All the information is held by private companies and the gov’t gets the info from them voluntarily.
Ditto for the First Amendment. Worthless. Instead of the govt prohibiting speech, the govt just has private companies do it for them.
How many times a week on HackerNews do you see this kind of exchange:
A: Facebook censored this or that and thus infringes on free speech.
B: It’s a private company; it can do what it wants.
A: But, but, there’s something wrong with that!
B: Don’t like it, make your own Facebook. Hur dur...
Etc. Ad nauseum.
Clearly, both (A) and (B) above are trying to reason through something within an outdated and outmoded framework; it’s why both sides sound silly.
Anyway, this is the same thing... but with the 4th amendment.
Same problem.
A private company that holds your data can do with it what it wishes. And, like the first amendment, if the govt makes it clear to these private companies that they ought ‘voluntarily’ cooperate with the govt “if they know what’s good for them,” then then Bill of Rights is worthless.
The 1st and 4th were meant to protect us from a tyrannical govt; not a tyrannical corporation.
Scrap the entire ball of wax and start over.
The Constitution — at this point — is an utter joke.
Businesses on the scale of a Facebook or a Google or Walmart simply did not exist anywhere, at any point in time in human history up to that point. But they rightly left these matters to the civil authorities, and the governed.
So no, the Constitution is not an utter joke. Our politicians and our indolent populace are.
Dutch East India Company?
That’s not blindingly obvious.
I believe a typical Founding Father would shudder at the thought of the government having anything whatsoever to say about the manner in which a church administered itself.
Surely you must be joking.