News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by cletus on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:13PM (#2597285)
No surprises there.

The transition to driverless cars is (IMHO inevitable. At some point it will be cheap enough that the additional cost will pale in comparison to the lives that will be saved as well as the simple convenience of being able to do something else while commuting somewhere.

Likewise I see this kind of thing replacing many forms of public transportation. There will simply be a fleet of cars. You'll say where you want to go and some system will route people and cars to destinations.

But, the transition won't be quick or easy. You need look no further than the aviation industry to see why.

Basically, automation in modern aircraft is a double-edged sword. It seems to erode the ability of pilots to actually fly [1], software errors causing deaths [2] and (I can't find the link to this) I also read a study that in more automated planes, pilots are more likely to believe erroneous instruments rather than their own senses and experience.

The issue won't be how the car normally behaves because as demonstrations have shown, current systems require very little human intervention.

The issue will be extraordinary circumstances plus the huge liability problem of any errors.

Example: if someone runs a red light and causes a crash, killing someone, that person is responsible. If an automated car does the same thing, the manufacturer will be responsible.

That alone will impede adoption.

Instead I think you'll have what we already have: slowly adding automation to cars. Cars already have radars and can stop themselves from colliding, they can park themselves and so on.

But at some point the driver will need to go away and that will be a tremendously challenging leap forward for society.

[1]: http://www.tourismandaviation.com/news-4530--Pilot_Reliance_...

[2]: http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/8.77.html#subj6

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by jerf on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:33PM (#2597338)
People generally cite the lawsuit threat, but the threat cuts both ways. I've seen lawsuits for putatively malfunctioning anti-lock brakes, and I've seen lawsuits for not including anti-lock brakes. At some point, once it is reasonably well demonstrated that automated cars drive more safely than humans under some circumstances, someone is going to file a lawsuit for not having automated drivers. It's only a matter of time. That's when it really gets legally interesting.

Note I said "interesting", not "the beginning of the inevitable victory". I say "interesting" because I think we can pretty much all agree how this plays out until that happens, but I can't see past that event.

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by fleitz on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:45PM (#2597379)
Yup, I forsee the current seat belt system, where even in situations when it's advisable not to be wearing a seatbelt and/or the other mandated safety systems it's still illegal.

The problem is a systemic one that stems from the belief that the gov't is the omnipresent nanny of its citizenry.

Note: Before I get downvoted, I recognize that statistically seat belts save lives, however, there are conditions in which seatbelts cause fatalities (even when used properly), and that the choice of whether to wear or not wear one should be that of informed consent.

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by erikpukinskis on Sunday May 29, 2011 @04:29PM (#2597507)
There are conditions when vaccines kill children, but there is NO situation where the sensible choice is to not vaccinate your healthy child. The same with seatbelts.

Edit: Added "healthy".

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by rmc on Sunday May 29, 2011 @05:13PM (#2597613)
there are conditions in which seatbelts cause fatalities (even when used properly)

Do you have an example?

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by erydo on Monday May 30, 2011 @12:57AM (#2598558)
Driving on an iced lake or any other condition where your car is more likely to become submerged than you are to run into something, being unable to exit the vehicle quickly can be fatal.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by nl on Sunday May 29, 2011 @11:23PM (#2598374)
The typical example is an underage child in an adult seatbelt. Because of the difference in dimensions, a crash causes the seatbelt to impact the neck.

I'm not sure that would be classed as "used properly", though.

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by dagw on Monday May 30, 2011 @05:00AM (#2598887)
Is it a legal requirement for underage children to use an adult seatbelt? I know here in Sweden for example it is illegal to have child, under a certain height, in a car without proper child seatbelt/car seat. Form a legal point of view no seatbelt and adult seatbelt are more or less equivalent.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by nl on Monday May 30, 2011 @06:32AM (#2599016)
Here (Australia) children have to use a correct child restraint and/or seat up to the age of 7.

I believe the legal point is the same as you've stated - the law is "not correctly restrained" or something.

