News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:29PM (#25937787)
> he quant types (mathematics and science majors) thought genius was due to natural gifts; parents and teachers had told them that they’d been born with a special talent for quantitative reasoning.

I don't think this is because people told them anything. To anyone who is good at maths it is painfully obvious that some people get it much easier than others. I started out thinking that people just did it wrongly, but the more I tried and the more I watched people do things the more I realized that they simply were bad at maths. There is nothing I can do for them. Some people just lack practice and motivation, true, but most lacks the brains to do it, since you need to have at least some level of intuition and some level of rational reasoning capacity to get anywhere in maths.

For those who disagree, how do you explain the very large number of people who spends tons of time and energy trying to get good at maths but fails to even grasp simple concepts like calculus? Contrast that with the much smaller but still considerable number of people who aren't really passionate about maths, don't put in the work yet still aces the class? Many on the "nurture is everything" side simply believes that those differences doesn't exist, the "geniuses" must have learned this beforehand or something else silly. But if you are one of those who aced the classes without even trying and see others try really really hard and still don't even pass, how could you explain that without considering talent as a variable? That person doesn't need to be told that talent is important.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by vector_spaces on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:13PM (#25938063)
I disagree because math is too vast and ill defined a field for any claim that anyone can be good or bad at all of it to be taken seriously.

In high school, I was one of those people who spent tons of time and energy on it, and failed miserably, barely graduating as a result. It wasn't until I was about 25 when I picked up a basic algebra and trigonometry book on a whim and started self-teaching, that it began making sense to me. I eventually went back to school for pure math.

In my case, I think what helped me as an adult was the freedom to learn on my own terms without the pressure of deadlines, and also a strong support network of friends encouraging me (compare with my teachers in high school who would actively embarrass me in front of the class or joke about their low expectations of me). And of course, some years of life experience in the real world doing things that were actually hard compared to (elementary) math as someone of limited means helped a bit too.

So, all of that is to say that people who struggle in math classes struggle for different reasons. I suspect that much of the time the dominating forces are psychosocial, cultural, or plain & simple lack of interest (which itself might be driven by traumatic experiences with shitty teachers or parents with weird expectations)

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by red75prime on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:23AM (#25938863)
And I tried and tried, but to no avail. I can understand what formulas describe, if I take time to remember definitions. But my mind refuses to grasp the reality behind those formulas, if that reality doesn't map well to everyday things like 3D space, objects, movement and so on.

It could be possible that I haven't tried long enough, but at about 35 I decided to put less effort into it and to prioritize other things.

I'm not encouraging anyone to avoid trying, of course. It was a very useful experience. Knowing that seemingly different things may have unifying mathematical structure (like monad in programming) can expand your approaches even if you aren't good at recognizing and exploring those mathematical structures.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:44PM (#25938292)
So you failed, then took your time and practiced more to succeed. I don't see how that contradicts anything I said. Circumstances matters, effort matters. Talent being a huge factor doesn't contradict that.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username91 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:21AM (#25938852)
Sorry for the lack of post history: I made an account to jump in.

You asked..

> how do you explain the very large number of people who spends tons of time and energy trying to get good at maths but fails to even grasp simple concepts like calculus?

One answer, as vector_spaces said, is that the learning environment can completely change the outcome of this effort. You agreed:

> Circumstances matter

It's true that talent being a factor doesn't contradict that, but given how homogenous early-life learning environments are, it's -extremely- difficult to tell whether a person "failed" because of lack of talent, vs. lack of the right environment to experiment and learn.

Basically, because a "wrong environment" fail looks like a "lack of talent" fail, I believe a lot of talented people don't find out that they have the talent in the first place, as they believe that an attempt in the wrong environment is as good as any attempt, and never try again - particularly if they've been chastised and humiliated -during- that learning process, as vector_spaces was.

In any case, the reason I wanted to jump in was because of your original statement:

>I don't think this is because people told them anything

I would just ask that you reconsider that position, based especially on your agreement that "circumstances matter." Thanks for reading.

