I'm concerned that framing it as "anti-white, anti-male" is understating the problem. We're educating a generation of people to identify strongly with their own race and that society should be racially organized. I don't see how you can do this without getting almost everyone to lobby (socially and politically) on behalf of their own race. Sure, you'll have a few woke white people who are anti-white, but you'll end up creating many more "white identitarians" (for lack of a better term)--which is basically what we're already seeing with the uptick of far right groups. Obviously this is bad for white people and bad for people of color; racism is one of those rare lose-lose scenarios and yet we have a powerful contingent advocating for it (albeit in the guise of equality and justice).
The only way how to square this growing complexity of ethnic mixtures with a rigid racial system is something like "one drop rule" akin to the old South.
Because most people don't give a crap about race. There's a loud vocal minority that shapes the policy nobody cares about.
The loud vocal minority is perfectly capable of building a dystopia if no one has the stones or stomach to oppose them.
Not really. Even White racists had better solutions to that problem better tuned to dealing a complex system of admixture of multiple races (cf, apartheid South África); the “one drop rule” was White racists solution for the narrow circumstance of dividing the world into two categories, White and Nigger, and maximizing the latter in order to maximize the exploitation possible by those who were in the former category. Even strictly hereditary systems by White racists were often more complex and not much like the one-drop rule except that they involved some rule.
I mean, lots of other possibilities open up once you realize that the “races” are effectively ethnic (shared cultural experience) groups shaped by historical categorization based on assumptions of heredity, rather than biological facts with a necessary connection to heredity that can only be defined in strictly hereditary terms. Especially if you get beyond systems created explictly by and for White racial oppression, but, again, even the categorizationn system in apartheid, for all the ill use the categories it produced were put to, reflected that understanding to a much greater degree than the one-drop rule, which also made categorization, while largely rigid, potentially, though rarely, fluid.)
Let's hope we never have to dig this up
There seems to be a parallel thought process and definition of words that the "woke" operate by that are completely different than what is commonly accepted as the definition of a word.
Words like "racist" mean something completely different. Things like "it's impossible to be racist if you are black" and making people feel ashamed of themselves for the skin color they were born with (if they are white).
In the original story, seems like their decision is clearly racist and also sexist but it seems like these definitions are only selectively applied. It seems like "diversity" to them means no white people not having an equal distribution of races. They are doing the very things the are arguing against but it doesn't seem to register. How is this possible?
We simply don't live in the same world and same society. American people struggles are very different from European people struggles, and even inside Europe each country's population have their own personalities, quirks, vastly different history, culture, morale code.
Just look at how the "woke" US medias spinned the anti islamism (pro tip: islam != islamism) laws that were being discussed in France recently. It's almost as if ISIS struggle was compared to African Americans struggle. Some (most?) cultures are just not equipped to deal with other cultures' issues
And even in the same countries, or cities, thanks to social medias and totally biased paper/tv medias it's extremely easy to get sucked in a bubble.
No, they are not 'selectively applied' - in their view.
In 'their version' of 'racist' - they cannot be racist - only White People can, because it's a matter of power. Even if you're only 15%. Get it?
This is one of the 'root causes' - the rhetorical position that The Woke have taken is highlighted in 'White Fragility': White people are all White Supremcists by definition, they are all walking, talking 'root causes' of the problem, and therefore cannot even have any real knowledge of the problem. All they can do is shut-up and try to empathize.
So this is not 'racism is judgment based on race' it's 'racism as White people have power and others don't ergo, they are racist'.
It's a masterful rhetorical technique: your opponents are by definition wrong.
Scientologists do this. They are taught that they are 'clean and clear, essentially above human' and that regular people are 'broken people, like animals' and there's no point in arguing with a dog. Some of their rhetorical techniques are shocking.
That's a great world to live in, right?
It speaks to our worst prejudices. Every day on TikTok I see racist and misandrist content, mostly by White Women and it's not only 'ok' it's pass off as 'enlightened'.
It's a very powerful thing to be able to take ostensibly a moral position, but then to also bigoted at the same time - I feel it's the intellectual parallel to the power that police feel when holding a gun against someone who is 'bad'.
One group can run around wielding their arbitrary moral policing, the other can't speak on the issue and so you have bad public dynamics.
I don't know the answer but Phase 1 I think should be to recognize that irrespective of power, that bigotry is bigotry and actions, headlines, policies etc. that are race based have to be treated with caution, very conservatively (small-c), with deliberation.
I have to disagree with that. My personal impression is that Americans are the most accepting of other people's fortune, so much so they need an excuse before they can attack the rich and powerful, something on the moral plane because riches themselves are not considered a sin.
I wonder if it reflects current brain flow (are American students coming to French university in greater numbers than French students going to the US?).
Maybe the solution is to build an ecosystem where the culture and practices is exported instead of imported.
I never thought of it that way. That being said after 50+ years of Americanisation of Western culture (through movies, music, &c.) it's not really surprising that it flows that way. I think a lot of the American "woke" culture also emerges from things that are very easy to empathise for and trigger an outrage response. For example the George Floyd case which somehow triggered dozens of protests in Europe: no one with a fully formed brain can watch the video and not be outraged.