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by camtarn on Sunday May 29, 2011 @04:44PM (#2597547)
Given informed consent for seatbelts, what do you think the ratio would be between people who choose not to wear one because they have completely informed themselves from reliable sources and calculated that they're more likely to survive without one than with one, versus people who will just leave their seatbelt off because it's uncomfortable?
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by fleitz on Sunday May 29, 2011 @05:21PM (#2597632)
I'm not sure but if a person prefers to be more severely injured in the event of an accident rather than uncomfortable all the times they are not in an accident then it's an appropriate choice for them. I don't feel it's my place or any other third party to make these choices for adults.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by johnny22 on Sunday May 29, 2011 @06:01PM (#2597725)
except when we have to pay for their surgery or whatever via their emergency room visit.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by 13Psibies on Sunday May 29, 2011 @08:40PM (#2598013)
Sure, or even have to share emergency resources. I mean, why on earth would an ambulance attend a person who's seriously injured because they exercised their right to be comfortable when the ambulance could be attending someone who actually took some responsibility for his own safety and considers the well-being of the community at large.

Not that I'm this much of a bastard, but for those of us that have faith-based issues around community-provided health services.

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by rubinelli on Monday May 30, 2011 @07:07AM (#2599055)
Let's put aside the "who's paying for the ER" argument. A driver that loses control of the car trying to brace oneself or restrain a passenger that isn't wearing a seat belt can increase the severity of an accident for other people, too. A car crash victim that falls on to the street suddenly becomes a hazard to other vehicles, too.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by TheAmazingIdiot on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:55PM (#2597406)
The nanny state is what you get when you involve government in issues of health insurance and its kin.

The laws and regulations then turn towards cost reduction along with "taxes" to discourage higher health costs.

We only have the cigarette laws, seatbelt laws, and other 'endanger self only' actions that are regulated.

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by eru on Sunday May 29, 2011 @05:14PM (#2597615)
As a non-smoker I like smoking bans, since smoking affects me as a by-stander, too. I would also be OK with people injecting heroin instead of smoking---anything that doesn't stink.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by westicle on Monday May 30, 2011 @06:47AM (#2599035)
Spoken like someone who has never had to pick the used syringes from a public playground before their child could play on it.

But agreed in principle ;)

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by eru on Tuesday May 31, 2011 @09:01AM (#2602369)
We need a deposit on syringes.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by fleitz on Sunday May 29, 2011 @03:33PM (#2597337)
"pilots are more likely to believe erroneous instruments rather than their own senses and experience."

The human brain is not setup for 3D dimensions of orientation, unless you can accurately see the horizon it's more than likely that your perception of the planes orientation and vector is wrong than the instruments. In most turbulent situations the brain is wrong and the instruments are right. This is why pilots are trained to fly on instruments only. On most planes the instrumentation system actively and accurately informs pilots that their instruments are broken when they are in such a state.

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by nazgulnarsil on Sunday May 29, 2011 @07:35PM (#2597919)
it's not just the human brain. certain g-loads at certain vectors can cause a situation where 2 different scenarios are indistinguishable without outside reference. Illustrated most famously in Einstein's elevator thought experiments.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by blakeweb on Sunday May 29, 2011 @10:45PM (#2598293)
Could you explain what you mean? My understanding was that Attitude indicators solved this problem using a gyroscope a long time ago. Maybe this falls into what you meant by an "outside reference", but it seems to me autopilots would clearly take these measurements into account.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attitude_indicator

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by nazgulnarsil on Sunday May 29, 2011 @11:58PM (#2598443)
it does, they can fail. humans can fail at assessing relevant information as well.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by JoeCortopassi on Sunday May 29, 2011 @04:38PM (#2597534)
I couldn't get past the (unclosed parenthese in the second sentence. It's like my inner programmer went into OCD overload...
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by jacques_chester on Sunday May 29, 2011 @08:06PM (#2597972)
I couldn't get past the use of "parenthese"[] as a singular noun in the first sentence. It's like my inner pedant went into OCD overload.

1:Parenthesis :: >1:Parentheses

Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by jacques_chester on Monday May 30, 2011 @12:06AM (#2598466)
... hoist on my own petard.
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by JoeCortopassi on Monday May 30, 2011 @07:04AM (#2599051)
touche
Re:Regulation, not technology is holding back driverless cars by mryall on Monday May 30, 2011 @01:32AM (#2598614)