News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by ordinaryradical on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:07AM (#26251414)
I don’t understand how that graph cannot represent some kind of crisis in the making. Is there really a way to walk back from this without blowing up the dollar?
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by vmception on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:16AM (#26251563)
So, the classic the hyperinflation events occurred because it happened to a currency in isolation.

What is new here is that you cant really see it because all major currencies are increasing their supply at similar rates.

So stocks, houses and apples increase in value rapidly as more money exists than there are things to buy, but the relative inflation of any economic union is completely masked.

Therefore the classic concern - speculators loosing confidence in the currency - isn't quite a classic concern.

They don't have an alternative as all major currencies are doing the same thing. To play that script they would need to be exiting fiat currencies, so watch for that.

But the macro trend is worldwide speculators pounding against the dam for negative interest rates in the US. Thats the season finale for now and cliffhanger, with no real prediction on the next season’s contents.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by purple_ferret on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:35AM (#26251874)
>So stocks, houses and apples increase in value rapidly as more money exists than there are things to buy, but the relative inflation of any economic union is completely masked.

Wages/work notably excluded so hardly masked as has been the case to anyone looking at the share of taxable income over the past 40 years

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by danenania on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:33AM (#26251845)
Considering that cryptocurrencies are still treated more like high risk speculative bets than currencies, it seems like gold would be the main beneficiary of an across-the-board collapse of confidence in fiat currency?

The price of gold has gone up a bit during the crisis, but nothing close to the increase in M1. So it would seem that markets are indeed sticking with fiat currencies in spite of the huge supply expansion...

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by viklove on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:20PM (#26253482)
Markets aren't sticking with fiat currencies, they're buying up stocks like there's no tomorrow. Asset inflation is a very real thing.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by danenania on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @04:36PM (#26256366)
I agree that asset inflation is an inevitable consequence of money supply expansion. I just don’t see any indication that we’re headed toward a fiat collapse.

Markets might not be choosing fiat currency for a store of value, but they’re still apparently choosing it for a medium of exchange.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by viklove on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @05:41PM (#26257155)
They're not "choosing" it, it's literally their only option. If I want to trade my ETH to GME shares, I have to convert it to USD in between.

What this will do is erode faith in the USD. If demand for cryptos, for example, stays the same, but suddenly everyone has more $$$ to throw around, crypto will keep skyrocketing in value while the USD buys less and less of the things people actually need. At that point there will be runaway demand for crypto because people will start "believing" it's more stable than the USD.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by danenania on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @06:41PM (#26257746)
Yeah, that’s my point: it’s the only option, except maybe for gold. And gold is only going up a little. So how could fiat currency be collapsing?

Crypto may be seen as an alternative in the future, but right now it’s all over the map. No one is using it for their savings account (or checking account, for that matter).

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by viklove on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:36PM (#26259746)
Where can I buy stocks for gold?

Honestly though, a crypto-based brokerage probably isn't too far off. Might even be a billion dollar idea.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by simonbarker87 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:31AM (#26251812)
Back when the Covid crisis kicked off I (with minimal knowledge) speculated with friends that stuff would get weird economically because all the countries (developed economies) in the world are going to do similar things to counter this so we may not see obvious sides effects we would typically see. Sounds similar to what you’ve said above?
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by vmception on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:55PM (#26253164)
kind of, the only thing you are missing is that macroeconomic trend is in play no matter what the catalyst turned out to be

the yield curve flattening was a big headline long before and seen as a bearish sign, its not important that COVID spooked everyone to selloff and its not interesting that Congress and the Fed stepped in because of that.

All the monetary policy and the fiscal policy decisions were written in advance and just placed on Congress’s desk when they were scrambling for a solution. 5,000 page bills werent just made overnight.

the entire game is to put your losses on the balance sheet of the biggest whale in the market (a sovereign with no consequence) and keep all the profits for yourself, and reaching a place in society where that is practical. there is no andrew jackson to dismantle the central bank for the specific reason he dismantled the first one. so the outcome is always predictable, the cause and effect is easy to understand. the mechanism that all central banks (except china’s) use to flood the market with cash is by purchasing an ever expanding universe of bonds, with pushes the bond price up and interest rates of those bonds down.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by core-questions on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:33AM (#26251849)
Would negative interest rates actually percolate down to retail consumers? Will I be able to get paid to take a loan?
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by vmception on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:49AM (#26252113)
If US treasuries go steeply negative enough (and the spread remains as tight or gets tighter) then yes, banks will pay you interest, while you still pay principle.

Lenders so far stay in the market because they actively trade the debt object even if they lose the business of earning interest. (With debt, the price of the contract increases as interest rates go down)

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by machinecontrol on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:31AM (#26251825)
In other words: this time is different.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by vmception on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:45AM (#26252058)
Every time is different don't be reductive.

