News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by cortesoft on Monday February 15, 2021 @02:53PM (#26146505)
The ‘defense’ is the first amendment. It would violate it if you prevented people from telling other people about their products.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by heymijo on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:19PM (#26146821)
When was the last time you saw a cigarette ad on TV?

Commercial speech in the United States has limitations. Historically commercial speech was not protected by the 1st amendment. Protections and limitations have largely been established over the past 50 years in Supreme Court rulings [0].

[0] https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/939/corporate-speec...

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by tzs on Monday February 15, 2021 @08:24PM (#26149894)
The comparison to cigarettes isn't very convincing. To legally justify a of regulation of commercial speech, the government must show that it is to directly advance a substantial government interest and it is no more extensive than is necessary to serve that interest.

Cigarettes physically harm pretty much all of their users, and they are very addicting leading to psychological and financial harm to a large number of users too, and they are available over the counter with no more than an age check to try to keep them out of the hands of non-adults.

It's fairly easy to find a substantial government interest in the physical and psychological health of the population, and regulating the spread of something addicting that directly harms that interest directly advances that interest and doesn't seem to be going too far.

Prescription drugs cannot even be sold until the government approves them, and even then they can only be sold if prescribed by a doctor. Those measures should already keep them out of the hands of those who would be harmed by them, so it is hard to see what substantial government interest a TV ad ban would directly further that couldn't be better addressed without restricting speech (e.g., limitation on who doctors can prescribe the drug to).

I'm not saying that it wouldn't be possible to sufficient justify a TV ad ban on prescription drugs. Just that it is not anywhere near as easy as it is for cigarettes.

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by stjohnswarts on Monday February 15, 2021 @11:51PM (#26151057)
It's incredibly convincing given what happened with opiates and the current hundreds of thousands dead from overdoses over the past 20 years or so.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by dawnerd on Monday February 15, 2021 @02:57PM (#26146549)
I've heard another defense that's pretty laughable. Goes something like, the ads tell people about conditions they might have but not realize.

I fully think we should be banning prescription drugs. There's precedent already for banning product ads - tobacco ads are no longer allowed for example.

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by bryan0 on Monday February 15, 2021 @04:19PM (#26147571)
I think the more charitable interpretation of this defense is: Ads tell people about conditions they might have, but not realize there is an available drug that can treat it. Or at least an encouragement to talk to their doctor about it.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by throwawayboise on Monday February 15, 2021 @04:29PM (#26147699)
If your condition isn't bothersome enough that you need an ad to prompt you to mention it to your doctor, perhaps it's not really an issue.

I think a lot of these ads prod hypochondriacs to rush to their doctor (or perhaps even the ER) to "tell them about their symptoms" which just drives up costs for everyone.

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by renewiltord on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @02:47AM (#26151803)
> If your condition isn't bothersome enough that you need an ad to prompt you to mention it to your doctor, perhaps it's not really an issue.

Au contraire, people will live with all sorts of debilitating conditions, assuming that treatment is exceptionally hard.

I lived with an impacted wisdom tooth for a long time, and when it was removed I suddenly realized that it wasn't just a natural way for my body to feel.

I also just assumed that I had to poop explosively in the morning just because, and not because I drank the large cup of milk my mother gave me.

And that's normal. Loads of people are like this.

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by donpott on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @05:11AM (#26152586)
All the more so in a place without socialized health care.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by renewiltord on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @03:55PM (#26158700)
Yeah, in my case, I had access to the health care whenever I wanted. I just never thought to.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by nulbyte on Monday February 15, 2021 @04:14PM (#26147500)
The defenses I've seen are less about free speech and more to the tune of "doctors can't possibly know everything, so you should ask them in case they haven't looked into it." Frankly, if you think a TV advert does a better job at informing you about medical research then your doctor, who spent tons to graduate and more still on continuing education to maintain a license, you probably need new doctor.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by ComputerGuru on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:09PM (#26146698)
I’ve heard that argument and but it really doesn’t stand up to scrutiny. You also have a right to run a business and sell things - such as prescription medication - but that hasn’t stopped the government from (too heavily, imho) restricting that.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by parhamn on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:41PM (#26147048)
The US constitution explicitly grants regulation of commerce to Congress (see the commerce clause). Whereas the constitution explicitly prohibits the abridging of the freedom of speech through law.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by ComputerGuru on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:49PM (#26147157)
Yes, but let's not pretend there's "absolute" freedom of speech even here in the United States. Cigarette manufacturers no longer have "freedom of speech" to advertise their products with anthropomorphized cartoon characters and relaxing artwork depicting tropical getaways, even though their product is more "freely available" than 5mg of Propranolol, but somehow Tofacitinib¹ ("serious side effects may include infections, cancer, and pulmonary embolism") is spammed on every channel.

