News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Process Is Not the Product. The New Agile Anti-Manifesto by stunt on Saturday February 20, 2021 @11:44AM (#26205491)
Agile works but where companies fail miserably is the implementation. Especially many of those that go with Scrum (or its flavors). They treat Scrum Master as a person instead of a role within the team. So they assign a non-engineer to an engineering team permanently that has some influence on the way of working without ever guiding the team to be self managed agile team.
Re:The Process Is Not the Product. The New Agile Anti-Manifesto by Viliam1234 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:39PM (#26206065)
Most companies implement ScrumBut https://www.scrum.org/resources/what-scrumbut

For example: Scrum, but retrospectives are a waste of time so we don't do them here (or keep them as short as possible, because no one cares about your feedback anyway); and you can estimate the story points, but the management has already decided that the deadline for these features is one month, so your choice is really which ones you want to implement during the first two weeks, and which ones during the second two weeks, now go ahead and do your little Scrum poker ritual.

Meanwhile, on the Scrum training they tell you that the retrospective is the most important part of the Scrum; that everything else can be dropped if necessary but you must keep the retrospective at all cost. Then you get the certificate, and then the management tells you "that's nice, but we do it differently here".

Management wants the buzzwords, and perhaps some of the rituals, but not any actual change. You are free to do Scrum, as long as you only select the parts convenient for them, and remove everything inconvenient for them. The same would happen with any other methodology.

Re:The Process Is Not the Product. The New Agile Anti-Manifesto by paulmooreparks on Saturday February 20, 2021 @08:45PM (#26210054)
Agile, and Scrum in particular, is a lot like Communism and faith healing. When it doesn't work, its adherents claim the failure was due to not implementing it correctly or not believing in it enough.
Re:The Process Is Not the Product. The New Agile Anti-Manifesto by lmm on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:06AM (#26212022)
There's no such thing as a process that works when you don't actually follow it. Most critics of Agile are like recipe reviewers: "I ran out of sugar so I substituted goats' milk, and that sounds like a lot of flour so I used half as much. Tasted awful, 1/5."