[edit: linebreaks]

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:58AM (#25939019)
Learning environment matters, but I wouldn't say that it would completely change the outcome. If you are smart you don't have to work hard or have a good environment to understand high school maths. If you aren't that smart you can still pass the courses with hard work, but from my experience teaching a lot of college students in 1:1 settings people who have to work hard never really grasp the subjects. And some are so lacking that even with hard work they still can't pass.

So basically, just because someone managed to improve their grades and pass classes with hard work doesn't really say anything about my points. There are still people who pass easily without any of that. In short, my view is that hard work and environment can help improve your results, but unless you are completely prohibited from attending school you wont need that if you are smart enough.

For example, I skipped a lot of classes, was abused, was suicidal, never studied for any tests and didn't do any homework assignments in high school. I still got perfect math grades. Most people have better environments than that and spend more time on maths than that yet still do worse. I spent a lot of time doing 1:1 teaching in college, explaining things in intuitive ways etc helps, but ultimately I had to conclude that I can't make others understand things the way I do. They simply lacked something.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by antegamisou on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:19AM (#25941360)
The way you talk about the 'easiness' of high school math makes me think you've received education in the US, where the exams, and even some part of the curriculum, are laughably easier compared to what students from EU countries have experienced.

That is not to say that some people didn't have to put as much effort as others - learned faster. But when I come across people, mostly online, brushing off math at or above high school level as easy have either received subpar/simplified math education (happens almost exclusively in the US and some shitty EU countries), or have too much confidence from their positive experience with low-difficulty exams.

> I had to conclude that I can't make others understand things the way I do.

If you've had this happen too often you're probably just bad at explaining things, or even worse you haven't fully understood them.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:20PM (#25947478)
I took the most rigorous college degree in Sweden and did pure maths up to masters level. High school maths included calculus, although not as rigorous as you learn at college.

> If you've had this happen too often you're probably just bad at explaining things, or even worse you haven't fully understood them.

I understood the subjects well enough too solve problems on exams I hadn't seen before. That was the main way I managed to get good grades without doing practice problems or studying. I didn't manage to get others to understand things that well. I don't think that failing to get people to that level means I am bad at explaining as there is nobody in the entire world who can get average college students to that level.

For my masters thesis I solved a problem that had stumped one of the more renowned mathematicians in Sweden for decades. I'm not sure if that was hard or not, but to me it didn't seem hard. I didn't continue doing maths as I didn't really have enough passion for the subject to continue doing research, it is pretty boring. After that I realized I needed to earn money, so I learned programming, started getting top 100 spots and sometimes top 10 spots in world wide programming competitions and joined Google. That didn't seem particularly hard to me either, as it took about half a year just doing things on my own.

Why aren't I famous etc? Because I just don't care that much about things. I get bored and stop doing them long before I have worked enough hours on things to get any notable results. I aren't bragging here, I know my value to society thus isn't that high, I am just giving my perspective on things. There are tons of people online arguing that I can't exist, I don't like that.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by antegamisou on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:52PM (#25951273)
> I aren't bragging

No offense but that's exactly what I felt you were doing on your first comment when you were talking about people having trouble understanding math as easily as you can. We are on the Internet so it doesn't sound as condescending as it would IRL, but it still makes you come off as trying to convince us that you're superior. I'm certain you're not doing it intentionally, I'm just trying to explain why as you said, are there tons of people online arguing that you can't exist. People with academic achievements akin to yours tend to remain humble when similar topics about intelligence and genius are brought up. I don't think they act this way because they legitimately do not consider themselves smart, they just know it's quite socially inappropriate to boast about it. On the contrary, again on a systematic basis, those with negligible life achievements almost always try to inform everyone in the room that they feel superior in terms of mental capability. Based on your academic biography above you seem to be an exception to what I just described and have observed both online and IRL.

> For my masters thesis I solved a problem that had stumped one of the more renowned mathematicians in Sweden for decades.

