1) Digital is taking over all ad-channels
2) Digital ads can be tracked and attributed ways that were never possible with traditional media
3) It turns out most non-targeted ads aren't actually that effective, and aggregate ad spend is falling.
FB ads are effective and high value because of tracking. If tracking goes away, FB ad revenue will fall to that of banner advertising at roughly 1/100th to 1/10000th the price per impression that FB currently receives.
Such a change would effectively force a rethink of the entire consumer technology business, and see FB/GOOG re-structure to some form of subscription revenue or shutdown large feature sets and product offerings which would no longer be tenable.
Not really.
Digital advertising, frankly, sucks from the advertiser's point of view. It's just that people are online now and advertisers have no choice: the inventory providers are monopolistic and unregulated.
In the world of Nielson and print the only consistently measurable ads were brand ads - and brand awareness had a loose correlation across businesses with revenue. There was no way of rigorously testing whether individual customers propensity to purchase a good from a given business was actually tied to any of the brand awareness ads that were being purchased, or customer's brands they had heard of for trust reasons after deciding on a purchase, or if customer's simply didn't care about the branding. Bear in mind, any negative datapoint that indicates customer's didn't care could always be taken as a sign that the "brand" had to be improved. Not that the ads were worthless.
Now on digital any brand exercise, direct pay per conversion, or other form of ad gets attributed to downstream revenue, and we're quickly discovering which half of the marketing budget isn't working.
This isn't right. Of course there was - statistics, sampling and A/B testing was invented way before computers or the Internet existed.
Advertising is just applied sociology, and sociology is just statistics when done right.
What advertising does not suck from the advertiser's point of view? How are metrics gathered that demonstrate these forms of advertising work?
While this is a commonly held believe in many corners it doesn't appear to be well backed by data & research. Freakonomics also covered this topic in some detail recently.
Some examples where it's proven untrue:
Nytimes drops targeted advertising in Europe: https://digiday.com/media/gumgumtest-new-york-times-gdpr-cut...
>“The fact that we are no longer offering behavioral targeting options in Europe does not seem to be in the way of what advertisers want to do with us,” he said. “The desirability of a brand may be stronger than the targeting capabilities. We have not been impacted from a revenue standpoint, and, on the contrary, our digital advertising business continues to grow nicely.”
Danish broadcaster grew revenue after dropping targeted ads: https://techcrunch.com/2020/07/24/data-from-dutch-public-bro...
>The data shows the NPO grew ad revenue after ditching trackers to target ads in the first half of this year
FB/Goog dominate ad-spend as they are able to effectively match small advertisers with the appropriate audience, and these advertisers typically have specific customer goals in mind. If the goal of the ad buyers on the NYT is simply to associate their brand with the trustworthiness of the NYT, then there won't be much benefit from behavioral targets.
Non-personalised television advertising is still doing great.
There's now a mad rush to standardize tech for personalized tv advertising, as providers plan to use the email/phone number you used for your cable/streaming service as a personal identifier that can be joined against 3rd party targeting data.
I'm not trying justifying this - just describing where the industry (and money) is going.
And a 5% drop would be less than the drop in broader TV production, via coronavirus?
Major events that are associated with large advertising budgets haven't happened: the Olympics didn't happen. The Eurovision Song Contest didn't happen.
Depends on the metric you use.
> Facebook’s revenue per user is roaring. For Q4 2018 vs. Q4 2017, it’s global ARPU increased by 19 percent to $7.37, and the US-Canada ARPU by 30 percent to $35. Between 2011 and 2018, the social network global ARPU rose nearly 6x, while the US-Canada grew 11x. With a domestic revenue per user of $112, Facebook is the equivalent of a publisher charging $9 a month. It does that with a free service.
source: Slide 4 (ARPU) https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/doc_financials/2020/q4...
That's a whole can of worms. Does the existence of things like your website's Apache request log count as "tracking"? Or does it only count if it's multiple domains? Maybe we'd need to say multiple organizations, to account for applications with multiple domains (e.g. facebook.com, fbcdn.com, etc.) But then what is an organization? If I sign an agreement with you to sell you my Apache request log, is that now illegal? If so, what was it about that that made it illegal? How do you make that illegal without also making it illegal to share these otherwise benign logs with people for the purpose of debugging website issues? Are you going to base this on "intent"? That is, "you're free to share this data with X as long as X does not intend to use it for advertising, or to share it with anyone else who might [...] who might intend to use it for advertising"? These kinds of intent-chains are spectacularly ineffective, in part because the advertising ecosystem is set up to make these chains as convoluted as possible, and suddenly someone just has some data there and why not make profiles out of it? etc.
:\
This in itself is fine, as long as either: 1. The drop in convenience isn't so high that people would prefer an alternative service 2. We can impose these rules worldwide.
If the drop in convenience isn't too bad, then even though there's a little more friction, there's not a mass exodus from these services. If we could impose these rules worldwide, that'd also make this an easy decision.
Given that the web is global, however, my biggest area of worry is that we squeeze all national companies to protect privacy, but it turns out the consumers really did like the personalized and convenient experiences and immediately switch over to Baidu or some other site that falls outside national jurisdiction and personalizes user experience well (presumably through even stronger privacy invasions).
tl;dr: I am cool with legislation, but given the global scale of the web we need to make sure we get the incentives/changes just right.
The word you were probably looking for is fines, but they would have to be punitive and extraordinarily risky to stop the practice...
We have different licenses for code and projects. Why not have something similar for user data / metadata
It seems this kind of universal disarmament (so to speak) still leaves FB in the same dominant position from an advertising perspective. It has the same huge audience, and it’s advertising product is the same as everyone else. If so why wouldn’t FB be actively lobbying for this right now?
(I’m just putting aside questions of monopoly, etc. Purely from an FB self interest stand point.)