Proof of works is DESIGNED to waste energy. If tomorrow, you'd make hash computations 1000x as energy efficient, the hashing difficult is designed to adjust to make sure that 1000x as many computations are performed and the same amount of energy is wasted.
Think of it this way: Currently, 900 bitcoins are mined per day. At a price of $40K per bitcoin, whoever mines those bitcoins earns a combined $36M. So miners are incentivized to invest approximately that much money into energy & equipment per day (minus some profit margin). If they invested substantially less, somebody could invest more and pick off their coins. (And that's counting only mining profits. There are also transaction rewards, and, if you were to control a majority of mining, more nefarious sources of profit).
This means that PoW has some truly perverse incentives:
* Industry wide energy efficiency does not matter, because the difficulty will adjust accordingly.
* The higher the bitcoin price rises, the MORE energy gets wasted (That's a big difference with e.g. Gold. Sure, rising prices lead to more marginal deposits being exploited, but it's not like pickaxe prices for a given prices rose proportionally with gold prices).
The mean wealth of an adult on Earth (in USD) is ~$70,849 [1]. For all adults (let's say 70% of the global population, or 5.46 billion), on average, to have even 1% of their wealth stored in bitcoin, and assuming 14.8 million bitcoin in circulation (as 18.5 million have been mined, ~20% have been lost [2]), the bitcoin market rate would have to be $258,243 USD/BTC. This would mean an increase in mining incentive which will likely outpace advances in renewable energy technologies. With ballooning transaction fees, Bitcoin is not even useful for 90% of the world, for the scale of their transactions.
With Ethereum's 2.0 network (which uses PoS), we will have a much more sustainable cryptocurrency that can hopefully be adopted at a global scale without devastating impact on the planet. Perhaps Bitcoin Cash or some other contender with negligible fees will play an important role as well (I'm not sure what the Eth 2.0 transition will mean for mining fees on the Eth network, which are also undesirably high). I'm overall optimistic on blockchain technology as a whole, but I really hope Bitcoin isn't the dominant cryptocurrency in 10 years time
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_pe...
[2] https://www.investopedia.com/news/20-all-btc-lost-unrecovera...
But anyway, not every cryptocurrency uses PoW :)
See my other reply for why I believe it absolutely is.
> But anyway, not every cryptocurrency uses PoW :)
True, but Bitcoin is the one that people actually speculate in. Ethereum seems to be in some kind of transition phase. Tether is not designed for speculation, and operates more on a Proof of Shenanigans principle. So it seems the highest capitalized Proof of Stakes cryptocurrency right now is Cardano, which is tiny compared to Bitcoin.
Until someone crunches the math on how much energy the construction and maintenance of every bank on the whole planet costs, including digging shiny rocks out of the earth, I am not sold on "PoW is a waste of energy".
It merely compresses the concept behind the existing banking system into its very essence to do that efficiently without bells and whistles.
Here watch this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLYYh4aPXAM
Bitcoin mining allows energy companies to de-risk an investment in green energy solutions such as solar. If you place some miners onsite you always have full demand (which is a problem during peak production times). Bitcoin mining is a energy revolution.
His article starts talking about his investment portofolio, so I think we can safely conclude his opinions are predicated on there being economic growth.
And what is the magical reason why we need to keep the economy going?
We're burning through this planet's resources much faster than they are being replenished.
The economy needs to stop going.
If cryptocurrency causes people to use products until they fall apart instead of throwing away a pocket-size supercomputer every year then I am damn fine with that.