But yes, for now the central bank and legislative actions far outweigh my uber drivers and unemployed dates talking about daytrading, as more money is going to hit the market. US Congress is going to create/distribute $2 trillion more dollars and the US Federal Reserve is still purchasing corporate bonds, creating new money in every transaction. Babies better be daytrading on abacuses.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by throw0101a on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:18AM (#26251594)
In most cases in the past, the printing of money has actually been the effect, and not the cause, of problems like hyperinflation:

* https://clintballinger.wordpress.com/2021/01/12/the-myth-of-...

As a linked-to IMF paper observes (Benes and Michael Kumhof 2012, p. 12):

> To be fair, there have of course been historical episodes where government-issued currencies collapsed amid high inflation. But the lessons from these episodes are so obvious, and so unrelated to the fact that monetary control was exercised by the government, that they need not concern us here. These lessons are: First, do not put a convicted murderer and gambler, or similar characters, in charge of your monetary system(the 1717-1720 John Law episode in France). Second, do not start a war, and if you do, donot lose it (wars, especially lost ones, can destroy any currency, irrespective of whether monetary control is exercised by the government or by private parties).

* https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/wp12202.pdf

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by rmah on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:13AM (#26251510)
There was a change in regulations in May 2020 which changed how banks classified some deposit accounts which effectively changes how the Fed defined M1 money. IIRC, it was related to what sorts of liquid deposits were counted as M1 vs not M1. Either way, IMO, the more important number to watch is M2 money.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by PragmaticPulp on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:20AM (#26251625)
Yes, the M1 now includes some components that were previously only counted in M2:

> This suggests that the rapid acceleration in M1 since May 2020 is mainly from money moving out of the non-M1 components of M2 into M1, rather than reflecting any acceleration in the demand for transaction balances.

The chart looks shocking without context, but it’s also very misleading without the context.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by aluminum96 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:11AM (#26251485)
I think that the change to M2 is expected to be much flatter, since banks have walked back lending. Whether it's that much flatter, I would be surprised.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by MarkSweep on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:19AM (#26251614)
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/release/tables?eid=491&rid=21

From January to December of 2020, M1 increased by $14 trillion, while M1 “only” increased by $4 trillion. So not as steep at 25%.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by tryitnow on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:38AM (#26251925)
The increase is not as dramatic as this chart makes it out to be. It's more on the order of ~25%, not 300%+.

This is largely a function of a re-categorization of certain types of accounts: https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2021/01/whats-behind-the-rec...

From what I can understand a lot of accounts that used to be categorized as M1 are now categorized as M2.

M1 is a component of M2. So to get a better understanding of the real impact we should look at how M2 has changed: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2NS

The increase in M2 is around 25%.

Still pretty substantial and it looks to be way beyond the historical norm, so I think we should be concerned.

But maybe we should re-calibrate our concern by an order of magnitude.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by bryanlarsen on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:23AM (#26251680)
The standard mechanism for controlling inflation is to increase interest rates. Interest rates are currently at essentially zero, so it seems to me that this is a complete non-issue. If inflation starts to become problematic the fed will increase interest rates and we'll return to a more "normal" economic state.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by Sargos on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:28AM (#26251776)
This ignores all of the evidence that raising interest rates slows economic activity. In our currently economically weakened state raising interest rates would likely crush the economy into a depression.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by bryanlarsen on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:34AM (#26251863)
Which is probably the reason we don't currently have core inflation. If we had inflation then it would be evidence the economy is overheated, so cooling the economy would be appropriate at that time.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by anewaccount2021 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:26AM (#26251737)
No, debt levels are too high. Raise rates and you crush borrowers who are already saturated with debt and cannot absorb variable rates rising. The Fed is trapped.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by BenoitEssiambre on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:34AM (#26251856)
I mean, this is totally reversible and is mostly caused by hitting the zero lower bound. Consider that money is put into circulation by the fed buying safe assets. They can sell these assets to reverse this.

Not that there isn't any danger. Even better would have been if the Fed was ok going into negative rates (like the ECB did a few years ago). They wouldn't have had to create so much money. People, businesses and banks are just hording government money instead of private assets because it offers above market returns of 0% while marginal safe assets on the private markets have had negative returns (on a risk adjusted, liquidity adjusted basis). With sufficiently negative Fed rates more in line with the markets, people would have kept their assets instead of hoarding government paper and the Fed wouldn't have needed to print so much.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by CyberRabbi on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:25AM (#26251712)
Changes in the money supply don’t alone cause crisis. There might be some transient non-linear effects to certain sectors of the economy, which can be dangerous, but if done slow enough usually aren’t. In steady state money supply (and inflation) matters very little to how the economy functions.

