News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by bko on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:00PM (#25885079)
Tesla is the only participant that has a true path to self driving technology. Legacy car makers are Goliaths set in the past. They're stuck to the annual release cycle and can't even over the air updates and a touch screen on par with an iPad from 8 years ago.

Legacy automakers have failed to deliver on electric cars for decades. Musk talked about this. There was nothing special about the time he entered the market with Tesla. Any one of the auto makers could (and still theoretically can) develop an appealing electric car. They're simpler, cleaner and more efficient. But not a single one has been able to deliver a reasonable product. They're subsidizing the price of electric and losing 7-10k per [0] and still cannot produce a compelling product.

The legacy car companies are basically blackberry, as someone has finally shown there exists a way to create and produce a compelling car outside of the legacy participants.

Tesla actually has a path forward on self driving. They have the infrastructure, real driver data, and millions of cars on the road that can accept over the air updates. Waymo has a few Taxis in a few cities.

[0] https://insideevs.com/news/336213/moodys-says-automakers-los...

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by rasz on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:16PM (#25885640)
>Tesla is the only participant that has a true path to self driving technology.

They dont even ship cars with Stereo front facing cameras. Eight cameras, twelve hypersonic sensors, one forward facing radar, GPS, and still no stereo vision resulting in cars plowing full speed into stationary obstacles ....

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by jiggawatts on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:16PM (#25887027)
It's possible to extract depth information from a monocular lens. There's several ways to do this, and Tesla has talked publicly that they've implemented at least one approach.

One is depth-from-defocus combined with "overlap" hierarchy information that can be used to build a depth-map. This is the technique Tesla talked about. Interestingly, instead of manually coding up this algorithm, they simply trained a neural net to do it! The trick was to use the radar data as the "ground truth", and train the NN to predict it based on the optical input. It works quite well, and there are videos floating about showing how a Tesla can build up an accurate 3D model of the world around it as it drives along.

There are other approaches as well. For example, the way birds gather depth information is they move their head. One eye takes two "snapshots" of the scene in rapid succession from slightly different positions, producing a stereo pair. A moving car is constantly shifting the camera positions. Note that you don't have to be moving the cameras side-to-side, moving along the road can be enough, as the shift of the focal plane can be used as an additional channel of information for the depth-from-defocus method mentioned above. This is what some mirror-less cameras do: they shift focus back-and-forth a bit to gain more information about the scene. A moving car has the same effect.

Tesla has recently implemented some variant of this latter technique, they also talked about this publicly. Essentially, the first version of the self-driving hardware didn't have the computing power to analyse multiple frames together like this. The current version has the compute power to include the last few frames as well as inputs to the NN, which gives it not just more temporal stability but also the opportunity to extract depth information from motion. (However, I'm not sure if they've actually used motion in this specific way.)

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by amscanne on Sunday January 24, 2021 @03:03AM (#25890272)
> One is depth-from-defocus combined with "overlap" hierarchy information that can be used to build a depth-map. This is the technique Tesla talked about. Interestingly, instead of manually coding up this algorithm, they simply trained a neural net to do it! The trick was to use the radar data as the "ground truth", and train the NN to predict it based on the optical input. It works quite well, and there are videos floating about showing how a Tesla can build up an accurate 3D model of the world around it as it drives along.

Wow, that scares the shit out of me. I hope this is not serious. How could they possibly understand the neural net and how it will behave under novel scenarios? This is the opposite of what you want in a safety critical system.

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by godatemydog on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:37PM (#25886369)
U know u can do depth perception from time without stereo cameras?
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by lars_thomas on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:29PM (#25886723)
Things like this are not binary "can do/cannot do". Sure some kind of estimate could be made. But it is challenging when the scene is not static, the speed of the camera varies, lack of texture, motion blur... stereo is not without its problems of course. Lidars seem to be good in lot of the places where visible light cameras are struggling.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by gamblor956 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:18PM (#25886673)
That's true, but Tesla has yet to figure that out.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by uncoder0 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:34PM (#25885327)
In my opinion, the problem is Tesla and Elon refuse to acknowledge the value of LIDAR. A fused sensor approach is the only way we're going to get full autonomy. I was in this field in 2007 on the DARPA Urban challenge so maybe the state of the art indicates otherwise now however, from the NHTSA investigations into crashes from Tesla's autopilot all of them would have been fixed with even basic LIDAR.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by alicorn on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:00PM (#25885537)
This baffles me as well. The technology to solve so many problems hard to approach with other tools is right there, why not use it.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by agildehaus on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:16PM (#25885638)
LIDAR also provides more accurate data than stereo cameras could ever hope to achieve. Why not use it? Why limit ourselves to what humans have?
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by sagarm on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:31PM (#25886309)
Cost. Tesla has to sell cars to price-sensitive consumers. Adding a LIDAR would likely increase the price significantly. Given their business model, they basically have to argue that LIDAR is not necessary.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by lars_thomas on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:09PM (#25886607)
I agree that when Tesla made their first promises of delivering FSD HW (just add SW a little bit later) reasonably priced solid state lidars were not available. So a story had to be made 'humans have eyes and they can drive, lidar is not needed'. Super hard to back now when they sold FSD to so many customers still waiting for the SW update.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by uncoder0 on Friday January 29, 2021 @12:14AM (#25954258)
I think this right here is the issue. They've backed themselves into the corner of 'We Don't need LIDAR'. When we were scrapping together on a 75k budget we bought budget lidar with a 180 degree linear sweep and it cost ~5k, 14 years ago, from SICK and it still was better than a modern 2020 model Tesla is at detecting a white van crossing the road in broad daylight.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by HellDunkel on Saturday January 23, 2021 @03:00PM (#25885540)
Maybe when LICAMs become super cheap but so far, no competitor has shown a better/more advanced ADAS system using LIDAR.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by Closi on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:45PM (#25886847)
Well, Waymo has demonstrated full autonomous using lidar?
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by HellDunkel on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:27PM (#25887100)
I’d argue Waymo is not a competitor and offers no ADAS. They operate autonomous vehicles in confined areas afaik. Driving in traffic, interacting with humans is a different story.
Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by Closi on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:49AM (#25893448)
Well full automatic driving is more advanced than driver assistance, and Tesla is claiming that the current system will be scaled to full autonomous driving which is what the original article is about.

