He also claims he is not alt right, not homophobic, and not racist. So there is that.
Unlike Shapiro however you will be unlikely to find any overtly bigoted content scrolling through my public commentary.
I will forever be a work in progress when it comes to extending my privileges to others to stop the cycle. I would rather commit to the mindset that I am always a little bit unconcioisly bigoted and contributing to the problem than thinking I have reached some plateau of perfect ethically balanced harmony with others. My male blood relatives all have confederate flag tattoos, and boldly claim they are not racist in spite of openly admitting they only trust other white people.
I try to never let myself reach the denial stage anymore. It is a trap.
I think you should focus on yourself. Like I said, I don't know what's going on in your heart-of-hearts, but you do, and you see hate for others in there. I don't understand why you're like that. That's something you need to work on before you project what's inside you onto others. And let me tell you: The hate you feel for others not like you, is not normal.
>On my worst day I was white, cis, male, straight, and healthy.
Outside of health, who says those are the most important characteristics? What Scientific peer-review data says that?
None of those things intrinsically confer benefits. A poor white kid from a broken home isn't going to get any benefits in life just because he's white.
It's such an evil thing that is done where you single out children of a specific race who come, for example, from poverty and say to them: you're privileged because you're white.
What a terrible and evil philosophy you follow.
Study after study shows that success in life in modern democracies are dominated by factors other than things like race and gender. Things like:
- Height
- Attractiveness
- Age
- Immigration status
- Sense of Humor
- Verbal skill.
- Ingenuity
- Leadership qualities
- Sociability
- Upbringing
- Class status
- Imagination
- Cleverness
- Intelligence
- Education
- Athletic ability
all provide their own benefits and privileges. Many of those things I listed are a product of genetics and environment. I didn't choose to come to this country as 10 year old with parents who had no education, and 0 English, who then worked multiple blue-collar jobs, to then have you and others like you just see nothing but my skin color and say that everything was handed to me and my family because YOU had easy in life. Thanks but no thanks. And of course, the idea that only certain kinds of race or certain kinds of gender provide a benefit in very situation is insanity.
So please, you and I may share skin color hue but we are nothing alike and you don't know anything about me, so stop pretending you do.
I do think I am sometimes ignorant and am unintentionally offensive and am in need of correction. Sometimes bigotry is baked into our very language and social norms but doesn't nessesarily have hate attached. I also think my lifestyle and sometimes laziness likely contributes to making the lives of others harder and I think a lot about how to set that right.
Also yes, in some of the very racist small towns I grew up in, I got jobs because I spoke good English and because I was white, while others that worked harder didn't.
I even literally had an ex tell me a motivator for dating me was because her parents didn't approve of her ex because he was black.
That sort of thing is pretty messed up, but not being a part of any oppressed groups gave me priority treatment sometimes without question.
This was especially apparent when I would go to court for traffic tickets and get off scot-free every time while black and Latino people in front of me would get the book thrown at them for offenses more minor than mine. Many studies have shown black people get harsher sentences on average and I have certainly seen evidence of this.
I don't think white people -should- have an advantage and I agree it is evil that they do, but dominant racism in our country creates that advantage.
Also I never once made any statements or assumptions about you however you keep making them about me, like assuming I had an easy life. Not sure why.
If the left orthodoxy means treating people equally, sign me up.
> very smart
This is the guy who endorsed Trump in October 2020 for another four year term because “he’s already done all the damage he can, he can’t do anything more”. Genius.
If we all understand that this is actually (under the law) what MOST people want we'll be able to get along.
>What’s valuable about homophobia? What’s intellectually honest about hating people for their sexual orientation and advocating for discrimination against them?
I just started looking this up to write this comment. I was curious about it and I wanted to be as correct as I can. Ben Shapiro believes that contractually, under the law, homosexuality should be allowed. Full Stop. This is a very libertarian perspective. It's the idea that no matter what I personally believe due to my religion, you can and should be able to legally do what you want as long as it doesn't affect others (throwing that in for the abortion argument).
