News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by some_random on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:00PM (#25897507)
Utterly unsurprising. The idea that the military will accept having less freedom of action than a private company is absurd and was never going to last.

Honestly, I'm not sure why people care so much about the US government having access to this data while simultaneously not caring that any entity with a sufficiently large bank account can get it.

Maybe it's because so many of the people here work at the businesses that generate this data?

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by Accujack on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:18PM (#25898642)
Most people want there to be laws governing what can be done with aggregate personal data... whether it can be collected, whether it can be sold, what's allowed to be done with it.

A person's right to be forgotten should include their location.

Right now, the law doesn't even consider something like this as a possibility. The laws in the US governing information and what can be done with it haven't been updated for the computer age... yet another failure of our corrupted government.

People are concerned about the military and law enforcement getting the data because they're the typical "greatest threat".

If they did obey the law and not gain access to the data, people would then worry about corporations getting it and what they do with it. Priorities.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by trident5000 on Monday January 25, 2021 @09:43AM (#25903632)
Big tech just keeps greasing the politicians with donations and political favors.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by austhrow743 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:03PM (#25897883)
People do care, just not as much. Governments have murdered, kidnapped, tortured, and oppressed several magnitude more people than private enterprise.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by arcticbull on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:45PM (#25898136)
Oh, I'm not sure that's true. That's a very modern take.

Have you met the British East India Company [3] and the Dutch East India Company (VOC) [4]? The VOC even has a genocide to it's name [1]. [edit] Make that two. [2]

A lot of colonialism was actually carried out by private enterprise. Substantially all of slavery. Once you reach a certain size and scale, is there really even a difference between government and enterprise - except that the voters control one and shareholders the other?

[1] https://historibersama.com/the-voc-genocide-historia/

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amboyna_massacre

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_East_India_Company

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by el_jay on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:17PM (#25898634)
Let’s not forget Jardine Matheson, who in 1840 persuaded the British government to start a war with the Qing Dynasty over their right to keep addicting the Chinese population to opium[1][2].

The Brits got lots of mileage out of that one - Hong Kong for starters, and HSBC, which continues its storied tradition of facilitating immorality to this very day [3][4]. JM itself diversified after the wars and the company lives on as “a multinational conglomerate... with legal domicile in Bermuda”.

Kids, if you want to make it big without actually having to challenge yourself too much, make sure you stick to large-scale, officially-sanctioned crimes against othered groups of humans. That way, you get the George W. Bush treatment instead of accountability!

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Jardine_Matheson_....

[2] https://www.eiu.edu/historia/Cassan.pdf

[3] HSBC money laundering report: Key findings http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-18880269

[4] https://www.icij.org/investigations/fincen-files/hsbc-moved-...

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by austhrow743 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:51PM (#25899342)
My understanding is that those trading companies were effectively the tools with which those countries conducted foreign relations in those regions. I know at least the leader of the VOC was directly government appointed. Could be wrong though, I haven't done much reading on them.

>Once you reach a certain size and scale, is there really even a difference between government and enterprise - except that the voters control one and shareholders the other?

Voter control of countries over time and by country has varied from none to tenuous and I think shareholder control of enterprise might be the same. I think the bigger distinction is use of physical force/violence. A government is the collective with a near monopoly on force within a region. So the thing that makes it scarier when they get access to new tools of oppression is the exact thing that makes them what they are.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by paxys on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:03PM (#25898563)
Sure but the private enterprises of the time that you mention still didn't hold a candle to the monarchy or the church.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by caf on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:17PM (#25898630)
Both of those companies were extensions of the state.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by logicchains on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:05PM (#25898573)
None of your links contradict what the person you're replying to noted about orders of magnitude. Stalin, Mao and Hitler alone killed over a hundred million people in the 20th century.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by giantg2 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:03PM (#25898560)
I think the parent's point is valid - enterprise has generally been less likely to commit those acts. I mean, just look at Hitler, Stalin, and Mao. They killed tens of millions of people.

Even in the examples of the companies that you listed, their acts were generally state sanctioned, making government a party to that, and sometimes supplying state resources to commit them. And of course demanding their share of the spoils.

I do agree that there doesn't seem to be too much difference between large corporations and government. Also they tend to do a good bit of cross pollination of corruption.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by giantg2 on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:52AM (#25902151)
Why is this downvoted?
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by some_random on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:09PM (#25897924)
Of course, we need to give the common stalker and cutthroat corporations a chance to make up the gap.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by austhrow743 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:11PM (#25897940)
Yeah that’s definitely the concern.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by some_random on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:11PM (#25898288)
Apparently I wasn't clear enough. The reason that individuals and corporations have a smaller kill count than governments is because governments historically have more resources and freedom of action in order to commit atrocities. In the cases where corporations have had the opportunity, such as colonial companies or the United Fruit Company[1] for a more recent example they have not refrained from any action on moral grounds.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Fruit_Company#Aiding_an...

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by publicola1990 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:24PM (#25898016)
Because the military may use the information for actually killing people. Remember "We kill people on the basis of metadata" speech by a CIA official.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by AmericanChopper on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:44PM (#25898131)
I think many members of the general public are probably not very well informed on the actual risks that arise from these sorts of privacy issues. If you pay attention to mainstream media coverage of privacy/surveillance issues, you’ll often hear the old “if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear” trope promoted as if it were actually a reasonable counter argument.

