Secondly, the Reddit crowd would move else where.
Thirdly, working in investments myself, hedge fund types dont even think like this. It is hard to explain how far off the mark you are...I know financial services can look like a black box....but what is happening is much more boring than you might think. All the drama is happening on Reddit...the SEC is worried about retail investors creating a bubble and losing money....hedge funds and traders just want to make money.....they may take a loss here and move on quickly to the next thing. Doing crazy sheeeeet like you suggested would have them potentially lose all of their investors money or be blacklisted....
It would be irrelevant even if they could. The problem is/was not Reddit/WSB, but rather the positions that the hedge funds put themselves in.
Where are/were the PhDs in risk analysis at these places? How do you get into a position of shorts being >120% of the total float?
Take Willian Gibson's 'Law':
* The future is already here—it's just not evenly distributed.
And take the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH):
* The price of a security reflects all the available information about it.
And when you combine them you have the principle that the information is out there (too many short contracts), but it wasn't evenly distributed—yet.† Until someone noticed it, and it started to spread, and that caused people to change their positions in GME.
Shutting down Reddit, or any other random forum, isn't going to stop someone from noticing the shorts.
This is no different than what happened in The Big Short: some folks noticed discrepancies (e.g., mortgage delinquencies) and acted first, and as that information spread the market "corrected" its price. It's just that it ended up causing the Great Recession.
The spread of information isn't instantaneous either: at the very least it is limited by the speed of light. After that, it's limited by either (a) human attention spans, and/or (b) the machine learning systems that humans programmed in automated systems.
† Edit: I propose this phenomenon, if not labelled already, be called "Gibson's Market Corollary".
--
Now the price of GME is kind of meta though, in that it doesn't reflect on what's know about GameStop, but rather someone 'related' to GameStop.
Instead hedge funds will learn from this example and get smarter about using and manipulating social media. I wouldn't be surprised if they start leading secret PR campaigns to start trends like this on reddit--screw their competitors and make a lot of money.
Why try to swim upstream when it's so much easier to make money swimming with the current?
And why buy social media when you can just manipulate it anonymously?
That's 75% of the site as it is.
Have you... seen WSB? Yes, it's absolutely a place kids go to lose money. It's literally a sub that glorifies stupid investment decisions.
This is how I know you have 0 idea what you're talking about.
Agreed it won't work. A lot of the discussion has already moved from Reddit to discord, and then to another discord channel after the first, and it will move again too if it needs to.
I don't have any skin in the game, but it's fascinating to observe.
Telegram has threads now on announcement channels that are unlinked from discussion channels
And to put into focus how many people are involved here: the GME discussion threads go to tens of thousands of replies within MINUTES of being posted.
To be clear: I don't think that would work, but I think we're at the point where stuff like that is going to be tried. These guys are losing BILLIONS of dollars. Billions. Can they spend $1B to prevent the loss of $2B? (Is reddit worth more than $1B?)
Other stuff I won't be surprised if we see:
* Massive astroturf campaigns (the WSB mods are claiming that this is already happening.
* DDOS attacks on reddit
* Attacks against the mods of WSB
* "Institutional" attacks like SEC involvement
It's just sortof crazy to think what it looks like when there is this much money on the line. Everything goes out the window.