News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by annoyingnoob on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @10:11PM (#26097837)
Larry has an interesting take, especially given the current environment.

"You know, a free press is not freedom for the thought you love, but rather for the thought you hate the most. People need to tolerate the Larry Flynts of the world so they can be free." -Larry Flynt

Re:Larry Flynt has died by eplanit on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @10:51PM (#26098062)
I'm afraid people now see it as an antiquated and outmoded perspective on free speech. His attitude was embraced by progressive people of the late 20th century.

That said, he too had to own his own platform in order to exercise his rights.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by krapp on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @10:57PM (#26098095)
Given how much porn there is on the internet I don't think that many people have an issue with the Larry Flynts of the world.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by bdcravens on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:32AM (#26098569)
Larry Flynt was someone pushing the boundaries of his day, even in the world of pornography (Hustler was more explicit than Playboy, for example). Today's random pornographer is not a "Larry Flynt".

Flynt is more akin to Snowden or Assange, or even Parler, in boldness. (not comparing content, just free speech boldness)

Re:Larry Flynt has died by tinalumfoil on Thursday February 11, 2021 @10:00AM (#26102091)
To say Larry Flynt was politically correct by today's standards is completely false.

Just look at Wikipedia. He called Sandra Day O'Connor "a token cunt". He wore the American flag as a diaper. Hustler regularly published Chester the Molester, a comic strip, even after the author was convicted of molestation (which later got overturned).

Re:Larry Flynt has died by bdcravens on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:42PM (#26104641)
Definitely - not sure if you're responding to me with intention of suggesting it, but I definitely didn't say he was politically correct.

My father had a collection of Hustler from the 70s and 80s that as a teen in the early 90s I sneakily perused; this was definitely the golden age of the magazine's anti-PC speech, with all you mentioned, as well as unveiled racism.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by tinalumfoil on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:19PM (#26106573)
I guess I was reading too much into the "in his day" part. My point was that the world hasn't gotten less sensitive to his attitude and speech. It might have even gotten more sensitive.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by bdcravens on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:31PM (#26106705)
Yes, I was responding to a comment implying his pornography would be considered tame by today's standards (which it would, but you must consider the context of the time).

I agree that his non-pornographic content would be viewed with a very sensitive eye today.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by kenneth on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:02AM (#26098413)
Today the thought people can't bear is no longer porn, it's anything remotely not woke. It's any opinion that even slightly diverges from their own.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by viraptor on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:51AM (#26099565)
This is demonstrably not true - have you been on Twitter? You'll find every extreme represented there. Including accounts/messages not globally removed but marked "illegal in Germany".
Re:Larry Flynt has died by pjmlp on Thursday February 11, 2021 @04:11AM (#26099667)
We don't have any issue with pornography though, just with people that pretend the holocaust are a pile of lies that never happened.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by camjohnson26 on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:26AM (#26098534)
I’m not sure a minimum wage is a good idea.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by stonogo on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:13AM (#26099360)
So we keep hearing, ad infinitum, on every single platform open to public comment. It's amusing.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by igorkraw on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:29AM (#26099448)
While shutting down any idea that is not 100% aligned in their own platforms. But it's okay, I believe safe spaces are important
Re:Larry Flynt has died by camjohnson26 on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:27AM (#26098538)
I don’t think Trump is a racist.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by mariuolo on Thursday February 11, 2021 @01:52AM (#26098958)
A nice experiment:)
Re:Larry Flynt has died by aikinai on Thursday February 11, 2021 @02:50AM (#26099252)
Not really. Downvotes are specifically intended for comments that don't contribute to the discussion, so downvoting these wouldn't indicate disagreement or censorship.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by Const-me on Thursday February 11, 2021 @04:26AM (#26099735)
Doesn't matter what they are intended for. What matters is reality.

Based on my observations, quite a few people on this web site use downvotes to indicate disagreement or dislike. Many of them appear to hate Trump.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by malandrew on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:06AM (#26099323)
I felt like it contributed as it demonstrated the intended thought in a self-referential way.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by igorkraw on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:27AM (#26099439)
You know there's a difference between Larry flint not being legally allowed to peddle smut, do satire etc. and people telling you they don't like your opinion and not giving you a platform, organising boycotts etc?

Also, I assume you are completely offended by fox news,OANN etc. lack of progressive voices? I agree, conservative media should open themselves up to platform more leftwing ideas in order to ensure diversity of thought. Similarly to the conservative subreddit, which is enforcing its groupthink the same way the literal communist subreddit is.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by mbg721 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:50PM (#26098363)
Not anymore, but it was a huge deal a few decades ago. Not that porn was ever lacking an audience, but openly accepting it as okay for polite society was a much less popular opinion in the 80s than it is now.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by eyelidlessness on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:00PM (#26098109)
I don’t understand what’s wrong with owning your platform to exercise your speech rights. You still have a public square. It’s as free as it’s been since Flynt was a prominent figure. (I’m happy to talk about how unfree it can be from experience, but it hasn’t gotten worse especially for the people most up in arms about platform access.)

