Now I would understand the complaint if that company had the same hiring hoops as Google but a dud of TC but that's an orthogonal issue.
If you try to bake a cake following a recipe, but only using half of the ingredients listed, you are going to get an odd cake.
Cargo culting only by name.
EU might have more population, but USA has population that speaks single language and largely zero trade barriers for typical SV product.
Japan has a lot of cultural exporting, but certainly has its differences. And is not exactly known for being internet-forward. Korea is internet forward but is similarly culturally niche; kpop stans are pretty much in their own bubble, one that’s big enough to cause havoc in international music charts but still a bubble. And China’s Internet is double different because of the insulation of the Great Firewall.
Of course, how much stock one actually should put into this is up to the reader.
Is Silicon Valley actually a valley though? Isn't it a plateau? We have plenty of those.
It’s like the difference between a chef and a cook. You can make good food by following a recipe, but your aren’t going to get anything unique.
The other big cargo cult you often see is agile. Press an "agile" company on what agile practices the follow and more often than not you'll just get "we do daily stand ups". Ask them what they think the most important rule in the agile manifesto is and you'll get blank stares, they can't even read the cults literature.
My company didn't have a clue on what to purchase for software development equipment or how to organize it. As a result, they observed what Google did and copied it to the best of their ability as their pocketbook would allow. Although it's not perfect and they have no idea why it works, it's certainly better than anything they could organically have come up with.
You seem to be talking about production equipment.
At least I have never needed a datacenter to develop software. But hey, that is just anecdata of course.
Do you have services used by billions of people that process petabytes of data every day?
If not, you do not need Google caliber engineers. You need common sense.
In fact, they work faster and more reliably than competitors. Office 365 web sucks, for example.
I recall talking to someone who was very very happy to brag that his company was doing "everything just like Google" and following the exact same practices he read the company did on various engineering blogs.
I asked him what was the compensation like and how he managed to get kids from Stanford to work at his company instead of their startups and he just gave me a blank stare. Said something about how they were not in Silicon Valley and paid median salaries and that he had "no trouble finding Google caliber talent in the local market." and that "it's not really the local market's customs to give stocks to coders".