News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by chrisseaton on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:35PM (#26051192)
> I would imagine the average person on the street would expect to see a service life of >20 years.

For a car? Are many people driving around in a car from 2000 or earlier? When I search for cars that old or older it's 0.4% of the used market. Clearly the vast majority of cars do not last this long and I think you have an unreasonable expectation.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by throwaway2245 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:51PM (#26051289)
> it's 0.4% of the used market.

This sounded unlikely to me, so I checked a local site and got 4.9% >20 years old in the used market. A lot of people drive their old cars beyond the point that they are not worth re-selling, so I'd expect that to be an underestimate of how many cars are that old.

The article linked suggests the average age of a car on the road in the USA is 12 years - if you're then selling cars that are designed to obsolete in 6 years, that has potential consumer law implications.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by taylodl on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:04PM (#26051363)
Why is that an unreasonable expectation? There are far fewer mechanical parts to fail. Moreover, Elon Musk has announced their batteries can last a million miles. What's the point of the battery lasting a million miles if the car can't? Sure, I may have to replace the motors but I wouldn't have to expect to do that until at least 250,000 miles and it would be a lot cheaper than buying a whole new car and would be worth it if I knew I could expect to get 250,000 miles out of it.

We're flying airplanes that are 30-40 years old. 18 wheel trucks are routinely driven a million miles. I think we need to adjust our expectations that cars need to be replaced every 5-10 years because they're no longer reliable. That's not a wise management of natural resources.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by chrisseaton on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:11PM (#26051406)
> Why is that an unreasonable expectation?

Because they clearly don't often last that long in practice.

Are you saying you wished they lasted longer? Ok yeah that'd be great... but I mean they don't at the moment you can see that for yourself, so expecting it is an unreasonable expectation.

You can expect that cars should last a hundred years if you want... but you're going to be disappointed.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by sundaeofshock on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:02PM (#26051689)
Except they often do last that long. 25% of vehicles on the road are at least 16 years-old [1] and used cars sales far outpace new car sales [2].

Tesla does not need those screens to last 100 years; but it’s not unreasonable to expect at least 15 - 20 years.

1: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/28/25percent-of-cars-in-us-are-... 2: https://carsurance.net/blog/cars-sales-statistics/

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by o-__-o on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:17PM (#26052035)
A car accident will dramatically shorten the life of a car. Depreciation will determine the average lifespan of most cars. That is approximately 12-16 years
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by dingaling on Sunday February 07, 2021 @02:30PM (#26057457)
> Depreciation will determine the average lifespan of most cars.

Depreciation has little relevance to the majority of used-car buyers who need a vehicle, not an investment. They drive it until it can no longer be driven.

What is more relevant to the lifespan of a car is durability and availability of parts. For example Honda shared parts between the Civic, CR-V and Integra so they are relatively easy to obtain even going back to late 90s models.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by Breza on Monday February 08, 2021 @11:59PM (#26074063)
In fact, depreciation is a great thing for used car buyers. It means they pay less to buy a car.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by curryst on Saturday February 06, 2021 @11:36PM (#26052676)
That doesn't impact how long the cards would have lasted. They're basically moot in this dataset because they were eliminated before wear and tear could kill the car.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by ProfessorLayton on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:40PM (#26052154)
from 2016, but still relevant:

"...about 80 percent of all Toyota vehicles sold over the past 20 years are still on the road today." [1]

Used cars are an entry point into an automaker's brand, and they do indeed want their cars to last as long as possible. Furthermore, reliability is a pretty large factor in resale value, and by extension, lease rates.

[1] https://pressroom.toyota.com/america-best-selling-car-camry-...

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by Breza on Monday February 08, 2021 @11:58PM (#26074048)
Well said! I tend to drive cars until they stop working. My first car was almost twenty years old and I loved it. Even if I'm not planning to drive a car that long, I still want the option when I buy it and would have a hard time buying something that felt temporary.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by tjalfi on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:20PM (#26051449)
You probably aren't finding cars this old on the market because their owners drive them into the ground.

We were raised to follow this practice and it's hard to imagine doing anything else.

My current car is 20 years old and I have owned it for about a decade. All the other cars I previously owned were also about 15+ years old. I'm not interested in buying a car with a shorter lifespan.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by te on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:50PM (#26052482)
You can guesstimate the average service life of a car using Little's Law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little%27s_law

Share of new cars was 6.9% in 2019, ~5.0% in 2020, and scrappage rate was 5.1% in 2019 (source: https://news.ihsmarkit.com/prviewer/release_only/slug/bizwir...).

If the average in/out flow per year is ~5%, average life is 20 years. If 6%, ~17 years.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by illirik on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:59PM (#26052243)
I daily drive a 1997 Dodge Ram pickup, with roughly a quarter million miles on it, and it still works perfectly.

My previous vehicle was a 1984 Ford F350, which I purchased for $800 in 2017 and then subsequently drove from Seattle to North Carolina with only one breakdown (that I could fix roadside).