Instead of being constantly on the defense here... Why do you think you have a right to someone else’s resources for your speech? What entitles you to be published by anyone else at all?

Re:Larry Flynt has died by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:04PM (#26098141)
> "I don’t understand what’s wrong with owning your platform to exercise your speech rights."

MLK and the civil rights movement didn't own their own platform.

The LGBT rights movement didn't own their own platform.

The women's rights movement didn't own their own platform.

Would you have been okay with them being swept under the rug? It's not as if people in power didn't want to.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by AdamJacobMuller on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:24PM (#26098238)
The bigger problem is "define platform"

Don't like twitter censorship, make your own twitter.

Ergo, Parler.

Oh, but, that's not "your" platform, that's built on AWS's platform. So AWS can deplatform you.

What's next, if Parler sets up in a datacenter with their own physical servers are people going to attack their colocation/transit/peers or their DNS provider or their domain registrar or their SSL certificate issuer? Is LetsEncrypt a platform?

The biggest issue IMO is that with this you're centralizing all the idiotic and dangerous opinions and putting them in a huge echo chamber where they only ever see (mostly stupid) opinions of people they agree with. It's accomplishing the some of the goal the de-platformers want (they don't want to see the dumb content) but the content is still there, just more fringe and more radical and now they can rightfully complain about suppression of their opinions.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by ALittleLight on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:41PM (#26098319)
Oh, your phone app is banned? Just make your own phone, hardware and software.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by AdamJacobMuller on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:08AM (#26098441)
Phone apps are more complex.

My concern is less apple banning things and far more when apple and google operate in lockstep.

there is a fundamental misunderstanding in the app store review world, it was highlighted when google banned element(??) the matrix client. will apple ban IRC clients because they can connect to bad servers with universally objectionable content? will they ban SSH clients because they can be used to hack?

With the last big ban controversy (fortnight) I was firmly in the pro walled garden camp, but, now i’m no longer seeing where the big duopoly draws the line and i don’t like it.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by ALittleLight on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:54AM (#26099577)
I think part of the problem is that much of our laws and intuitions are built for a time when there were competitors or they are designed for local marketplaces rather than internet scale businesses.

If my grocer is a jerk, I can go to a different grocery store. If this mechanic is always giving me dubious advice I can find a different one. Modern businesses, at internet scale, really aren't that way though. They are much more "winner take all". Maybe there are one or two winners, but when they win they really do take almost all the market share. And for most of the developed world simultaneously.

I can kind of get my own phone. Someone else in this thread mentions Purism. I could also get a rooted Android phone and install a version of Android that takes out Google. What I can't do, effectively, is make my own app, if the duopoly would prefer I not. I could put my app in a private app store or offer it to the kinds of people who use Librem phones, but the market there is too small to run a successful business. Google (via Android) and Apple are effectively both a monopoly, they sell/control almost all of the phones, and a monopsony, they control almost all of the supply of phone users.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by njarboe on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:55PM (#26098381)
Re:Larry Flynt has died by AdamJacobMuller on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:11AM (#26098462)
I don’t feel like purism is a viable alternative. it’s very expensive for what you’re getting and in all respects that i’ve heard the software is not up to par and the ecosystem is effectively non-existent.

I have yet to try one personally and might soon in spite of the price tag, i would love to be wrong but i don’t think i am.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by AnthonyMouse on Thursday February 11, 2021 @01:34AM (#26098876)
> I don’t feel like purism is a viable alternative. it’s very expensive for what you’re getting and in all respects that i’ve heard the software is not up to par and the ecosystem is effectively non-existent.

Let's go through these.

It's basically brand new so there aren't a lot of third party apps. If you're the sort of person who loves installing the app for your Smart Toaster on your phone, you may not like this. But you get 95-99% of the value out of a phone if it can make phone calls, message people and has a web browser. Most apps are crap. They also have plans to support Android apps in the not too distant future.

The hardware is slower than similarly priced hardware. But again, does this really matter? You're not mining Bitcoin or rendering feature length motion pictures on your phone, are you?

Which leaves the price. It's high because they're still not making them in huge volumes. It means the early adopters will be people with money. But that's good; people with money attract developers etc. And once the volumes are higher the price will come down.