Sounds impressive but at the same time many would be quite skeptical about a really challenging problem being solved in the short, in terms of time, course of a Masters degree. Again, not attempting to undermine your achievement, but you usually hear about hard unsolved problems being a topic of a PhD thesis which almost always includes a number of publications being done during its course as part of it. I'd appreciate a few more details here but I understand you may hesitate stating more because of potential privacy concerns.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by red75prime on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:52AM (#25958539)
> as trying to convince us that you're superior

It could be, but it doesn't really matter. There are people who can think circles around me (and probably you). And I don't think that they ought to have some flaws just to not be totally superior out of some universal law of fairness.

Obsessing about it is obviously not healthy.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username91 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @03:43AM (#25939641)
Interesting. I'm still mulling over some of your points, but overall what you're saying makes sense to me.

I appreciate you sharing your story - I'm sorry you had to deal with that experience.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by vector_spaces on Thursday January 28, 2021 @01:35AM (#25938911)
What do you even mean with talent? Specifically when it comes to mathematics, that is. Some astrological alignment of circumstance such that someone can realize their potential unimpeded by their economic class, physical or mental health status, abilities in the language of instruction, lack of interest in the material, or innumerable other such challenges? Or are you referring also to some eugenicist fantasy of a person whose neurochemistry/physiology happens to be optimized for that specific subset of human activities that we call mathematics?

The latter assumes the former, since if such a thing exists, you can be sure that external factors would limit such a person's ability to succeed in traditional settings.

In either case, I don't understand why such a notion would be useful to anyone except as a justification for gatekeeping and maintaining a culture of elitism in math, which is very much not needed. I'm genuinely curious as to why you find the concept useful

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:10AM (#25939074)
If you have enough talent for maths you can get good results in every maths course up to graduate level without studying or doing practice problems outside of just listening to classes. I know I did that, so I know it is possible. I don't particularly like maths courses, I just took a lot of them since they were free credits.

Is this useful information for how to treat typical students? No. However, talent having such a profound impact on peoples ability to learn, understand and apply mathematics is something most people are aware of and hence it isn't strange that people who studied maths thinks that genius requires inborn talent. The author of this piece instead takes a jab at it and tries to say that they just believe that since they got told by their parents that they were smart, I don't think that is true. Most people studying maths doesn't view themselves as good at maths, so what is more likely is that they take their own struggles despite hard work and passion as evidence that genius requires inborn talent.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by randcraw on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:08PM (#25944978)
So for you, there was a royal road to math? No homework necessary? If so, you're one in a billion. It's no wonder you don't share the perspective of others who must practice in order to learn.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @02:28PM (#25947600)
It wasn't that I didn't need practice, its just that the practice you get from sitting and listening in classes and doing problems in exams was enough practice. It wasn't as if I could just go to the exams without doing anything else.

The trick was mostly that most things just clicked for me, and I could use that to figure the rest out and fill in the gaps during exams to solve the problems they didn't explain in any classes.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by konjin on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:21PM (#25938134)
>For those who disagree, how do you explain the very large number of people who spends tons of time and energy trying to get good at maths but fails to even grasp simple concepts like calculus?

Calculus isn't simple, calculus is an abuse of notation that works by anomalous cancellation in most of the cases you see in university.