The waymo car is the only actively-used car with Lidar anyway as far as I’m aware, so if you exclude Waymo then your statement is self fulfilling no matter how good or bad Tesla’s ADAS is!

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by HellDunkel on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:05PM (#25922093)
The point i wanted to express is that although LIDAR could be an improvement it is not per se the „way to go“ with ADAS today. Please consider that some, eg Audi, offer ADAS using lidar and it is not nearly as capeable as Teslas system.

Costs matter.

I am very certain that Waymo has no autonomous vehicle today that mist people would be ok to go around their neighbourhood driverless. „Full autonomy“- socially acceptable- does not exist today. Whether it can be done, with or without Lidar, remains to be seen.

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by bko on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:56PM (#25885503)
Lidar adds complexity and domain that's not available to humans. Humans drive without lidar, so presumably we can train a neural net to drive without it as well.

Lidar is almost like adding a hand crafted dimension to the decision making process. It makes the system more explainable, but doesn't necessarily mean it will help achieve better results. I look at ML in games like chess and go. Originally, they had a set of hand crafted features, like the concept of "eyes" in go. But later iterations removed those and the network performed better. I think lidar is the same thing where it'll add unnecessary complexity and ultimately hurt in learning.

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by qeternity on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:45PM (#25885410)
> Tesla is the only participant that has a true path to self driving technology.

You can’t make a statement without qualifying this. You attack legacy automakers but then go on to discuss Waymo. I would bet money you’re long TSLA.

You talk about OTA updates as if that’s some huge technological moat? Hell, cars have been receiving very frequent software updates for over a decade.

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by Infinitesimus on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:52PM (#25886487)
> You talk about OTA updates as if that’s some huge technological moat? Hell, cars have been receiving very frequent software updates for over a decade.

I think OTAs are a moat but highlight an important incentive difference. Traditional automakers want to sell you next year's model of the car. Tesla seems like they want your car to get better over time.

Perhaps it is organizational cruft or the dealer network but consider even the simple case of adaptive cruise control systems in cars today that have radar + cameras. Most of those systems bounce between lanes and can't even stay centered well. This is something that could be a software fix but you'll have to wait for the next N models when they redesign the car to see it.

Infotainment systems are another example - they are almost universally crappy and it is rare to get updates OTA. Shipping a car with capable hardware and slowly improving software capability imo is a smarter long-term approach.

Time will tell though.

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by bko on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:51PM (#25885466)
> You attack legacy automakers but then go on to discuss Waymo

Paragraphs 1-3 discuss legacy automakers. Only paragraph 4 references Waymo.

> You talk about OTA updates as if that’s some huge technological moat?

Of course they're not a technological moat. These auto makers are hundreds of thousands of employees. They're likely an organizational nightmare and stuck to the way things have been done. The fact that they don't have over the air updates or have to iterate on an annual cadence is evidence of something deeply flawed in their organizational structure. And I'm not confident that they can overcome it.

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by joshuamorton on Saturday January 23, 2021 @02:23PM (#25885253)
Tesla has just over a million cars on the road. Waymo has approximately 100,000. 100000 vehicles that have proven the ability to reach L4 autonomy, unlike tesla's.

And waymos approach isn't too be a car manufacturer, but an Uber competitor. So fewer vehicles is fine.

> They're subsidizing the price of electric and losing 7-10k per [0]

To be fair, so is tesla.

Re:Tesla’s autopilot won’t achieve full autonomy, Waymo CEO ... by clouddrover on Saturday January 23, 2021 @06:41PM (#25887222)
> and still cannot produce a compelling product

The Renault Zoe was the best selling BEV in Europe in 2020:

https://insideevs.com/news/467101/renault-bev-sales-december...

Tesla has gone from being the top BEV maker in Europe to now being third. Soon Tesla will become fourth in Europe after Hyundai overtakes them.

Different markets like different cars. The Audi e-tron was the best selling BEV in Norway in 2020 and is currently the best seller in 2021:

https://ev-sales.blogspot.com/2021/01/norway-december-2020.h...

https://elbilstatistikk.no/