News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by qeternity on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:20PM (#26244905)
Classic. People like floating rates when rates are low. News at 10.

It will be interesting to see how the courts treat this. She’s suing over price gouging, which is a grey area anyway, but seems very difficult to prove when the grid was on the verge of collapse. Power prices are volatile because it’s (for all intents and purposes) an immediately perishable good.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by elihu on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:30PM (#26244992)
Griddy's take according to the article is that the per-kilowatt-hour price was set arbitrarily by a political appointee. If the price were set by real-time auctions, that would be one thing, but if someone arbitrarily sets the price at $9 per kilowatt hour, it's not unreasonable that some people are going to be very angry about it.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by sandworm101 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:36PM (#26245047)
Auctions would only make sense if those buying the power participated. If i knew that turning on my computer would cost 100/hour i would keep it off. But if i have no idea what the current market price actually is, i cannot make a rational choice. These people had no idea what they were buying until the bill came in the mail/email. This is precicely the sort of area for consumer protection laws.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by elihu on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:52PM (#26245203)
I agree that utility bills without upper bounds is a thing that should be covered by consumer protection laws.

My point was more that the $9 per kilowatt hour wasn't even set by extreme market conditions; rather, it was an arbitrary number that someone made up (if Griddy's take is accurate).

Individual people wouldn't participate in a power auction; that's supposedly what Griddy does on their customer's behalf and just sends them a bill for whatever the costs were.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gizmo686 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:01PM (#26245267)
It is a number set by Texas law as the maximum price of electricity [0]. The arguement that the commision used to justify staying with the maximum price seems straightforward:

> At various times today, energy prices across the system have been as low as approximately $1,200. The Commission believes this outcome is inconsistent with the fundamental design of the ERCOT market. Energy prices should reflect scarcity of the supply. If customer load is being shed, scarcity is at its maximum, and the market price for the energy needed to serve that load should also be at its highest.

[0] Actually, there are 2 maximum prices, and $9/PWh is supposed to be the greater of them. Due to the high price of natural gas, the "lower" maximum turned out to be more expensive, to the commission waved the rule that would have switch to using the other maximum.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:46PM (#26245148)
> But if i have no idea what the current market price actually is, i cannot make a rational choice.

It doesn't seem that hard to make an IOT electricity price display.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by cameldrv on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @12:35AM (#26246942)
Griddy has an app that shows the price, and they were sending out email alerts at least, maybe more -- I am not a customer of theirs.

The price system could have actually led to a better outcome here. If all the electric customers in Texas knew about the huge price spike, and actionable information like "You have electric heat, so if you heat normally, it will cost you $3000/day", many would have turned down their thermostats to the absolute minimum tolerable level, some would have fired up generators, and some would have shut things down and stayed with someone else. If everyone had been faced with that choice, there probably would not have been a need for the blackouts at all, and the price would have come down to a high, but less outrageous level. As it was, the supply was constrained, and the demand was essentially inelastic, because people didn't have any real incentive to radically conserve, since they weren't paying the wholesale rates.

Now that said, I'm not sure this is really a good idea after all. There are so many things that I'm supposed to be optimizing these days, I just don't have the bandwidth to think about all of them. I really am not interested in planning when I do the laundry or set the thermostat based on what is happening with the electrical grid. I'd much rather just pay somewhat of a premium for the grid to be overprovisioned like it used to be and not have to worry about any of this crap.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by saghm on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:51PM (#26245195)
If you decided not to pay for the power when you saw the price was high, wouldn't it turn off? How would you know when the price was low enough to turn back on?
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by wmf on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:10PM (#26245354)
The price isn't transmitted over the power lines; you use an app to check prices over the Internet.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by saghm on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @03:56PM (#26255757)
An app on your phone? Why would that need to be IoT like the person I responded to said?
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by wmf on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @04:24PM (#26256200)
IoT has no meaning so I ignored that part.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by saghm on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:53PM (#26268818)
Ah, that was the specific part I was responding to in my original comment
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:57PM (#26245239)
batteries? amazon used to sell kindles with 3g connection, which had battery life of "up to 8 weeks". It's not too hard to imagine a similar device with battery life of a week at least.

text alerts would also work.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by shalmanese on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:06PM (#26245329)
What happens if the cell towers are down? As can often happen during a power emergency.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:17PM (#26245409)
The person can make their own decision. It's balmy outside and the cell connection cuts out? Probably a network issue or terrorist attack, neither of which should affect electricity prices. On the other hand if it's been unusually cold for the past week and it cuts out, you probably should keep an eye on your electricity usage. Although in extreme weather events it's usually the electricity that goes out first, not the cell connection, because the latter tends to have battery backups.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by wmf on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:12PM (#26245373)
If the free market had been allowed to do its work the price would have been even higher than $9,000.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by 93po on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:29PM (#26244979)
I cannot believe you're blaming someone for not reading the million pages of fine print and not completely understanding the ramifications of a situation where your power is shut off for days with freezing temperatures, no water, no heat, sometimes no gas, and risking thousands of dollars of damage to your home with freezing pipes.