With proper maintenance and repair, most vehicles can last several hundred thousand miles and 30+ years. The lack of representation of these vehicles on used car search sites is that most of these inexpensive vehicles are sold private-party. Look at your local Craigslist site for examples.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by verall on Sunday February 07, 2021 @10:44AM (#26055740)
I thought "Hey, I know a guy who drove an old Ford pickup from Seattle to NC", and then I saw your username.

Hope you're doing well man. With love from Texas <3

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by rasz on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:52PM (#26052492)
>1997 Dodge Ram pickup ... still works perfectly

How many times did you replace the dashboard before ending up with a dash blanket?

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by throwawayboise on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:04PM (#26051359)
20 years is getting out there but it's not uncommon. A car can certainly be maintained and kept in use much longer than that. The only thing really terminal in the northern climes is rust, once that gets a foothold it's hard to stop. Everything else can be maintained and/or repaired.

My newest car is a 2009, purchased in 2018 for $4,000. Everything works except the tire pressure sensors (the batteries in the wheel sensors have died; I'll replace them at next tire change).

My oldest car is a 1969 but that's a toy, so I don't really count it. My oldest car that I use for transportation is a 1983. The air conditioning has failed on that one, but I live without it.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by ce4 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:17PM (#26051744)
You maybe can replace the coin cell lithium batteries. The sensors are not built to be servicable but I got it done by scratching off the rubber/glue/expoxy stuff and soldering in replacement cr2025's + sealing it afterwards again. Youtube has some videos
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by SignalNotSecure on Sunday February 07, 2021 @07:19AM (#26054536)
Thanks for the suggestion to hack a new battery in. I'm planning to drill a zerk grease fitting into any new moving parts that go on my cars.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by forty on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:45PM (#26051250)
I think looking at the used market might not be a good way to measure, because 20+ are worth essentially nothing, so they don't get sold a lot :) but that doesn't mean they don't continue working. Think that many people cannot afford changing car, even more so when the current car is worth nothing on the market.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by burnt_toast on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:56PM (#26051313)
Personally one of my cars is a 93, and the other is a 00. Both are DDed half of the year depending on the weather. But, I'm an ethusiast so not exactly the norm.

In rural areas (read lower income) it's not uncommon to see late 80s, 90s vehicles out and about. Some are in good shape, others not so much...

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by totalZero on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:55PM (#26051917)
The income factor is a big deal. Rust is also much less of a factor in some regions than others.

Outside of the US, some countries have heavy import taxes on new vehicles, meaning that the secondary market dominates and older vehicles are more likely to be overhauled than junked.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by NathanielK on Sunday February 07, 2021 @03:23AM (#26053542)
In Tesla's environmental impact report [1], they estimate the average car in the US is driven 12,000miles/year for 17 years before it's scrapped. They amortize over this period for their lifecycle C02 impact of a Model 3. From my own research, this number is a good guess, though it's region dependant. This doesn't match the OP which claims Tesla's are only engineered to last 6 years before expensive maintenance.

[1] https://www.tesla.com/ns_videos/2019-tesla-impact-report.pdf (page 8)

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by steve_adams_86 on Sunday February 07, 2021 @01:31AM (#26053135)
Up until I bought my 2017 Highlander I was driving a 2001 Golf which was purchased in 2008. It was still running well in the end. I just couldn’t see myself replacing the clutch when I was already sick how poorly it fit my lifestyle. If I didn’t have kids I’d have kept it on the road for sure.

It had 300k km on it and ran just fine. Newer cars run forever with basic maintenance. I sold it for $1k and the buyer planned to give it to their teen as a commuter, so I assume it’ll be on the road a while yet.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by jeroen on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:06PM (#26051378)
In the Netherlands, there are 207K cars for sale on marktplaats.nl (comparable to craigslist). 15K or 7% of those were built in or before 2001.

That does not take into account older cars being exported to eastern Europe.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by totalZero on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:53PM (#26051904)
"Research by R.L. Polk says that the average age of a modern vehicle is 11.4 years, while the average length of time drivers keep a new vehicle is 71.4 months — around 6 years."

https://www.autotrader.com/car-shopping/buying-car-how-long-...

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by chrisseaton on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:56PM (#26051922)
> the average age of a modern vehicle is 11.4 years

I don't think you can use this statistic on its own to say how many live >20 years can you?

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by totalZero on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:28PM (#26052096)
I don't believe I did that.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by chrisseaton on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:08PM (#26052289)
Well how is the statistic relevant then? Why did you mention it?
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by totalZero on Saturday February 06, 2021 @11:21PM (#26052618)
Not sure why you're going after me, but I believe it's relevant because if I'm judging the expected lifetime of a car, it makes sense to know the age of an average car. I looked it up after reading the parent comment so I shared the information for others to benefit from it as well. The post has a couple of upvotes so presumably others also found it relevant.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by AdrianB1 on Saturday February 06, 2021 @11:04PM (#26052541)
Yes. Until a week ago I used to drive a car built in 2000 and the average age of cars in my country is 14 years, so cars of 20 or more years are not exceptions.

