if a deploy is incorrect for some reason, the old service is sitting there running. No outage = no escalation = everyone sleeps at night.

Even if I was a tiny startup, I would still recommend using Kubernetes. The patterns, tooling and insight that Kubernetes gives you will save you TIME. The time saved is worth more than the tiny cost of a 3 node Kubernetes cluster. That is time you can use to develop your product and sell it vs time spent ftp'ing binaries to your Digital Ocean instance. :)
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by jrockway on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @02:46PM (#26254689)
I know you're only picking on Digital Ocean incidentally here, but their managed Kubernetes offering is Pretty Okay. I use it for my personal stuff and it's pretty much everything I expect from a managed Kubernetes offering.

Just don't use EKS. That is managed Kubernetes in the checkbox marketing sense only.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by cbushko on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @06:20PM (#26257539)
Definitely. I have nothing against Digital Ocean or their offering. It was only an example of a different mindset.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by CodesInChaos on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @03:11PM (#26255102)
What makes GCP's Kubernetes offering better than the competition?
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by cbushko on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @06:29PM (#26257628)
There are several reasons:

  - Google has a lot of experience running containerized services because of Borg. Google Research says that they have been running these workloads since 2005.
  - The above gives them insight into how to do this well. They would have the internal infrastructure, logging and monitoring already setup.
  - They are the creator and still a major contributor to Kubernetes itself which means they can insert their influence on it.
To be fair, my only experience running Kubernetes is on GCP so maybe they are all this easy to use and run. The internet tells me that other offerings are not as good. Compared to running workloads on EC2 instances and ECS, using GKE is amazing and pain free.

Note: I am responsible for 5 clusters, 300+ nodes total and several thousand running services. Not huge by any means.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by amzn-throw on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:18PM (#26259652)
The Borg thing is pure marketing.

Amazon also has been running internally on containers for years before ECS. But workloads for massive FAANG companies designed by FAANG engineers turn out to be quite different than most AWS/GCP customers.

Just like EC2 wasn't Amazon selling its "spare capacity during off-peak" but always a purpose built service with completely isolated data centers and network fabric from day 1, the connection between Borg and Kubernetes is tenuous at best.

Honestly, I would encourage you to evaluate ECS and Fargate. Forget Kubernetes and direct instance management. Try a construct like https://docs.aws.amazon.com/cdk/api/latest/docs/@aws-cdk_aws... and see how much simpler it is than all the K8S overhead.

Source: I'm at Amazon but I work on none of these services and opinions are my own. I played with K8S and am eternally confused how it's as popular as it is. I guess it gives you the illusion of not having lock in?

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by cbushko on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:14PM (#26266873)
I only have one thing to point out about Borg and that is large numbers of Borg developers started working on Kubernetes. They got rid of Borg mistakes and replaced them with all new mistakes. :)

I don't see K8S being about lock-in at all. Using a cloud provider gives you some sort of lock-in and you should be utilizing that providers strengths.

Using Kubernetes is all about the patterns that it provides and how it removes a certain class of problems for you. Deployments, scaling, logging, etc are some of the patterns it provides and the consistency matters. How many of us have worked at companies where deploying two services have been completely different? One team runs the jenkins pipeline while another ftps the files over. Now multiply that by several services and several tasks (logging, scaling, etc).

The benefit is in the patterns.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by CodesInChaos on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:08AM (#26264342)
1. Is instance management on ECS really annoying enough to justify the higher fargate price?

2. Does ECS have something similar to pods, i.e. colocated containers which can communicate over localhost, share filesystems, etc? A quick search didn't turn anything up.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by CodesInChaos on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:05AM (#26264287)
I was hoping for something more concrete, like limitations or incidents and not just "Google has more Kubernetes experience".

What were your pain points with ECS? Did you use ECS with or without fargate? What about EKS, since that sounds like a closer equivalent to GKE.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by cbushko on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:54PM (#26266606)
That's fair. As I pointed out in another reply, most of my experience is with GKE so I may be spoiled in how painless it is. All I can say is that GKE is treating me well. Node upgrades are seemless, defaults are decent, it was very easy to create clusters through the console or terraform. I only run 5 clusters and that is not that huge compared to others.

I've used ECS more than fargate. My biggest problem comes from reliability and having to manage things. We still run things on ECS and we get about 30x as many maintenance things we need to do, like retiring instances or instances just dying on us and we have to move things off of it manually.

I have a little bit of experience in Fargate from a previous job but not enough to make a real conclusion about it.

I've never used EKS but I do have friends that would rather roll their own version of Kubernetes on EC2 instance instead of using EKS.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by bilal4hmed on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:04PM (#26252355)
maybe they are confused between Google & GCP
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by sz4kerto on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:04PM (#26252363)
Anecdotally we had great experience with GCP support.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by vincentmarle on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:33PM (#26252836)
GCP Support is not free though.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by colde on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:53PM (#26253972)
Neither is AWS Support. But they do have much lower priced offers though.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by ForHackernews on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:26PM (#26252729)
Some of the GCP stuff works really well, whereas the AWS equivalent feels like a janky afterthought. Looking at you, EKS.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by make3 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:45PM (#26253017)
I think this sorts of makes sense for free services like Search, Gmail and Youtube, where each "client" (user) only gives them a tiny amount of revenue.

This makes very little sense for Cloud Computing where each one your clients gives you large amounts of cash. Maybe they are too used to the first scenario.

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by konne88 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:22PM (#26252659)
Wouldn't Google have a very long history of business to business from their advertising platform?
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by fnord77 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:31PM (#26253659)
google's propensity for abruptly cancelling products seems like a substantial business risk, too. GCP revenue has been declining, so...

edit: revenue GROWTH is declining

Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by jsnell on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @02:27PM (#26254422)
That is not even remotely true. In the latest earnings, Google Cloud revenue grew by 46% year on year, and they said GCP specifically grew faster than Cloud as a whole.
Re:Google Cloud vs. AWS Onboarding Comparison by fnord77 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @03:13PM (#26255137)
sorry, meant to say revenue GROWTH has been declining.

https://venturebeat.com/2020/07/31/probeat-slowing-aws-micro...