The arctic is warming much faster that the rest of the planet, so these events will probably become much more common. Other sorts of extreme weather events are also going to become more common with climate change
Some explainers on the polar vortex: https://www.carbonbrief.org/qa-how-is-arctic-warming-linked-...
https://blogs.ei.columbia.edu/2012/03/07/climate-change-may-...
The slowing of the jet stream, therefore, could cause weather patterns to remain in place for longer, resulting in prolonged heat waves or cold snaps.
Also in what sense is it supposed to be a "destabilizing event"? I predict it will get warm again.
The destabilizing event which is the change in air circulation patterns related to the poles is here to stay.
Not everything is as big of a crisis as your Facebook posts make out.
A few days without power... big woop. The power goes down longer in most coastal cities every summer during hurricane season. Not to mention the usual outages of a day or two due to tornados and ordinary storms. And the cold? Who cares? Kids are playing in the snow, most everyone in my neighborhood had been grilling out, if it’s been a wake-up call for anything, it would be to maybe buy a quieter diesel generator.
Jesus H... can’t we have a winter storm any more without using it as grist for ideological arguments?
It will be 70f in a few more days. All this will be forgotten.
As for "no big deal", I don't know what else to say other than 15 people have already died. When it's below freezing and people are without heat, they will freeze to death. Not to mention people who have medical equipment they need to stay alive that requires electricity.
Many areas see this temperate every year and they're prepared for it. It's not the same thing in Texas.
This is a black swan event -- this is the coldest it's been in over 100 years.
edit: to be clear about what I'm claiming, I'm saying that if Texas invested in coal instead of making the large investments they made in solar and wind, this never would have happened. I don't see how anyone can dispute that. This is not the time to be gloating about green energy.
While everyone else is taking you to the woodshed for the rest of the comment, I'd like to take a moment to address this, because I think it's a misunderstanding of the term and a misreading of the book.
The point of "Black Swans" was that an over-reliance on standard distributions derived from historical data generates predictions and confidence intervals that misrepresent the underlying phenomenon by assuming away "fat tails" and ignoring changing circumstances. If there's not some good reason why an event can't happen, any forecast or plan which precludes that event is necessarily flawed.
To describe this as a "black swan" event assumes nobody could've seen it coming, there was no reason to suspect it would happen, and it's unlikely to happen again. All of those are false. Every bit of climate forecasting over the last ~decades has pointed towards increased weather variability and increased likelihood of extreme weather events. Specific to this case, increasing the overall energy levels in the atmosphere increases the variability of the polar jet stream and increases the likelihood of polar vortex events like the one Texas is currently experiencing.
So, no, this wasn't a "black swan" event, this was a predictable - and predicted - outcome of climate change, which is a predictable outcome of burning as much coal and carbon-based fuels as we have over the last couple generations.
And then it happened again in February 2011, for almost exactly the same reasons, despite the weather not being quite as severe.
https://www.nerc.com/pa/rrm/ea/February%202011%20Southwest%2...
This is unprecedented in the modern era. Statewide load on the grid, for this time of year, is unreasonably high. Black swan.
So yeah, it happens. Not often, but at least a half dozen times in living memory
Yeah, but you did not say that.
You said:
> It gets below freezing every year in Texas. But in the biggest city in Texas -- Houston, with a metro population of 7 million, it does not. This is unprecedented in the modern era.
If you want to change that to say "this is an unusually long and wide freeze across the entire state", or "this is an unprecedented power outage" that's arguably true. But you didn't actually say that, you said that freezing temps in Houston were unprecedented, which is objectively not true.
Heck, a long freeze knocking off the Texan power grid isn't even unprecedented in this century. A similar thing happened back in 2011[0].
0 - https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ercot-rollingblackouts/te...
That’s an outright lie. The vast majority of the missing production is in fossil plants.
Wind only accounts for about 20% of nameplate capacity, and has been performing above expectations for the period. And that’s with Texan wind being as un-weatherised at the rest (hint: when wind turbines work just fine in Montana or Washington State, if they freeze over it’s not because they’re wind turbines).
> if Texas invested in coal instead of making the large investments they made in solar and wind, this never would have happened.
If they invested that money in coal and failed to winterise it in the same way they failed to winterise the other plants then there would be absolutely zero difference.
This is kind of a meta point and probably sounds patronising, but you’ve just said a bunch of stuff that’s flat out wrong. It’s time to start questioning your information diet. Where are you being fed disinformation from? What can you do to diversify your sources of news?
If I remember the statistics correctly, there is more coal power offline right now than wind power offline. If that is true, that rather debunks your theory, doesn't it?
All I'm really arguing is that non-renewables are able to accommodate bursty and unpredictable demand much better than renewables. For every dollar spent on solar and wind, if that built X amount of coal or NG plants, they would have such an excess of capacity that the few plants that have gone offline would be completely irrelevant.
My point isn't that Texas shouldn't have invested in renewables. It's just that this is really not an appropriate time to be lecturing Texas about renewable energy, because had they invested their money in non-renewables instead of renewables, they would likely not be in this situation.
The problem is not a lack of regulation. It gets below freezing every single year in Texas. The problem is that it doesn't get this cold in Houston every year, and they misjudged demand.
With the exception of natural gas (where some plants shut down to allow the pipeline capacity go to people who heat their homes with natural gas instead), the primary driver of the lack of capacity appears to be a failure to winterize for what is objectively a pretty rare situation, combined with an unwillingness to draw the power from those places where production isn't so heavily impacted by the weather.
You do realize that all of this is happening because a bunch of non-renewable power plants failed, right? You're making an argument that's literally countermanded by the exact situation we're discussing.
2) This might be a black swan event, but we've seeing a lot of "once in a 100/500 year" weather events in the last decade. Which is exactly what climate scientists predicted would happen if we continued ignoring climate change.
3) and as everyone else said, the fossil fuel plants are also offline.
Even nuclear went down due to frozen pumps.
And how is more coal the solution when these kinds of event will just become more common with global climate change?
Should we not push for changes which halts the ongoing climate change?
That doesn't sound at all like a potential disaster. Presumably the emergency cooling pumps didn't freeze.
This is technically true, but kind of irrelevant to the big picture. Solar beat expectations, which is great until you realize how little it was expected to produce in the first place. Solar and wind do not scale to demand as well as non-renewables.
And look, I'm not saying that Texas should have invested in coal, I'm saying that it's tone deaf to admonish them for not embracing green energy when they did embrace green energy pretty strongly, and when their lack of capacity currently is mostly about their lack of production in renewables.
The core problem is that you can almost always burn more coal or NG and get more juice out of the coal and NG plants. But you can't make the wind go faster, and you can't make the sun shine brighter or longer. Had they invested in an abundance of non-renewables, people would not be freezing in their dark homes right now. It's not Texas fault, proponents of green energy need to have a better answer for this.