¹ I have absolutely nothing against what I'm sure is a very fine drug - it was merely the first result in my search for "most advertised prescription medication" and I'm sure that the side effects are not representative of typical outcome and that someone suffering from serious rheumatoid arthritis is better off taking the drug than not.

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by parhamn on Monday February 15, 2021 @04:14PM (#26147501)
> Yes, but let's not pretend there's "absolute" freedom of speech even here in the United States.

This isn't whats happening is it? The exemptions to free speech are well known and taught in entry level civic classes [1]. There are quite a few. Whats happening here is another discussion on the intricacies of free speech (which have hundreds of pages of professional opinion and case law for each exemption) full of nuance. However here, as is the case for most discussion forums, you can only fall into two groups: anarchist or fascist.

Heres a more honest view: given free speech laws in the US it's not clear what we should or what is right to do with regards to advertising medicine. We will probably have a populist exemption when it's needed, as we have in the past.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by ComputerGuru on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:22PM (#26148323)
But that was the point I was trying to make when you first replied to me. It’s freedom of speech to the extent “we” (the people and their representatives) allow, meaning the first amendment isn’t an absolute barrier to preventing the enforcement of a law “for the common good” (and the abuse that automatically entails, cf anything regarding encryption and the prevention of the distribution of child pornography) and it can accordingly make room for outlawing anything from PACs to advertising prescription medication.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by parhamn on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:29PM (#26149073)
Well the nuances lie in what "we" and "common good" are. In fact, the fact that these ads have already not been restricted probably implies the thresholds for "we" and "common good" have not been met. Notably America holds a high standard here for "we" (hyper majorities) and "common good" (severe public threat) when it comes to free speech.

I don't share you confidence that this is very obviously worth another exemption at a federal level, but I do share your concern with misinformation through these sorts of ads.

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by ComputerGuru on Monday February 15, 2021 @08:01PM (#26149766)
Oh, I'm not arguing for restricting any/either of those. Merely pointing out that the common argument against doing so doesn't hold water in the real world that we live in.

In fact, I'd go so far as to say that criminalization tends to only stop law-abiding citizens, have second-order effects that discriminate against those whose needs were not considered by the policy makers at the time, create a hole that's usually filled by another issue/crime, and tend to be far less effective than they were made out to be. Just so my position is clear :)

Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by midasuni on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:30PM (#26149089)
I wonder how many commenters actually watched the video, and the section about freedom of speech and the first ammendment
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @03:22AM (#26151975)
Buying an ad is... commerce.
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by ComputerGuru on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @11:15AM (#26168042)
It’s actually more nuanced than that. The actual buying/selling of the ad is commerce, but the right to spend your money to buy a specific ad is partially first amendment (and partially not).
Re:YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [... by anonymfus on Monday February 15, 2021 @04:32PM (#26147730)
A person exercises their freedom of speech when they say whatever they want. The advertisement is when somebody is paid to say something with implication that they don't want to say that, as otherwise they would not be paid. So advertisement is an opposite of the freedom of speech.

P. S.: I am watching the video and Tom Scott gives a very similar definition of advertisement at 3:44, and basically the whole video is about how that logic is applied in British and American laws.

P. P. S.: I am now at the last section "The Land Of The Free" (24:47) where Tom Scott talks specifically about freedom of speech in US, and basically everything in this thread is brought up by him.