Even for something as simple as arithmetic our notation is terrible and misleading. The people who are 'good at maths' are actually good at making unwarranted assumptions and extrapolations from incomplete data. Drawing the actual parse tree for expressions let my 7 year old cousin work at the level of a 12 year old even though she was failing the maths class before I helped her.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:46PM (#25938302)
It isn't simple to a computer, no. But humans have intuition to help guide us which is what makes maths simple. The more of it you have the simpler maths become, the less of it you have the more you have to approach it like a computer as you describe. Being able to approach something like a computer doesn't mean that you understand it though, otherwise you could argue that anyone being able to follow the instructions of a Turing engine understands basically all knowledge.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by konjin on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:57PM (#25938379)
Were that the case we could use human brains in jars to solve np problems. We can't. Human intuition is a poor thing that got us through the middle ages. It should stay there.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:05AM (#25938424)
Human intuition is what lets humans solve problems we still can't solve using computers. It is therefore highly relevant until we have invented general purpose AI.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by konjin on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:22AM (#25938528)
I'm old enough to remember that being said about chess and go. We do not need general purpose AI to solve either of those, and neither do we need it for solving mathematical problems.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by red75prime on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:38AM (#25938620)
Chess and go aren't solved in the proper sense. There's no mathematically proven optimal strategy. What we have is a sort of artificial intuition engines.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Thursday January 28, 2021 @12:41AM (#25938633)
I'm not sure how that is relevant for this discussion.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by antegamisou on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @10:52PM (#25937934)
Not that you're making bad points, but there's a big difference in acing a math exam vs actually assimilating the various underlying concepts, at least at a university level IME. I know plenty of people who would pass as 'geniuses' by your definition that just cram past problems and get high grades. And honestly if you've been to college you'd know that it's almost impossible for a novel problem you've never encountered before show up on an test.

A lot of otherwise intelligent people fairly despise such practices so they adopt inefficient studying habits , failing to complete a set syllabus and achieving subpar results.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:04PM (#25938001)
I didn't say people who ace math exams are geniuses, just that maths makes it very clear that talent is a huge factor for success in the field. So it isn't that STEM students were all told by their parents that they are intelligent and therefore believe that genius is about talent, it is that it is pretty hard to study STEM without noticing the huge difference in talent between people in the field.
Re:Exploring the nature of genius by antegamisou on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:16PM (#25938093)
> talent is a huge factor for success in the field.

Success in the field as in research? Most certainly so.

However I think you're overestimating the 'math IQ' of STEM (under)grads especially considering the large discrepancy among its different subfields. Engineering students (EE/ME/Civil) are systematically 'dumber' maths-wise compared to their science (Maths [duh] or Physics) counterparts. Still, it's quite likely that you do not have to be a genius to be successful at landing a highly-paid, mentally-challenging related job.

About parenting, smart math kids may not have had their egos boosted however their parents almost certainly exposed them to science from an early age. This holds true especially for children coming from 'STEM families'.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by username90 on Wednesday January 27, 2021 @11:26PM (#25938161)
> Still, it's quite likely that you do not have to be a genius to be successful at landing a highly-paid, mentally-challenging related job.

I never said otherwise. However you can't be dumb to land those jobs.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by lordnacho on Thursday January 28, 2021 @06:23AM (#25940594)
> For those who disagree, how do you explain the very large number of people who spends tons of time and energy trying to get good at maths but fails to even grasp simple concepts like calculus?

Are there really a lot of these people? Everyone I know who is good at math likes it and spends a lot of time on it.

In school I was one of those kids who got it pretty easily. I skipped a year in math, I did my exams a year early, I won a math contest, and I went to top uni. But then I also went out of my way to buy extra math texts (not cheap for me) and had extra lessons to learn more stuff.

The kids who didn't do so well were the ones who just saw it as a bunch of riddles to be memorized. That works briefly for an exam or two, but if you don't pick up the ideas properly it gets pretty easy to run into a question that can't be answered.

> Contrast that with the much smaller but still considerable number of people who aren't really passionate about maths, don't put in the work yet still aces the class?

My brother told me he never saw me studying. This is true, why would I have him around when I was studying? I did a fair bit at night when he was asleep. Or I'd think about things on the train.

Also at uni there was a culture of pretending you made no effort but did well anyway. It was childish. Clearly people were studying, because there are very simple things you won't know in any other way, such as the names of concepts or people associated with them.

Re:Exploring the nature of genius by strikelaserclaw on Thursday January 28, 2021 @08:25AM (#25941433)
There are two things at play here in my opinion.

First is that math builds upon itself. You can't do algebra without understanding operators, you can't do calculus without understanding algebra etc...

Second is that many feel math is boring, and they just zone out during the critical years. To get good at math, you need to assimilate concepts by playing around with them and doing the homework.

Combine both these and you really have no way to tell if a person is lost because they are not good at math or because they've done #1 and #2 their whole lives.