But this is all kind of chicken and egg. It's not impossible but it's hard and they may or may not succeed. If your point is that isn't already viable for everyone, that's certainly true.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by mrweasel on Thursday February 11, 2021 @04:35AM (#26099765)
Well... Yes, that's one very valid cause of action. It might not be the only way forward, it depends on a lot of things.

There's absolutely nothing standing in the way of PornHub introducing a phone, because they want to adult apps to be allowed.

Want to sell adult content on Instagram, but you're not allowed? Go build onlyfans.com.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by hoseja on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:19AM (#26099403)
>they don't want to see the dumb content

I don't think that's the point. They want to feel the warm satisfaction of righteous fury and enemy defeated.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by phs318u on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:26PM (#26098250)
I'm not sure that's really true. They did not have unfettered access to the media "platforms" of the day. And they did create their own platforms. Lookup the long history of black newspapers and radio stations.

In your last line you almost prove the opposite of your point. Yes, people in power didn't want to, and yet - despite not having unfettered access to the platforms of the day - they were not swept under the rug. My view is that's because they had a critical mass of people that cared enough that they literally couldn't be swept under any rug.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by mannykannot on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:41PM (#26098318)
I am not sure you are making the point you intended to. These movements were opposed by powerful elements, they did not own the largest platforms, and yet they prevailed. Any movement that depends on the most powerful elements of society to secure it a platform is at grave risk of becoming dependent on them.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by dragonwriter on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:41AM (#26098605)
> MLK and the civil rights movement didn't own their own platform.

Yes, they largely either did or relied on convincing platform owners, not relying on platform entitlement. Now, they and the allies they convinced didn't own a single centralized platform, it was a decentralized network with big nodes like Rev. Dr. King’s Ebenezer Baptist Church, and small nodes like the individual members of the movement, which relied substantially on person-to-person face-to-face grassroots mobilization.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by oilbagz on Thursday February 11, 2021 @03:28AM (#26099444)
These entities didn't own their own platforms? Really?

Maybe they weren't handed a platform on a plate, like we are today, but that is entirely the point: I think they did have their own publications and financed their own media. That's how they became a movement in the first place. You can't get mass acceptance at scale from your target demographic without building a platform.

I think the examples you gave are of people who struck out to build their own platforms, and did so successfully. This is why we even know about them in the first place, thankfully.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by eyelidlessness on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:44AM (#26098617)
> MLK and the civil rights movement didn't own their own platform. [... etc ...]

And they didn’t demand publication by others’ platforms either. They demonstrated in public spaces, often at great personal risk because they didn’t have equal access to public spaces.

Edit: sibling comment said even better, yes they did own their own platforms.

> Would you have been okay with them being swept under the rug? It's not as if people in power didn't want to.

Maybe you should stop “they”ing me. I’m not other than the groups that you’re using for your point. I’m directly a part of all of the movements you mention, either directly affected or in solidarity. And while you’re at it stop with the past tense.

In none of these cases did any movement demand to be published by someone else’s platform. All have tried to gain recognition sometimes seeking publication. But none have such entitlement to expect to be in someone else’s mouth against their will.

Re:Larry Flynt has died by phs318u on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:15PM (#26098191)
So, public square, but bring your own soapbox/megaphone.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by eyelidlessness on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:48AM (#26098646)
I don’t see why that’s so controversial. That’s what me and mine been doing for decades. I consider myself lucky to have access to a comment box on a forum someone else operates.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by CerealFounder on Thursday February 11, 2021 @01:48AM (#26098934)
Your comment is confusing. Flynt fought the government, people who are complaining about cancel culture are complaining about people not liking their spicy takes.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by lightgreen on Thursday February 11, 2021 @05:16AM (#26099999)
> people who are complaining about cancel culture are complaining about people not liking their spicy takes

This is oversimplification.

There’s quite a difference between “not liking” and ruining career, denial of access to services etc.

Part of the problem is that only small group of people really “don’t like it” but capable of cancelling, and vast majority of people are happy to just ban that person in their feed and go on with their life (and large number of people are actually open to opposing views).

Re:Larry Flynt has died by postalrat on Thursday February 11, 2021 @10:34AM (#26102586)
How cute and simplistic.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by david38 on Thursday February 11, 2021 @02:43AM (#26099203)
Indeed. It’s now been reframed as “freedom from government prosecution”, not from organized canceling.
Re:Larry Flynt has died by mywittyname on Thursday February 11, 2021 @09:34AM (#26101840)
It's always been "freedom from government prosecution."

Flynt faced "organized canceling" from many groups. They just couldn't (continue to) use their influence in the government to punish him. He's in a wheelchair because of a failed "permanent cancellation" attempt.

Also, Democrats of the era didn't much liked him either. Could you imagine 90s-era Hillary Clinton ranting against language in rap music while simultaneously supporting this guy?