Personally, Ben Shapiro is a homophobe. Politically, he is not. He's pro-equality of opportunity and recognition under the law.
As someone who grew up really religious, I can understand how he justifies this idea. You are indoctrinated to hate the sin and love the sinner. This does not always come out the way it's supposed to, and leads to homophobia which I believe is evil and a reason I left religion. However, this dualism allows for one to strive for political equality, while still spouting homophobic ideas.
This is a very fine line to draw on a topic like this, but I think it's important for us to recognize if we're ever going to get less divided hateful towards each other. Most people, even bigots, racists, homophobes, etc. want equality. They want the government to give them the same rights as anyone else and to be left alone. They want their rallies, protests, sermons, etc. In order to get that they recognize (at least people like Shapiro do) that they need to fight a cultural war instead of a political one on this stuff.
It doesn't mean that those ideas are ok for people to personally have, but it does mean that we can work together to agree on a lot of shit, make progress.
tl;dr; Don't hate people on the other side of politics, talk to them.
Can you provide any evidence he does any of these things?
What % of people on the right would you consider alt-right? What % of people on the left would you consider alt-left?
Not the GP, but the 'alt' prefix to me seems to invoke the similar usage in the term 'alternative' music like Nirvana, Pearl Jam, etc, which were an 'alternative' to pop music from the 80s and 90s. The prefix suggests a change of type and not just a change of degree. They aren't just "more conservative Republicans".
This is why it applies more to the right than the left in today's social discourse, since the spectrum on the left is still more a matter of degree than kind.
In the context of the right, this change of type means abandonment of traditional establishment Republican stances like free trade and foreign interventionism in near totality, and the promotion of previously fringe movements within the right like ethnic nationalism (often under the guise of 'economic nationalism').
I do disagree about a change of type not happening on the left. I see a very large rift developing on the left around whether to honor classically liberal values or not.
I do think the trends in 'alt' usage are predominately aimed at the right as more of a pejorative towards the outgroup, and less of a descriptive term. You can see a snapshot of the vast disparity in usage here: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?geo=US&q=Alt-right,...
If I were to wager a guess, I'd guess that the targets of the term 'alt-right' would rarely accept that description of their politics. Whereas 'right' or 'conservative' or 'social conservative' or similar terms would have a high acceptance rate for those that are being called it. 'Alt' has become a pejorative in everyday use (at least in the liberal circles that I run in).
I am a proponent of aiming for accuracy when trying to describe other people's politics, and being charitable whenever possible.
If I see a group of people using words to describe another group of people in a way that purposely misrepresents them, particularly in a negative way, I think that's something worth calling out.
I don't have the nihilistic take that "if you can't 100% accurately describe something, then it's okay to not even try".
My personal take would be that alt right is a rightwing suberversion of traditional american conservatism. In addition to largely white identity politics, there's also a strong push for anti-establishment, and indifference to traditional norms.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alt-right
> The term is ill-defined, having been used in different ways by various self-described "alt-rightists", media commentators, and academics. Groups which have been identified as alt-right also espouse white supremacism, white separatism, right-wing populism, anti-immigration, racism, anti-communism, anti-Zionism, antisemitism, Holocaust denial, xenophobia, anti-intellectualism, antifeminism, homophobia, and Islamophobia.
The core underlying theme is that 'alt' gets used as a pejorative towards your outgroup. Your descriptions of the right here are quite uncharitable, which is a strong signal of your biased thinking.
You also conveniently didn't answer my question about % of the right you'd classify as 'alt-right' and the % of the left that you'd classify as 'alt-left'. I suspect the reason you chose not to is because of that same bias. It would make clear that you use 'alt' as a pejorative selectively towards your outgroup.
You lack perspective.
Sounds like a classic case of the "flat-earth society that has members all around the globe".
In any case, it doesn't get much more fact free and hypocritical than that.
What the hell is alt-right anyways? As in, what are the fundamental principles of its ideology?
I think he has apologised for that one but it still shows some genuine racism.
Do you take into account any counter-evidence when making such a deduction?