I also feel like a lot of the American ideas about progressivism are fairly "feel good" measures that are very easily adopted (everyone wants to be upset about something, everyone wants to be themselves/special, &c.) and are all somewhat based on "identity", it feeds the "us vs them" part of the brain very nicely.
In Canada, they would lose their jobs immediately.
I'm not sure who is right in all of this, but I do think that rational discussion ought to be had among the plebes and bureaucracy, and the problem with the more authoritarian woke is that they will destroy anyone who does not agree.
I think one simple, ugly, but useful tactic is to refer to these policies as racist - because in a way they are.
'Racism' is the weaponized term that the crowd will use to try to destroy everything they don't like.
But since their acts are almost entirely racially based, the argument is easily made the term 'racist' applies. Even though they generally would not agree.
Because the shoe fits: making boards or any group hyper-representative based on race is basically racist, so use the word.
The hypocrisy on that one is spectacular.
Basically any other politician in North America would be completely destroyed and cancelled forever.
Ironically, I think public reaction was appropriate - he obviously was not intending malice, it was just a bit inappropriate.
But make no mistake, if that were to have happened to anyone else they would have been destroyed.
I think that public opinion is basically irrelevant, as most people are not really offended by all of this stuff.
But special interest groups, individuals with power, and institutions acting out of caution, and occasionally opportunity (i.e. how can we make money or leverage this scandal?) would be sup-groups to identify and characterize.
He's been caught several times in Blackface and when asked directly about other possible incidents he would not reply. Does that seem transparent and heartfelt?
Everyone who gets caught in Blackface apologizes, and they are usually heartfelt, in the sense that in most cases, there was no malice intended.
He was treated differently because he's the champion of 'one side of a narrative' - and without his figurehead, the movement would be lost as none of the political movements in Canada have any truly popular figures among them.
Given that Trudeau is a champion of progressive causes, and the he, alone among politicians of all stripes was caught doing the most 'visibly offensive thing' (just Google 'Trudeau Blackface' and see the photos) - it really does exemplify the height of hypocrisy.
In this case, the NYT article cited by the PostMillenial article was much more well-balanced with opinions included of multiple French political parties, and if someone wants to read more on this, they should read that article.
They should not read the PostMillenial article, which only mentioned what the French far-right (Le Front National) party & similar political leanings mentioned and they neglected to mention they were only including those points of view.
For an even more concrete example:
From the PM:
> Nathalie Heinich, a French sociologist told The Times, "It was a series of incidents that was extremely traumatic to our community and that all fell under what is called cancel culture," said.
From the NYT:
> “I was pleasantly astonished,’’ said Nathalie Heinich, a sociologist who last month helped create an organization against “decolonialism and identity politics.’’ Made up of established figures, many retired, the group has issued warnings about American-inspired social theories in major publications like Le Point and Le Figaro.
> For Ms. Heinich, last year’s developments came on top of activism that brought foreign disputes over cultural appropriation and blackface to French universities. At the Sorbonne, activists prevented the staging of a play by Aeschylus to protest the wearing of masks and dark makeup by white actors; elsewhere, some well-known speakers were disinvited following student pressure.
> “It was a series of incidents that was extremely traumatic to our community and that all fell under what is called cancel culture,’’ Ms. Heinich said.
Do you see what I mean?
So, would Hong Kong be better of under British rule or Chinese rule?
Even contemporary EU has some quasicolonial attributes: industrial powerhouses like Germany siphon off qualified workforce from the periphery and export their products back without trade barriers.
Two semi-serious responses come to mind:
"Wait, which one?" or "Haiti paid huge reparations to France, isn't that good enough?"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_occupation_of_Ha...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Uphold_Democracy
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Haitian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...
"CARICOM, an organization of Caribbean countries that included Haiti, called for a United Nations investigation into Aristide's removal, but were reportedly pressured by the U.S. and France to drop their request"
Hypocrites. Look at how Asians are targeted in hate crime in France, by both whites and non whites. Covid being called the "China virus" threw oil on this fire.
Here, the issue the school board is that it has only 1 Asian America (10%) for a 33% SFUSD student body.
The way I see it, Asians always get the short end of the stick, for some reason unknown.
In the US, there are anti Asian admission policies in most universities, and somehow we can't make that stop.
Maybe because they are called "equal opportunity" and made to favor other races who can use it to get admitted with a fraction of the SAT (and predictably fail, while other races with higher scores are not even given the chance to compete).
Now we hear France hypocrisy and think it will make this right. People, look at what happens there and tell me to my face you think they got it right and we should emulate them:
https://www.scmp.com/news/world/europe/article/3043079/racis...
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-37720780
I say no. French thinkers would be best to focus on their own problems, and leave us alone.
We have a problem with Asian representation, but so far I have not seen anything I can support.
I fear that if we don't find a way to put a stop to this, anti-white and anti-male discrimination will be fully accepted in the near future, which would be absolutely terrible for our society.
[1] https://thepostmillennial.com/french-leaders-concerned-ameri...