Please have compassion. I need to take a break from this site, these comments make me sick sometimes

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by qeternity on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:34PM (#26245025)
It’s literally the point of Griddy. It’s not the fine print. It’s the whole damn product.

She was happy to take lower rates 99.9% of the time. She can’t cry foul the 0.1% of the time when the trade goes against her.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by spankalee on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:45PM (#26245141)
Look at their home page. The emphasis is on paying wholesale meaning no markup.

The word "risk" does not appear on the front page.

There's a hidden tab where they downplay the risk of spikes by saying $1 happens less than < 0.1% of the time and there's no bucket near the $9 that it cost last week.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by hellomyguys on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:45PM (#26245135)
>She can’t cry foul the 0.1% of the time when the trade goes against her.

If you're a person completely devoid of empathy, yes that is a fine perspective.

We all know what happened here is that Texas politicians deregulated the power system in a way that allowed for people to be taken advantage of. Your ire shouldn't go towards this woman who is probably doing this as a last resort, but to the politicians who sold out a public utility and any investment in the electric grid for the public good so a few people could profit.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by qeternity on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:50PM (#26245184)
Griddy has 29k customers. There are millions of other Texans paying higher fixed rates who did not get screwed here.

This is not about deregulation. This is about someone taking a risk that didn’t work out, and trying to get a court to fix it for her.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gizmo686 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:06PM (#26245326)
The deregulation is allowing the retail consumers direct access to the wholesale market. The product that Griddy was selling is not something that should be legal to sell to normal consumers.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by chomp on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:23PM (#26245462)
Why not? I’m a happy Griddy customer. They provide an API and I have my stuff set to progressively shut down once the price gets over 50 cents/kWh. I’ve saved about $5000 total just being smart about my usage. In short, I like the product, I’m more eco minded as it reduces my usage in times of demand, and it rewards my good behavior.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by syshum on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:27PM (#26268551)
Well we did just have a congressional hearing where it was suggested that people should be able to get refunds on their stock purchases for 30 or 60 days so.....

It seems people have seen the "Socialize the losses" that the government has been doing in many industries and instead of recognizing it as corruptions and advocating its elimination they say "I gotta get me some of that"

Of course that is a game of musical chairs and when the music stops the dollar will be worth less than toilet paper but.....

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:35PM (#26245031)
>I cannot believe you're blaming someone for not reading the million pages of fine print and not completely understanding the ramifications of a situation where your power is shut off for days with freezing temperatures, no water, no heat, sometimes no gas, and risking thousands of dollars of damage to your home with freezing pipes.

how is it any different than being overleveraged in the stock market, and when the crash comes you end up losing your life savings and your job?

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by mrzimmerman on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:41PM (#26245094)
You actually compare having electricity supplied to your home with over leveraging in the stock market? Literally the most bizarre comparison.

She wasn't running a bitcoin farm out of her house or anything, she was just doing normal day-to-day living.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:51PM (#26245192)
> You actually compare having electricity supplied to your home with over leveraging in the stock market? Literally the most bizarre comparison.

In the default state (regular electricity provider, no investments), you're relatively insulated from price fluctuations. You can make the choice to gain exposure to various markets by various ways, buying stocks, buying futures, buying/writing options, etc. By doing so, you can earn some profit, but you're also exposed to risk. What I'm arguing is that there's nothing fundamentally different between the two because in both cases you're making the decision to be exposed to a market in exchange for profits.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by teachrdan on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:42PM (#26245099)
The difference is that most people don't actively invest in the stock market. Everyone depends on access to electricity.

Signing a contract for a utility shouldn't be equivalent to investing in a high risk financial instrument.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:45PM (#26245136)
>Signing a contract for a utility shouldn't be equivalent to investing in a high risk financial instrument.

