Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by yks on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @04:54PM
(#26019671)
I guess I disagree. Yes, you need a high class talent to move the field forward but once the new frontier is conquered, it ceases to be a frontier and everyone else can enjoy the fruits. Regular engineering practices of today are cutting edge of yesterday.
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by issamehh on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @07:01PM
(#26020908)
That's good and fine but is not the same thing as operating like Google
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by the-dude on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @04:59PM
(#26019719)
And still all initiatives to clone SV successes failed ( The Netherlands is full of Valleys, we have a Food Valley, an Energy Valley etc )
Cargo culting only by name.
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by p_l on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @07:14PM
(#26021005)
Without massive, cheap investment money combined with massive simple integrated market, one cannot replicate conditions of Silicon Valley :/
EU might have more population, but USA has population that speaks single language and largely zero trade barriers for typical SV product.
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by barry-cotter on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:36PM
(#26022302)
Israel seems to do pretty well, by which I mean Tel Aviv. They always go US or global first for obvious reasons but there’s no a priori reason Europe couldn’t have a genuine startup hub.
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by solveit on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @07:36PM
(#26021157)
While your argument is hard to prove wrong because the US ranks third in population as a single nation, I am skeptical that there is somehow a market population threshold that allows Silicon Valley in a country of 3X10^9 but not, say, 1.2X10^9 (Japan).
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by bobthepanda on Thursday February 04, 2021 @12:47AM
(#26022990)
The argument there is that America has sufficiently exported enough culture via traditional means that using American products is not that strange.
Japan has a lot of cultural exporting, but certainly has its differences. And is not exactly known for being internet-forward. Korea is internet forward but is similarly culturally niche; kpop stans are pretty much in their own bubble, one that’s big enough to cause havoc in international music charts but still a bubble. And China’s Internet is double different because of the insulation of the Great Firewall.
Of course, how much stock one actually should put into this is up to the reader.
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by divtiwari on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:13PM
(#26022166)
It should be 10^8 :)
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by newswasboring on Thursday February 04, 2021 @04:18AM
(#26023958)
At this point I think we have moved quite far from the OP's acquaintance's comment. It's quite clear they meant operation day to day. The procedures Google follows and processes they have developed are out there and quite publicly available. Anyone can follow them with even a mediocre engineering team.
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by azza2110 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @07:30PM
(#26021123)
Does the Netherlands even have hills and valleys?
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by cjfd on Thursday February 04, 2021 @12:21AM
(#26022883)
It actually has these. Mostly in the extreme south east and in some other places where the boundary of the ice was in the ice age. Highest point in the Netherlands is about 300m above sea level.
Re:Cargo Cult Software Engineering (2000)
by the-dude on Thursday February 04, 2021 @08:08AM
(#26024990)
But that's what we call a mountain :-)
Is Silicon Valley actually a valley though? Isn't it a plateau? We have plenty of those.
If you try to bake a cake following a recipe, but only using half of the ingredients listed, you are going to get an odd cake.