Microsoft has public documentation that describes how it works:
> The session host is the console or device that runs the game play simulation for titles built on a host-based peer-to-peer network architecture. This console or device is typically the same as the arbiter, but it does not have to be the same.[0]
[0] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/gaming/xbox-live/features/m...
Just talking about authentication / autorization do you know how much it takes in term of infra at the scale of Xbox?
At a high level overview what they provide:
- authz / authn / entitlment
- rewards
- social ( voip, group, friends, chat, profil )
- achievments
- store / marketplace
- matchmaking
- leaderboard
- object storage for entities, cloud save game
Just open: https://support.xbox.com/en-US/xbox-live-status
As for gameserver the definition is very broad depending on what you do on those gameservers, some of them are heavy other are light depending of what's happening server side ( physics, ai, gameplay replication etc ... )
Also, the online services don't provide game servers, these are paid for by the game publishers.
Please don't make excuses for the anti-consumer profiteering of gigantic mega-corporations. No PC platform is 'compelled' to require payment for online play, despite many offering a similar or greater level of server to XBL or PSN.
This is so wrong, infra is very expensive for online games. It's that expensive that it's still a question to use dedicated server vs p2p because of cost.
Obviously P2P has many advantages apart from being free for the publisher - such as lower latency.