Why not? You willingly chose to expose yourself to it. You wanted to pick up pennies in front of a steamroller and got burned. It's the same whether you're doing it with stocks or commodities. To modify my original analogy a bit, it's like someone who was overleveraged in commodity futures (think corn, hog, and oil futures, all essential to survival), and got wiped out in a recession.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by spankalee on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:47PM (#26245160)
There are regulations that prevent brokers from allowing most customers to become over-leveraged.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by chickenpotpie on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:39PM (#26245075)
I don’t have to participate in the stock market to stop my children from freezing to death
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:42PM (#26245105)
You don't have to participate in the energy market either. She willingly chose to. To modify my original analogy a bit, it's like someone who was overleveraged in commodity futures (think corn, hog, and oil futures, all essential to survival), and got wiped out in a recession.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by chickenpotpie on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:48PM (#26245173)
She’s not buying commodities or stocks or bonds. She was purchasing electricity to not freeze to death and the electric company said “sorry about the emergency we caused by not winter proofing, that’ll be $10,000.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:55PM (#26245224)
Being enrolled with a regular electricity provider essentially provides you with an financial instrument in the form of electricity futures. That is, a contract that allows you to buy electricity at a fixed rate, regardless of what the market rate is. Signing up with griddy is essentially the same as selling electricity futures, which exposes you to price fluctuations. In that manner there's nothing different between signing up for griddy, electricty prices rising, and getting wiped out; and selling oil futures, oil prices rising, and getting wiped out.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by dont__panic on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:50PM (#26245185)
Someone comes to you with an offer to buy avocados for far below standard rates, something like 2 cents per avocados on average. It comes with a catch, though: the rates differ from day to day depending on demand. This someone tells you that this is possible through the magic of wholesale pricing. So some days the avocados are 1 cent and other days the avocados spike up to 5 cents. One day you check, and due to an avocado shortage the avocados cost $500 each. Except you just made an order for a giant bowl of guacamole you were going to share with your friends while you watch the super bowl.

Can you sue the avocado provider for these rates? To me, it doesn't seem like it's out of the realm of reasonable given the money you've saved in the past through this provider.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gizmo686 on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:44PM (#26245127)
I don't see the grey area in this particular suit. Texas law clearly allows selling electricity at a price of $9/KWh:

> (B) The high system-wide offer cap (HCAP) will be $9,000 per MWh and $9,000 per MW per hour. [0]

Thanks to the article for linking the order [1] which in turn cited the specific law. Also, it points out that the law actually allowed for an even higher price, as the "low system-wide offer cap" turned out to be greater than the "high system-wide offer cap". The public utility commission therefore elected to grant an exemption to allow continued use of the (cheaper) high system-wide offer cap.

If you, somehow, get past the fact that this price is literally and explicitly anticipated, allowed, and set by Texas law; and you assume that someone is guilty of price gouging, then you have an interesting question of what liability Griddy has.

[0] http://txrules.elaws.us/rule/title16_chapter25_sec.25.505

[] http://www.puc.texas.gov/51617WinterERCOTOrder.pdf

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by qeternity on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:48PM (#26245171)
I mean price gouging is a grey area of law. It’s dependent on there being an emergency and then the prickly question of what price is illegal vs just responding to supply/demand.

But I agree with you. This is going to be interesting. It should get dismissed but I have a feeling it won’t and that an overzealous judge will want to make a point about ERCOT.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by munk-a on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:25PM (#26244943)
I wonder how much money she saved on an average bill - 10k is a lot of money, but if she's been getting advantageous rates for years and years this might not even put her into the red overall.
Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by gruez on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:40PM (#26245083)
https://web.archive.org/web/20201201084406/https://www.gridd...

they claim an average savings of around $600 per year. So if this is a once-every-16-years event then she'll come out on top, on average.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by DavidPeiffer on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:37PM (#26245058)
"...if she's been getting advantageous rates for years and years this might not even put her into the red overall."

I agree on a whole, but this doesn't align with the day to day reality for many people with these huge bills. With a large percent of the country unable to pay an unexpected $400 bill and living paycheck to paycheck, they won't have the long-term net savings there ready for a time like this. Instead they're in a sudden financial bind roughly equivalent to crashing a car and having it not covered by insurance.

People are really bad at understanding low probability events. People had never seen prices in that realm before. Multiply the two, and here we are.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by munk-a on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:21PM (#26245443)
This is pretty much precisely why I'm socialist leaning - it's much easier to force regular savings in the government than to expect people to independently manage their finances in a responsible manner. And everyone from the poorest to the richest is occasionally bankrupted by a sudden unexpected hurricane.

I understand the red scare left people thinking that any kind of socialism will instantly turn into bread lines but I think that allowing more government oversight to make sure those who are left shafted by the tribulations of life get some assistance is the only real ethical choice.

Re:Woman who received $9,300 electric bill sues wholesale el... by qeternity on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:28PM (#26244967)
She won’t see it this way and neither will the pitchfork equipped public.

Even if it puts her in the red, I hope the courts don’t succumb to the populism.