What matters more is the functional status / size of the economy. If the economy ceases to function then you should be alarmed. Of course the economy has been damaged during the past year but to what extent is not still fully known and is not easily gleanable from changes in the money supply.

Politicians go very wrong with this when they assume that pumping the money supply has a causal effect on the economy. At small scales it can but generally it doesn’t. You can throw millions of dollars at a pig, it will never be able write software for FAANG.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by nrmitchi on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:14AM (#26251519)
I'm pretty sure that taxation is the way to collect and "recapture" those printed dollars.

They were printed in order to be spent and "stimulate" the economy, not make already rich people look richer on paper.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by fullshark on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:25AM (#26251718)
Well they were printed mostly to stop rich people from defaulting on loans, keep companies alive for the and keep them paying their workers etc. So the fed may have very well succeeded there (we don't have the counterfactual, no fed intervention would have likely been not good though). Possibly it was overkill and taxation -> wealth transfer to poorer people makes sense though.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by asmos7 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:18AM (#26251597)
All depends. We increased the supply of money creating downward pressure on the purchasing power of the dollar e.g. inflation but those effects are being countered by decreased consumer demand keeping prices low and less job opportunities again leading to decreased demand for consumer goods. Most likely want to see heavy inflation till we get back to a more "normal" way of life. Keep in mind some inflation is healthy, roughly 3%.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by CyberRabbi on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:41AM (#26251994)
There isn’t decreased demand for basic goods like food, so there is no countering effect in those markets. Sure the cost of flat screens and nikes may be stable.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by QuesnayJr on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:21AM (#26251645)
The Fed prints money and uses it to buy bonds. It can reverse this by selling the bonds, and destroying the money. (Of course, most of this "money" exists electronically.)

The bonds themselves pay interest to the Fed (which will take money out of circulation). Even if the Fed does nothing, the whole thing will reverse itself when the bond reaches maturity, and the principal is paid to the Fed.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by clint on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:10AM (#26251457)
Take it from the rich people who have primarily hoarded all that money, and give it to poor people who are on the brink of death.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by Tuna-Fish on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:20AM (#26251636)
> Take it from the rich people who have primarily hoarded all that money

That's not how any of this works. Rich people generally have much less of their assets as cash or cash-equivalent than poor people. They also in general have much more debt than poor people, both in absolute values and as proportion of their net worth. (Simply because they are able to take more debt, and with the neverending low interest rates, taking more debt and investing it is basically free money.)

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by core-questions on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:48AM (#26252096)
Doesn't the "hoarding money" thing only even apply if you keep your money as literal physical cash in your mattress?

If it's in a bank account, it's being lent out and is working, no?

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by mypalmike on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:52AM (#26252172)
Aside from primary home ownership, do wealthy individuals generally borrow money in order to invest it? My financial advisors have never suggested such a strategy.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by stainforth on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:21PM (#26252641)
Those assets can be converted to cash then and redistributed.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by hpoe on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:12AM (#26251488)
That doesn't suddenly change the amount of stuff there is to buy though.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by hanniabu on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:17AM (#26251578)
No but it makes it more affordable, which increases spending, which improves the economy, which combats inflation. Or maybe we should continue the "trickle down economy" that has worked so, so well.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by ars on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:28AM (#26251771)
More people buying things makes them less affordable, not more. (At least until supply adjusts.)

I'm not understanding your logic - it seems backward to me.

Also we have never actually done "trickle down", it's a bogyman people like to trot out, not something actually done.

Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by lun4r on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:13AM (#26251505)
That surely would be a quick way to turn it all into inflation
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by williamdclt on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:21AM (#26251643)
Not if you "take it" with taxation and "give it" through social programs, I don't think
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by CyberRabbi on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:27AM (#26251756)
If giving it causes the economy to slow down it could have very hazardous effects. The challenge for lawmakers is how do we aid people in need without causing too much harm to the economy.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by pkulak on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:15AM (#26251542)
Only redistribute half of it.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by xhkkffbf on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:17AM (#26251577)
Exactly. If the rich are happy to leave it in a bank account gathering dust, it doesn't affect prices. But when everyone is actively bidding for scarce assets, we get inflation.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by Tuna-Fish on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:21AM (#26251641)
Rich people don't have tons of money sitting in bank accounts gathering dust.
Re:Money Creation: 344% in the Last 12mo (Fed, M1, $) by reedjosh on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @11:36AM (#26251905)
No, they just have it in gold, stocks, real estate, art, etc... all of which probably doesn't gather much dust--maybe the gold, but if you can afford art, you can probably afford someone to clean it.

I also agree that they have debt for that as well. No reason not to use debt to gain real assets when the fiat debt loses value regularly.