Maybe I’m just a tinfoil hat wearing conspiracy theorist, but I have a hard time believing media outlets are capable of giving reasonable coverage to those issues, given their entire revenue model is based upon exploiting mass data gathering in the form of modern ad tech.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by salawat on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:22PM (#25897640)
Oh, people do care about that part. It's just that the capability to reatrain that organization is highly constrained through the Government edifice. That the overnment edifice itself is at the center of the problem is even more cause for alarm.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by some_random on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:48PM (#25897797)
So then why do so many seem to want to start by constraining the organization with the highest level of trust?

Right now, individuals, businesses, and the US military can obtain this data without a warrant or due process. How can you look at this and say "let's start by reigning in the military"? Who, I might add, have a far more limited scope than businesses since the military only cares about information related to whatever mission they're tasked with.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by eue6e6ey on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:44PM (#25897774)
I'm not sure it makes sense to suggest people who work with data are normally the other way around. People who work with data and their activists are why regular Americans are at all scared of government digital surveillance. On the other side of that, people who don't work with data use free digital services everyday and so even if they know those products are built with their data they are more likely to be sympathetic because in their minds it's a fair trade for the utility they've gained and even the trades they didn't make still serve as evidence to them of how useful doing things this way is. An interesting experiment would be if a single city went all-in on digital surveilance and monetization so that the country could see clearly what was being gained and lost for the participants.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by some_random on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:04PM (#25897887)
I cannot push back against the idea that ordinary people consent to collection when they use free services enough. This is an utterly transparent myth that data collectors, aggregators, and consumers tell themselves and others to justify their actions.

People do not understand what is being collected. I and probably everyone here has heard speculation that phones are constantly monitoring for keywords which are used in ads. It's an incredibly common idea that (afaik) isn't true, but shows just how little people understand how data collection works and again, what is actually being collected.

People do not understand how this data is used. The best example I can think of is with pregnant women. Every ad on every platform suddenly revolving around pregnancy and caring for a newborn is not the expected outcome of just googling for some mayoclinic articles. And of course if they're trying to conceal their pregnancy or worse, have a miscarriage, this has resulted in real world harm.

Finally, people cannot possibly consent to how this data will be used in the future. This should be pretty self explanatory.

Those who work for organizations that sell data or information gained from data such as Google or Facebook have to convince themselves the above is not true. In which case, it makes complete sense to insist that the US military needs to have a warrant in order to collect, since obviously a warrant is needed if the target for collection doesn't consent.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by eue6e6ey on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:16PM (#25897960)
Just because people don't understand all the technical details doesn't mean they are sufficiently ignorant to cash in on power words like consent. While I realize it's shortsighted reasoning, it's incredibly common to hear some variant of "x already knows everything about me so who cares" or "my stuff's already in the cloud, I bet x could get to it if it mattered". People in the mainstream are /already/ assuming the worst case scenario, they just don't care as much as we think they should and the only reason the Europeans do is because they're not the ones running the services so the power balance is different.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by some_random on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:38PM (#25898420)
I don't really want to go through a whole sex analogy for consent, but suffice to say that "they consented once at the very beginning without an actual understanding of what was going to happen but it's fine because they're already assuming the worst case scenario" would get one thrown in jail.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:49PM (#25898489)
> People in the mainstream are /already/ assuming the worst case scenario

People in the mainstream don't understand what the worse case scenario is.

They give up their information and don't see any obvious consequences because they don't understand what the consequences actually are. The data gets used for things like price discrimination, which you're not even aware is happening, but then that "free" service ends up costing you $250/month.

Partisans spend all day calling one another fascists and communists, never thinking what would happen with the data in these companies if a government at the level of totalitarianism that existed in actual reality during the 20th century came to power in the 21st.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by nitrogen on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:11AM (#25899512)
what would happen with the data in these companies if a government at the level of totalitarianism that existed in actual reality during the 20th century came to power in the 21st.

The past year should give everyone pause in this regard, no matter which side (or no side) you are on.

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by rendall on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:04AM (#25899452)
> the only reason the Europeans do is because they're not the ones running the services so the power balance is different.

My experience as an American having lived in Europe now for over 7 years is that Europeans (in general, particularly in the Nordic region) have a profoundly different relationship to their governments than US citizens do to ours. The will to protect individual users' data and privacy as expressed in the GDPR for instance is a sincere expression of European values, and would be as in effect if "the power balance" were tilted towards European companies. I know European companies who avoid Google services and all American companies to hold important data, as but one example

Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by DenisM on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:17PM (#25897609)
The government has more guns than your garden variety rich guy.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by some_random on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:29PM (#25897689)
I _wish_ guns were required to cause harm to others.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by chordalkeyboard on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:19PM (#25897623)
More to the point, the government has the socially assigned role of deciding whether anyone’s use of said guns is legal or not.
Re:Military intelligence buys location data instead of getti... by jancsika on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:08PM (#25897914)
I love the presence of this talking point here because its usefulness is self-refuting in this case.

1. To guard against tyranny, always focus more on government overreach than corporate overreach because the government is the one with the guns.

2. Corporations scooping up endless streams of data don't get the same level of scrutiny and pithy talking points from libertarians as the entity with the guns.

3. Class of data-mining corporations collect so much data that it's functionally equivalent to a tyrannical government demanding direct access to everyone's location data.

4. The government-- the entity with the guns that we want to protect ourselves against-- simply buys access to the data from corporations to get around the law.

5. We've done a poor job of guarding against tyranny!

Edit: clarification