The sad thing is I can barely find some parts for that 21 year old car that is mostly in perfect running order, but several small buttons don't work anymore, most of the display (showing basic info like outside temperature, fuel consumption etc), rear windshield blade, so at some point good running cars are abandoned because of lack of parts, not because they really need to. Replacing with newer cars is not just the financial cost, but the associated energy and pollution costs that manufacturing processes have.

For electric cars I have huge life expectations, 30 years or more with just batteries and tires as consumables, but the car body and electrical engine should last a very, very long time. There is no reason to accept less than that.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by SignalNotSecure on Sunday February 07, 2021 @07:26AM (#26054566)
Junkyards often have good replacements for those worn out interior parts; you can pull nice stuff from newer cars that were crashed

Lots of useful parts for all kinds of cars going back decades:

https://www.rockauto.com/

If not living in the USA, add: https://www.viabox.com/

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by Tepix on Sunday February 07, 2021 @06:53AM (#26054416)
This attitude is what destroys the planet. We need to build things that last long and can be repaired well. It uses much fewer resources than throwing stuff away and making new things.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by dragonwriter on Tuesday February 09, 2021 @12:20AM (#26074179)
> For a car?

Yes.

> Are many people driving around in a car from 2000 or earlier?

A fair number, though not a lot because an accident or neglected maintenance will often kill them first. Though the average age of a car on the road has been climbing quite a bit recently, so 20+ years being common probably isn't unreasonable to see during the lifespan of cars sold today. Well, maybe not for the Teslas, but...

> When I search for cars that old or older it's 0.4% of the used market.

That's because there is little demand outside of collectibles, so they mostly aren't worth selling; if you've got a car that old, you are probably going to drive it until it's ready for the scrapyard, not reselling it.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by Ancapistani on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:23PM (#26052360)
I drive a 2000 Jeep Wrangler. My dad has a 1997 Wrangler, and his “farm” truck is a 2002 F350 if memory serves.

A quick look at eBay shows a nearly identical F350 listed at $21,500, with >190k miles, so clearly someone sees value in vehicles of that vintage.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by stefan_ on Saturday February 06, 2021 @07:35PM (#26051535)
It depends entirely on your market. It's not that the cars don't last that long, it's that cars this old are commonly shipped out to places with a lower standard of living (and maintenance requirements/testing).
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by everdrive on Saturday February 06, 2021 @10:50PM (#26052483)
Our car is from 2004. 20 years is a bit of a stretch, but i hope it makes it.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by lotsofpulp on Sunday February 07, 2021 @12:04AM (#26052800)
20 years (or 200k to 300k miles) is easily doable in a Toyota in an area that doesn’t get salted.

There’s a reason old 4Runners and Tacomas and Land Cruisers are worth so much, and barely come up for sale in decent condition.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by everdrive on Sunday February 07, 2021 @01:00PM (#26056707)
We get a LOT of salt. We're in the northeast US. I think it'll rust out before the engine and transmission die.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by dognotdog on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:45PM (#26051248)
This is interesting, 0.4% in numbers or value?
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by chrisseaton on Saturday February 06, 2021 @06:48PM (#26051276)
In numbers.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by dognotdog on Saturday February 06, 2021 @09:00PM (#26051946)
That doesn't seem to bad, all considered. 5% would be the natural number for any one year out of 20, to get to 0.4% from 5% in 20 yrs should be about 8 yrs of mean life per car, assuming exponential decay. I'm fairly sure this thought process is missing some fudge factor to make it exact, but seems about the right ballpark.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by hnburnsy on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:01PM (#26051680)
Many car companies are offering 84 month financing, that would be 7 years.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by chrisseaton on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:14PM (#26051736)
Ok? What's that got to do with going beyond 20?
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by IOT_Apprentice on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:27PM (#26051792)
The point is you are paying for a car over 7 years, with the expectation that you will drive it longer than that. I'm not sure how old you are (as that may color your experience), but I'd expect a high end, expensive car to last 20 years, especially if it does not have all the parts of an ICE car.

Your service points on an EV are going to be tires and brakes. If the car battery is rated for 1 million miles, how many years is that?

The central control system is a Touchscreen which will be exposed to a variety of heat/cold/Sun exposure how long should it last?

Not everyone can afford to buy a car every 7 years or WANT to do so.

Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by hnburnsy on Saturday February 06, 2021 @08:21PM (#26051767)
Sorry nothing to do with that, just addressing the 6 year lifespan from the article.
Re:Tesla: Recalled touchscreens were meant to only last 5-6 ... by grogenaut on Saturday February 06, 2021 @11:11PM (#26052567)
I won't sell my pre 2000 car, it works too well